In the late 1990s, when otherwise healthy women in Aotearoa New Zealand started to
die as a result of venous thrombosis attributed to third generation oral
contraceptive pills, this contraceptive technology became the subject of media
scrutiny and professional re-investigation. This research utilizes a qualitative
methodology to explore the accounts of a small selection of contraceptive consumers.
Many of this study’s consumers constructed an alternative framing of the
3GOC controversy, which accessed official information (such as medical statistics)
but critically framed these facts by grounding them in relation to how their bodies
reacted to pharmaceuticals. Bricolage is used as a metaphor for thinking about the
ways that women engage in decision-making by creating
‘toolboxes’ from a multitude of readily available material and
information. Lévi-Strauss’s original formulation of bricolage,
in particular the claim that bricoleurs do not create ‘new
knowledge’, is critiqued.
Aggett, M.
(1997)
‘Anatomy of a Decision - Pills Under Scrutiny’
, New Zealand Doctor 25 June:
19-20
.
2.
Arksey, H.
(1994)
‘Expert and Lay Participation in the Construction of Medical Knowledge’
, Sociology of Health and Illness16(4):
448-468
.
3.
Bloemenkamp, K.
,
F. Rosendaal
,
F. Helmerhorst
,
H. Buller
and
J. Vandenbroucke
(1995)
‘Enhancement by Factor V Leiden Mutation of Risk of Deep-vein
Thrombosis Associated with Oral Contraceptive Containing a Third Generation Progestagen’
, Lancet346:
1097-1101
.
4.
Bunkle, P.
(1992) ‘Withdrawal of the Copper 7: The
Regulatory Framework and the Politics of Population Control’,
in
P. Davies
(ed.) For Health or Profit? Medicine, the Pharmaceutical Industry, and
the State in New Zealand.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
5.
Carnell, D.
,
H. Karcher
,
T. Sheldon
,
L. Lie
,
D. Spurgen
and
D. Josefson
(1995)
‘Third Generation Oral Contraceptives - The Controversy’
, British Medical Journal311:
1589-1590
.
6.
Coulter, A.
(1985)
‘Decision-making and the Pill: The Consumer’s View’
, British Journal of Family Planning11:
98-103
.
7.
Denzin, N.K.
and
Y.S. Lincoln
(1994) Handbook of Qualitative Research.
London: Sage
.
8.
Edwards, R.G.
and
J. Cohen
(2000) Human Reproduction Update. Reproductive Choices in
2000: The Relative Safety of Current Oral Contraceptives.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
9.
Egermayer, P.
and
C. Roke
(2000)
‘OCs and the Risk of Thrombosis’
, New Ethicals JournalJanuary:
49-55
.
10.
Farmer, R.
,
R. Newson
,
K. MacRae
,
R. Lawrenson
and
F. Tyrer
(1997)
‘Mortality from Venous Thromboembolism among Young Women in
Europe: No Evidence for any Effect of Third Generation Oral Contraceptives’
, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health51:
630-635
.
11.
Frank, A.
(1995) The Wounded Storyteller: Body, Illness and
Ethics.
Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press
.
12.
Gabe, J.
and
M. Bury
(1996) ‘Risking Tranquillizer Use: Cultural and
Lay Dimensions’, in
S.J. Williams
and
M. Calnan
(eds) Modern Medicine: Lay Perspectives and Experiences.
London: UCL Press
.
13.
Gifford, S.
(1986) ‘The Meaning of Lumps: A Case Study of
the Ambiguities of Risk’, in
C.R. James
,
R. Stall
and
S. Gifford
(eds) Anthropology and Epidemiology: Interdisciplinary Approaches to the
Study of Health and Disease.
Dordrecht: Reidel
.
14.
Grant, E.
(1985) The Bitter Pill: How Safe is the Perfect Contraceptive?Great Britain: Elm Tree Books
.
15.
