The ‘incomplete’ failure of political Islam: The Justice and Development Party and the Freedom and Justice Party as case studies

Abstract

How would Islamists succeed to sustain their rule in spite of their lack of an Islamic blueprint for governance? I draw on an original fieldwork study conducted in Turkey and Egypt from 2010 to 2013 to advance a theory linking Islamists’ rule sustainability and political leverage vis-à-vis the state establishment. In contrast with post-Islamism, the results contended that Islamists sustain their rule if they have a high political leverage based on the adoption of a three-fold strategy comprising identification, differentiation, and alliance mobilisation. Based on 45 open-ended and semi-structured interviews conducted with members of Turkey’s Justice and Development Party and Egypt’s Freedom and Justice Party, findings significantly hold in authoritarian and hybrid regimes in the Middle East.

Keywords

Middle East politics post-Islamism the Justice and Development Party the Freedom and Justice Party

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abdelrahman

(2009) ‘With the Islamists? Sometimes: With the state? Never!’ Cooperation between the Left and Islamists in Egypt. British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies 36(1): 37–54.

Al-Kharabawi

(2013) The Secret of the Temple: The Hidden Secrets of the Muslim Brotherhood. Cairo, Egypt: Nahdet Masr.

Arango

(2015) Erdoğan urges cooperation in forming New Turkish Government. New York Times, 11 June. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/12/world/europe/erdogan-urges-cooperation-in-forming-new-turkish-government.html

Arinç

(2006) Sosyal Hayati Cezaevine Cevirmeyelim [Let’s not control social life]. Hürriyet, 25 April. Available at: https://www.hurriyet.com.tr/gundem/arinc-sosyal-hayati-cezaevine-cevirmeyelim-4312365

Arinç

(2013) Turkish Deputy PM condemns military coup in Egypt. Daily Sabah, 9 July. Available at: https://www.dailysabah.com/turkey/2013/07/09/turkish-deputy-pm-condemns-military-coup-in-egypt

Ashour

(2009) The De-radicalization of Jihadists: Transforming Armed Islamist Movements. Abingdon: Taylor & Francis.

Ayubi

(1991) Political Islam: Religion and Politics in the Arab World. London: Routledge.

Bayat

(2005) Islamism and social movement theory. Third World Quarterly 26: 891–908.

Bayat

(2013) Post-Islamism: The Changing Faces of Political Islam. New York: Oxford University Press.

10.

Beinin

(2005) Political Islam and the new global economy the political economy of an Egyptian social movement. The New Centennial Review 5(1): 111–139.

11.

Bostanci

(2019) The AKParty to launch 29th consultation and assessment meeting. Daily Sabah.

12.

Brooke

(2014) Why Do Islamists Provide Social Services? Paper presented at the Conference of Rethinking Islamist Politics. Washington, DC: The Project of Middle East Political Science.

13.

Browers

(2009) Political Ideology in the Arab World: Accommodation and Transformation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

14.

Brown

(2011) The Muslim brotherhood as helicopter parent. The Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Available at: https://carnegieendowment.org/2011/05/27/muslim-brotherhood-as-helicopter-parent-pub-44266

15.

Burgat

Dowell

(1993) The Islamic Movement in North Africa. Austin, TX: The Center for Middle Eastern Studies, The University of Texas.

16.

Cavatorta

(2018) The complexity of Tunisian Islamism: Conflicts and rivalries over the role of religion in politics. In: Rivetti

Kratzschmar

(eds) Uprisings. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, pp. 243–258.

17.

Cavatorta

Merone

(2013) Moderation through exclusion? The journey of the Tunisian. Ennahda from Fundamentalist to Conservative Party, Democratization 20(5): 857–875.

18.

Chams El-Dine

(2018) Out of the ashes: The rise of an anti-sectarian discourse in post-2011 Iraq. In: Rivetti

Kratzschmar

(eds) Uprisings. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, pp. 341–358.

19.

Clark

(2004) Islamist women in Yemen: Informal nodes of activism. In: Wiktorowicz

(ed.) Islamic Activism: A Social Movement Theory Approach. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, pp.164–184.

20.

Davutoğlu

(2001) Stratejik Derinlik: Türkiye’nin Uluslararasi Konumu [Strategic Depth: Turkey’s Position and Role in the International Scene]. Istanbul: Kure Yayinlari.

21.

Davutoğlu

(2007) Speech at Bergdorf’s 136th roundtable conference. The Prime Ministry Headquarter, 2011. Available at: https://www.koerber-stiftung.de/en/bergedorf-round-table/round-tables/136th-round-table/lecture-by-ahmet-davutoglu

22.

Davutoğlu

(2013) FM Davutoğlu and Deputy PM Bozdağ strongly condemn fire opened by Egyptian army. Daily Sabah, 8 July. Available at: https://www.dailysabah.com/turkey/2013/07/08/fm-davutoglu-and-deputy-pm-bozdag-strongly-condemn-fire-opened-by-egyptian-army

23.

