Recent research and real-world processes suggest that effective climate change mitigation policies are not feasible without at least a certain degree of public support. Hence, we investigate the link between existing domestic energy policies and individual policy instrument preferences in 21 European countries. We assume a policy feedback perspective and, thus, start from the idea that the current domestic energy context influences what future policies are possible and preferred by citizens. High political trust and strong climate change attitudes are expected to strengthen this relationship. Our results do not lend support to a general link between existing policies and future policy preferences. However, we find evidence of a positive policy feedback in individuals with strong climate change attitudes and/or high levels of political trust, which, depending on each country’s current energy policy, either hinders or facilitates the energy transition.
AasenMarianneVatnArild (2018) Public Attitudes Toward Climate Policies: The effect of institutional contexts and political values. Ecological Economics146: 106–114.
2.
BlondeelMathieuVan de GraafThijs (2018) Toward a Global Coal Mining Moratorium? A comparative analysis of coal mining policies in the USA, China, India and Australia. Climatic Change150(1–2): 89–101.
3.
BrounenDirkKokNilsQuigleyJohn M (2013) Energy Literacy, Awareness, and Conservation Behavior of Residential Households. Energy Economics38: 42–50.
4.
CarattiniStefanoBaranziniAndreaThalmannPhilippeVaroneFrédéricVöhringerFrank (2017) Green Taxes in a Post-Paris World: Are millions of nays inevitable?Environmental and Resource Economics68(1): 97–128.
5.
CherryTodd LGarcíaJorge HKallbekkenSteffenTorvangerAsbjørn (2014) The Development and Deployment of Low-carbon Energy Technologies: The role of economic interests and cultural world views on public support. Energy Policy68: 562–566.
6.
CitrinJackStokerLaura (2018) Political Trust in a Cynical Age. Annual Review of Political Science21(1): 49–70.
7.
DermontClau (2018) Environmental Decision-Making: The influence of policy information. Environmental Politics. OnlineFirst: 1–24.
8.
DermontClauIngoldKarinKammermannLorenzStadelmann-SteffenIsabelle (2017) Bringing the Policy Making Perspective in: A political science approach to social acceptance. Energy Policy108: 359–368.
9.
DrewsStefanvan den BerghJeroen CJM (2016) What Explains Public Support for Climate Policies? A review of empirical and experimental studies. Climate Policy16(7): 855–876.
10.
EdenhoferOttmarPichs-MadrugaRamónSokonaYoubaSeybothKristinMatschossPatrickKadnerSusanneZwickelTimmEickemeierPatrickHansenGerritSchloemerSteffenStechowChristoph von (2012) IPCC Special Report on Renewable Energy Sources and Climate Change Mitigation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
11.
EngelsAnitaHütherOttoSchäferMikeHeldHermann (2013) Public Climate-change Skepticism, Energy Preferences and Political Participation. Global Environmental Change23(5): 1018–1027.
12.
FirestoneJeremyKemptonWillettLilleyMeredith BlaydesSamoteskulKateryna (2012) Public Acceptance of Offshore Wind Power Across Regions and Through Time. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management55(10): 1369–1386.
13.
FredrikssonPer GNeumayerEric (2016) Corruption and Climate Change Policies: Do the bad old days matter?Environmental and Resource Economics63(2): 451–469.
14.
HarringNiklas (2014) Corruption, Inequalities and the Perceived Effectiveness of Economic Pro-environmental Policy Instruments: A European cross-national study. Environmental Science & Policy39: 119–128.
15.
HarringNiklasJagersSverker C (2013) Should We Trust in Values? Explaining public support for pro-environmental taxes. Sustainability5(1): 210–227.
16.
HarringNiklasJagersSverker C (2018) Why Do People Accept Environmental Policies? The prospects of higher education and changes in norms, beliefs and policy preferences. Environmental Education Research24(6): 791–806.
17.
HetheringtonMarc J (2014) The Political Relevance of Political Trust. American Political Science Review92(4): 791–808.
18.
IngoldKarinStadelmann-SteffenIsabelleKammermannLorenz (2019) The Acceptance of Instruments in Instrument Mix Situations: Citizens’ perspective on Swiss energy transition. Research Policy48(10): 103694.
19.
