Tensions, conflicts, and community instability associated with heightened immigration – especially of nonwhite immigrant groups – threaten to balkanize America. This article highlights the root causes of the growing opposition to both immigrants and U.S. immigration policy — the nativist backlash, presents a typology of the community-level conflicts that have arisen as a consequence of heightened immigration – legal and illegal — to the United States over the last 30 years, and outlines the conditions under which diversity can be brought to the forefront as one of society's strengths.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbelmannN. and LieJ.1995Blue Dreams: Korean Americans and the Los Angeles Riots. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
2.
AdlerJ. and WaldmanS.1995 “What Is An American?; Sweet Land of Liberties,” Newsweek, July 10. P. 18.
3.
AlarconE.1995 “Anti-Immigrant Racism and the Fight for Unity,” Political Affairs, 74:6–11.
4.
AndersenK.1983 “The New Ellis Island,” Time, 121:18–25. June 13.
5.
AndreasP.1994 “Border Troubles: Free Trade, Immigration and Cheap Labour,” The Ecologist, 24:230–234.
6.
AubryL.1987 “The State of L.A.'s Black Korean Relations,” Los Angeles Sentinel, March 26.
7.
BakerS.G.1997 “The Amnesty’ Aftermath: Current Policy Issues Stemming from the Legislation Progress of the 1986 Immigration Reform and Control Act,” International Migration Review, 30:5–27.
8.
BanksS.1985 “Korean Merchants, Black Customers – Tensions Grow,” Los Angeles Sentinel. April–15.
9.
BoboL.D., ZubrinksyC. L., JohnsonJ. H.Jr., and OliverM.L.1995a “Public Opinion before and after the Spring of Discontent.” In The Los Angeles Riots: Lesson for the Urban Future. Ed. BaldassareM.Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Pp. 103–133.
10.
BoboL.D., ZubrinksyC. L., JohnsonJ. H.Jr., and OliverM.L.1995b “Work Orientation, Job Discrimination, and Ethnicity: A Focus Group Perspective.” In Research in the Sociology of Work, Vol. 5, The Meaning of Work. Ed. SimpsonR. L. and SimpsonI. H.Greenwich, CT: JAI Press. Pp. 45–86.
11.
BorjasG.J.1987 “Immigrants, Minorities, and Labor Market Competition,” Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 40:382–392.
12.
BowermasterD.1995 “Closing the Golden Door: The Immigration Battle,” U.S. News and World Report, September 25. P. 42.
13.
BrennerE.1995 “Census Study Sees Ethnic Shirts,” The New York Times, August 6. P. 1.
14.
BriggsV.1995 “Immigration Policy Sends Blacks Back to the South,” The Social Contract, 5:270–271.
15.
BrimelowP.1995Alien Nation: Common Sense about America's Immigration Disaster. New York: Random House.
16.
BrownsteinR.1995 “Washington Outlook: Affirmative Action, Immigration: Wedge Issues That Need Not Divide,” Los Angeles Times, February 27. P. 5A.
17.
CarneyD.1996 “Law Restricts Illegal Immigration,” Congressional Quarterly, November 16. Pp. 3287–3289.
18.
Center for Immigration Studies1997a “Immigration Reform and Welfare: The Devil Is in the Details,” Immigration Review, 28:13.
19.
Center for Immigration Studies1997b “5 Million Illegal Immigrants: An Analysis of New INS Numbers,” Immigration Review, 28:1–4.
20.
Center for Immigration Studies1995 “Immigration-Related Statistics – 1995,” Backgrounder, No. 2–95. July.
21.
Center for Immigration Studies1994 “Immigration and the Labor Market,” CIS Paper No. 9. November 1.
22.
ChangE.T.1988 “Korean-Black Conflict in Los Angeles: Perceptions and Realities.” Paper presented at Annual Regional Seminar on Koreans, University of California at Berkeley, April 29.
23.
CharlesN.1995 “Closing the Door,” Emerge, July/August. Pp. 34–39.
