Recently, several mainstream media organizations have moved away from using “illegal immigrant” in their immigration coverage. While this shift in immigration coverage is positive, seemingly positive language may still be exclusionary, particularly if the content of stories remains the same. We investigate whether newspaper articles that describe immigrants as “illegal” are more negative in content than articles that present immigrants as “undocumented” by analyzing 1,616 newspaper articles and letters to the editor in The Arizona Republic between 2000 and 2016, a critical period of immigration legislative activity in Arizona. We find that The Arizona Republic inundated readers with negative news coverage and that this coverage is baked into the content of stories and transcends the use of either term, “illegal” or “undocumented.” We then draw on letters to the editor and original interview data to consider how social forces outside of the media may influence coverage.
AbregoLeisy J.2014. “Immigrants’ Diverse Experiences of ‘Illegality.’” Pp. 139–60 in Constructing Immigrant “Illegality”: Critiques, Experiences, and Responses, edited by MenjívarCeciliaKanstroomDaniel. New York: Cambridge University Press.
2.
AckermanEdwin. 2014. “‘What Part of Illegal Don’t You Understand?’: Bureaucracy and Civil Society in the Shaping of Illegality.” Ethnic and Racial Studies37(2):181–203.
3.
AlamilloRudyHaynesChrisMadridRaulJr.2019. “Framing and Immigration through the Trump Era.” Sociology Compass13:e12676. doi:10.1111/soc4.12676.
4.
BensonRodney. 2013. Shaping Immigration News: A French-American Comparison. New York: Cambridge University Press.
5.
BleichErikBloemraadIrenede GraauwEls. 2015. “Migrants, Minorities and the Media: Information, Representation and Participation in the Public Sphere.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies41(6):857–73.
6.
BlinderScottJeannetAnne-Marie. 2018. “The ‘Illegal’ and the Skilled: Effects of Media Portrayals on Perceptions of Immigrants in Britain.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies44(9):1444–62.
7.
BloemraadIrenede GraauwElsHamlinRebecca. 2015. “Immigrants in the Media: Civic Visibility in the USA and Canada.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies41(6):874–96.
8.
EduardoBonilla-Silva. 2018. Racism without Racists: Color-blind Racism and the Persistence of Racial Inequality in America. 5th ed.Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
9.
BraderTedValentinoNicholas A.SuhayElizabeth. 2008. “What Triggers Public Opposition to Immigration? Anxiety, Group Cues, and Immigration Threat.” American Journal of Political Science52(4):959–78.
10.
BrantonRegina P.DunawayJohanna. 2009a. “Slanted Newspaper Coverage of Immigration: The Importance of Economics and Geography.” Policy Studies Journal37(2):257–27.
11.
BrantonRegina P.DunawayJohanna. 2009b. “Spatial Proximity to the U.S.-Mexico Border and Newspaper Coverage of Immigration Issues.” Political Research Quarterly62(2):289–302.
12.
BrownHana E.2013. “Race, Legality, and the Social Policy Consequences of Anti-immigration Mobilization.” American Sociological Review78(2):290–314.
13.
BrownHana E.JonesJennifer A.BeckerAndrea. 2018. “The Racialization of Latino Immigrants in New Destinations: Criminality, Ascription, and Countermobilization.” RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences4(5):118–40.
14.
ButzAdam M.KehrbergJason E.2019. “Anti-immigrant Sentiment and the Adoption of State Immigration Policy.” Policy Studies Journal47(3):605–23.
15.
CampbellKristina M.2011. “The Road to S.B. 1070: How Arizona Became Ground Zero for the Immigrants’ Rights Movement and the Continuing Struggle for Latino Civil Rights in America.” Harvard Latino Law Review14:1–21.
16.
ChavezLeo R.2001. Covering Immigration: Popular Images and the Politics of the Nation. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
17.
ChavezLeo R.2013. The Latino Threat: Constructing Immigrants, Citizens, and the Nation. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
18.
CookTimothy E.1998. Governing with the News: The News Media as a Political Institution. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
19.
CooperChristopherKnottsH. GibbsHaspelMoshe. 2009. “The Content of Political Participation: Letters to the Editor and the People Who Write Them.” PS: Political Science and Politics42(1):131–37.
20.
De GenovaNicholas P.2002. “Migrant ‘Illegality’ and Deportability in Everyday Life.” Annual Review of Anthropology31:419–47.
21.
De GenovaNicholas P.2004. “The Legal Production of Mexican/Migrant ‘Illegality.’”Latino Studies2:160–85.
22.
DhaliwalSukhwantForkertKirsten. 2016. “Deserving and Undeserving Migrants.” Soundings61:49–61.
23.
