Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2026-3
The effect of social exclusion and aggregation on firm performance: Empirical evidence from entrepreneurial teams managed by minority Italian entrepreneurs
Minority entrepreneurs, belonging to marginalised communities/groups, are at risk of experiencing social exclusion, that is, being outside the dominant social group. Whether this is structural – due to unintended events – or intentional – due to explicit choices, they struggle to escape their situation; for example, by creating direct ties with other members of the same community/group (aggregation). Focusing on social exclusion and aggregation, this article asks the following research question: whether and to what extent does social exclusion and aggregation experienced by entrepreneurial teams affect the performance of startups launched by minority entrepreneurs. Based on data retrieved from the Italian Ministry of Enterprises and Made in Italy website on 11,985 entrepreneurial firms, stochastic frontier analyses reveal that minority entrepreneurs’ aggregation improves the performance of their startups. Trust and reciprocity have a positive impact on performance, but they may fuel even greater social exclusion. This creates several implications for entrepreneurs, policymakers and scholars.
AcheampongAOAdebayoTSDzatorJ, et al (2023) Income inequality and economic growth in BRICS: Insights from non-parametric techniques. The Journal of Economic Inequality21: 619–640.
2.
AhujaG (2000) Collaboration networks, structural holes, and innovation: A longitudinal study. Administrative Science Quarterly45: 425–455.
3.
AignerDLovellCSchmidtP (1977) Formulation and estimation of stochastic frontier production function models. Journal of Econometrics6: 21–37.
4.
AldrichHEKimPH (2007) Small worlds, infinite possibilities? How social networks affect entrepreneurial team formation and search. Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal1: 147–165.
5.
Al-KwifiOTien-KhoaTOngsakulVAhmedZ (2020) Determinants of female entrepreneurship success across Saudi Arabia. Journal of Transnational Management25: 3–29.
6.
AudretschDB (2002) Entrepreneurship: A Survey of the Literature. Enterprise Directorate General, European Commission.
7.
AudretschDBCoadASegarraA (2014) Firm growth and innovation. Small Business Economics43: 743–749.
8.
AudretschDBFalckOFeldmanMPHeblichS (2012) Local entrepreneurship in context. Regional Studies46: 379–389.
9.
BackmanMKarlssonC (2013) Who Says Life is Over After 55? Entrepreneurship and An Aging Population. CESIS Paper 325. Available at: www.cesis.se.
10.
BakkerRMMcMullenJS (2023) Inclusive entrepreneurship: A call for a shared theoretical conversation about unconventional entrepreneurs. Journal of Business Venturing38: 106268.
11.
BatenMAKamilAAHaqueMA (2009) Modeling technical inefficiencies effects in a stochastic frontier production function for panel data. African Journal of Agricultural Research4: 1374–1382.
12.
BatteseGCoelliT (1995) A model for technical inefficiency effects in a stochastic frontier production function for panel data. Empirical Economics20: 325–332.
13.
BélandD (2007) The social exclusion discourse: Ideas and policy change. Policy & Politics35: 123–139.
14.
BettinGBianchiPNicolliFRamaciottiLRizzoU (2019) Migration, ethnic concentration, and firm entry: Evidence from Italian regions. Regional Studies53: 55–66.
15.
BinhasACohenN (2019) Policy entrepreneurs and anti-racism policies. Policy Studies42: 327–345.
16.
BlackburnRRamM (2006) Fix or fixation? The contributions and limitations of entrepreneurship and small firms to combating social exclusion. Entrepreneurship and Regional Development18: 73–89.
17.
BoikoK (2022) R&D activity and firm performance: Mapping the field. Management Review Quarterly72: 1051–1087.
18.
BorgattiSPHalginDS (2011) On network theory. Organization Science22: 1168–1181.
19.
BoudreauxC (2020) Ethnic diversity and small business venturing. Small Business Economics54: 25–41.
20.
BrunettiICorsiniL (2019) School-to-work transition and vocational education: A comparison across Europe. International Journal of Manpower40: 1411–1437.
21.
BrushCCarterNGatewoodE, et al (2001) The Diana Project: Women Business Owners and Equity Capital – The Myths Dispelled. Kauffman Center for Entrepreneurial Leadership. Available at: www.entreworld.org.
22.
BuschCMudidaR (2023) Asserting and transcending ethnic homophily: How entrepreneurs develop social ties to access resources and opportunities in socially contested environments. Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal18: 229–257. DOI: 10.1002/sej.1491.
23.
CarterSMwauraSRamM, et al (2015) Barriers to ethnic minority and women’s enterprise: Existing evidence, policy tensions and unsettled questions. International Small Business Journal33: 49–69.
24.
Castells-QuintanaDRoyuelaV (2014) Agglomeration, inequality, and economic growth. The Annals of Regional Science52: 343–366.
