This paper argues that features of Japanese organizations, previously held to be the foundations of innovation, change and flexibility, can equally be significant barriers to change, innovation and adaptation in turbulent economic environments. This paper draws on two in-depth case studies of Japanese organizations. It shows how, in both cases, these firms displayed specific weaknesses in the ways in which they integrate and bundle knowledge, in particular around their research and development (R&D) functions. Despite the adoption of strategies of technological innovation and internationalization, the data suggest that the pursuit of both strategies is beset by barriers of inertia. Embedded internal network connections and knowledge-sharing routines between central R&D and other divisions are inappropriate for the revised strategy. Existing external connections, with preferred suppliers and customers within keiretsu structures, and close relationships with existing R&D partners retard these firms' strategic flexibility. With a limited variety of latent routines, knowledge, capabilities and agency to draw on when needed, these firms have limited organizational responsiveness and high levels of path-dependency.
Alvesson, Mats , and Dan Karreman2001‘Odd couple: Making sense of the curious concept of knowledge management’ . Journal of Management Studies38/7: 995–1018 .
2.
Archibugi, Daniele2001‘Pavitt's Taxonomy sixteen years on: A review article’ . Economics of Innovation & New Technology10/5: 415–426 .
3.
Arrow, Kenneth1962‘The economic implications of learning by doing’ . Review of Economic Studies29: 155–173 .
4.
Ashforth, Blake E. , and Y. Fried1988The mindlessness of organizational behaviors' . Human Relations41: 305–329 .
5.
Belderbos, Rene2003‘Entry mode, organizational learning, and R&D in foreign affiliates: Evidence from Japanese firms’ . Strategic Management Journal24/3: 235–260 .
6.
Birkinshaw, Julian , and C. F. Fey2000‘Building an internal market system: Insights from five R&D organizations’, in The flexible firm: Capability management in network organisations. Julian Birkinshaw and Peter Hagström (eds). Oxford: Oxford University Press .
7.
Blackler, Frank1995‘Knowledge, knowledge work and organisations: An overview and interpretation’ . Organization Studies16/6: 1021–1046 .
8.
Boisot, Max1995Information space: A framework for learning in organizations, institutions and cultures. London: Routledge .
9.
Bowonder, B. , and T. Miyake1993‘Japanese innovations in advanced technologies: An analysis of functional integration’ . International Journal of Technology Management8/1/2: 135–156 .
10.
Bowonder, B. , and T. Miyake1999‘Japanese LCD industry: Competing through knowledge management’ . Creativity and Innovation Management8/2: 77–100 .
11.
Burns, Tom , and G. M. Stalker1968The management of innovation, 2nd edn.London: Tavistock .
12.
Calori, Roland1999‘National administrative heritages in borderless organizations’ in Managing organizations: Text, readings and cases. R. H. Rosenfeld and D.C. Wilson (eds). Maidenhead: McGraw-Hill .
13.
Clark, Kim B. , and Stephen Wheelwright , editors 1995The product development challenge. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press .
14.
Clegg, Stewart , and Toyohiro Konno2001Trends in Japanese management: Continuing strengths, current problems, and changing priorities. London: Palgrave .
15.
Cohen, Wesley M. , and Daniel A. Levinthal1990‘Absorptive capacity: A new perspective on learning and innovation’ . Administrative Science Quarterly35: 128–152 .
16.
Collinson, Simon1993‘Managing product innovation at Sony: the development of the Data Discman’ . Technology Analysis and Strategic Management5/3: 285–306 .
17.
Collinson, Simon1997‘Knowledge integration for innovation: Comparing multimedia product development at Sony and Philips’ in Knowledge, technology and innovative organizations. J. Butler and A. Piccaluga (eds). Milan: Guerini E. Associati .
18.
Collinson, Simon1999‘Knowledge management capabilities for steel makers: A British-Japanese corporate alliance for organisational learning’ . Technology Analysis and Strategic Management11/3: 337–358 .