DiazPriscilaSaenzDelia S.KwanVirgina S. Y.2011. “Economic Dynamics and Changes in Attitudes toward Undocumented Mexican Immigrants in Arizona.” Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy11(1):300–13.
ElciogluE. F.2017. “The State Effect: Theorizing Immigration Politics in Arizona.” Social Problems64:239–55. doi:10.1093/socpro/spw060.
28.
EstradaEmily P.EbertKimHalla LoreMichelle. 2016. “Apathy and Antipathy: Media Coverage of Restrictive Immigration Legislation and the Maintenance of Symbolic Boundaries.” Sociological Forum31(3):555–76.
29.
FarrisEmily M.MohamedHeather Silber. 2018. “Picturing Immigration: How the Media Criminalizes Immigrants.” Politics, Groups, and Identities6(4):814–24.
FloresRené D.2017. “Do Anti-immigrant Laws Shape Public Sentiment? A Study of Arizona’s SB 1070 Using Twitter Data.” American Journal of Sociology123(2):333–84.
33.
FloresRené D.2018. “Can Elites Shape Public Attitudes toward Immigrants? Evidence from the 2016 US Presidential Election.” Social Forces96(4):1649–90.
34.
FloresRené D.SchachterAriela. 2018. “Who Are the ‘Illegals’? The Social Construction of Illegality in the United States.” American Sociological Review83(5):839–68.
35.
Flores MoralesJosefinaFarago.Fanni2021. “‘Of Course We Need to Help the Undocumented Immigrants!’ Twitter Discourse on the (Un)Deservingness of Undocumented Immigrants in the United States during the COVID-19 Pandemic.” Sociological Perspectives. (DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177%2F07311214211005494).
36.
GamsonWilliam A.1992. Talking Politics. New York: Cambridge University Press.
37.
GamsonWilliam A.CroteauDavidHoynesWilliamSassonTheodore. 1992. “Media Images and the Social Construction of Reality.” Annual Review of Sociology18:373–93.
38.
GamsonWilliam A.ModiglianiAndre. 1987. “The Changing Culture of Affirmative Action.” Pp. 137–77 in Research in Political Sociology, Vol. 3, edited by BraungartRichard D.Greenwich, CT: Jai Press.
39.
GamsonWilliam A.ModiglianiAndre. 1989. “Media Discourse and Public Opinion on Nuclear Power: A Constructionist Approach.” American Journal of Sociology95:1–37.
40.
Gil de ZúñigaHomeroCorreaTeresaValenzuelaSebastian. 2012. “Selective Exposure to Cable News and Immigration in the U.S.: The Relationship Between FOX News, CNN, and Attitudes toward Mexican Immigrants.” Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media56(4):597–615.
41.
GilensMartin. 1999. Why Americans Hate Welfare: Race, Media, and the Politics of Antipoverty Policy. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
42.
GilliamFranklin D.Jr.IyengarShantoSimonAdamWrightOliver. 1996. “Crime in Black and White: The Violent, Scary World of Local News.” The International Journal of Press/Politics1(3):6–23.
43.
GilliamFranklin D.Jr.ValentinoNicholas A.BeckmannMatthew N.2002. “Where You Live and What You Watch: The Impact of Racial Proximity and Local Television News on Attitudes about Race and Crime.” Political Research Quarterly55(4):755–80.
HartRoderick P.2001. “Citizen Discourse and Political Participation: A Survey.” Pp. 407–32 in Mediated Politics: Communication in the Future of Democracy, edited by BennettW. LanceEntmanRobert M.Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
46.
HaughneyChristine. 2013. “The Times Shifts on ‘Illegal Immigrant,’ but Doesn’t Ban the Use.” The New York Times, April23. Retrieved August 6, 2021 (https://nyti.ms/11ifm1B).
47.
HaynesChrisMerollaJenniferRamakrishnanS. Karthick. 2016. Framing Immigrants: News Coverage, Public Opinion, and Policy. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
48.
HopkinsDaniel J.SidesJohnCitrinJack. 2019. “The Muted Consequences of Correct Information about Immigration.” The Journal of Politics81:315–20.
49.
JefferiesJulian. 2009. “Do Undocumented Students Play By the Rules? Meritocracy in the Media.” Critical Inquiry in Language Studies1(2):15–38.
50.
KilSang Hea. 2019. Covering the Border War: How the News Media Creates Crime, Race, Nation and the USA-Mexico Divide. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
51.
LeerkesArjenLeachMarkBachmeierJames. 2012. “Borders behind the Border: An Exploration of State-level Differences in Migration Control and their Effects on US Migration Patterns.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies38(1):111–29.
52.
LópezIan Haney. 2015. Dog Whistle Politics: How Coded Racial Appeals Have Reinvented Racism and Wrecked the Middle Class. New York: Oxford University Press.
