Nearly one-third to one-half of U.S. women meets the medical criteria for infertility at some point in their reproductive lives. Yet many do not view lack of conception as problematic. Why might some women self-identify as having a fertility problem but others do not? Using two waves of the National Survey of Fertility Barriers, we conducted binary and longitudinal multinomial logistic regression to answer this question. Results suggest that only a portion of women actually experience infertility as a “spoiled identity” or as disruptive to their lives. Rather, consistent with symbolic interactionist perspectives, there is evidence that infertility symptoms (i.e., not conceiving) depend upon interpretations and definitions of the situation. Multiple patterns of self-identification over time (identity non-adopters, maintainers, adopters, and relinquishers) suggest an indeterminate association between illness and impacts on the self, even for a condition that is highly medicalized in the United States.
AbbeyAntoniaAndrewsFrank M.HalmanL. Jill. 1994. “Psychological Predictors of Life Quality: How Are They Affected by Infertility, Gender, and Parenthood?” Journal of Family Issues15:253–71.
2.
AltheideDavid L.2000. “Identity and Definition of the Situation in a Mass-mediated Context.” Social Forces23:1–27.
BarnesLiberty W.2014. Conceiving Masculinity: Male Infertility, Medicine, and Identity. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
5.
BarskyArthur J.Borus.Jonathan F.1995. “Somatization and Medicalization in the Era of Managed Care.” Journal of the American Medical Association274:1931–34.
6.
Beauboeuf-LaFontantTamara. 2007. “‘You Have to Show Strength’: An Exploration of Gender, Race, and Depression.” Gender & Society21:28–51.
7.
BeckerGay. 2000. The Elusive Embryo: How Women and Men Approach New Reproductive Technologies. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
8.
BeckerGayNachtigall.Robert D.1992. “Eager for Medicalisation: The Social Production of Infertility as a Disease.” Sociology of Health & Illness14:456–71.
9.
BellAnn V.2014. Misconceptions: Infertility and Social Class in America. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
10.
BlumerHerbert. 1969. Symbolic Interactionism: Perspective and Method. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
11.
BroekmansFrank J.H KnauffErik A.te VeldeEgbert R.MacklonNick S.Fauser.Bart C.2007. “Female Reproductive Ageing: Current Knowledge and Future Trends.” Trends in Endocrinology & Metabolism18:58–65.
12.
BuryMichael. 1982. “Chronic Illness as Biographical Disruption.” Sociology of Health & Illness4(2):167–82.
13.
ChandraAnjaniHervey StephenElizabeth. 2010. “Infertility Service Use among US Women: 1995 and 2002.” Fertility & Sterility93:725–36.
14.
CharmazKathy. 1983. “Loss of Self: A Fundamental Form of Suffering in the Chronically Ill.” Sociology of Health & Illness5:168–95.
15.
CharmazKathy. 1995. “The Body, Identity, and Self: Adapting to Impairment.” The Sociological Quarterly36:657–80.
16.
CherlinAndrew. 2010. “Demographic Trends in the United States: A Review of Research in the 2000s.” Journal of Marriage and Family72:403–19.
17.
CollinsPatricia Hill. 1990. Black Feminist Thought: Knowledge, Consciousness, and the Politics of Empowerment. New York: Unwin Hyman.
18.
ConradPeter. 2005. “The Shifting Engines of Medicalization.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior46:3–14.
19.
ConradPeterLeiterValerie. 2004. “Medicalization, Markets and Consumers.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior45:158–76.
20.
EdinKatherynKefalasMaria. 2005. Promises I Can Keep: Why Poor Woman Put Motherhood Ahead of Marriage. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
21.
ExleyCatherineLetherbyGayle. 2001. “Managing a Disrupted Lifecourse: Issues of Identity and Emotion Work.” Health5:112–32.
22.
FranklinSarah. 1990. “Deconstructing ‘Desperateness’: The Social Construction of Infertility in Popular Representations of New Reproductive Technologies.” Pp. 200–29 in The New Reproductive Technologies, edited by McneilMaureenVarcoeIanYearleySteven. New York: Springer.
23.
GoffmanErving. 1963. Stigma: Notes on the Management of a Spoiled Identity. New York: Simon & Schuster.
24.
GreilArthur L.1991a. “A Secret Stigma: The Analogy between Infertility and Chronic Illness and Disability.” Advances in Medical Sociology2:17–38.
25.
GreilArthur L.1991b. Not Yet Pregnant: Infertile Couples in Contemporary America. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
26.
GreilArthur L.JohnsonKatherine M.McQuillanJuliaLacyNaomi. 2011. “Are Prior Pregnancy Outcomes Relevant for Models of Fertility Specific Distress or Infertility Helpseeking?”Human Fertility14:160–66.
27.
GreilArthur L.Leyser-WhalenOphraLowryMichelleMcQuillanJuliaShrefflerKarina M. “Infertility Treatment and Self-identity as Someone with a Fertility Problem: A Longitudinal Analysis of a Population-based Sample of U.S. Women.” Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Midwest Sociological Society, St. Louis, MO, March 2011.
28.
GreilArthur L.McQuillanJuliaJohnsonKatherine M.Slauson-BlevinsKathleen S.ShrefflerKarina M.2010. “The Hidden Infertile: Infertile Women without Pregnancy Intent in the United States.” Fertility & Sterility93:2080–83.
29.
