This paper compares changing patterns of science news over a period of 50 years. The
study analyses a biannual corpus of 2800 news articles in Britain (the Daily
Telegraph) and 5800 in Bulgaria (Rabotnichesko Delo), and shows
divergent and convergent trends. Britain carries considerably more science news than
Bulgaria all through the period, while the coverage shows parallel swings:
increasing intensity during the 1950s, a turning point in the early 1960s, declining
into the 1970s, and rising again in the 1980s and 1990s. Media coverage in both
countries shows similar swings in public appeal. The trends in the medicalization of
science news, the reporting of controversy and the evaluation of science diverge in
the two contexts. The paper concludes with speculative explanations of these
results. Similarities and differences in these long-term trends point to common
factors and specific differences at work on either side of the (former)
‘Iron Curtain’.
Bauer, Martin
(1998a)
‘The Medicalisation of Science News: From
“Rocket-Scalpel” to the
“Gene-Meteorite” Complex’
, Social Science Information37(4):
731-751
.
2.
Bauer, Martin (1998b) ‘La “Longue Duree” of
Popular Science, 1830-Present’, in D. Deveze-Berthet (ed.), La
Promotion de la Culture Scientifique et Technique: Ses Acteurs et leurs Logic,
Actes du Colloque (12 et 13 décembre 1996): 75-92.
3.
Bauer, Martin W.
(2000a) ‘Classical Content Analysis - A
Review’, in
M.W. Bauer
&
G. Gaskell
(eds), Qualitative Researching with Text, Image and Sound. A Practical
Handbook (
London: SAGE Publications
): 131-151.
4.
Bauer, Martin
(2000b) ‘“Science in the
Media” as Cultural Indicator: Contextualising Surveys with Media
Analysis’, in
M. Dierkes
&
C. von Grote
(eds), Between Understanding and Trust: The Public, Science and
Technology (
Reading, Berks.: Harwood Academic Publishers
): 157-178.
5.
Bauer, Martin W.
(2002a)
‘Arenas, Platforms and the Biotechnology Movement’
, Science Communication24(2):
144-161
.
6.
Bauer, Martin W.
(2002b)
‘Controversial Medical and Agri-food Biotechnology: A Cultivation Analysis’
, Public Understanding of Science2(11):
1-19
.
7.
Bauer, Martin W.
(2005)
‘Distinguishing RED and GREEN Biotechnology: Cultivation Effects
of the Elite Press’
, International Journal of Public Opinion Research17(1):
63-89
.
8.
Bauer, Martin W.
&
George Gaskell
(1999)
‘Towards a Paradigm for Research on Social Representations’
, Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour29(2):
163-185
.
9.
Bauer, Martin W.
&
George Gaskell
(eds) (2002) Biotechnology: The Making of a Global
Controversy (
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
).
10.
Bauer, Martin
,
John Durant
&
Geoff Evans
(1994)
‘European Public Perceptions of Science’
, International Journal of Public Opinion Research6:
163-186
.
11.
Bauer, Martin
,
John Durant
,
Agnes Ragnarsdottir
&
Annadis Rudolfsdottir
(1995) Science and Technology in the British Press,
1946-1990, Volumes 1-4 (
London: The Science Museum & Wellcome Trust
).
12.
Bauer, Martin W.
,
Matthias Kohring
,
Agnes Allansdottir
&
Jan Gutteling
(2001) ‘The Dramatisation of Biotechnology in
the Elite Mass Media’, in
G. Gaskell
&
M.W. Bauer
(eds), Biotechnology, 1996-2000: The Years of Controversy (
London: Science Museum
): 35-52.
13.
Baylis, John
(1997) Anglo-American Relations Since 1939: The Enduring
Alliance (
Manchester: Manchester University Press
).
14.
Beck, Ulrich
(1991) Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity. (
London: SAGE Publications
).
15.
Burke, Kenneth
(1945) A Grammar of Motives (
Berkeley, CA: University of California Press
).
16.
Childs, David
(1992) Britain Since 1945: A Political History (
London: Routledge
).
17.
Cohen, Bernard C.
(1963) The Press and Foreign Policy (
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
).
18.
Crampton, Richard J.
(1997) A Concise History of Bulgaria (
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
).
19.
Dainton, Lord
(1971) The Future of the Research Council System (The Dainton
Report), Cmnd 4814 (
London: H.M. Stationery Office
).
20.
Dasgupta, Partha
&
Paul A. David
(1994)
‘Toward a New Economics of Science’
, Research Policy23:
487-521
.
21.
Doran, Christopher
(1990)
‘Some Problems in Conceptualising the Issue of “Science
and the Media”’
, Critical Studies in Mass Communication7:
48-71
.
22.
Durant, J.
,
M. Bauer
,
C. Midden
,
G. Gaskell
&
M. Liakopoulos
(2000) ‘Two Cultures of Public Understanding of
Science’, in
M. Dierkes
&
C. von Grote
(eds), Between Understanding and Trust: The Public, Science and
Technology (
Reading, Berks.: Harwood
): 131-156.
23.
Entman, Robert M.
(1993)
‘Framing: Toward Clarification of a Fractured Paradigm’
, Journal of Communication43:
51-58
.