Davutoğlu

(2015) In: Turkish PM seeks joint declaration against terrorism. Anadolu Agency, 17 July. Available at: https://www.aa.com.tr/en/turkey/turkish-pm-seeks-joint-declaration-against-terrorism/25800

24.

Drevon

(2018) The reconfiguration of the Egyptian Islamist social movement family after two political transitions. In: Rivetti

Kratzschmar

(eds) Uprisings. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, pp. 258–273.

25.

Durac

(2018) Islamism in Yemen: From Ansar Allah to Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula. In: Rivetti

Kratzschmar

(eds) Uprisings. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, pp. 307–321.

26.

El-Ghobashy

(2005) The metamorphosis of the Egyptian Muslim Brothers. International Journal of Middle East Studies 37(3): 373–395.

27.

Erdoğan

(2004) Harvard Universitesi’nde Konferans [The Harvard University conference]. Boston, MA. Available at: https://twitter.com/politikaloji/status/1315712042637111297

28.

Erdoğan

(2005) NATO Zirvesi Basın Toplantısı. In: The NATO summit press meeting, Brussels, 22 February.

29.

Erdoğan

(2006) Georgetown Universitesi’nde Yaptigi ‘Kuresel Barış ve Adalet Için Turkiye’nin Vizyonu’. [Turkish Global Vision of Peace and Justice at the Georgetown University]. Washington, DC: Georgetown University.

30.

Erdoğan

(2008) Medeniyetler Itifaki 1. Forumu Acılış Oturumu. In: The opening session of the first alliance of civilizations conference, Madrid, 15–16 January.

31.

Erdoğan

(2012) Erdoğan speech at Yildiz Technical University. 5 October. Available at: https://www.alamy.com/turkish-prime-minister-tayyip-erdogan-addresses-the-audience-after-receiving-his-honorary-doctorate-degree-from-yildiz-technical-university-in-istanbul-october-5-2012-reutersosman-orsal-turkey-tags-politics-education-image378890501.html

32.

Erdoğan

(2013) Erdoğan attacks West reactions to Morsi’s overthrow. Financial Times, 5 July. Available at: https://www.ft.com/content/b8396b56-e582-11e2-ad1a-00144feabdc0

33.

Erdoğan

(2015) Ankara bombing ‘collective terrorist act’: Erdoğan. Agence France Press.

34.

Erdoğan

(2016) Erdoğan rallies Turks against unprecedented terror wave. Agence France Press.

35.

Feldman

(2012) The Fall and Rise of the Islamic State. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

36.

Guiler

(2020) From prison to parliament: Victimhood, identity, and electoral support. Mediterranean Politics 26(2): 168–197.

37.

Gül

(2004) Common values and vision for co-existence in Europe. Warsaw. Available at: http://turkishpolicy.com/images/stories/2004-03-EUodyssey1/TPQ2004-3-gul.pdf

38.

Gül

(2005) Turkey and the European Union: Shaping a brighter future. Istanbul. Available at: https://www.europeansources.info/corporate-author/turkey-ministry-of-foreign-affairs/

39.

Gurcan

(2016) Turkey’s New Erdoğan Doctrine. Al-Monitor, 3 November. Available at: https://www.al-monitor.com/originals/2016/11/turkey-wants-use-its-hard-power-solve-regional-problems.html

40.

Hallaq

(2013) The Impossible State: Islam, Politics, and Modernity’s Moral Predicament. New York: Columbia University Press.

41.

Ismail

(2003) Rethinking Islamist Politics: Culture, the State and Islamism. London: I.B. Tauris.

42.

Ismail

(2004) Islamist movements as social movements: Contestation and identity frames. Historical Reflections 3: 385–402.

43.

Joya

(2018) Is Islamism accommodating neoliberalism? The case of Egypt’s Muslim brotherhood. In: Rivetti

Kratzschmar

(eds) Uprisings. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, pp. 89–106.

44.

Kalin

(2021) Turkish-Egyptian reconciliation: Statements and responses. EPISS, 10 March. Available at: https://en.eipss-eg.org/turkish-egyptian-reconciliation-statements-and-responses/

45.

Kandil

(2016) Inside the Brotherhood. Cambridge: Polity Press.

46.

Kepel

(2005) The Roots of Radical Islam. London: Saqi Books.

47.

Kraetzschmar

Rivetti

(eds) (2018) Islamists and the Politics of the Arab Uprisings: Governance, Pluralisation and Contention. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

48.

Kraetzschmar

Saleh

(2018) Political parties and secular-Islamist polarisation in post-Mubarak Egypt. In: Rivetti

Kratzschmar

(eds) Uprisings. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, pp. 221–242.

49.

Kurzman

(2018) Conclusion unruly protest. In: Jasper

Volpi

(eds) Microfoundations of the Arab Uprisings. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press, pp.183–192.

50.

LaCroix

Shalata

(2016) The rise of revolutionary Salafism in post-Mubarak Egypt. In: Rougier

Lacroix

(eds) Egypt’s Revolutions. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, pp.163–178.

51.

Magued

(2018) The Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood’s transnational advocacy in Turkey: A new means of political participation. British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies 45(3): 480–497.