24.
ChiswickB. and SullivanT.A.1995 “The New Immigrants.” In State of the Union: America in the 1990s. Ed. FarleyR.New York: Russell Sage Foundation. Pp. 211–270.
25.
ChiswickB., ChiswickC. and MillerP.1985 “Are Immigrants and Natives Perfect Substitutes in Production?” International Migration Review, 19:(4)674–685.
26.
CleaverJ.H.1987 “One Answer to an Outcry,” Los Angeles Sentinel, March 19.
27.
CleaverJ.H.1983a “Asian Businesses in Black Community Cause Stir,” Los Angeles Sentinel, August 11.
28.
CleaverJ.H.1983b “Asian Attitudes Toward Blacks Cause Raised Eyebrows,” Los Angeles Sentinel, August 18.
29.
CleaverJ.H.1983c “Residents Complain About Alleged Asian ‘Problem’,” Los Angeles Sentinel, August 25.
30.
CleaverJ.H.1983c “Citizens Air Gripes About Asians,” Los Angeles Sentinel, September 1.
31.
EstradaR.1995 “Immigration Buries Blacks,” The Social Contract, 5:262–263.
32.
Field Institute1988Statistical Tabulations from the February 1988 Survey of the Field Institute on Ethnic Minorities. San Francisco: The Field Institute.
33.
FlaniganJ.1994 “Keep Immigration on the Side of Common Sense,” Los Angeles Times, October 30. P. D1.
34.
FreemanR.B.1991 “Employment and Earnings of Disadvantaged Young Men in a Labor Shortage Economy.” In The Urban Underclass. Ed. JencksC. and PetersonP.Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution. Pp. 103–121.
35.
FreerR.1995 “Black-Korean Conflict.” In The Los Angeles Riots: Lessons for the Urban Future. Ed. BaldassareM.Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Pp. 175–204.
36.
FreyW.H.1995a “The New Geography of Population Shifts: Trends toward Balkanization.” In State of the Nation: America in the 1990s. Ed. FarleyR.New York: Russell Sage Foundation. Pp. 271–336.
37.
FreyW.H.1995b “Immigration and Internal Migration Flight: A California Case Study,” Population and Environment, 16:351–375.
38.
FreyW.H.1993 “The New Urban Revival,” Urban Studies, 30:741–774.
39.
FuchsL.1995 “What Do Immigrants Deserve? A Warm Welcome and the Usual Benefits – But Not Affirmative Action,” The Washington Post, January 29. P. C2.
40.
GarciaP.1985 “Immigration Issues in Urban Ecology: The Case of Los Angeles.” In Urban Ethnicity in the United States: New Immigrations and Old Minorities. Ed. MaldonadoL. and MooreJ.Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications.
41.
GrahamJ.L.1994 “Commentary on Multiculturalism,” Los Angeles Times, Orange County edition, November 27. P. 17B.
42.
GrantD. and JohnsonJ.H.Jr., 1995 “Conservative Policymaking and Growing Urban Inequality during the 1980s.” In Research in Politics and Society. Vol. 5, The Politics of Wealth and Inequality. Ed. RatcliffR., OliverM. L., and ShapiroT.Greenwich, CT: JAI Press. Pp. 127–160.
43.
GrimsleyK.D.1995 “The Downside of Downswing,” The Washington Post National Weekly Edition, November 13–19. P. 16.
44.
GuthrieP. and HutchinsonJ.1995 “The Impact of Perceptions on Interpersonal Interactions in an African American/Asian American Housing Project,” Journal of Black Studies, 25:377–395.
45.
HeaddenS.1995a “One Nation, One Language?” U.S. News & World Report, September 25. Pp. 38–42.
46.
HeaddenS.1995b “Tongue–tied in the Schools,” U.S. News & World Report, September 25. Pp. 44–46.
47.
HenryC. P1980 “Black-Chicano Coalitions: Possibilities and Problems, Western Journal of Black Studies, 4:222–232.
