Managed as offenders,ignored as survivors: Modern slavery,criminalisation,and the gaps in practice provision

Abstract

This paper explores how people encounter the criminal justice system, as well as related support services for those victims of modern slavery who also have a history of offending. Drawing on a focus group with three participants, the study examines how moral complexity, bureaucratic rigidity, and systemic misunderstanding shape processes of rehabilitation and engagement with UK modern slavery support and criminal justice systems. Participants described deep frustration at being simultaneously managed as offenders and overlooked as survivors, highlighting the limitations of current trauma-informed approaches when faced with non-stereotypical victim–offender identities. The paper situates these findings within contemporary debates on trauma-informed care, responsivity, and desistance, and argues for reforms that embed lived experience more deeply in system design, strengthen cross-sector continuity of care, and position probation as a relational and reparative form of rehabilitation.

Keywords

modern slavery criminal exploitation victim-offender overlap trauma and recovery rehabilitation and support supervision

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alliance for Youth Justice (2025) Exploited to exploiter? Preventing the unjust criminalisation of victims of child criminal exploitation in the transition to adulthood. Available at: https://www.ayj.org.uk/news-content/exploited-to-expoiter-new.

Barlow

(2022) Victims perpetrating a crime: a critique of responses to criminal exploitation and modern slavery in the UK. In: Murphy

Lazzarino

(eds) Modern Slavery and Human Trafficking (1st ed.). UK: Bristol University Press, 146–162. Available at: https://www.cambridge.org/core/product/identifier/9781447363668%23c8/type/book_part (accessed 1 December 2025).

Braun

Clarke

(2006) Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology 3(2): 77–101.

Brayley

Cockbain

Laycock

(2011) The value of crime scripting: deconstructing internal child sex trafficking. Policing (Bradford, England) 5(2): 132–143.

Broad

Turnbull

(2019) From human trafficking to modern slavery: the development of anti-trafficking policy in the UK. European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research 25(2): 119–133.

Burnett

McNeill

(2005) The place of the officer-offender relationship in assisting offenders to desist from crime. Probation Journal 52(3): 221–242.

Christie

(1986) The ideal victim. In: From Crime Policy to Victim Policy: Reorienting the Justice System. London, UK: Palgrave Macmillan, 17–30.

Davis

(2022) Adultification bias within child protection and safeguarding. Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Probation. Available at: https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5b7ea2794cde7a79e7c00582/t/65518cd5a7588544ea06f0ab/1699843285898/Adultification(bias.pdf.

Davis

Marsh

(2020) Boys to men: the cost of ‘adultification’ in safeguarding responses to Black boys. Critical and Radical Social Work 8(2): 255–259.

10.

Davis

(2024) Identifying victims of human trafficking: the legal issues, challenges and barriers. In: Identifying Victims of Human Trafficking. Palgrave Studies in Victims and Victimology. Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland, 1–27. Available at: https://link.springer.com/10.1007/978-3-031-61741-6_1 (accessed 1 December 2025).

11.

Deering

Feilzer

(2019) Hollowing out probation? The roots of transforming rehabilitation. Probation Journal 66(1): 8–24.

12.

Diedhiou

Roberts

Raino

(n.d.) Trauma, coercion, and the tools of trafficking exploitation: examining the consequences for children and youth in the justice system. Kentucky Law Journal 109(4): 6.

13.

Farmer

(2003) Pathologies of Power: Health, Human Rights, and the New War on the Poor. California series in public anthropology 4. Berkeley: University of California Press.

14.

Gadd

Broad

(2018) Troubling recognitions in British responses to modern slavery. The British Journal of Criminology 58(6): 1440–1461.

15.

Gadd

Broad

(2024) When victims of modern slavery became offenders: the unravelling of the UK’s Modern Slavery Agenda. Journal of Human Trafficking 10(2): 302–315.

16.

Galtung

(1969) Violence, peace, and peace research. Journal of Peace Research 6(3): 167–191.

17.

Hodkinson

Lewis

Waite

, et al. (2021) Fighting or fuelling forced labour? The Modern Slavery Act 2015, irregular migrants and the vulnerabilising role of the UK’s hostile environment. Critical Social Policy 41(1): 68–90.

18.

Hoyle

Bosworth

Dempsey

(2011) Labelling the victims of sex trafficking: exploring the borderland between rhetoric and reality. Social & Legal Studies 20(3): 313–329.

19.

Hynes

(2022) Exploring the interface between asylum, human trafficking and/or ‘modern slavery’ within a hostile environment in the UK. Social Sciences 11(6): 246.

20.

