As trust in the validity of forest carbon credits decreases, a market for high integrity forest carbon credits is emerging in Central Appalachia, a region known for its vast natural resources and fundamentally shaped by their extraction. This market is also emerging in the context of a just transition away from fossil fuels (just according to whom?) that have historically supported the region’s economy. This paper situates the initial contours and outcomes of the Family Forest Carbon Program, a joint project by The Nature Conservancy and the American Forest Foundation, as either contributing to yet another round of capitalist accumulation – accumulation by transition – or representing an opportunity for genuine socioecological transformation. Utilizing a speculative political ecology approach and a combination of power mapping, archival analysis, site visits, and semi-structured interviews, this paper identifies three themes, or conjunctures, that can be understood as chances to either continue historical patterns of dispossession or potentially disrupt them: addressing histories of unequal land ownership; identifying and avoiding processes of primitive accumulation; and determining who is ultimately benefiting from the forest carbon economy.
Appalachian Land Ownership Task Force (1983) Who Owns Appalachia? Landownership and Its Impact. The University of Kentucky Press.
6.
Avila-CaleroS (2017) Contesting energy transitions: Wind power and conflicts in the Isthmus of Tehuantepec. Journal of Political Ecology24(1): 992–1012.
BraunB (2015) From critique to experiment? Rethinking political ecology for the Anthropocene. In: PerreaultTBridgeGMcCarthyJ (eds) The Routledge Handbook of Political Ecology. Routledge, pp.102–114.
9.
BridgeG (2011) Resource geographies 1: Making carbon economies, old and new. Progress in Human Geography36(6): 820–824.
10.
BridgeGMcCarthyJPerraultT (2015) Editors’ introduction. In: PerreaultTBridgeGMcCarthyJ (eds) The Routledge Handbook of Political Ecology. Routledge, pp.3–18.
11.
BryantG (2019) Carbon Markets in a Climate-Changing Capitalism. Cambridge University Press.
12.
CamargoJ (2021) Is health a just transition issue? Cross-cutting multiple crisis: Economic, unemployment, climate and healthcare. In: FihloWLVidalDGDinisMAP, et al. (eds) Sustainable Policies and Practices in Energy, Environment and Health Research. Springer, pp.609–623.
13.
Carbon Pulse (2025) Finite Carbon hit by mass layoffs as new owner restructures operations. Carbon Pulse. Available at: https://carbon-pulse.com/376442/ (accessed 9 June 2025).
CummingLHawkinsJSminchakJ, et al. (2019) Researching candidate sites for a carbon storage complex in the Central Appalachian Basin, USA. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control88: 168–181.
16.
DaltonCMason-DeeseL (2012) Counter (mapping) actions: Mapping as militant research. ACME: An International Journal for Critical Geographies11(3): 439–466.
EkersMPrudhamS (2017) The socioecological fix: Fixed capital, metabolism, and hegemony. Annals of the American Association of Geographers108(1): 17–34.
20.
EllerRD (1982) Miners, Millhands, and Mountaineers: Industrialization of the Appalachian South, 1880-1930. University of Tennessee Press.
21.
Family Forest Carbon Program (2025) Homepage. Family Forest Carbon Program. Available at: https://familyforestcarbon.org/ (accessed 9 June 2025).
22.
FearnG (2024) The end of the experiment? The energy crisis, neoliberal energy, and the limits to a socio-ecological fix. Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space7(1): 212–223.
FordS (2024) Subsurface power: How mineral rights are hidden and how to uncover them. ACME: An International Journal for Critical Geographies23(5): 338–355.
GilmoreRW (2007) Golden Gulag: Prisons, Surplus, Crisis, and Opposition in Globalizing California. University of California Press.
27.
HarrisDMMcCarthyJ (2020) Revisiting power and powerlessness: Speculating on West Virginia’s energy future and the externalities of the socioecological fix. Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space4(3): 915–939.
28.
HarrisDMMcCarthyJ (2023) A just transition to what, for whom, and by what means? Transition technology, carbon markets, and an Appalachian coal mine. Energy Research & Social Science106: 103307.
29.
HarrisDMMulleniteJ (2024) Ruins and ruination in political ecology: An introduction to the special issue. Capitalism Nature Socialism35(1): 4–11.
30.
HarrisDMSantosD (2023) A case for experimental and speculative political ecologies. Journal of Political Ecology30(1): 524–541.
31.
HarveyD (2001) Globalization and the ‘spatial fix’. Geographische Revue8: 23–30.
32.
HarveyD (2004) The new imperialism: Accumulation by dispossession. Socialist Regsiter40: 63–87.
33.
HeffronRJMcCauleyD (2018) What is the ‘just transition’?Geoforum88: 74–77.
34.
HollimanACollinsK (2023) California’s cap-and-trade program: Is it effective in advancing social, economic, and environmental equity?Public Administration and Policy26(2): 128–141.
KaljonenMKortetmäkiTTribaldosT (2023) Introduction to the special issue on just food system transition: Tackling inequalities for sustainability. Environmental Innovations and Societal Transitions46: 100688.
37.
KarplusVJIacobIMooreEJ, et al. (2024) Risks in the design of regional hydrogen hub systems: A review and commentary. Risk Analysis45(3): 581–599.
38.
KayK (2017a) A hostile takeover of nature? Placing value in conservation finance. Antipode50(1): 164–183.
39.
KayK (2017b) Rural rentierism and the financial enclosure of main’s open lands tradition. Annals of the American Association of Geographers107(6): 1407–1423.
40.
KinchyALehmanJ (2025) Not your grandpa’s energy system? Fossil fuel inheritances in the decarbonization of industrial geographies. Energy Research & Social Science127: 104238.