48.
HernandezM. and ScottA.1980 “Latino Influx: New Strains Emerge as Watts Evolves,” Los Angeles Times, August 24.
49.
HingB.O.1993 “Beyond the Rhetoric of Assimilation and Cultural Pluralism: Addressing the Tension of Separatism and Conflict in an Immigration—Driven Multiracial Society,” California Law Review, 81:863–925.
50.
HolmesS.A.1995 “Report of Accelerating U.S. Immigration Will Intensify Debate,” The (Raleigh) News and Observer, September 3. P. 30A.
51.
HudsonT.1995 “Cutting Off Care,” Hospitals and Health Networks, 69:36.
52.
Institute for Social Science Research1994Los Angeles Survey of Urban Inequality.
53.
Institute for Social Science Research1992Los Angeles County Social Survey.
54.
JacksonJ.J.1995 “Competition Between Blacks and Immigrants,” The Social Contract, 5:247–254.
55.
JacksonM.R., JohnsonJ. H.Jr., and FarrellC.W.Jr., 1994 “After the Smoke Has Cleared: An Analysis of Selected Responses to the Los Angeles Civil Unrest of 1992,” Contentions: Debates in Society, Culture, and Science, 3:3–22.
56.
JenksR.1995 “Chances for Immigration Reform Improve,” Immigration Review, 22:1–5. Summer.
57.
Jet1988a “Black Stereotypes Used to Market Products in Japan,” Jet, 75:36–37. August 15.
58.
Jet1988b “Japanese Slurs on Blacks Causing Rift Between Them,” Jet, 75:12. October 31.
59.
JohnsonJ.H.Jr., and FarrellW.C.Jr. Forthcoming “Growing Income Inequality in American Society: A Political Economy Perspective.” In The Growth of Income Disparity. Ed. AuerbachJ.Washington, DC: National Policy Association.
60.
JohnsonJ.H.Jr., and FarrellW.C.Jr.1993 “The Fire This Time: The Genesis of the Los Angeles Rebellion of 1992,” North Carolina Law Review, 71:1403–1420.
61.
JohnsonJ.H.Jr., FarrellW. C.Jr. and JacksonR.M.1994 “Los Angeles One Year Later: A Prospective Assessment of Responses to the 1992 Civil Unrest,” Economic Development Quarterly, 8:19–27.
62.
JohnsonJ.H.Jr., and GrantD.1997 “Post–1980 Black Population Redistribution Trends in the U.S.,” Southeastern Geographer, 37:1–19.
63.
JohnsonJ.H.Jr., JonesC. K., FarrellW. C.Jr., and OliverM.L.1992 “The Los Angeles Rebellion: A Retrospective View,” Economic Development Quarterly, 6:356–372.
64.
JohnsonJ.H.Jr., and OliverL.M.1992 “Structural Changes in the U.S. Economy and Black Male Joblessness: A Reassessment.” In Urban Labor Markets and Job Opportunity. Ed. PetersonG. E. and VromanW.The Urban Institute Press. Pp. 113–147.
65.
JohnsonJ.H.Jr., and OliverM.L.1989 “Interethnic Minority Conflict in Urban America: The Effects of Economic and Social Dislocations,” Urban Geography, 10:449–463.
66.
JohnsonJ.H.Jr., OliverM. L. and BoboL.D.1994 “Understanding the Contours of Deepening Urban Inequality: Theoretical Underpinnings and Research Design of Multi-City Study,” Urban Geography, 15:77–89.
67.
JohnsonJ.H.Jr., OliverM. L. and RosemanC.C.1989 “Ethnic Dilemmas in Comparative Perspective,” Urban Geography, 10:425–433.
68.
JohnsonJ.H.Jr., and RosemanC.C.1990 “Recent Black Outmigration from Los Angeles: The Role of Household Dynamics and Kinship Systems,” Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 80:205–222.
69.