25.
ChadwickICDawsonA (2024) From imposter fears to authenticity: A typology of women entrepreneurs. Small Business Economics62: 1025–1050.
26.
ChagantiRGreenePG (2002) Who are ethnic entrepreneurs? A study of entrepreneurs’ ethnic involvement and business characteristics. Journal of Small Business Management40: 126–143.
27.
CheahSBellavitisCMuscioA (2021) The impact of technology complexity on the financial performance of R&D projects: Evidence from Singapore. The Journal of Technology Transfer46: 431–458.
28.
CookeFXiaoM (2021) Women entrepreneurship in China: Where are we now and where are we heading?Human Resource Development International24: 104–121.
29.
DarnihamedaniPTerjesenS (2022) Male and female entrepreneurs’ employment growth ambitions: The contingent role of regulatory efficiency. Small Business Economics58: 185–204.
30.
DasDKwesigaESardesmukhS, et al (2017) To be or not to be an ethnic firm: An analysis of identity strategies in immigrant-owned organizations. New England Journal of Entrepreneurship20: 18–33.
31.
DavidssonPHonigB (2003) The role of social and human capital among nascent entrepreneurs. Journal of Business Venturing18: 301–331.
32.
De ClercqDHonigB (2011) Entrepreneurship as an integrating mechanism for disadvantaged persons. Entrepreneurship & Regional Development23: 353–372.
33.
Dell’AnnoRAmendolaA (2015) Social exclusion and economic growth: An empirical investigation in European economies. Review of Income and Wealth61: 274–301.
34.
Di CataldoMRodríguez-PoseA (2017) What drives employment growth and social inclusion in the regions of the European Union?Regional Studies51: 1840–1859.
35.
DibehGFakihAMarrouchW (2019) Employment and skill mismatch among youth in Lebanon. International Journal of Manpower40: 1438–1457.
36.
DuanCSandhuKKoteyB (2021) Understanding immigrant entrepreneurship: A home-country entrepreneurial ecosystem perspective. New England Journal of Entrepreneurship24: 2–20.
37.
ErnstHConleyJOmlandN (2016) How to create commercial value from patents: The role of patent management. R&D Management46: 677–690.
FernandesAJFerreiraJJ (2022) Entrepreneurial ecosystems and networks: A literature review and research agenda. Review of Managerial Science16: 189–247.
40.
FriedEI (2020) Lack of theory building and testing impedes progress in the factor and network literature. Psychological Inquiry31: 271–288.
41.
GartziaLBaniandrésJ (2019) How feminine is the female advantage? Incremental validity of gender traits over leader sex on employees' responses. Journal of Business Research99: 125–139.
42.
GhauriPFuXMinayoraA (2022) Digital technology-based entrepreneurial pursuit of marginalized communities. Journal of International Management28: 100948.
43.
GranovetterM (1985) Economic action and social structure: The problem of embeddedness. The American Journal of Sociology91: 481–510.
44.
GranovetterM (2005) The impact of social structure on economic outcomes. The Journal of Economic Perspectives19: 33–50.
45.
GreeneW (2005) Fixed and random effects in stochastic frontier models. Journal of Productivity Analysis23: 7–32.
46.
GreveASalaffJW (2003) Social networks and entrepreneurship. Entrepreneurship: Theory and Practice28: 1–22.
47.
HallJMatosSSheehanL, et al (2012) Entrepreneurship and innovation at the base of the pyramid: A recipe for inclusive growth or social exclusion?Journal of Management Studies49: 785–812.
48.
HallenBLEisenhardtKM (2012) Catalysing strategies and efficient tie formation: How entrepreneurial firms obtain investment ties. Academy of Management Journal55: 35–70.
49.
HallenBLDavisJPMurrayA (2020) Entrepreneurial network evolution: Explicating the structural localism and agentic network change distinction. Academy of Management Annals14: 1067–1102.
50.
HansenMT (1999) The search-transfer problem: The role of weak ties in sharing knowledge across organization subunits. Administrative Science Quarterly44: 82–111.
51.
HansenHT (2024) Feelings of being socially excluded: A matter of education, labour market situation, income, deprivation, or other things?International Journal of Social Welfare33: 202–219.
52.
HardleWMammenE (1993) Comparing nonparametric versus parametric regression fits. The Annals of Statistics21: 1926–1947.
53.
HeijCVVolberdaHWVan den BoschFA, et al (2020) How to leverage the impact of R&D on product innovation? The moderating effect of management innovation. R&D Management50: 277–294.
54.
HeirmanAClarysseB (2004) How and why do research-based start-ups differ at founding? A resource-based configurational perspective. The Journal of Technology Transfer29: 247–268.
55.