LaneRNewellP (2016) The political economy of carbon markets. In: Van de GraafTSovacoolBKGhoshA, et al. (eds) The Palgrave Handbook of the International Political Economy of Energy. Palgrave Macmillan, pp.247–267.
LoK (2024) The politics of just transition: Authoritarian environmentalism and implementation flexibility in forest conservation. Political Geography109: 103066.
45.
LoperenaCA (2017) Settler violence?: Race and emergent frontiers of progress in Honduras. American Quarterly69(4): 801–807.
46.
McCarthyJ (2015) A socioecological fix to capitalist crisis and climate change? The possibilities and limits of renewable energy. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space47(12): 2485–2502.
47.
McEnally to Willey (1864) Waitman T Willey Papers. Box 2, Folder 11 – 578. West Virginia & Regional History Center at West Virginia University.
48.
MalmA (2016) Fossil Capital: The Rise of Steam Power and the Roots of Global Warming. Verso.
49.
MartinW (2023) AFF announces new strategic direction. Woodland: A Publication of the American Forest Foundation11(1): 6–7.
50.
MarxK (1990) Capital Volume I. Penguin Classics.
51.
MasonOSarmaJSidawayJD, et al. (2023) Interventions in walking methods in political geography. Political Geography106: 102937.
MillsS (2013) Cultural-historical geographies of the archive: Fragments, objects and ghosts. Geography Compass7(10): 701–713.
54.
NewellPBoykoffMBoydE (2012) The New Carbon Economy: Constitution, Governance and Contestation. Wiley-Blackwell.
55.
NewellPMulvaneyD (2013) The political economy of the ‘just transition’. The Geographical Journal179(2): 132–140.
56.
NicholsTS (1962) Real property taxation of divided interests. University of Kansas Law Review11: 309.
57.
PatelRMooreJW (2018) A History of the World in Seven Cheap Things: A Guide to Capitalism, Nature, and the Future of the Planet. University of California Press.
RighettiTK (2020) Liberating split estates. International Journal of the Commons14(1): 638–649.
62.
RignallKE (2015) Solar power, state power, and politics of energy transition in pre-Saharan Morocco. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space48(3): 540–557.
63.
RobertsonM (2012) Measurement and alienation: Making a world of ecosystem services. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers37(3): 386–401.
64.
RobertsonMBenDorTKLaveR, et al. (2014) Stacking ecosystem services. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment12(3): 186–193.
65.
RobertsonMM (2004) The neoliberalization of ecosystem services: Wetland mitigation banking and problems in environmental governance. Geoforum35(3): 361–373.
66.
RosembergA (2013) Developing global environmental union policies through the International Trade Union Confederation. In: RäthzelNUzzelD (eds) Trade Unions in the Green Economy. Routledge, pp.15–28.
67.
RuscaMHarrisDMSantosD (2024) Experimental and speculative political ecologies for an age of crisis, hope, and action. Progress in Environmental Geography3(4): 374–395.
68.
SaitoK (2021) Primitive accumulation as the cause of economic and ecological disaster. In: MustoM (ed.) Rethinking Alternatives with Mark. Palgrave MacMillan, pp.93–112.
ScheptJ (2022) Coal, Cages, Crisis: The Rise of the Prison Economy in Central Appalachia. New York University Press.
72.
SchrammE (2023) Examining the role of minor experiments in French and Catalan eco-communities: Between critique and post-capitalist world-building. Journal of Political Ecology30(1): 558–580.
73.
SchwartzmanG (2022) Climate rentierism after coal: Forests, carbon offsets, and post-coal politics in the Appalachian coalfields. The Journal of Peasant Studies49(5): 924–944.
74.
ScottRR (2010) Removing Mountains: Extracting Nature and Identity in the Appalachian Coalfields. University of Minnesota Press.
75.
ScottS (2008) The Appalachian land ownership study revisited. Appalachian Journal35(3): 236–252.
76.
ShadeLVan SantL (2023) Geographies of land ownership change in the rural United States: Challenges, methods, and possibilities. The Professional Geographer75(5): 844–854.
77.
SlovinskyKJohnsonJ (2025) LiKEN Martin County Land Study, ASA Draft edn. LiKEN Knowledge.
78.
SovacoolBKDunlapAANovakovićB (2025) When decarbonization reinforces colonization: Complex energy injustice and solar development in the California desert. Annals of the American Association of Geographers115(3): 640–670.
79.
SuellDT (2022) The creation of capitalist time: Rethinking primitive accumulation through conservation. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space40(5): 881–899.
80.
TernesVMardsenGHarrisonG (2024) A just transition or just a transition? The understanding and relevance of fairness in planning for a decarbonised transport system. Energy Research & Social Science113: 103549.
ThomasA (2021) Framing the just transition: How international trade unions engage with climate negotiations. Global Environmental Change70: 102347.
83.
ThompsonEP (1975) Whigs and Hunters: The Origins of the Black Act. Penguin Books.
84.
van den BoldM (2021) In pursuit of diverse energy futures: The political economy of electricity in Senegal. Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space5(4) 1807–1830.
WangXLoK (2021) Just transition: A conceptual review. Energy Research & Social Science82: 102291.
88.
WeiseR (1995) Property, gender, and the sale of mineral rights in pre-industrial Eastern Kentucky. Journal of Appalachian Studies7: 79–90. Available at: https://www.jstor.org/stable/41445682 (accessed 12 October 2025).
WhiteD (2020) Just transitions/design for transitions: Preliminary notes on a design politics for a green new deal. Capitalism Nature Socialism31(2): 20–39.