Greaves, M.
and
D. Tabener
(1996) ‘Thrombotic Disease’,
in
D.J. Weatherall
,
J.G.G. Ledingham
and
D.A. Warrell
(eds) Oxford Textbook of Medicine.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
16.
Griffiths, M.
(1995) Feminisms and the Self: The Web of Identity.
London and New York: Routledge
.
17.
Grimes, D.A.
(1990) ‘Breast Cancer, the Pill and the
Press’, in
R.D. Mann
(ed.) Oral Contraceptives and Breast Cancer: The Implications of the
Present Findings for Informed Consent and Informed Choice.
Carnforth: Parthenon Publishing Group
.
18.
Grosz, E.
(1994) Volatile Bodies: Towards a Corporeal Feminism.
Indianapolis: Indiana University Press
.
19.
Guillemin, M.
(2000)
‘Blood, Bone, Women and HRT: Co-constructions in the Menopause Clinic’
, Australian Feminist Studies15(32):
191-203
.
20.
Hammersley, M.
(1999)
‘Not Bricolage but Boatbuilding: Exploring Two Metaphors for
Thinking about Ethnography’
, Journal of Contemporary Ethnography28(5):
574-585
.
21.
Harthorn, B.
and
L. Oaks
(eds) (2003) Risk, Culture, and Health Inequality.
London: Praeger
.
22.
Hess, D.J.
(1997) Science Studies: An Advanced Introduction.
New York and London: New York University Press
.
23.
Hester, J.S. (2001) ‘Bricolage and Blackboxing: Exploring the
Responses of Consumers and Health Providers to Controversy about the Third
Generation Oral Contraceptive Pill’, unpublished MA Thesis, University of
Canterbury Christchurch, Aotearoa New Zealand.
24.
Jick, H.
,
S. Jick
,
V. Gurewich
,
M. Myers
and
C. Vasilakis
(1995)
‘Risk of Idiopathic Cardiovascular Death and Non-fatal Venous
Thromboembolism in Women Using Oral Contraceptives with Differing
Progestagen Contents’
, Lancet346:
1589-1592
.
25.
Katovich, M.A.
(1995)
‘Couch the Bricoleur: Using Ethnographic and Laboratory
Traditions to Establish Data Careers’
, Symbolic Interaction18(3):
283-301
.
26.
Ketting, E.
(1996)
‘Third Generation Oral Contraceptives: CSM’s Advice
will Harm Women’s Health Worldwide’ [Letter]
, British Medical Journal312(7030):
576
.
27.
Leder, D.
(1990) The Absent Body.
Chicago: University of Chicago Press
.
28.
Ledingham, J.G.C.
and
D.J. Weatherall
(1996) ‘Pulmonary Embolism’,
in
D.J. Weatherall
,
J.G.G. Ledingham
and
D.A. Warrell
(eds) Oxford Textbook of Medicine.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
29.
Lévi-Strauss, C.
(1968) The Savage Mind.
London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson
.
30.
Marks, L.
(1999)
‘Not Just a Statistic: The History of USA and UK Policy over
Thrombotic Disease and the Oral Contraceptive Pill, 1960s-1970s’
, Social Science and Medicine49:
1139-1155
.
31.
Medsafe (New Zealand Medicines and Medical Devices Safety Authority, A
Business Unit of MOH)
(February 1999) Oral Contraceptives and Blood Clots.
Wellington: Medsafe
.
32.
Ministry of Health (MOH)
(1999) Advice For Women about Oral Contraceptives: Consumer
Information.
Wellington: MOH
.
33.
Mol, A.
and
J. Law
(2003)
‘Embodied Action, Enacted Bodies: The Example of
Hypoglycaemia’, special issue, ‘Bodies on Trial’
, Body & Society10(2-3):
43-62
.
34.
Parsons, A.
and
E. Atkinson
(1992)
‘Lay Constructions of Genetic Risk’
, Sociology of Health and Illness14(4):
437-455
.
35.
Pharmac
(1996) Return to Monthly Dispensing.
Wellington: Pharmac
.
36.
Pharmac
(1998) New Zealand Pharmaceutical Schedule.
