We examine the historical phenomenon of truces, as these occurred during a period of intense warfare during World War I, around Christmas 1914. These were processes of resistance that could not have been planned (otherwise they would obviously have been thwarted by authority) and that occurred in a setting with continuously changing conditions. Our purpose in making this analysis is to identify the micro-foundations and behaviours of enacting resistance and forming a truce under conditions where planning and executing cannot be assumed to be orderly and linear. We discuss the battlefield context of intense competition and mutual suffering as an organizational setting in order to provide a more precise explanation of how rules and structures can be (at least) temporarily suspended in the workplace. We rethink the construct of resistance as an act of improvisation; we do so by developing a framework that explains how resistance can emerge and be quashed in workplace settings that might appear at first sight to be immune. Therefore, we combine two themes that have largely been separated in theory: resistance and improvisation. Doing so opens new ground in three ways. First, we contribute to literature about resistance by explaining how it was constructed as action suspending rules and structures in hostile contexts. Second, we show the political-motivational dimension of improvisation. Third, we extend the notion of truce as not an end in itself (a temporary settlement) but as an avenue to achieve a real objective (e.g. to change the course of history for the better).
(1974). “Il y a 60 ans sur le front: La leçon de noel” [newspaper clipping]. In Flanders Field Museum, Ypres.
2.
ActonJ. H. (1975). “Interview by K. Chambers” [tape recording]. Imperial War Museum Collection (No. 24881). Imperial War Museum, London.
3.
AdamsI. (2015). A game for Christmas: The Argylls, Saxons and football on the Western Front, December 1914. International Journal of the History of Sport, 32, 1395–1415.
4.
AlcadipaniR.HassardJ.IslamG. (2018). “I Shot the Sheriff”: Irony, sarcasm and the changing nature of workplace resistance. Journal of Management Studies, 55), 1452–1487.
5.
AlfanoM.RobinsonB. (2017). Gossip as a burdened virtue. Ethical Theory Moral Practice, 20, 473–487.
6.
AllenA. (2008). Rationalizing oppression. Journal of Power, 1(1), 51–65.
7.
AmabileT. M. (1998). How to kill creativity. Harvard Business Review, 76(4), 77–87.
8.
AndersonB. (2006). Imagined communities: Reflections on the origin and spread of nationalism. London: Verso Books.
9.
ArgyrisC. (1985). Strategy, change and defensive routines. Boston, MA: Pitman.
10.
ArmesR. J. (1914). [Letter to his wife]. Imperial War Museum Collection (No. 16576). Imperial War Museum, London.
11.
AshurstG. (1987). “Interview by P. M. Hart” [tape recording]. Imperial War Museum Collection (No. 9875). Imperial War Museum, London.
12.
AustinF. (n.d.). “Interview by S. Sedley” [tape recording]. Imperial War Museum Collection (No. 33292). Imperial War Museum, London.
13.
BairnsfatherB. (1916). Bullets and billets. London: Grant Richards.
14.
BambergerP. A.PrattM. G. (2010). Moving forward by looking back: Reclaiming unconventional research contexts and samples in organizational scholarship. Academy of Management Journal, 53, 665–671.
15.
BarluetA. (1988). Les fraternisations de Noël. L’Histoire, 107, 77–79.
16.
BellJ. F. (1930). The First Battle of Ypres, October 1914. In PurdomC. B.(Ed.), Everyman at war. Sixty personal narratives of the war (pp. 17–21). London: J.M. Dent.
17.
BigleyG. A.RobertsK. H. (2001). The incident command system: High-reliability organizing for complex and volatile task environments. Academy of Management Journal, 44, 1281–1299.
18.
BlumA. F.McHughP. (1971). The social ascription of motives. American Sociological Review, 36, 98–109.
19.
BoyleD. (2015). Peace on earth: The Christmas Truce of 1914: CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform.
20.
BradyM. (2011). Improvisation versus rigid command and control at Stalingrad. Journal of Management History, 17(1), 27–49.
21.
BrownD. (2004). Remembering a victory for human kindness. Washington Post, 25December2004, p. C01.
22.
BrownM.SeatonS. (1984). The Christmas Truce: The Western Front December 1914. London: Pan Books.
23.
