The objective of the study was to assess the efficacy of surgical resection of solitary brain metastasis in patients with non-small-cell lung cancer.
Methods and Study Design
We report a retrospective analysis of 32 patients with single brain metastasis surgically excised at our hospital. All but one patient underwent postoperative whole brain radiation therapy.
Results
The median survival of patients was 12.5 months postoperatively (mean, 17 months), and the overall 1-year survival was 53%. Thirteen patients had recurrence of brain metastasis: 6 of 13 underwent reoperation for the recurrent lesion, and 1 of the 6 patients had a third craniotomy. Baseline characteristics, which significantly influenced survival, included age less than 60 years, tumor histology (ie, adenocarcinoma), and treatment of the primary lung cancer. The analysis did not yield any significant differences between treatment modalities.
Conclusions
Our findings correspond well with those reported in the literature and suggest that surgical resection of single brain metastasis in patients with non-small cell lung cancer can improve survival over conservative management. Furthermore, surgical treatment of the primary tumor and the single brain metastasis, combined or not with radiotherapy and chemotherapy, represents an approach that merits further investigation with more patients and a prospective longitudinal design.
KellyK., BunnP.A.Jr.: Is it time to reevaluate our approach to the treatment of brain metastases in patients with non-small cell lung cancer?Lung Cancer,20: 85–91, 1998.
2.
DelattreJ.Y., KrolG., ThalerH.T., PosnerJ.B.: Distribution of brain metastases.Arch Neurol,45: 741–744, 1988.
3.
BlackP.: Brain metastasis: current status and recommended guidelines for management.Neurosurgery,5: 617–631, 1979.
HsiungC.Y., LeungS.W., WangC.J., LoS.K., ChenH.C., SunL.M., FangF.M.: The prognostic factors of lung cancer patients with brain metastases treated with radiotherapy.J Neurooncol,36: 71–77, 1998.
7.
MontanaG.S., MeachamW.F., CaldwellW.L.: Brain irradiation for metastatic disease of lung origin.Cancer,29: 1477–1480, 1972.
8.
SneedP.K., LarsonD.A., WaraW.M.: Radiotherapy for cerebral metastases.Neurosurg Clin N Am,7: 505–515, 1996.
9.
SundströmJ.T., MinnH., LertolaK.K., NordmanE.: Prognosis of patients treated for intracranial metastases with whole-brain irradiation.Ann Med,30: 296–299, 1998.
10.
FriedB.M., BuckleyR.C.: Primary carcinoma of the lungs.IV. Intracranial metastases. Arch Pathol,9: 483–527, 1930.
11.
NoordijkE.M., VechtC.J., Haaxma-ReicheH., PadbergG.W., VoormolenJ.H., HoekstraF.H., TansJ.T., LambooijN., MetsaarsJ.A., WattendorffA.R.: The choice of treatment of single brain metastasis should be based on extracranial tumor activity and age.Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys,29: 711–717, 1994.
12.
PatchellR.A., TibbsP.A., WalshJ.W., DempseyR.J., MaruyamaY., KryscioR.J., MarkesberyW.R., MacdonaldJ.S., YoungB.: A randomized trial of surgery in the treatment of single metastases to the brain.N Engl J Med,322: 494–500, 1990.
13.
VechtC.J., Haaxma-ReicheH., NoordijkE.M., PadbergG.W., VoormolenJ.H., HoekstraF.H., TansJ.T., LambooijN., MetsaarsJ.A., WattendorffA.R.: Treatment of single brain metastasis: radiotherapy alone or combined with neurosurgery?Ann Neurol,33: 583–590, 1993.
14.
SauseW.T., CrowleyJ.J., MorantzR., RotmanM., MowryP.A., BouzaglouA., BorstJ.R., SelinH.: Solitary brain metastasis: results of an RTOG/SWOG protocol evaluation surgery + RT versus RT alone.Am J Clin Oncol,13: 427–432, 1990.
15.
MintzA.H., KestleJ., RathboneM.P., GasparL., HugenholtzH., FisherB., DuncanG., SkingleyP., FosterG., LevineM.: A randomized trial to assess the efficacy of surgery in addition to radiotherapy in patients with a single cerebral metastasis.Cancer,78: 1470–1476, 1996.
16.
WeberF., RiedelA., KoningW., MenzelJ.: The role of adjuvant radiation and multiple resection within the surgical management of brain metastases.Neurosurg Rev,19: 23–32, 1996.
HazukaM.B., BurlesonW.D., StroudD.N., LeonardC.E., LilleheiK.O., KinzieJ.J.: Multiple brain metastases are associated with poor survival in patients treated with surgery and radiotherapy.J Clin Oncol,11: 369–373, 1993.
19.
NakagawaH., MiyawakiY., FujitaT., KuboS., TokiyoshiK., TsuruzonoK., KodamaK., HigashiyamaM., DoiO., HayakawaT.: Surgical treatment of brain metastases of lung cancer: retrospective analysis of 89 cases.J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry,57: 950–956, 1994.
20.
PostmusP.E., SmitE.F.: Chemotherapy for brain metastases of lung cancer: a review.Ann Oncol,10: 753–759, 1999.
21.
ColleoniM., GraiffC., NelliP., VicarioG., SgarbossaG., PancheriF., ManenteP.: Activity of combination chemotherapy in brain metastases from breast and lung adenocarcinoma.Am J Clin Oncol,20: 303–307, 1997.
