This article considers the philosophical underpinnings that have shadowed the
emergence of focus group methods as a counterpoise to positivist research design.
Examples of the application of focus group methods are drawn from two studies where
the voices of marginalized groups were facilitated: 1) focus groups with patients
diagnosed with personality disorder; and 2) focus groups with gypsy travellers. In
both groups there were varying degrees of coherence in communication although
particular attention here is paid to the role of dissonance and `negative
dialectics' in the formation of opinion. Data generation in focus groups is
considered in relation to group size, structure and clinical techniques.
Appleton, L.
,
Hagan, T.
,
Goward, P.
,
Repper, J.
and
Wilson, R.
(2003)'
Smail's Contribution to Understanding the Needs of the Socially Excluded:
The Case of Gypsy and Traveller Women
', Clinical Psychology24:
40—47
.
2.
Bion, W.R.
(1960) Experiences in Groups.
London : Tavistock
.
3.
Callaghan, J.
,
Young, B.
,
Pace, F.
and
Vostanis, P.
(2003) `
Mental Health Support For Youth Offending Teams: A Qualitative Study
', Health and Social Care in the Community11(1):
55—63
.
4.
Cambridge, P.
and
McCarthy, M.
(2001) `
User Focus Groups and Best Value in Services for People with Learning Disabilities
', Health and Social Care in the Community9(6):
476—89
.
5.
Denzin, N.K.
and
Lincoln, Y.
(eds) (1998) Collecting and Interpreting Qualitative
Materials.
London
and
Thousand Oaks, CA. Sage
.
6.
de Maré, P.
,
Piper, R.
and
Thompson, S.
(1991) Koinonia. From Hate Through Dialogue to Culture in the
Large Group.
London: Karnac
.
7.
DoH
(2003) Personality Disorder: No Longer a Diagnosis of
Exclusion.
London: HMSO
.
8.
Foulkes, S.H.
(1948) Introduction to Group Analytic Psychotherapy.
London: Heinemann
.
9.
Fraser, M.
and
Fraser, A.
(2001) `
Are People with Learning Disabilities able to Contribute to Focus Groups on
Health Promotion?
', Journal of Advanced Nursing33(2):
225—33
.
10.
Gadamer, H.-G.
(1977) Philosophical Hermeneutics (translated and edited by
David E. Linge)Berkeley, CA.: University of California Press
.
11.
Garley, D.
,
Gallop, R.
,
Johnston, N.
and
Pipitone, J.
(1997) `
Children of the Mentally Ill: A Qualitative Focus Group Approach
', Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing4(2):
97—103
.
12.
Gibson, B.
,
Acquah, S.
and
Robinson, P.G.
(2004) `
Entangled Identities and Psychotropic Substance Use
', Sociology of Health and Illness26(5):
597—616
.
13.
Giddens, A.
(1976) New Rules of Sociological Method.
London: Hutchinson
.
14.
Giddens, A.
(1994)
Beyond Right and Left
.
Cambridge, MA
: Polity.
15.
Golding, W.
(1960) Lord of the Flies.
London: Faber
.
16.
Green, J.
(1997) `
Risk and the Construction of Social Identity: Children's Talk about Accidents
', Sociology of Health and Illness19(4):
457—79
.
17.
Greenbaum, T.L.
(1988) The Practical Handbook and Guide to Focus Group
Research.
Lexington, MA: Lexington
.
18.
Grotstein, J.
(2000) `Bion's Transformations in `O' and the Concept of the
`Transcendent Position', in
P. Bion Talamo
,
F. Borgogno
and
S.A. Merciai
(eds), W.R. Bion: Past and Present .
London: Karnac
.
19.
Habermas, J.
(1985) Psychic Thermidor and the Rebirth of Rebellious
Subjectivity in
Bernstein, R J.
(ed.), Habermas and Modernity, pp.
67—77.
Cambridge, MA: Polity Press
.
20.
Habermas, J.
(1992) Post Metaphysical Thinking.
Cambridge, MA: Polity Press
.
21.
Hammersley, M.