BucherS.LangleyA. (2016). The interplay of reflective and experimental spaces in interrupting and reorienting routine dynamics. Organization Science, 27, 594–613.
24.
BurawoyM. (1979). Manufacturing consent: Changes in the labor process under monopoly capitalism. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
25.
BurnesB. (2007). Kurt Lewin and the Harwood studies: The foundations of OD. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 43(2), 213–231.
26.
BurnesB. (2015). Understanding resistance to change: Building on Coch and French. Journal of Change Management, 15(2), 92–116.
27.
CacciatoriE. (2012). Resolving conflict in problem-solving: Systems of artefacts in the development of new routines. Journal of Management Studies, 49, 1559–1585.
28.
ChorbaT. (2018). Trench conflict with combatants and infectious disease. Emerging Infectious Diseases, 24, 2136–2137.
29.
CleggS. R.CourpassonD.PhillipsN. (2006). Power and organizations. Foundations for organizational science. London: SAGE Publications.
30.
CoghlanD. (1993). A person-centered approach to dealing with resistance to change. Leadership & Organization Development Journal, 14(4), 10–14.
31.
CooperC. E. (1982). Behind the lines: One woman’s war 1914–18. Sydney: Collins.
32.
CourpassonD.DanyF.CleggS. R. (2012). Resisters at work: Generating productive resistance in the workplace. Organization Science, 23, 801–819.
33.
CourpassonD.MartíI. (2019). Collective ethics of resistance: The organization of survival in the Warsaw Ghetto. Organization, 26(6), 853–872.
34.
CourpassonD.VallasS. (2016). The Sage handbook of resistance. London: SAGE Publications.
35.
CowanJ. (1922). The New Zealand wars: A history of the Maori campaigns and the pioneering period (Vol. 1). Wellington: Government Printer.
36.
CrossanM. M.SorrentiM. (1997). Making sense of improvisation. Advances in Strategic Management, 14, 155–180.
37.
CrowleyM. (2012). Control and dignity in professional, manual and service-sector employment. Organization Studies, 33, 1383–1406.
38.
CunhaM. P.CleggS. R.RegoA.NevesP. (2014). Organizational improvisation: From the constraint of strict tempo to the power of the avant-garde. Creativity and Innovation Management, 23, 359–373.
39.
CunhaM. P.CunhaJ. V. d.KamocheK. (1999). Organizational improvisation: What, when, how and why. International Journal of Management Reviews, 1(3), 299–341.
40.
CunhaM. P.KamocheK.CunhaR. C. (2003). Organizational improvisation and leadership. International Studies of Management & Organization, 33(1), 34–57.
41.
Daily Mail (1915). One day of peace at the front. Daily Mail, 1January1915.
42.
DentE. B.GoldbergS. G. (1999). Challenging “resistance to change”. Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 35, 25–41.
43.
DittrichK.GuérardS.SeidlD. (2016). Talking about routines: The role of reflective talk in routine change. Organization Science, 27, 678–697.
44.
DuboisP. (1979). Sabotage in industry. Harmondsworth, UK: Penguin.
45.
EisenhardtK. M.GraebnerM. E. (2007). Theory building from cases: Opportunities and challenges. Academy of Management Journal, 50, 25–32.
46.
EmirbayerM.MischeA. (1998). What is agency?American Journal of Sociology, 103, 962–1023.
47.
EwartW. (1934). Scots guard: On the Western Front, 1915–1918. London: Rich & Cowan.
48.
FergusonN. (1999). The pity of war. New York: Basic Books.
49.
FlemingP.SpicerA. (2007). Contesting the corporation: Struggle, power and resistance in organizations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
50.
FoucaultM. (1979). Discipline and punish. London: Penguin.
51.
GhobadiS.CleggS. (2015). “These days will never be forgotten . . .”: A critical mass approach to online activism. Information and Organization, 25(1), 52–71.
52.
GilbertM. (2004). The First World War: A complete history. London: Macmillan.
53.
GiorgiS.BartunekJ. M.KingB. G. (2017). A Saul Alinsky primer for the 21st century: The roles of cultural competence and cultural brokerage in fostering mobilization in support of change. Research in Organizational Behavior, 37(Supplement C), 125–142.
54.