JacobssonStaffanLauberVolkmar (2006) The Politics and Policy of Energy System Transformation – Explaining the German Diffusion of Renewable Energy Technology. Energy Policy34(3): 256–276.
20.
JagersSverker CHarringNiklasMattiSimon (2018) Environmental Management from Left to Right – on Ideology, Policy-specific Beliefs and Pro-environmental Policy Support. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management61(1): 86–104.
21.
KirchgässnerGebhardSchneiderFriedrich (2003) On the Political Economy of Environmental Policy. Public Choice115(3): 369–396.
22.
KumlinStaffanStadelmann-SteffenIsabelle (eds) (2014) How Welfare States Shape the Democratic Public: Policy Feedback, Participation, Voting and Attitudes. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing Limited.
23.
Le QuéréCorinneKorsbakkenJan IvarWilsonCharlieTosunJaleAndrewRobbieAndresRobert JCanadellJosep GJordanAndrewPetersGlen PVuurenDetlef P van (2019) Drivers of Declining CO2 Emissions in 18 Developed Economies. Nature Climate Change9(3): 213–217.
24.
LowryWilliam RJoslynMark (2014) The Determinants of Salience of Energy Issues. Review of Policy Research31(3): 153–172.
25.
MayerAdamSmithE Keith (2017) Education, Political Affiliation and Energy Policy in the United States: A case of Tea Party exceptionalism?Energy Research & Social Science23(1): 74–81.
26.
McCrightAaron MDunlapRiley EMarquart-PyattSandra T (2016) Political Ideology and Views About Climate Change in the European Union. Environmental Politics25(2): 338–358.
27.
PetersB GuyJordanAndrewTosunJale (2017) Over-Reaction and Under-Reaction in Climate Policy: An institutional analysis. Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning19(6): 612–624.
28.
PiersonPaul (2011) The New Politics of the Welfare State. World Politics48(2): 143–179.
29.
SchmidtNicole MFleigAndreas (2018) Global Patterns of National Climate Policies: Analyzing 171 country portfolios on climate policy integration. Environmental Science & Policy84: 177–185.
30.
ShwomRachaelBidwellDavidDanAmyDietzThomas (2010) Understanding U.S. Public Support for Domestic Climate Change Policies. Global Environmental Change20(3): 472–482.
31.
SkocpolTheda (1992) Protecting Soldiers and Mothers: The Political Origins of Social Policy in the United States. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
32.
SorokaStuart NWlezienChristopher (2009) Degrees of Democracy: Politics, Public Opinion, and Policy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
33.
SossJoeSchramSanford F (2007) A Public Transformed? Welfare reform as policy feedback. American Political Science Review101(1): 111–127.
34.
Stadelmann-SteffenIsabelle (2019) Bad News is Bad News: Information effects and citizens’ socio-political acceptance of new technologies of electricity transmission. Land Use Policy81: 531–545.
35.
Stadelmann-SteffenIsabelleDermontClau (2018) The Unpopularity of Incentive-based Instruments: What improves the cost–benefit ratio?Public Choice175(1): 37–62.
36.
StokesLeah C (2013) The Politics of Renewable Energy Policies: The case of feed-in tariffs in Ontario, Canada. Energy Policy56: 490–500.
37.
TosunJale (2018) Investigating Ministry Names for Comparative Policy Analysis: Lessons from energy governance. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice20(3): 324–335.
38.
TosunJaleMišićMile (2020) Conferring Authority in the European Union: Citizens’ policy priorities for the European Energy Union. Journal of European Integration42(1). Forthcoming.
39.
WlezienChristopher (1995) The Public as a Thermostat: Dynamics of preferences for spending. American Journal of Political Science39(4): 981–1000.
40.
WlezienChristopherSorokaStuart N (2016) Public Opinion and Public Policy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
41.
WolskoChristopherAriceagaHectorSeidenJesse (2016) Red, White, and Blue Enough to be Green: Effects of moral framing on climate change attitudes and conservation behaviors. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology65(1): 7–19.
42.
WüstenhagenRolfWolsinkMaartenBürerMary Jean (2007) Social Acceptance of Renewable Energy Innovation: An introduction to the concept. Energy Policy35(5): 2683–2691.
43.
ZieglerAndreas (2017) Political Orientation, Environmental Values, and Climate Change Beliefs and Attitudes: An empirical cross-country analysis. Energy Economics63: 144–153.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