(1991) What's Wrong with Ethnography?London: Routledge
.
22.
Higgit, A.
and
Fonagy, P.
(1992) `
Psychotherapy in Borderline and Narcissistic Personality Disorders
', British Journal of Psychiatry161:
23—43
.
23.
Hildebrandt, E.
(1999) `
Focus Groups and Vulnerable Populations: Insight into Client Strengths and
Needs in Complex Community Health Care Environments
', Nursing and Health Care Perspectives20:
256—59
.
24.
Hirschman, A.O.
(1970) Exit, Voice and Loyalty.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
25.
Kenny, A.J.
(2005) `
Interaction in Cyberspace: An Online Focus Group
', Journal of Advanced Nursing49(4):
414—22
.
26.
Kitzinger, J.
(1994) `
The Methodology of Focus Groups: The Importance of Interaction between
Research Participants', Sociology of Illness andHealth16(1):
104—20
.
27.
Kitzinger, J.
(1999) `Focus Groups with Users and Providers of Health
Care' in
C. Pope
and
N. Mayes
(eds), Qualitative Research in Health Care, pp.
20—29.
London: BMJ Books
.
28.
Koppelman, N.F.
and
Bourjolly, J.N.
(2001) `
Conducting Focus Groups with Women with Severe Psychiatric Disabilities: A
Methodological Overview
', Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal25(2):
142—51
.
29.
Kreeger, L.
(ed.) (1975) The Large Group: Dynamics and Therapy.
London: Constable
. Reprinted, 1994.
London: Karnac
.
30.
Krueger, R.A.
(1994) Focus Groups: A Practical Guide For Applied
Research .
London: Sage
.
31.
Krueger, R.A.
(2001) `The Future of Focus Groups', in
M.R. Jalongo
,
G.J. Gerlach
, and
W. Yan
(eds), Research Methods, pp.
111—113.
Guilford, CT: McGraw-Hill
/
Dushkin
.
32.
Lester, H.
and
Tritter, J.Q.
(2005) ` ``
Listen to my Madness'': Understanding the Experiences of People with
Serious Mental Illness
', Sociology of Health and Illness27(5):
649—61
.
33.
Lincoln, Y.S.
(2001) `Engaging Sympathies: Relationships between Action
Research and Social Constructivism', in
Reason, P.
and
Bradbury, H.
(eds), Handbook of Action Research, pp.
124—32.
London: Sage
.
34.
McLafferty, I.
(2004) `
Focus Group Interviews as a Data Collecting Strategy
', Journal of Advanced Nursing48(2):
187—194
.
35.
Mishan, J.
and
Bateman, A.
(1994) `
Group-Analytic Therapy of Borderline Patients in a Day Hospital Setting
', Group Analysis27(4):
483—95
.
36.
Owen, S.
(2001) `
The Practical, Methodological and Ethical Dilemmas of Conducting Focus
Groups with Vulnerable Clients
', Journal of Advanced Nursing36(5):
652—58
.
37.
Perring, C.
,
Willmot, J.
and
Wilson, M.
(1995)
Reshaping the Future
.
London
: Mind.
38.
Rey, H.
( 1994) Universal of Psychoanalysis.
London : Free Association Books
.
39.
Rustin, M.
(2001) `
Looking in the Right Place: Complexity Theory, Psychoanalysis and Infant Observation
', Paper presented at conference: Origins and Evolution of
Attachment Theory and British Object Relations, University of
Virginia, Charlottesville. 5—8 April.
40.
Stacey, R.
(2001) `Complexity at the Edge of the Basic Assumption
Group', in
Gould, L.
,
Stapley, L.F.
and
Stein, M.
(eds), The Systems of Psychodynamics of Organizations , pp.
91—114.
London: Karnac
.
41.
Webb, C.
and
Kevern, J.
(2001) `
Focus Groups as a Research Method: A Critique of Some Aspects of their Use
in Nursing Research
', Journal of Advanced Nursing33(6):
798—805
.
42.
Winship, G.
(2000) `
Jury Deliberation: An Observation Research Study
', Group Analysis33(4):
547—57
.