19.
Collinson, Simon2001a‘Knowledge management capabilities in R&D: A UK–Japan company comparison’ . R&D Management31/3: 335–347 .
20.
Collinson, Simon2001b‘Developing and deploying knowledge for innovation: British and Japanese corporations compared’ . International Journal of Innovation Management5/1: 73–103 .
21.
Coombs, Rod1996Core competencies and the strategic management of R&D' . R&D Management26/4: 345–355 .
22.
Coombs, Rod , and Richard Hull1998‘Knowledge management practices and path-dependency in innovation’ . Research Policy27/3: 237–253 .
23.
Cusumano, Michael A. , and Kentaro Nobeoka1992‘Strategy, structure and performance in product development: Observations from the auto industry’ . Research Policy21: 265–293 .
24.
Cyert, Richard M. , and James G. March1963A behavioral theory of the firm. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall .
25.
Delios, Andrew , and Paul W. Beamish2001‘Survival and profitability: The roles of experience and intangible assets in foreign subsidiary performance’ . Academy of Management Journal44/5: 1028–1039 .
26.
Dodgson, Mark1993‘Organizational learning: A review of some literatures’ . Organization Studies14/3: 375–394 .
27.
Dore, Ronald1986Flexible rigidities: Industrial policy and structural readjustment in the Japanese economy 1970–1980. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press .
28.
Dosi, Giovanni , Richard R. Nelson , and Sidney G. Winter2001The nature and dynamics of organizational capabilities, new edn.New York: Oxford University Press .
29.
Dyer, J. H.1996‘Specialised supplier networks as a source of competitive advantage: Evidence from the auto industry’ . Strategic Management Journal17: 271–292 .
30.
Eisenhardt, Kathleen M. , and Jeffrey A. Martin2000‘Dynamic capabilities: What are they?’Strategic Management Journal21/10/11: 1105–1122 .
31.
Faulkner, Wendy , James Fleck , and Robin Williams , editors 1998Exploring expertise: Issues and perspectives. Basingstoke: Macmillan .
32.
Feldman, Martha S.2000‘Organizational routines as a source of continuous change’ . Organization Science11/6: 611–629 .
33.
Feldman, Martha S. , and Brian T. Pentland2003‘Reconceptualizing organizational routines as a source of flexibility and change’ . Administrative Science Quarterly48: 94–118 .
34.
Fransman, Martin1994‘Knowledge segmentation: Integration in theory and in Japanese companies’ in Economics of technology. Ove Granstrand (ed.). Amsterdam: Elsevier .
35.
Fruin, W. Mark1997Knowledge works: Managing intellectual capital at Toshiba. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
36.
Giddens, Anthony1984The constitution of society: Outline of the theory of structuration. Cambridge: Polity Press .
37.
Gold, Allan, R. , Masao Hirano , and Yoshinori Yokohama2001‘An outsider takes on Japan’ . McKinsey Quarterly1: 94–105 .
38.
Grant, Robert M.1996‘Prospering in dynamically-competitive environments: Organizational capability as knowledge integration’ . Organization Science7/4: 375–388 .
39.
Greenwood, Royston , and Bob (C.R.) Hinings1988‘Organizational design types, tracks and the dynamics of strategic change’ . Organization Studies9/2: 293–316 .
40.
Gulati, Ranjay , Nitin Nohria , and Akbar Zaheer2000‘Strategic networks’ . Strategic Management Journal21/3: 203–216 .
41.
Hedlund, Gunnar1994‘A model of knowledge management and the N-form corporation’ . Strategic Management Journal15/5: 73–90 .
42.
Hickson, David J. , S. J. Miller , and D. C. Wilson2003‘Planned or prioritized? Two options in managing the implementation of strategic decisions’ . Journal of Management Studies40/7: 1803–1836 .
43.