GomesJ. F. S.Weerd-NederhofP. C. d.PearsonA. W.CunhaM. P. (2003). Is more always better? An exploration of the differential effects of functional integration on performance in new product development. Technovation, 23, 185–191.
55.
HagermanE. (1992). The American Civil War and the origins of modern warfare: Ideas, organization, and field command. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
56.
HällgrenM.RouleauL.de RondM. (2017). A matter of life or death: How extreme context research matters for management and organization studies. Academy of Management Annals, 12(1), 111–153.
57.
HallifaxS. (2010). Over by Christmas: British popular opinion and the short war in 1914. First World War Studies, 1(2), 103–121.
58.
HamiltonJ. (2004). Trench fighting of World War I. Edina, MN: Abdo.
59.
HancockP. (2016). A Christmas carol: A reflection on organization, society, and the socioeconomics of the festive season. Academy of Management Review, 41, 755–765.
60.
HatchM. J. (1997). Jazzing up the theory of organizational improvisation. Advances in Strategic Management, 14, 181–191.
61.
HeydenM. L.FournéS. P.KoeneB. A.WerkmanR.AnsariS. (2017). Rethinking ‘top-down’and ‘bottom-up’roles of top and middle managers in organizational change: Implications for employee support. Journal of Management Studies, 54(7), 961–985.
62.
HodsonR. (2001). Dignity at work. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
63.
HousmanL. (2002). War letters of fallen Englishmen. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
64.
JüngerE. (1920). In Stahlgewittern: Aus dem Tagebuch eines Stosstruppführers. Leisnig: Meier.
65.
JürgsM. (2005). Der kleine Frieden im Großen Krieg: Westfront 1914: Als Deutsche, Franzosen und Briten gemeinsam Weihnachten feierten. Munich: Random House.
66.
KamocheK.CunhaM. P. (2001). Minimal structures: From jazz improvisation to product innovation. Organization Studies, 22, 733–764.
67.
KnightE.TsoukasH. (2019). When fiction trumps truth: What ‘post-truth’ and ‘alternative facts’ mean for management studies. Organization Studies, 40, 183–197.
68.
LaurentinM.GrégoireM. (1965). Carnets d’un fantassin de 1914: 32 croquis [de l’auteur]. Grenoble: Arthaud.
69.
MacKenzieI. (2018). Resistance and the politics of truth: Foucault, Deleuze, Badiou. Bielefeld: Transcript Verlag.
70.
MaherT. V. (2010). Threat, resistance, and collective action. American Sociological Review, 75, 252–272.
71.
MainemelisC. (2010). Stealing fire: Creative deviance in the evolution of new ideas. Academy of Management Review, 35, 558–578.
72.
MartíI.FernándezP. (2013). The institutional work of oppression and resistance: Learning from the Holocaust. Organization Studies, 34), 1195–1223.
73.
MathewsW. V. (1915). Football match. Evening News, 2January1915.
74.
MauriceF. (1921). The history of the London Rifle Brigade, 1859–1919.
75.
MetzgerM. (1915). Snapshots from the field. Kölnische Volkszeitung und Handelsblatt, 13January1915.
76.
MillsC. W. (1940). Situated actions and vocabularies of motive. American Sociological Review, 5, 904–913.
77.
MinerA. S.BassoffP.MoormanC. (2001). Organizational improvisation and learning: A field study. Administrative Science Quarterly, 46, 304–337.
78.
MoormanC.MinerA. S. (1995). Walking the tightrope: Improvisation and information in new product development. Cambridge, MA: Marketing Science Institute.
79.
MoormanC.MinerA. S. (1998a). Organizational improvisation and organizational memory. Academy of Management Review, 23, 698–723.
80.
MoormanC.MinerA. S. (1998b). The convergence of planning and execution: Improvisation in new product development. Journal of Marketing, 62(3), 1–20.
NelsonR. R.WinterS. G. (1982). An evolutionary theory of economic change (4th edition). Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press.
83.
North Mail (1915). North Mail, 9January1915.
84.
Officer of the Westminster Rifles (1914). Fraternization between the Lines. New York Times, 31December, 1914, p. 3.
85.
OregS. (2006). Personality, context, and resistance to organizational change. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 15(1), 73–101.
86.