53.
López-SandersLauraBrownHana E.2020. “Political Mobilisation and Public Discourse in New Immigrant Destinations: News Media Characterizations of Immigrants during the 2006 Immigration Marches.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies46:820–38. doi:10.1080/1369183X.2018.1556464.
54.
MasseyDouglas S.DurandJorgePrenKaren A.2016. “Why Border Enforcement Backfired.” American Journal of Sociology121(5):1557–600.
55.
MasuokaNatalieJunnJane. 2013. The Politics of Belonging: Race, Public Opinion, and Immigration. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
56.
McConnellEileen Diaz. 2011. “An ‘Incredible Number of Latinos and Asians’: Media Representations of Racial and Ethnic Population Change in Atlanta, Georgia.” Latino Studies9(2–3):177–97.
57.
McConnellEileen Diaz. 2014. “Good News and Bad News: Numeracy and Framing in Newspaper Reporting of Unauthorized Migration Estimates in Arizona.” Aztlan: A Journal of Chicano Studies1:41–70.
58.
MenjívarCecilia. 2006. “Liminal Legality: Salvadoran and Guatemalan Immigrants’ Lives in the United States.” American Journal of Sociology111(4):1380–421.
59.
MenjívarCecilia. 2011. “The Power of the Law: Central Americans’ Legality and Everyday Life in Phoenix, Arizona.” Latino Studies9(4):377–95.
60.
MenjívarCecilia. 2014. “Implementing a Multilayered Immigration System: The Case of Arizona.” Pp. 179–204 in Hidden Lives and Human Rights in the United States: Understanding the Controversies and Tragedies of Undocumented Immigration, edited by LorentzenLois A.Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger.
61.
MenjívarCecilia. 2016. “Immigrant Criminalization in Law and Media: Effects on Latino Immigrant Workers’ Identities in Arizona.” American Behavioral Scientist60(5–6):597–616.
62.
MenjívarCeciliaAbregoLesiy J.2012. “Legal Violence: Immigration Law and the Lives of Central Americans Immigrants.” American Journal of Sociology117(5):1380–421.
63.
MenjívarCeciliaKanstroomDaniel. 2014. “Introduction—Immigrant ‘Illegality’: Constructions and Critiques.” Pp. 1–33 in Constructing Immigrant “Illegality”: Critiques, Experiences, and Responses, edited by MenjívarCeciliaKanstroomDaniel. New York: Cambridge University Press.
64.
MenjívarCeciliaKilSang H.2002. “For Their Own Good: Benevolent Rhetoric and Exclusionary Language in Public Officials’ Discourse on Immigrant-related Issues.” Social Justice29:160–76.
65.
MerollaJenniferRamakrishnanS. KarthickHaynesChris. 2013. “‘Illegal, ‘Undocumented,’ or ‘Unauthorized’: Equivalency Frames, Issue Frames, and Public Opinion on Immigration.” Perspectives on Politics11(3):789–807.
66.
MohamedHeather SilberFarrisEmily. 2020. “Bad Hombres? An Examination of identities in U.S. Media Coverage of Immigration.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies46(1):158–76.
67.
MohlRaymond A.2016. “The Politics of Expulsion: A Short History of Alabama’s Anti-immigrant Law, HB 56.” Pp. 362–87 in Immigrant Identity and the Politics of Citizenship, edited by BukowczykJohn J.Champaign, IL: University of Illinois Press.
68.
NewtonLina. 2005. “It Is not a Question of Being Anti-immigration: Categories of Deservedness in Immigration Policy Making.” Pp. 139–72 in Deserving and Entitled: Social Constructions and Public Policy, edited by SchneiderA. L.IngramH. M.Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
69.
NichollsWalter J.2013. The DREAMers: How the Undocumented Youth Movement Transformed the Immigrant Rights Debate. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
70.
NillAndrea Christina. 2011. “Latinos and SB 1070: Demonization, Dehumanization, and Disenfranchisement.” Harvard Latino Law Review14:35–66.
71.
OmmundsenReidarLarsenKnud S.van der VeerKeesEilertsenDag-Erik. 2014. “Framing Unauthorized Immigrants: The Effects of Labels on Evaluations.” Psychological Reports: Sociocultural Issues in Psychology114(2):461–78.
72.
PatlerCaitlinGonzalesRoberto G.2015. “Framing Citizenship: Media Coverage of Anti-deportation Cases Led by Undocumented Immigrant Youth Organizations.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies41(9):1453–74.
73.
PearsonMatthew R.2010. “How ‘Undocumented Workers’ and ‘Illegal Aliens’ Affect Prejudice toward Mexican Immigrants.” Social Influence5(2):118–32.
74.