Johnson-WebbK. and JohnsonJ.H.Jr1997 “North Carolina Communities in Transition: An Overview of Hispanic In-Migration,” North Carolina Geographer.
70.
JostK.1995 “Cracking Down on Immigration: Should Government Benefits and Service Be Cut Off? Congressional Quarterly– Researcher, 5:99–119.
71.
KatzJ.L.1996 “Provisions of the Welfare Bill, Congressional Quarterly, August 3. Pp. 2192–2194.
72.
KeelerW.C.1995 “Welcoming the Stranger: A Reflection of the Current Immigration Debate,” Migration World Magazine, 23:33.
73.
KimS.1984 “Seeking a Dialogue by Koreans, Blacks,” Los Angeles Times, June 8. Part 5, p. 8.
74.
KirshermanJ. and NeckermanK.1991 “We Love to Hire Them But …: The Meaning of Race for Employers.” In The Urban Underclass. Ed. JencksC. and PetersonP.Washington, DC: Brookings Institution. Pp. 203–224.
LeeC.S. and SloanL.1994 “Its Our Turn Now – Prop. 187: As California Cracks Down on Illegals, Blacks and Hispanics Fight a Deeper Ethnic War,” Newsweek, November 21. P. 57.
77.
LeeK.W.1995 “From Dream to Nightmare: The L.A. Riots and the Korean-American Community.” Los Angeles Times, April 23. Book Review Desk P. 2.
78.
Los Angeles Sentinel1988 “Maker of Racist Toys: Japanese Firm Offers Sensitivity Proposals, Los Angeles Sentinel, October 27. Pp. Al, A20.
79.
LowellB.L. and JingZ.1994 “Unauthorized Workers and Immigration Reform: What Can We Ascertain from Employers?” International Migration Review, 28(3):427–448.
80.
LuttwakE.1992 “The Riots: Underclass vs. Immigrants,” The New York Times, May 15. P. A29.
81.
MacdonaldH.1995 “The American Nightmare; Why Korean Entrepreneurs Are Fleeing Our Cities,” The Washington Post, May 7. P. C1.
82.
MalloyR. and KirkorianM.1995 “Three Decades of Mass Immigration: The Legacy of the 1965 Immigration Act,” Immigration Review, 23:1–4.
83.
MartinJ.1995a “The Politics and Demographics of Immigration Reform,” Immigration Review, 23:4–8.
84.
MartinJ.1995b “Immigration Contributes Over Half of U.S. Population Growth,” Immigration Review, 23:10–12.
85.
MasseyD.S. and DentonN.A.1993American Apartheid: Segregation and the Making of the Underclass. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
86.
McDanielA.1995 “The Dynamic Racial Composition of the United States,” Daedalus124:179–198.
87.
McDonnellP.J.1994 “As Change Again Overtakes Compton, So Do Tensions,” Los Angeles Times, August 21. P. 1A.
88.
MillerJ.J.1994 “Immigration, the Press and the New Racism,” Media Studies Journal, 8:19–28.
89.
MinesR.1985 “Undocumented Immigrants and California Industries: Reflections and Research.” Hearings before the Intergovernmental Relations Committee, November 15.
90.
MuellerE.J.1994 “Running Hard to Stay in One Place: Low-Wage Poverty Among Immigrant Women in Los Angeles,” Economic Development Quarterly, 8:158–170.
91.
MullerT. and EspenshadeT.1985The Fourth Wave. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute Press.
92.
National Research Council1997The New Americans: Economic, Demographic and Fiscal Effects of Immigration. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
93.
NomaniA.Z., RoseF. and OrtegaB.1995 “Labor Department Asks $5 Million for Alleged Worker Enslavement,” Wall Street Journal, August 16. P. B6.
94.
OliverM.L. and JohnsonJ.H.Jr1984 “Interethnic Conflict in an Urban Ghetto: The Case of Blacks and Latinos in Los Angeles,” Research in Social Movements, Conflict, and Change, 6:57–84.