Jay

(2013) Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Exploitation in Rotherham 1997–2013. Available at: https://www.rotherham.gov.uk/downloads/file/279/independent-inquiry-into-child-sexual-exploitation-in-rotherham.

21.

Jennings

Piquero

Reingle

(2012) On the overlap between victimization and offending: a review of the literature. Aggression and Violent Behavior 17(1): 16–26.

22.

Johns D, Flynn C, Hall M, et al. (2022) Co-Production and Criminal Justice. Routledge.

23.

Komarovskaya

Booker Loper

Warren

, et al. (2011) Exploring gender differences in trauma exposure and the emergence of symptoms of PTSD among incarcerated men and women. Journal of Forensic Psychiatry & Psychology 22(3): 395–410.

24.

Landman

Brewster

Thornton

(2024) Taking back control: human rights and human trafficking in the United Kingdom. Societies 14(4): 47.

25.

Lauritsen

Laub

(2007) Understanding the link between victimization and offending: new reflections on an old idea. Crime Prevention Studies 22: 55–75.

26.

Lumley-Sapanski

Rodriguez-Huerta

Young

, et al. (2026) Criminalising survivors of modern slavery: the United Kingdom’s National Referral Mechanism as a border-making process. Journal of Social Policy 55(1): 222–241.

27.

Marshall

(2023) Victims first? Examining the place of ‘child criminal exploitation’ within ‘child first’ youth justice. Children & Society 37(4): 1156–1170.

28.

McAnallen

McGinnis

(2024) Trauma-Informed practice and the criminal justice system: a systematic narrative review. Irish Probation Journal 21: 117–136.

29.

McNeill

Farrall

Lightowler

, et al. (2012) How and why people stop offending: discovering desistance. IRIS Institute for Research and Innovation in Social Sciences. Available at: https://www.iriss.org.uk/sites/default/files/iriss-insight-15.pdf.

30.

McNeill

Raynor

Trotter

(eds) (2010) Offender Supervision: New Directions in Theory, Research and Practice. Oxon; New York: Willan.

31.

O’Loughlin

Leader

Classmann

, et al. (n.d.) Defendants as Victims: A Scoping Review of Vulnerability, Victimhood and Safeguards from Charge to Conviction. University of York. Available at: https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/id/eprint/217790/.

32.

Rex

(1999) Desistance from offending: experiences of probation. The Howard Journal of Criminal Justice 38(4): 366–383.

33.

Robinson

(2005) What works in offender management? The Howard Journal of Criminal Justice 44(3): 307–318.

34.

Robinson

Burke

Millings

(2016) Criminal justice identities in transition: the case of devolved probation services in England and Wales. British Journal of Criminology 56(1): 161–178.

35.

Roennfeldt

Byrne

(2021) Skin in the game: the professionalization of lived experience roles in mental health. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing 30(S1): 1445–1455.

36.

Samota

Ariyo

(2022) Racialising and criminalising vulnerable migrants: the case of human trafficking and modern slavery. In: Murphy

Lazzarino

(eds) Modern Slavery and Human Trafficking. UK: Policy Press, 130–145. Available at: https://bristoluniversitypressdigital.com/view/book/9781447363668/ch007.xml (accessed 1 December 2025).

37.

Schwarz

Williams-Woods

(2022) Protection and support for survivors of modern slavery in the UK: assessing current provision and what we need to change. Journal of Poverty and Social Justice 30(2): 98–119.

38.

Shaw

Greenhow

(2020) Children in care: exploitation, offending and the denial of victimhood in a prosecution-led culture of practice. The British Journal of Social Work 50(5): 1551–1569.

39.

Villacampa

Torres

(2017) Human trafficking for criminal exploitation: the failure to identify victims. European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research 23(3): 393–408.

40.

Walker

(2021) Trauma-informed care in the criminal justice system. In: Crighton

Towl

(eds) Forensic Psychology. 1st ed. Wiley, 735–751. Available at: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/9781394260669.ch35 (accessed 1 December 2025).

41.

Walklate

(2011) Reframing criminal victimization: finding a place for vulnerability and resilience. Theoretical Criminology 15(2): 179–194.

42.

Weaver

(2011) Co-producing community justice: the transformative potential of personalisation for penal sanctions. British Journal of Social Work 41(6): 1038–1057.

43.

Williams

Clarke

(2016) Dangerous Associations: Joint Enterprise, Gangs and Racism. London: Centre for Crime and Justice Studies.

44.

Zelechoski

(2016) Trauma, adverse experience, and offending. In: Heilbrun

DeMatteo

Goldstein

NES

(eds) APA Handbook of Psychology and Juvenile Justice. Washington: American Psychological Association, 325–342. Available at: https://content.apa.org/books/14643-015 (accessed 1 December 2025).