HoangHAntoncicB (2003) Network-based research in entrepreneurship: A critical review. Journal of Business Venturing18: 165–187.
56.
HuangYLiPChenL, et al (2023) Opportunity or necessity entrepreneurship? A study based on the national system of entrepreneurship. Journal of Innovation & Knowledge8: 100448.
57.
HubnerS (2020) When entrepreneurs become leaders: How entrepreneurs deal with people management. International Journal of Entrepreneurial Venturing12: 161–182.
58.
HugginsRThompsonP (2015) Entrepreneurship, innovation and regional growth: A network theory. Small Business Economics45: 103–128.
59.
HunderaMDuystersGNaudéW, et al (2019) How do female entrepreneurs in developing countries cope with role conflict?International Journal of Gender and Entrepreneurship11: 120–145.
60.
HuqATanCVenugopalV (2020) How do women entrepreneurs strategize growth? An investigation using the social feminist theory lens. Journal of Small Business Management58: 259–287.
61.
IndartiNHapsariNLukito-BudiAS, et al (2021) Quo vadis, ethnic entrepreneurship? A bibliometric analysis of ethnic entrepreneurship in growing markets. Journal of Entrepreneurship in Emerging Economies13: 427–458.
62.
IsagaN (2019) Start-up motives and challenges facing female entrepreneurs in Tanzania. International Journal of Gender and Entrepreneurship11: 102–119.
63.
IshaqMHussainAWhittamG (2010) Racism: A barrier to entry? Experiences of small ethnic minority retail businesses. International Small Business Journal28: 362–377.
64.
KarlaftisM (2010) Ownership and competition in European transit: Assessing efficiency. Transportmetrica6: 143–160.
65.
KatharakisGKatharakiMKatostarasT (2014) An empirical study of comparing DEA and SFA methods to measure hospital units’ efficiency. International Journal of Operational Research21: 341–364.
66.
KautonenTDownSMinnitiM (2014) Ageing and entrepreneurial preferences. Small Business Economics42: 579–594.
LiuY (2020) The micro-foundations of global business incubation: Stakeholder engagement and strategic entrepreneurial partnerships. Technological Forecasting and Social Change161: 120294.
69.
LongAWoodMSBennettDL (2023) Entrepreneurial organizing activities and nascent venture performance. Small Business Economics60: 433–461.
70.
LorenziP (2016) Inequality and economic growth. Society53: 474–478.
71.
MarinoniA (2023) Immigration and entrepreneurship: The role of enclaves. Management Science69: 7266–7284.
72.
Martinez DyA (2020) Not all entrepreneurship is created equal: Theorising entrepreneurial disadvantage through social positionality. European Management Review17: 687–699.
73.
MatricanoDSorrentinoM (2014) Ukrainian entrepreneurship in Italy: Factors influencing the creation of ethnic ventures. Journal of Innovation and Entrepreneurship3: 1–28.
74.
MatricanoD (2015) Lo Studio dell’Imprenditorialità. Un Approccio di Indagine Multidimensionale. Roma (IT): Carocci Editore.
75.
MatricanoD (2018) Grey vs. Young entrepreneurs: Are they really that different in terms of entrepreneurial intentions? Empirical evidence from Italy. International Journal of Business and Management13: 76–86.
76.
MatricanoD (2020) The effect of R&D investments, highly skilled employees, and patents on the performance of Italian innovative startups. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management32: 1195–1208.
77.
MatricanoD (2022a) Economic and social development generated by innovative startups: Does heterogeneity persist across Italian macro-regions?Economics of Innovation and New Technology31: 467–484.
78.
MatricanoD (2022b) The influence of gender on technology transfer processes managed in Italian Young Innovative Companies: A stochastic frontier analysis. Technovation111: 102383.
79.
MatricanoD (2023) Young entrepreneurs and skills mismatch in school-to-work transition: Empirical evidence from innovation processes managed in Italian NTBFs. International Journal of Manpower44: 1028–1045.
80.
MaulaMStamW (2020) Enhancing rigor in quantitative entrepreneurship research. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice44: 1059–1090.
81.
MinnitiM (2010) Female entrepreneurship and economic activity. European Journal of Development Research22: 294–312.
82.
MudambiRSwiftT (2011) Proactive R&D management and firm growth: A punctuated equilibrium model. Research Policy40: 429–440.
83.
MuldoonJLucyCLidzyS (2019) The impact of social dominance orientation on female entrepreneurial intention. New England Journal of Entrepreneurship22: 109–125.
84.
MuldoonJBendicksonJSLiguoriEW, et al (2024) Relational models and entrepreneurship ecosystems. International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behavior & Research30: 938–954.
85.
NguyenPHPhamDTB (2020) The cost efficiency of Vietnamese banks—The difference between DEA and SFA. Journal of Economics and Development22: 209–227.