Pelham-BurnA. (1914). “Mass burying at Christmas 1914” [letter to Cecil Mathew]. Industrial War Museum Collection (No. 8632). Industrial War Museum, London.
87.
PerryJ. (2010). Christmas in Germany: A cultural history. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
88.
PettigrewA. M. (1990). Longitudinal field research on change: Theory and practice. Organization Science, 1, 267–292.
89.
PrasadA.PrasadP. (1998). Everyday struggles at the workplace: The nature and implications of routine resistance in contemporary organizations. In BambergerP. A.SonnenstuhlW. J. (Eds.), Research in the sociology of organizations: Vol. 15. Deviance in and of organizations (pp. 225–257). Stamford, CT: JAI Press.
RhodesC.BadhamR. (2018). Ethical irony and the relational leader: Grappling with the infinity of ethics and the finitude of practice. Business Ethics Quarterly, 28, 71–98.
92.
RosenM. (1988). You asked for it: Christmas at the bosses’ expense. Journal of Management Studies, 25(5), 463–480.
93.
ScottJ. C. (1985). Weapons of the weak: Everyday forms of peasant resistance. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
94.
ScottJ. C. (1990). The infrapolitics of subordinate groups. In ScottJ. C. (Ed.), Hidden transcripts: Domination and the arts of resistance (pp. 183–201). New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
95.
ScottJ. C. (2005). Beyond the war of words: Cautious resistance and calculated conformity. In AmooreL. (Ed.), The global resistance reader (pp. 392–410). London: Routledge.
96.
ShortellC. K.PaddockT. R. E. (2011). Teaching the Great War through peace. History Teacher, 45(1), 9–24.
ThompsonP. (2016). Dissent at work and the resistance debate: Departures, directions, and dead ends. Studies in Political Economy, 97, 106–123.
108.
The Times (1915). The Times, 1January1915.
109.
WadeR. A. (2016). The revolution at one hundred: Issues and trends in the English language historiography of the Russian Revolution of 1917. Journal of Modern Russian History and Historiography, 9(1), 9–38.
110.
Wedderburn-MaxwellJ. (1985). “Interview by L. E. Smith” [tape recording]. Imperial War Museum Collection (No. 9146). Imperial War Museum, London.
111.
WeickK. E. (1979). The social psychology of organizing (2nd edition). New York: McGraw-Hill.
112.
WeickK. E. (1993). Organizational redesign as improvisation. In HuberG. P.GlickW. H. (Eds.), Organizational change and redesign (pp. 346–379). New York: Oxford University Press.
113.
WeickK. E. (1999). The aesthetic of imperfection in orchestras and organizations. In CunhaM. P.MarquesC. A. (Eds.), Readings in organization science (pp. 163–180). Lisbon: Ispa.
114.
WeickK. E.RobertsK. H. (1993). Collective mind in organizations: Heedful interrelating on flight decks. Administrative Science Quarterly, 38, 357–381.
115.
WeintraubS. (2001). Silent Night: The story of World War I Christmas Truce. New York: Free Press.
116.
WiedemannN. J. B.WiegmannL.WeberJ. (2018). Artefacts and the dynamics of truces in organizational routines. In FarjounM.SmithW.LangleyA.TsoukasH. (Eds.), Perspectives on process organization studies: Vol. 8. Dualities, dialectics and paradoxes in organizational life (pp. 195–217). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
117.
WildmanA. (1970). The February Revolution in the Russian army. Soviet Studies, 22(1), 3–23.
118.
WillmottH. (1993). Strength is ignorance; slavery is freedom: Managing culture in modern organizations. Journal of Management Studies, 30, 515–552.
119.
WitkopP.WeddA. F. (2002). German students’ war letters. Philadelphia, PA: Pine Street Books.
120.
WoodwardD. R. (2011). Christmas Truce of 1914: Empathy under fire. Phi Kappa Phi Forum, 91(1), 18–19.
121.
YbemaS.HorversM. (2017). Resistance through compliance: The strategic and subversive potential of frontstage and backstage resistance. Organization Studies, 38, 1233–1251.
122.
YinR. K. (1995). Case study research: Design and methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
123.
ZbarackiM. J.BergenM. (2010). When truces collapse: A longitudinal study of price-adjustment routines. Organization Science, 21, 955–972.