52.

Magued

(2020) Arab scholarship on Turkey’s regional role before and after the rise of the AKP. The Middle East Journal 74(4): 579–597.

53.

Mecham

(2014) The evolution of Islamism since the Arab uprisings (Project on Middle East political science: Monkey Cage). The Washington Post, 24 October. Available at: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2014/10/24/the-evolution-of-islamism-since-the-arab-uprisings/

54.

Meijer

(2013) The Muslim brotherhood and the political: An exercise of ambiguity. In: Bakker

Meijer

(eds) The Muslim Brotherhood in Europe. New York: Oxford University Press, pp.294–320.

55.

Morsi

(2012) Speech at Cairo University. Available at: https://cu.edu.eg/Cairo-University-News-339.html

56.

Morsi

(2013) Speech during a press conference with Chancellor Angela Merkel. 30 January. Available at: https://www.dw.com/en/merkel-urges-morsi-to-foster-political-dialogue-in-egypt/a-16562334

57.

Morsi

In Bickel

Hermann

(2013) Interview with Mohamed Morsi: We don’t want a theocratic state. Qantara.de. Available at: https://en.qantara.de/content/interview-with-mohamed-morsi-we-dont-want-a-theocratic-state

58.

Munson

(2001) Islamic mobilization: Social movement theory and the Egyptian Muslim brotherhood. The Sociological Quarterly 42(4): 487–510.

59.

Nugent

(2020) The psychology of repression and polarization in authoritarian regimes. World Politics 72(2): 291–334.

60.

Osman

(2017) Islamism: A History of Political Islam from the Fall of the Ottoman Empire to the Rise of ISIS. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

61.

Pew Research Center (2012) Most Muslims want democracy: Personal freedoms, and Islam in political life. Available at: https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2012/07/10/most-muslims-want-democracy-personal-freedoms-and-islam-in-political-life/

62.

Ranko

(2014) The Muslim Brotherhood and Its Quest for Hegemony in Egypt: State-Discourse and Islamist Counter-Discourse. Wiesbaden: Springer.

63.

Roy

(1994) The Failure of Political Islam. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

64.

Schwedler

(2006) Faith in Moderation: Islamist Parties in Jordan and Yemen. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

65.

Schwedler

(2011) Can Islamists become moderates? Rethinking the inclusion-moderation hypothesis. World Politics 36: 347–376.

66.

Schwedler

(2018) Routines and ruptures in anti-Israeli protests in Jordan. In: Jasper

Volpi

(eds) Microfoundations of the Arab Uprisings. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press, pp.67–88.

67.

Schwedler

Lynch

(2020) Introduction to the special issue on ‘Islamist politics after the Arab uprisings’. Middle East Law and Governance 12(1): 3–13.

68.

Sheline

(2020) Shifting reputations for ‘moderation’: Evidence from Qatar, Jordan, and Morocco. Middle East Law and Governance 12(1): 109–129.

69.

Stein

Volpi

(2014) Islamism and regime change in the Middle East and North Africa: Looking beyond the Arab uprisings. In: Stein

Volpi

Merone

Alfasi

Alles

(eds) Islamism and the Arab Uprisings. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, pp. 2–8.

70.

Tuğal

(2009) Transforming everyday life: Islamism and social movement theory. Theory and Society 38: 423–458.

71.

Turkish Economic Social Studies Foundation (TESEV) (2009) The perception of Turkey in the Middle East. December. Available at: https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/135216/Middle%20East%20Report_WEB18_12_09.pdf

72.

Wagemakers

(2020) Between exclusivism and inclusivism: The Jordanian Muslim brotherhood’s divided responses to the ‘Arab Spring’. Middle East Law and Governance 12(1): 35–60.

73.

Westphal

(2018) Violence in the name of god? A framing processes approach to the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria. Social Movement Studies 17(1): 19–34.

74.

Wickham

(2002) Mobilizing Islam, Religion, Activism and Political Change in Egypt. New York: Columbia University Press.

75.

Wickham

(2004) The path to moderation: Strategy and learning in the formation of Egypt’s Wasat Party. Comparative Politics 36(2): 205–228.

76.

Wiktorowicz

(2002) Islamic activism and social movement theory: A new direction for research. Mediterranean Politics 7(3): 187–211.

77.

Wickham

(2013) The Muslim Brotherhood: Evolution of an Islamic Movement. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

78.

Yadav

(2020) Fragmentation, disintegration, and resurgence: Assessing the Islamist field in Yemen. Middle East Law and Governance 12(1): 14–34.

79.

Yasun

(2020) Are Islamists in the MENA more pro-democracy than seculars? The Arab Barometer, 21 August. Available at: https://www.arabbarometer.org/2020/08/are-islamists-in-mena-more-pro-democracy-than-seculars/

80.

Yavuz

(2003) Islamic Political Identity in Turkey. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

81.

Yilmaz

(2009) Muslim democrats in Turkey and Egypt: Participatory politics as a catalyst. Insight Turkey 11(2): 93–113.