24.
Gamson, William A.
&
Andre Modigliani
(1989)
‘Media Discourse and Public Opinion on Nuclear Power: A
Constructionist Approach’
, American Journal of Sociology95:
1-37
.
25.
Habermas, Jurgen
(1989 [1962]) The Transformation of the Public Sphere (
Cambridge: Polity Press
).
26.
Hansen, Anders
(1994)
‘Journalistic Practices and Science Reporting in the British Press’
, Public Understanding of Science3:
111-134
.
27.
Hilgartner, Stephen
&
Charles L. Bosk
(1988)
‘The Rise and Fall of Social Problems: A Public Arena Model’
, American Journal of Sociology94:
53-78
.
28.
Hoffmann, Eric P.
&
Robbin F. Laird
(1982) The Scientific-Technological Revolution and Soviet
Foreign Policy (
New York: Pergamon Press
).
29.
Holsti, Ole R.
(1969) Content Analysis for the Social Sciences and
Humanities (
Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley
).
30.
House of Lords
(2000) Science and Society: Third Report by the Select
Committee to Consider Science and Technology (
London: H.M. Stationery Office
).
31.
Imhof, Kurt, Heinz Kleger & Gaetano Romano (eds) (1993) Krise und
Sozialer Wandel. Band 1: Zwischen Konflikt und Konkordanz. Analyse von
Medienereignissen in der Schweiz der Vor- und Zwischenkriegszeit (Z
ürich: Seismo Verlag).
32.
Irwin, Alan
&
Brian Wynne
(eds) (1996) Misunderstanding Science? The Public
Reconstruction of Science and Technology (
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
).
33.
Kepplinger, H. Matthias
(1989) Kunestliche Horizonte. Folgen, Darstellung und
Akzeptanz von Technik in der Bundesrepublik (
Frankfurt: Campus
).
34.
Krippendorff, Klaus
(1980) Content Analysis: An Introduction to its
Methodology (
London: SAGE Publications
).
35.
LaFollette, Marcel C.
(1990) Making Science Our Own: Public Images of Science
1910-1955 (
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
).
36.
Lewenstein, Bruce
(1995) ‘Science and the
Media’, in
S. Jasanoff
,
J. Petersen
,
G. Markle
&
T. Pinch
(eds), Handbook of Science and Technology Studies (
Beverly Hills, CA: SAGE Publications
).
37.
Maddison, Angus
(1998) Monitoring the World Economy, 1820-1992 (
Paris: OECD
).
38.
Moscovici, Serge (1976) La Psychanalyse - Son Image et Son Public
(Paris: PUF [abridged and revised edition of 1961]).
39.
Neidhardt, Friedhelm
(1993)
‘The Public as a Communication System’
, Public Understanding of Science2:
339-350
.
40.
Nelkin, Dorothy
(1987) Selling Science: How the Press Covers Science and
Technology (
New York: W.H. Freeman
).
41.
Osgood, Charles E.
,
George J. Suci
&
Percy H. Tannenbaum
(1957) The Measurement of Meaning (
Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press
).
42.
Petkova, Kristina
,
Tsocho Boyadjiev
,
Ivan Tchalakov
,
Galin Gornev
&
Martin Bauer
(1997) ‘Scientific Institutions in a Society of
Transition: Strategies of Modernisation’. Project Report to the
Central European University, Soros-Foundation
(Sofia/London, June [RSS/HESB 634/1995]).
43.
Reynolds, David
(1988-89)
‘Rethinking the Anglo-American Relations’
, International Affairs65:
89-111
.
44.
Rothschild, Lord
(1971) The Organisation and Management of R&D
(The Rothschild Report), Cmnd 4184 (
London: H.M. Stationery Office
)
45.
Royal Society
(1985) Public Understanding of Science (
London: Royal Society
).
46.
Rubinstein, Modest I.
(1954) Soviet Science and Technique in the Service of
Building Communism in the USSR (
Moscow: Foreign Language Publishing House
).
47.
Sampson, Anthony
(2004) Who Runs this Place? Britain in the 21st Century (
London: John Murray
).
48.
Scheufele, Dietram A.
(1999)
‘Framing as a Theory of Media Effects’
, Journal of Communication49:
103-121
.
49.
Seymore-Ure, Colin
(1994) The British Press and Broadcasting since 1945 (
Oxford: Blackwell
).
50.
Spasova, Maria
&
Dimitar Ivanchev
(eds) (1975) Bulgarian Press, 1944-1969 (
Sofia: National Library Cyril and Methodius Press
).
51.
Tunstall, Jeremy
(1987) The Media in Britain (
London: Constable
).
52.
Tunstall, Jeremy
(1996) Newspaper Power: The New National Press in
Britain (
Oxford: Oxford University Press
).
53.
Wilkie, Tom
(1991) British Science and Politics since 1945 (
Oxford: Blackwell
).
54.
Woolley, John T.
(2000)
‘Using Media-Based Data in Studies of Politics’
, American Journal of Political Science44(1):
156-173
.
55.
Yahiel, Niko
(1997) Todor Zhivkov and Personal Power (Todor Zhivkov i
lichnata vlast). (
Sofia: M & M Publishers
).
