This critique conducts a technical analysis of a UK Home Office report which was a key justification for passing the Immigration Act 2014. The law seeks to reduce non-EU immigration to the UK. The report is based on a 2012 report by the Migration Advisory Committee which used firmly established methods in the field of immigration studies. Despite this, it is concluded that the Home Office report not only excludes several important aspects of analysis, the entrepreneurialism of migrants and student immigration, but also has severe statistical problems. The report’s choice of operationalisations, lack of information regarding confidence intervals, and lack of sufficient model testing and repetition all combine to make it a weak piece of research and substantially undermine its suitability to inform policy. In the final analysis, this critique posits that the Home Office report reflects the Conservative government’s utilisation of ‘policy driven evidence’.
AlfanoMDustmannCFrattiniT (2016) Immigration and the UK: Reflections After Brexit. In: FasaniF (ed.) Refugees and Economic Migrants: Facts, Policies and Challenges. London: CEPR Press, 55–81.
2.
AndersenR (2008) Modern Methods for Robust Regression. London: Sage.
Conservative Party (2014) David Cameron: Speech on Immigration. London: CCHQ Press Office.
11.
ConsterdineE (2013) One Step Forward, Two Steps Back: Evaluating the Institutions of British Immigration Policy Making. London: Institute for Public Policy Research.
12.
DevlinCBoltOPatelDHardingDHussainI (2014) Impacts of Migration on UK Native Employment: An Analytical Review of the Evidence. London: Department for Business, Innovation and Skills & Home Office.
13.
DinasEGeorgiadouVKonstantinidisIRoriL (2016) From dusk to dawn: Local party organization and party success of right-wing extremism. Party Politics22(1): 80–92.
14.
DustmannCFrattiniT (2014) The fiscal effects of immigration to the UK. The Economic Journal124(580): 593–643.
15.
DustmanCFabbriFPrestonIWadsworthJ (2003) The Local Labour Market Effects of Immigration in the UK. London: Home Office.
16.
DustmannCFabbriFPrestonI (2005) The impact of immigration on the British labour market. The Economic Journal115(507): F324–F341.
17.
DustmannCSchönbergUStuhlerJ (2016) The impact of immigration: Why do studies reach such different results?The Journal of Economic Perspectives30(4): 31–56.
18.
GelmanAHillJ (2006) Data Analysis using Regression and Multilevel/Hierarchical Models. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
19.
GrantS (2014) Immigration Act 2014 – Summary Provisions. London: Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants.
20.
HM Government (2013) International Education: Global Growth and Prosperity. London: Department for Business, Innovation and Skills.
21.
HM Government Press Office (2013) New Push to Grow UK’s £17.5 Billion Education Exports Industry. London: Department for Business, Innovation and Skills.
22.
JohnsonLKimmelmanD (2014) Migrant Entrepreneurs: Building our Businesses Creating our Jobs. London: Centre for Entrepeneurs and DueDil.
23.
KaufmanRL (2013) Heteroskedasticity in Regression: Detection and Correction. London: Sage.
24.
LambertPS (2015) Advances in data management for social survey research. In: ProcterRHalfpennyP (eds) Innovations in Digital Research Method. London: Sage.
25.
LambertPSBihagenE (2014) Using occupation-based social classifications. Work, Employment and Society28(3): 481–494.
26.
Layton-HenryZ (1985) Immigration into Britain: The new commonwealth migrants 1945–62. History Today35(12): 27–32.
27.
LemosSPortesJ (2008) The Impact of Migration from the New European Union Member States on Native Workers. London: Department for Work and Pensions.
28.
LucchinoPBondibeneCRPortesJ (2012) Examining the relationship between immigration and unemployment using National Insurance Number registration data. NIESR Discussion Paper 386. London: National Institute of Economic and Social Research.
29.
MacInnesTAldridgeHBusheSTinsonABarry BornT (2014) Monitoring Poverty and Social Exclusion 2014. York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation.
30.
MagnussonK (2014) Interpreting confidence intervals: An interactive visualisation. R Psychologist. Available at: http://rpsychologist.com/d3/CI/ (accessed 26 February 2016).
31.
MetcalfD (2012) Analysis of the Impacts of Migration. London: Migration Advisory Committee.
32.
MoreyRHoekstraRRouderJLeeMWagenmakersJ (2016) The fallacy of placing confidence in confidence intervals. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review21(103): 103–123.
33.
NickellSSaleheenJ (2008) The Impact of Immigration on Occupational Wages: Evidence from Britain. London: Spatial Economics Research Centre.
34.
ReedHLatorreM (2009) The Economic Impacts of Migration on the UK Labour Market. Economics of Migration Working Paper 3. London: Institute for Public Policy Research.
35.
SheldonA (1990) UK Political Parties since 1945. London: Philip Allan.
36.
Shelter Scotland (2016) Shelter Scotland Briefing for Debate on Motion S4M-15116 Impact of the UK Immigration Bill on Scotland. Scotland: Shelter Scotland.
37.
SmithMRockM (2014) Migrants Behind One in Seven UK Companies. London: The Centre for Entrepreneurs and DueDil.
38.
StockemerDBarisioneM (2016) The ‘new’discourse of the Front National under Marine Le Pen: A slight change with a big impact. European Journal of Communication. DOI: DOI: 10.1177/0267323116680132.