86.
ParkheAWassermanSRalstonDA (2006) New frontiers in network theory development. Academy of Management Review31: 560–568.
87.
PartanenJKauppilaOPSepulvedaF, et al (2020) Turning strategic network resources into performance: The mediating role of network identity of small-and medium-sized enterprises. Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal14: 178–197.
88.
PastoreF (2019) Why so slow? The school-to-work transition in Italy. Studies in Higher Education44: 1358–1371.
89.
PidduckRJClarkDR (2021) Transitional entrepreneurship: Elevating research into marginalized entrepreneurs. Journal of Small Business Management59: 1081–1096.
90.
PinquartMJuangLPSilbereisenRK (2003) Self-efficacy and successful school-to-work transition: A longitudinal study. Journal of Vocational Behavior63: 329–346.
91.
PittMMLeeL (1981) The measurement and sources of technical inefficiency in the Indonesian weaving industry. Journal of Development Economics9: 43–64.
92.
Polidoro JrFJacobsC (2024) Knowledge diffusion in nascent industries: Asymmetries between startups and established firms in spurring inventions by other firms. Strategic Management Journal45: 807–845.
93.
RechterEAvnimelechG (2024) Intensive personal mentoring: Accelerators’ secret sauce. Small Business Economics64: 1–26. DOI: 10.1007/s11187-024-00943-x.
94.
RyanP (2001) The school-to-work transition: A cross-national perspective. Journal of Economic Literature39: 34–92.
95.
SantosSCLiguoriEWMorrisMH, et al (2024) A racial identity approach to entrepreneurship: The lived experiences of African American and Black entrepreneurs. Small Business Economics64: 1–25.
96.
SantosSCNeumeyerX (2022) Culture and gender in entrepreneurial teams: The effect on team processes and outcomes. Small Business Economics58: 1035–1050.
97.
SchmidtPSicklesR (1984) Production frontiers and panel data. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics2: 367–374.
98.
SequeiraJMuellerSLMcGeeJE (2007) The influence of social ties and self-efficacy in forming entrepreneurial intentions and motivating nascent behaviour. Journal of Developmental Entrepreneurship12: 275–293.
99.
ShantzASKistruckGZietsmaC (2018) The opportunity not taken: The occupational identity of entrepreneurs in contexts of poverty. Journal of Business Venturing33: 416–437.
100.
Slotte-KockSCovielloN (2010) Entrepreneurship research on network processes: A review and ways forward. Entrepreneurship: Theory and Practice34: 31–57.
101.
SmithDALohrkeFT (2008) Entrepreneurial network development: Trusting in the process. Journal of Business Research61: 315–322.
102.
SolesvikMIakovlevaTTrifilovaA (2019) Motivation of female entrepreneurs: A cross-national study. Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development26: 684–705.
103.
StamEWennbergK (2009) The roles of R&D in new firm growth. Small Business Economics33: 77–89.
104.
UgomoriT (2007) The relative efficiency of various targeting regimes in Japan: A simulation study with linear quadratic dynamic programming. Japan and the World Economy19: 292–302.
105.
UmphressEESmith-CroweKBriefAP, et al (2007) When birds of a feather flock together and when they do not: Status composition, social dominance orientation, and organizational attractiveness. Journal of Applied Psychology92: 396–409.
106.
UzziB (1996) The sources and consequences of embeddedness for the economic performance of organizations: The network effect. American Sociological Review61: 674–698.
107.
VissaBChacarAS (2009) Leveraging ties: The contingent value of entrepreneurial teams' external advice networks on Indian software venture performance. Strategic Management Journal30: 1179–1191.
108.
WaldingerRAldrichHWardR (1990) Ethnic Entrepreneurs. Newbury Park, California: Sage Publications.
109.
WangLWangYLouY, et al (2020) Impact of different patent cooperation network models on innovation performance of technology-based SMEs. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management32: 724–738.
110.
WardanaLHandayatiPNarmadityaB, et al (2020) Determinant factors of young people in preparing for entrepreneurship: Lesson from Indonesia. Journal of Asian Finance, Economics, and Business7: 555–565.
111.
WittP (2004) Entrepreneurs’ networks and the success of start-ups. Entrepreneurship & Regional Development16: 391–412.
112.
YasinNHafeezK (2023) Three waves of immigrant entrepreneurship: A cross-national comparative study. Small Business Economics60: 1281–1306.
113.
ZhangJAO’KaneCChenG (2020) Business ties, political ties, and innovation performance in Chinese industrial firms: The role of entrepreneurial orientation and environmental dynamism. Journal of Business Research121: 254–267.
114.
ZuoXBlackburnJKourtellisN, et al (2016) The power of indirect ties. Computer Communications73: 188–199.
