Previous research suggests that extracurricular engagement reduces the likelihood of high school dropout, particularly among traditionally at-risk populations such as racial and ethnic minorities and students from low-income families. Using social bond theory, we examine how the breadth and intensity of extracurricular engagement are related to the likelihood of dropout among a nationally representative sample of students over three years of schooling. Using logistic regression models, we use data from the Education Longitudinal Study of 2002 to examine how extracurricular participation relates to the potential of dropping out by accounting for known correlates and potential selection biases. We find a significant positive relationship between engagement in extracurricular activities (both in number and distribution over different types of activities) and a reduced likelihood of dropout. This relationship is particularly strong in the case of athletic involvement among African American students and for students who simultaneously participate in both athletic and academic/fine arts activities. Implications of these findings are discussed in light of current policy trends toward the elimination of extracurricular programming and the assessment of student participation fees.
AgnewRobert. 1991. “A Longitudinal Test of Social Control Theory and Delinquency.” Journal of Research in Crime & Delinquency28(2):126–56.
2.
AgrestiAlan. 1990. Categorical Data Analysis. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
3.
AlexanderKarl L.EntwisleDoris R.HorseyCarrie S.1997. “From First Grade Forward: Early Foundations of High School Dropout.” Sociology of Education70(2):87–107.
4.
AllisonPaul. 1999. “Comparing Logit and Probit Coefficients across Groups.” Sociological Methods & Research28(2):186–208.
ArchambaultIsabelleJanoszMichelFalluJean-SebastienPaganiLinda S.2009. “Student Engagement and Its Relationship with Early High School Dropout.” Journal of Adolescence32(3):651–70.
7.
BarnettLynn A.2008. “Predicting Youth Participation in Extracurricular Recreational Activities: Relationships with Individual, Parent, and Family Characteristics.” Journal of Park and Recreation Administration26:28–60.
8.
Battin-PearsonSaraNewcombMichael D.AbbottRobert D.HillKarl G.CatalanoRichard F.HawkinsJ. David. 2000. “Predictors of Early High School Dropout: A Test of Five Theories.” Journal of Educational Psychology92(3):568–82.
9.
BjerkDavid. 2012. “Re-examining the Impact of Dropping Out on Criminal Labor Outcomes in Early Childhood.” Economics of Education Review31:110–22.
10.
BohnertAmyFredricksJenniferRandallEdin. 2010. “Capturing Unique Dimensions of Youth Organized Activity Involvement Theoretical and Methodological Considerations.” Review of Educational Research80(4):576–610.
11.
BoothJeb A.FarrellAmyVaranoSean P.2008. “Social Control, Serious Delinquency, and Risky Behavior: A Gendered Analysis.” Crime & Delinquency54(3):423–56.
12.
BradleyChristen L.RenzulliLinda A.2011. “The Complexity of Non-completion: Being Pushed or Pulled to Drop Out of High School.” Social Forces90(2):521–45.
13.
BrohBeckett A.2002. “Linking Extracurricular Programming to Academic Achievement: Who Benefits and Why?”Sociology of Education75(1):69–95.
14.
BrownRandallEvansWilliam P.2002. “Extracurricular Activity and Ethnicity: Creating Greater School Connection among Diverse Student Populations.” Urban Education37(1):41–58.
15.
BryanJuliaMoore-ThomasCherylGaenzleStaceyKimJungnamLinChia-HueiNaGoeun. 2012. “The Effects of School Bonding on High School Seniors’ Academic Achievement.” Journal of Counseling & Development90(4):467–80.
16.
BucyMichah. 2013. “The Costs of the Pay-to-play Model in High School Athletics.” University of Maryland Law Journal of Race, Religion, Gender, and Class13(6):278–302.
17.
CamiréMartinTrudelPierreFornerisTanya. 2012. “Coaching and Transferring Life Skills: Philosophies and Strategies Used by Model High School Coaches.” The Sports Psychologist26(2):243–60.
18.
CampbellColin. 2015. “The Socioeconomic Consequences of Dropping Out of High School: Evidence from an Analysis of Siblings.” Social Science Research51(1):108–18.
19.
CherngHua-Yu SebastianTurneyKristinKaoGrace2014. “Less Socially Engaged? Participation in Friendship and Extracurricular Activities among Racial/Ethnic Minority and Immigrant Adolescents.” Teachers College Record116(3):1–28.
20.
CohenDeborah A.TaylorStephanie L.ZontaMichelaVestalKatherine D.SchusterMark A.2007. “Availability of High School Extracurricular Sports and High-risk Behaviors.” Journal of School Health77(2):80–86.