GreilArthur L.McQuillanJuliaShrefflerKarina M.JohnsonKatherine M.Slauson-BlevinsKathleen S.2011. “Race/ethnicity and Medical Services for Infertility: Stratified Reproduction in a Population-based Sample of U.S. Women.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior52:493–509.
30.
GreilArthur L.McQuillanJuliaShrefflerKarina M.JohnsonKatherine M.Slauson-Blevins.Kathleen S.2013. “The Importance of Social Cues for Medical Helpseeking: The Example of Infertility.” Sociological Inquiry8:209–37.
31.
GreilArthur L.Slauson-BlevinsKathleen S.McQuillanJulia. 2010.” The Experience of Infertility: A Review of Recent Literature.” Sociology of Health & Illness32(1):140–62.
32.
GurunathSumanaPandianZabeenaAndersonRichard A.BhattacharyaSiladitya. 2011. “Defining Infertility: A Systematic Review of Prevalence Studies.” Human Reproduction Update17:575–88.
33.
IkemotoLisa C.1996. “The In/fertile, the Too Fertile, and the Dysfertile.” Hastings Law Journal47:1007–56.
34.
JohnsonKatherine M.FledderjohannJasmine. 2012. “Revisiting “Her” Infertility: Medicalized Embodiment, Self-identification, and Distress.” Social Science & Medicine75:883–91.
35.
JohnsonKatherine M.Johnson.David R.2009. “Partnered Decisions? Infertility and Help-seeking in U.S. Couples.” Family Relations58:431–44.
36.
JohnsonKatherine M.ShrefflerKarina M.GreilArthur L.McQuillanJulia. 2018. “Fertility and Infertility: Toward an Integrative Research Agenda. Population Research and Policy Review37:641–66.
37.
JutelAnnemarie G.2011. Putting a Name to It: Diagnosis in Contemporary Society. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
38.
JylhaMarja. 2009. “What Is Self-Rated Health and Why Does It Predict Mortality? Towards a Unified Conceptual Model.” Social Science & Medicine69:307–16.
39.
KarpDavid. 1994. “Living with Depression: Illness and Identity Turning Points.” Qualitative Health Research4:6–30.
40.
LetherbyGayle. 1999. “Other than Mothers and Mothers as Others: The Experience of Motherhood and Non-motherhood in Relation to ‘Infertility’ and ‘Involuntary Childlessness.’”Women’s Studies International Forum22:359–72.
41.
Leyser-WhalenOphraGreilArthur L.McQuillanJuliaJohnsonKatherine M.ShrefflerKarina M.2018. “Just because a Doctor says Something, Doesn’t Mean That Will Happen’: Infertility Medical Encounters and Self-perception as Having a Fertility Problem.” Sociology of Health & Illness40:445–62.
42.
LoftusJeni. 2009. ““Oh, no, I’m not infertile”: Culture, Support Groups, and the Infertile Identity.” Sociological Focus42:394–415.
43.
LoftusJeniAndriot.Angie L.2012. “That‘s what makes a woman”: Infertility and Coping with a Failed Life Course Transition.” Sociological Spectrum32:226–43.
MarkusHazelNuriusPaula. 1986. “Possible Selves.” American Psychologist41:954–69.
46.
MatthewsRalphMartin MatthewsAnne. 1986. “Infertility and Involuntary Childlessness: The Transition to Nonparenthood.” Journal of Marriage and Family48:641–49.
ParsonsTalcott. 1970. Social Structure and Personality. New York: The Free Press.
49.
PescosolidoBernice. 1992. “Beyond Rational Choice: The Social Dynamics of How People Seek Help.” American Journal of Sociology97:1096–1138.
50.
RobertsDorothy. 1997. Killing the Black Body: Race, Reproduction, and the Meaning of Liberty. New York: Pantheon.
51.
SandelowskiMarguerite. 1993. With Child in Mind: Studies of the Personal Encounter with Infertility. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press.
StephenElizabeth H.ChandraAnjani. 2000. “Use of Infertility Services in the United States: 1995.” Family Planning Perspectives32:132–37.
54.
SternAlexandra Minna. 2005. “Sterilized in the Name of Public Health: Race, Immigration, and Reproductive Control in Modern California.” American Journal of Public Health95:1128–38.
55.
StrykerSheldonBurkePeter. 2000. “The Past, Present, and Future of an Identity Theory.” Social Psychology Quarterly63:284–97.
56.
ThomsonElizabeth. 1997. “Couple Childbearing Desires, Intentions, and Births.” Demography34:343–54.
57.
VignolesVivian L.ManziClaudiaRegaliaCamilloJemmoloSimoneScabiniEugenia. 2008. “Identity Motives Underlying Desired and Feared Possible Future Selves.” Journal of Personality76: 1165–1200.
58.
WaggonerMiranda. 2017. The Zero Trimester: Pre-pregnancy Care and the Politics of Reproductive Risk. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
59.
WhiteLynnMcQuillanJuliaGreilArthur L.Johnson.David R.2006. “Infertility: Testing a Helpseeking Model.” Social Science & Medicine62:1031–41.
60.
WhittHugh P.Meile.Richard L.1985. “Alignment, Magnification, and Snowballing: Processes in the Definition of “Symptoms of Mental Illness.” Social Forces63:682–97.
61.
WilsonKristen J.2014. Not Trying: Infertility, Childlessness, and Ambivalence. Nashville, TN: Vanderbilt University Press.
62.
ZolaIrving K.1973. “Pathways to the Doctor: From Person to Patient.” Social Science & Medicine7:677–89.