95.
PostrelV.1992 “The Real Story Goes Beyond Black and White,” Los Angeles Times, May 8. P. A11.
96.
PyleM.1995 “Bilingual Backlash: A Closer Look at Immigrant Education,” Los Angeles Times, June 1. P. 1A.
97.
RichardsL.1995 “Middle Class Jobs on the Immigration Chopping Block,” The Social Contract, 5:291–292.
98.
RobertsS.1994 “Hispanic Population Outnumbers Blacks in Four Major Cities as Demographics Shift,” The New York Times, October 9. P. 34.
99.
RoseH.M.1989 “Blacks and Cubans in Metropolitan Miami's Changing Economy,” Urban Geography, 10:464–486.
100.
RossK.1994 “Southern California Voices/A Forum for Community Issues: Proposition 187,” Los Angeles Times, October 24. P. 5B.
101.
SalinP.1997Assimilation, American Style. New York: Basic Books.
102.
SchultzW.L.1993 “Culture in Transition: Alternative Futures of Immigration, Ethnic Composition, and Community Conflict Within the U.S.,” Futures Research Quarterly, 9:51–72.
103.
ScottA.J.1986Metropolis: From Division to Urban Form. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
104.
SilversteinS. and BrooksN.R.1994 “Prop. 187 is Affecting Workplace; Immigration: More Companies Have Started Checking Job Candidates’ Papers, and Employees Talk of Rising Tensions,” Los Angeles Times, November 10. P. D1.
105.
SojaE., MoralesR. and WolffG.1983 “Urban Restructuring: An Analysis of Social and Spatial Change in Los Angeles,” Economic Geography, 58:221–235.
106.
StanfieldR.1994 “New Faces of Hate,” National Journal, 26:1461–1463. June 18.
107.
SunL.H.1995 “Lumping the Legal with the Illegal,” The Washington Post National Weekly Edition, November 20–26. P. 31.
108.
TeitelbaumM.S. and WeinerM.1995Threatened Peoples, Threatened Borders: World Migration and U.S. Policy. New York: W. W. Norton & Company.
109.
ThomL.1995 “Babies, Welfare, and Crime,” The Social Contract, 5:283–290.
110.
TichenorD.J.1994 “Immigration and Political Community in the United States,” Responsive Community, 4:16–28.
111.
TurnerM., FixM. and StruykR.1991Opportunities Diminished, Opportunities Denied: Discrimination in Hiring. Unpublished project report, Urban Institute Press, Washington, DC.
112.
UnzR.K.1994 “Immigration or the Welfare State: Which Is Our Real Enemy?” Policy Review, 70:33–38. Fall.
113.
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development1995Empowerment: A New Covenant with America's Communities: President Clinton's National Urban Policy Report. Washington, DC: Office of Policy Development and Research, U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
114.
U.S. General Accounting Office1995 “Janitors in the Los Angeles Area,” The Social Contract, 5:258.
115.
ValenzuelaA.Jr.1995 “California's Melting Pot Boils Over: The Origins of a Cruel Proposition,” Dollars and Sense, March/April. Pp. 28–31.
116.
WaldingerR. and GilbertsonG.1994 “Immigrants’ Progress: Ethnic and Gender Differences among U.S. Immigrants in the 1980s,” Sociological Perspectives, 37:431–444.
117.
WeintraubD.M.1994 “California Closes Its Doors,” State Legislatures, 20:16–17.
118.
ZacharyG.P.1995 “U.S. Reaches Pact With Software Firm Over Payment of Foreign Professionals,” Wall Street Journal, August 16. P. A3.
119.
ZolbergA.R.1995 “From Invitation to Interdiction: U.S. Foreign Policy and Immigration since 1945.” In Threatened Peoples, Threatened Borders: World Migration and U.S. Policy. Ed. TeitelbaumM. S. and WeinerM.New York: W. W. Norton & Company. Pp. 117–159.