C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital. 2015. National Poll on Children’s Health: Pay-to-play Sports Keeping Some Kids on the Sidelines. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Health System.
23.
DavalosDeana B.ChavezErnest L.GuardiolaRobert J.1999. “The Effects of Extracurricular Activity, Ethnic Identification, and Perception of School on Student Dropout Rates.” Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences21(1):61–77.
24.
De WitteKristofCabusSofieThyssenGeertGrootWimvan den BrinkHenriette Maassen. 2013. “A Critical Review of the Literature on School Dropout.” Educational Research Review10:13–28.
25.
EcclesJacquelynne S.BarberBonnie L.1999. “Student Council, Volunteering, Basketball, or Marching Band: What Kind of Extracurricular Involvement Matters?”Journal of Adolescent Research14(1):10–43.
26.
EderDonnaKinneyDavid A.1995. “The Effects of Middle School Extracurricular Activities on Adolescents Popularity and Peer Status.” Youth & Society26(3):298–324.
EmpeyLamar T.StaffordMark C.1991 [1982, 1978]. American Delinquency: Its Meaning and Construction. 3rd ed.Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing.
29.
EversonHoward T.MillsapRoger E.2005. “Everyone Gains: Extracurricular Activities in High School and Higher SAT Scores.” College Entrance Examination Board, New York.
30.
FairclothBeverly S.HammJill V.2005. “Sense of Belonging among High School Students Representing 4 Ethnic Groups.” Journal of Youth and Adolescence34(4):293–309.
31.
FallAnna-MariaRobertsGreg. 2012. “High School Dropouts: Interactions between Social Context, Self-perceptions, School Engagement, and Student Dropout.” Journal of Adolescence35(4):787–98.
32.
FarbAmy FeldmanMatjaskoJennifer L.2012. “Recent Advances in Research on School-based Extracurricular Activities and Adolescent Development.” Developmental Review32:1–48.
33.
FeldmanAmy F.MatjaskoJennifer L.2005. “The Role of School-based Extracurricular Activities in Adolescent Development: A Comprehensive Review and Future Directions.” Review of Educational Research75(2):159–210.
34.
FinnJeremy D.1989. “Withdrawing from School.” Review of Educational Research59(2):117–42.
35.
FletcherAnne C.ShawRobin A.2000. “Sex Differences in Associations between Parental Behaviors and Characteristics and Adolescent Social Integration.” Social Development9(2):133–48.
36.
FredricksJennifer A.2012. “Extracurricular Participation and Academic Outcomes: Testing the Over-scheduling Hypothesis.” Journal of Youth and Adolescence41(3):295–306.
37.
FredricksJennifer A.EcclesJacquelynne S.2006. “Is Extracurricular Participation Associated with Beneficial Outcomes? Concurrent and Longitudinal Relations.” Developmental Psychology42(4):698–713.
38.
FredricksJennifer A.SimpkinsSandra D.2012. “Promoting Positive Youth Development through Organized After-school Activities: Taking a Closer Look at Participation of Ethnic Minority Youth.” Child Development Perspectives6(3):280–87.
39.
FreudenbergNicholasRuglisJessica. 2007. “Reframing School Dropout as a Public Health Issue.” Preventing Chronic Disease4(4):A107.
40.
GoldschmidtPeteWangJia. 1999. “When Can Schools Affect Dropout Behavior? A Longitudinal Multilevel Analysis.” American Educational Research Journal36(4):715–38.
41.
GuoGuangZhaoHongxin. 2000. “Multilevel Modeling for Binary Data.” Annual Review of Sociology26:441–62.
42.
HarrisLinda. 2013. “The Unrelenting Challenge of Young Black Male Unemployment.” CLASP, Washington, DC. Retrieved March13, 2017 (www.clasp.org).
43.
HirschiTravis. 1969. Causes of Delinquency. Berkley, CA: University of California Press.
44.
HollandAlyceAndreT. Thomas. 1987. “Participation in Extracurricular Activities in Secondary School: What Is Known, What Needs to Be Known?Review of Educational Research57:437–66.
45.
JanoszMichelArchambaultIsabelleMorizotJulienPaganiLinda S.2008. “School Engagement Trajectories and Their Differential Predictive Relations to Dropout.” Journal of Social Issues64:21–40.
46.
JiangXinPegueroAnthony A.2017. “Immigration, Extracurricular Activity, and the Role of Family.” Education and Urban Society49:314–40. doi:10.1177/0013124516643759
47.