22.
AndrewsR.J., GluckD.S., KonchingeriR.H.: Surgical resection of brain metastases from lung cancer.Acta Neurochir,138: 382–389, 1996.
23.
CatinellaF.P., KittleC.F., FaberL.P., MilloyF.J., WarrenW.H., Von RoennK.A.: Surgical treatment of primary lung cancer and solitary intracranial metastasis.Chest,95: 972–975, 1989.
24.
ChidelM.A., SuhJ.H., GreskovichJ.F., KupelianP.A., BarnettG.H.: Treatment outcome for patients with primary non-small cell lung cancer and synchronous brain metastasis.Radiat Oncol Invest,7: 313–319, 1999.
25.
MacchiariniP., BuonaguidiR., HardinM., MussiA., AngelettiC.A.: Results and prognostic factors of surgery in the management of non-small cell lung cancer with solitary brain metastasis.Cancer,68: 300–304, 1991.
26.
ReadR.C., BoopW.C., YoderG., SchaeferR.: Management of non-small cell lung carcinoma with solitary brain metastasis.J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg,98: 884–890, 1989.
27.
MagilliganD., DuvernoyC., MalikG., LewisJ.W., KnightonR., AusmanJ.I.: Surgical approach to lung cancer with solitary cerebral metastasis: twenty-five years’ experience.Ann Thorac Surg,42: 360–364, 1986.
28.
SalvatiM., CervoniL., DelfiniR.: Solitary brain metastases from non-oat cell lung cancer: clinical and prognostic features.Neurosurg Rev,19: 221–225, 1996.
29.
SundaresanN., GalicichJ., BeattieE.: Surgical treatment of brain metastases from lung cancer.J Neurosurg,58: 666–671, 1983.
30.
WronskiM.: Surgical treatment of brain metastases from non-microcellular lung cancer.Neurol Neurochir Pol,26: 837–844, 1992.
31.
BurtM., WronskiM., ArbitE., GalicichJ.H.: Resection of brain metastases from non-small-cell lung carcinoma: results of therapy.J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg,103: 399–410, 1992.
32.
MandellL., HilarisB., SullivanM., SundaresanN., NoriD., KimJ.H., MartiniN., FuksZ.: The treatment of single brain metastasis from non-oat cell lung carcinoma: surgery and radiation versus radiation therapy alone.Cancer,58: 641–649, 1986.
33.
SundaresanN., GalicichJ.H.: Surgical treatment of brain metastases: clinical and computerized tomography evaluation of the results of treatment.Cancer,55: 1382, 1985.
34.
SundaresanN., GalicichJ.H.: Surgical treatment of single brain metastases from non-small cell lung cancer.Cancer Invest,3: 207, 1985.
35.
PatchellR.A., TibbsP.A., RegineW.F., DempseyR.J., MohiuddinM., KryscioR.J., MarkesberyW.R., FoonK.A., YoungB.: Post-operative radiotherapy in the treatment of single metastases to the brain.JAMA,280: 1485–1489, 1998.
36.
YoungR.F.: Radiosurgery for the treatment of brain metastases.Semin Surg Oncol,14: 70–78, 1998.
37.
BindalA.K., BindalR.K., HessK.R., ShiuA., HassenbuschS.J., ShiW.M., SawayaR.: Surgery versus radiosurgery in the treatment of brain metastasis.J Neurosurg,84: 748–754, 1996.
38.
ShinouraN., YamadaR., OkamotoK., NakamuraO., ShitaraN.: Local recurrence of metastatic brain tumor after stereotactic radiosurgery or surgery plus radiation.J Neurooncol,60: 71–77, 2002.
39.
AlexanderE., MoriartyT.M., DavisR.B., WenP.Y., FineH.A., BlackP.M., KooyH.M., LoefflerJ.S.: Stereotactic radiosurgery for the definitive, noninvasive treatment of brain metastases.J Natl Cancer Inst,87: 34–40, 1995.
40.
MuacevicA., KrethF.W., HorstmannG.A., Schmid-ElsaesserR., WowraB., SteigerH.J., ReulenH.J.: Surgery and radiotherapy compared with gamma knife radiosurgery in the treatment of solitary cerebral metastases of small diameter.J Neurosurg,91: 35–43, 1999.
41.
MehtaM., NoyesW., CraigB., LamondJ., AuchterR., FrenchM., JohnsonM., LevinA., BadieB., RobbinsI., KinsellaT.: A cost-effectiveness and cost-utility analysis of radiosurgery versus resection for single-brain metastases.Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys,39: 445–454, 1997.
42.
RutiglianoM.J., LunsfordL.D., KondziolkaD., StraussM., KhannaV., GreenM.: The cost effectiveness of stereotactic radiosurgery versus surgical resection in the treatment of solitary metastatic brain tumors.Neurosurgery,37: 445–455, 1995.
43.
SawayaR.: Approaches to the surgical management of metastatic brain disease: when to do what.Proc ASCO, Clinical Practice Forum, Orlando, FL, November 3–6, 2000, pp 25–28.
44.
SauseW.T.: Metastatic disease to the brain.Proc ASCO, Clinical Practice Forum, Orlando, FL, November 3–6, 2000, pp 29–31.