Wellington: Pharmac
.
37.
Phillimore, P.
and
S. Moffatt
(1994) ‘Discounted Knowledge: Local Experience,
Environmental Pollution and Health’, in
J. Popay
and
G. Williams
(eds) Researching the People’s Health.
New York and London: Routledge
.
38.
Pool, I.
(1999) New Zealand’s Contraceptive
Revolutions.
Hamilton: University of Waikato
.
39.
Preston, L.
(1996)
‘Women and Alcohol: Defining the Problem and Seeking Help’
, International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy16(5):
52-72
.
40.
Sartwell, P.
and
P. Stolley
(1982)
‘Oral Contraceptives and Vascular Disease’
, Epidemiological Reviews4:
95-109
.
41.
Scott, A.
(1997) ‘The Knowledge in Our Bones: Standpoint
Theory, Alternative Health and the Quantum Model of the
Body’, in
M. Maynard
(ed.) Science and the Construction of Women.
London: UCL Press
.
42.
Shildrick, M.
and
J. Price
(1998) Vital Signs: Feminist Reconfigurations of the
Bio/Logical Body.
Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press
.
43.
Spitzer, W.O.
,
M.A. Lewis
,
L. Heinemann
,
M. Thorogood
and
K. MacRae
(1995)
‘Third Generation Oral Contraceptives and Risk of Venous
Thromboembolic Disorders: An International Case Control Study’
, British Medical Journal312:
83-88
.
44.
Stacey, M.
(1994) ‘The Power of Lay
Knowledge’, in
J. Popay
and
G. Williams
(eds) Researching the People’s Health.
London and New York: Routledge
.
45.
Stadel, B.
(1981)
‘Oral Contraceptives and Cardiovascular Disease’
, New England Journal of Medicine305:
612-617
.
46.
Tuckett, D.
,
M. Boulton
,
C. Olson
and
A. Williams
(1985) Meetings Between Experts: An Approach to Sharing Ideas
in Medical Consultations.
London and New York: Tavistock
.
47.
Turkle, S.
and
S. Papert
(1990)
‘Epistemological Pluralism: Styles and Voices within the Computer Culture’
, Signs16(1):
128-157
.
48.
Usher, J.
(1997) Body Talk: The Material and Discursive Regulation of
Sexuality, Madness and Reproduction.
London and New York: Routledge
.
49.
Weinstein, D.
(1991) Heavy Metal: A Cultural Sociology.
New York and Oxford: Lexington
.
50.
Weinstein, D.
and
M.A. Weinstein
(1991)
‘Georg Simmel: Sociological Flaneur Bricoleur’
, Theory, Culture & Society8:
151-168
.
51.
Weinstein, D.
and
M.A. Weinstein
(1993)
‘Postmodernising (Macro)Sociology’
, Sociological Inquiry63(2):
224-238
.
52.
Whiteman, M.
,
Y. Cui
,
J. Flaws
,
P. Langenberg
and
T. Bush
(2000)
‘Media Coverage of Hormone Replacement Therapy and Breast Cancer:
Stop the Presses’
, American Journal of Epidemiology151(11):
592
.
53.
Williams, G.
and
J. Popay
(1994) ‘Lay Knowledge and the Privilege of
Experience’, in
J. Gabe
and
D. Kelleher
(eds) Challenging Medicine.
London and New York: Routledge
.
54.
World Health Organization Collaborative Study of Cardiovascular Disease and
Steroid Hormone Contraception
(1995a)
‘VTE Disease and Combined Oral Contraceptives: Results of an
International Multi-centre Case-control Study’
, Lancet346:
1575-1582
.
55.
World Health Organization Collaborative Study of Cardiovascular Disease and
Steroid Hormone Contraception
(1995b)
‘Effect of Different Progestagens in Low Oestrogen Oral
Contraceptives on Venous Thromboembolic Disease: Results of an International
Multi-centre Case-control Study’
, Lancet346:
1582-1588
.