KaoGraceThompsonJennifer S.2003. “Racial and Ethnic Stratification in Educational Achievement and Attainment.” Annual Review of Sociology29:417–42.
48.
KaoGraceVaqueraElizabeth. 2006. “The Salience of Racial and Ethnic Identification in Friendship Choices among Hispanic Adolescents.” Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences28:23–47.
49.
KhatiwadaIshwarMcLaughlinJosephSumAndrew. 2007. “The Fiscal Economic Consequences of Dropping Out of High School: Estimates of the Tax Payments and Transfers Received by Massachusetts Adults in Selected Educational Subgroups.” Center for Labor Market Studies, Northeastern University, Boston, MA.
50.
KirshnitCarol E.HamMarkRichardsMaryse H.1989. “The Sporting Life: Athletics Activities during Early Adolescence.” Journal of Youth and Adolescence18:601–15.
51.
LaGrangeRandy L.WhiteHelen R.1985. “Age Differences in Delinquency: A Test of Theory.” Criminology23:19–45.
52.
LangbeinLauraBessRoseana. 2002. “Sports in School: Source of Amity or Antipathy.” Social Science Quarterly83(2):436–54.
53.
LareauAnnette. 2003. Unequal Childhoods: Class, Race, and Family Life. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
54.
LeeValerie E.BurkamDavid T.2003. “Dropping Out of High School: The Role of School Organization and Structure.” American Educational Research Journal40(2):353–93.
55.
LevinHenry M.BelfieldClive R.2007. “Educational Interventions to Raise High School Graduation Rates.” Pp. 177-199 in The Price We Pay: Economic and Social Consequences of Inadequate Education, edited by BelfieldClive R.LevinHenry M.Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
56.
LongJ. ScottFreeseJeremy. 2003. Regression Models for Categorical Dependent Variables Using Stata. College Station, TX: Stata Press.
MacKinnon-SlaneyFiona. 1993. “Theory to Practice in Co-curricular Activities: A New Model for Student Involvement.” College Student Affairs Journal12(2):35–40.
59.
MahoneyJoseph L.2000. “School Extracurricular Activity Participation as a Moderator in the Development of Antisocial Patterns.” Child Development7(2):502–16.
60.
MahoneyJoseph L.CairnsRobert B.1997. “Do Extracurricular Activities Protect against Early School Dropout?”Developmental Psychology33(2):241–53.
61.
MarshHerbertKleitmanSabina. 2002. “Extracurricular School Activities: The Good, the Bad, and the Nonlinear.” Harvard Educational Review72:464–513.
62.
MassoniErin. 2011. “Positive Effects of Extracurricular Activities on Students.” Essai9(1):84–87.
63.
McNealRalph B.1995. “Extracurricular Activities and High School Dropouts.” Sociology of Education68(1):62–80.
64.
McNealRalph B.1997. “High School Dropouts: A Closer Examination of School Effects.” Social Science Quarterly78(1):209–22.
65.
McNealRalph, B.Jr.1998. “High School Extracurricular Activities: Closed Structures and Stratifying Patterns of Participation.” Journal of Educational Research91(3):183–91.
66.
McNealRalph B.1999. “Participation in High School Extracurricular Activities: Investigating School Effects.” Social Science Quarterly80(2):291–309.
67.
MelnickMerrill J.SaboDonald F.1992. “Educational Effects of Interscholastic Athletic Participation on African American and Hispanic Youth.” Adolescence27(106):295–308.
68.
MelnickMerrill J.SaboDonald F.VanfossenBeth1992. “Effects of Interscholastic Athletic Participation on the Social, Educational, and Career Mobility of Hispanic Girls and Boys.” International Review for the Sociology of Sport27(1):57–74.
69.
MoodCarina. 2010. “Logistic Regression: Why We Cannot Do What We Think We Can Do, and What We Can Do about It.” European Sociological Review26(1):67–82.
70.
NewcombMichael D.AbbottRobert D.CatalanoRichard F.HawkinsJ. DavidBattin-PearsonSaraHillKarl. 2002. “Mediational and Deviance Theories of Late High School Failure: Process Roles of Structural Strains, Academic Competence, and General versus Specific Problem Behaviors.” Journal of Counseling Psychology49(2):172–86.
71.
OkamotoDina G.HerdaDanielHartzogCassie. 2013. “Beyond Good Grades: School Composition and Immigrant Youth Participation in Extracurricular Activities.” Social Science Research42(1):155–68.
72.
PaulsenRonnelle. 1991. “Education, Social Class, and Participation in Collective Action.” Sociology of Education64:96–110.