PerrinAndrewVaiseyStephen. 2008. “Parallel Public Spheres: Distance and Discourse in Letters to the Editor.” American Journal of Sociology114(3):781–810.
PhamHuyenPhamVan H.2014. “Measuring the Climate for Immigrants: A State-by-state Analysis.” Pp. 21–40 in The Role of the States in Immigration Enforcement and Policy, edited by ChinGabriel JackHessickCarissa. New York: New York University Press.
Santa AnaOtto. 2013. Juan in a Hundred: The Representation of Latinos on Network News. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.
82.
SantosCarlos E.MenjívarCecilia. 2013. “Youths’ Perspective on Senate Bill 1070 in Arizona: The Socio-emotional Effects of Immigration Policy.” Association of Mexican-American Educators7(2):7–17.
83.
SantosCarlos E.MenjívarCeciliaGodfreyErin. 2013. “Effects of SB 1070 on Children.” Pp. 79–92 in Latino Politics and Arizona’s Immigration Law SB1070, edited by MaganaLisaLeeErik. New York: Springer.
84.
SchildkrautDeborahJiménezTomás R.DovidioJohn F.HuoYuen J.2019. “A Tale of Two States: How State Immigration Climate Affects Belonging to State and Country among Latinos.” Social Problems66(3):332–55.
SohoniDeeneshMendezJennifer Bickham. 2014. “Defining Immigrant Newcomers in New Destinations: Symbolic Boundaries in Williamsburg, Virginia.” Ethnic and Racial Studies37(3):496–516.
87.
SohoniDeeneshSohoniTracy W. P.2014. “Perceptions of Immigrant Criminality: Crime and Social Boundaries.” The Sociological Quarterly55(1):49–71.
88.
StewartJulie. 2012. “Fiction over Facts: How Competing Narrative Forms Explain Policy in a New Immigration Destination.” Sociological Forum27(3):591–616.
89.
StowellJacob I.GostjevFeodor A.2018. “Immigration and Crime Rates: Lasting Trends and New Understandings.” Pp. 81–92 in Routledge Handbook on Immigration and Crime, edited by MillerHolly VenturaPegueroAnthony. New York: Routledge.
90.
TanYueWeaverDavid H.2009. “Local Media, Public Opinion, and State Legislative Policies: Agenda Setting at the State Level.” International Journal of Press/Politics14(4):454–76.
91.
TichenorPhillip J.DonohueGeorge A.OlienClarince N.1980. Community Conflict and the Press. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
92.
ToomeyR. B.Umaña-TaylorA. J.WilliamsD.Harvey-MendozaE. C.JahromiL. B.UpdegraffK. A.2014. “The Impact of Arizona’s S.B. 1070 Immigration Law on Utilization of Health Care and Public Assistance among Mexican-origin Teen Mothers and their Mother Figures.” American Journal of Public Health104(Suppl. 1):S28–34.
93.
TorcheFlorenciaSiroisCatherine. 2019. “Restrictive Immigration Law and Birth Outcomes of Immigrant Women.” American Journal of Epidemiology188(1):24–33.
94.
ValentinoNicholas A.BraderTedJardinaAshley E.2013. “Immigration Opposition among U.S. Whites: General Ethnocentrism or Media Priming of Attitudes about Latinos?” Political Psychology34(2):149–66.
95.
ViladrichAnahí. 2019. “‘We Cannot Let Them Die’: Undocumented Immigrants and Media Framing of Health Deservingness in the United States.” Qualitative Health Research29(10):1447–60.
VillegasPaloma E.VillegasFrancisco J.2019. “Migrant Illegalization and Minoritized Populations.” Pp. 1–17 in The Palgrave Handbook of Ethnicity, edited by RatuvaS.Springer. doi:10.1007/978-981-13-0242-8_87-1.
98.
VossKimBloemraadIrene, eds. 2011. Rallying for Immigrant Rights: The Fight for Inclusion in 21st Century America. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
99.
Wahl-JorgensenKarin. 2001. “Letters to the Editor as a Forum for Public Deliberation: Modes of Publicity and Democratic Debate.” Critical Studies in Mass Communication18(3):303–20.
100.
Wahl-JorgensenKarin. 2002. “Understanding the Conditions for Public Discourse: Four Rules for Selecting Letters to the Editor.” Journalism Studies3(1):69–81.
101.
Wahl-JorgensenKarin. 2004. “A ‘Legitimate Beef’ or ‘Raw Meat’? Civility, Multiculturalism, and Letters to the Editor.” The Communication Review7(1):89–105.
102.
WrightMatthewLevyMorrisCitrinJack. 2016. “Public Attitudes toward Immigration Policy Across the Legal/Illegal Divide: The Role of Categorical and Attribute-based Decision-making.” Political Behavior3891:229–53.