73.
PegueroAnthony A.OvinkSarah M.LiYun Ling. 2016. “Social Bonding to School and Educational Inequality: Race/Ethnicity, Dropping Out, and the Significance of Place.” Sociological Perspectives59(2):317–44.
74.
PegueroAnthony A.Marie PoppT. AnnLatimoreLorraineShekarkharZahraKooDixie. 2011. “Social Control Theory and School Misbehavior: Examining the Role of Race and Ethnicity.” Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice9(3):259–75.
75.
Pennsylvania School Boards Association. 2010. “Special Report on Pay-to-play: Fees for Participation in School Extracurricular Activities.” Pennsylvania School Boards Association: Research and Policy Center, Mechanicsburg, PA.
76.
PoeJohn David. 2013. “Social Science Methods: Clustered Standard Errors for Multilevel Data.” Social Science Methods. Retrieved March13, 2017.
77.
ReesDaniel I.SabiaJoseph J.2010. “Sports Participation and Academic Performance: Evidence from the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health.” Economics of Education Review29:751–59.
78.
RumbergerRussell W.1987. “High School Dropouts: A Review of Issues and Evidence.” Review of Educational Research57(2):101–21.
RumbergerRussell W.LarsonKatherine A.1998. “Student Mobility and the Increased Risk of High School Dropout.” American Journal of Education107(1):1–35.
81.
RyanShannon M.2003. “Fees for Extracurricular Activities Alienate Students Who Would Otherwise Participate and Should Be Replaced with Alternate Means of Fundraising.” Seton Hall Journal of Sport Law13(2):239–60.
82.
SchoggenPhilSchoggenMaxine. 1988. “Student Voluntary Participation and High School Size.” Journal of Educational Research81(5):288–93.
83.
ShoemakerDonald J.2010 [2005, 2000, 1996, 1990, 1984]. Theories of Delinquency: An Examination of Explanations of Delinquent Behavior. 6th ed.Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
84.
ShulrufBoaz. 2010. “Do Extra-curricular Activities in Schools Improve Educational Outcomes? A Critical Review and Meta-analysis of the Literature.” International Review of Education56(5–6):591–612.
SinclairMary F.ChristensonSandra L.LehrCamilla A.AndersonAmy Reschly. 2003. “Facilitating Student Engagement: Lessons Learned from Check & Connect Longitudinal Studies.” The California School Psychologist8:29–42.
87.
SnyderEldon E.SpreitzerElmer. 1990. “High School Athletic Participation as Related to College Attendance among Black, Hispanic, and White Males: A Research Note.” Youth & Society21:390–98.
88.
SnyderEldon E.SpreitzerElmer. 1992. “Social Psychological Components of Adolescents’ Role Identities as Scholars and Athletes: A Longitudinal Analysis.” Youth & Society23(4):507–22.
89.
StaffJeremyKreagerDerek A.2008. “Too Cool for School? Violence, Peer Status, and High School Dropout.” Social Forces87(1):445–71.
ThornberryTerrence P.MooreMelanieChristensonR. L.1985. “The Effect of Dropping Out of High School on Subsequent Criminal Behavior.” Criminology23(1):3–18.
92.
TintoVincent. 1975. “Dropout from Higher Education: A Theoretical Synthesis of Recent Research.” Review of Educational Research45(1):89–125.
93.
U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics. 2011. High School Dropout and Completion Rates in the United States: 1972–2009. NCES 2012-006. Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics.
94.
U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics. 2015. The Condition of Education 2015. NCES 2015-144. Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics.
95.
U.S. Department of Education, Office of Research and Improvement. 1989. Dropout Rates in the United States: 1988. DOE Publication No. NCES-89-609. Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics.
96.
VaqueraElizabethKaoGrace. 2006. “The Implications of Choosing ‘No-race’ on the Salience of Hispanic Identity: How Racial and Ethnic Identification Intersect among Hispanic Adolescents.” The Sociological Quarterly47:375–96.
97.
WesternBrucePettitBecky. 2000. “Incarceration and Racial Inequality in Men’s Employment.” ILR Review54(1):3–16.
98.
WillowerDonald J.1991. “Micropolitics and the Sociology of School Organizations.” Education and Urban Society23(4):442–54.
99.
ZaffJonathon F.MooreKristin A.PapilloAngela RomanoWilliamsStephanie. 2003. “Implications of Extracurricular Activity Participation during Adolescence on Positive Outcomes.” Journal of Adolescent Research18(6):599–630.