Hislop, Donald , Sue Newell , Harry Scarbrough , and Jacky Swan2000‘Networks, knowledge and power: Decision making, politics and the process of innovation’ . Technology Analysis & Strategic Management12/3: 399–411 .
44.
Hull, Richard2000‘Knowledge management and the conduct of expert labour’ in Managing knowledge: Critical investigations of work and learning. Craig Prichard , Richard Hull , Mike Chumer , and Hugh Willmott (eds). Basingstoke: Macmillan Business .
45.
Ianisti, Marco , and Kim B. Clark1994‘Integration and dynamic capability: Evidence from product development in automobiles and mainframe computers’ . Industrial and Corporate Change3/3: 557–607 .
46.
Jameson, Mel , Michael J. Sullivan , and Richard L. Constand2000‘Ownership structure and performance of Japanese firms: Horizontal keiretsu, vertical keiretsu, and independents’ . Review of Pacific Basin Financial Markets & Policies3/4: 535–556 .
47.
Jones, Oswald , Steve Conway , and Fred Steward1998‘Social interaction and innovation networks’ . International Journal of Innovation Management2/2: 123–136 .
48.
Kodama, Mitsuru2003‘Strategic innovation in traditional big business: Case studies of two Japanese companies’ . Organization Studies24/2: 235–269 .
49.
Kogut, Bruce , and Udo Zander1992‘Knowledge of the firm: Combinative capabilities and the replication of technology’ . Organization Science3/3: 383–397 .
50.
Laage-Hellman, Jens1997Business networks in Japan: Supplier–customer interaction in product development. London: Routledge .
51.
Lam, Alice1997‘Embedded firms, embedded knowledge: Problems of collaboration and knowledge transfer in global cooperative ventures’ . Organization Studies18/6: 973–996 .
52.
Lam, Alice2000‘Tacit knowledge, organizational learning and societal institutions: An integrated framework’ . Organization Studies21/3: 487–513 .
53.
Latour, Bruno1986‘The powers of association’ in Power, action and belief. J. Law (ed.). London: Routledge .
54.
Law, J. , and J. Hassard1999Actor network theory and after. Oxford: Blackwell Science .
55.
Leonard-Barton, Dorothy1992‘Core capabilities and core rigidities: A paradox in managing new product development’ . Strategic Management Journal13: 111–126 .
56.
Leonard-Barton, Dorothy1995Wellsprings of knowledge: Building and sustaining the sources of innovation. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press .
57.
Leonard, Dorothy , and Sylvia Sensiper1998‘The role of tacit knowledge in group innovation’ . California Management Review40/3: 112–132 .
58.
Levinthal, Daniel A. , and John G. March1993‘The myopia of learning’ . Strategic Management Journal14: 95–112 .
59.
Maurice, M. , A. Sorge , and M. Warner1980‘Societal differences in organizing manufacturing units: A comparison of France, West Germany and Great Britain’ . Organization Studies1/1: 59–86 .
60.
McCormick, Kevin1995‘Career paths, technological obsolescence and skill formation: R&D staff in Britain and Japan’ . R&D Management25/2: 197–211 .
61.
McGee, John , Howard Thomas , and David C. Wilson2005Strategy: Analysis and practice. Maidenhead: McGraw-Hill .
62.
McGuire, Jean , and S. Dow2003‘The persistence and implications of Japanese keiretsu organization’ . Journal of International Business Studies34/4: 374–389 .
63.
Metcalfe, Stan , and Nicola De Liso1998‘Innovation, capabilities and knowledge: The epistemic connection’ in Technological change and organization. Rod Coombs , Kenneth Green , Albert Richards , and Vivien Walsh (eds). Cheltenham: Edward Elgar .
64.
METI2001‘The twenty-eighth survey of industrial economic trends’. Japanese Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry white paper. Tokyo: Economic and Industrial Policy Bureau .
65.
Miller, Danny1990The Icarus paradox: How excellent companies can bring about their own downfall. New York: Harper Business .
66.
Nahapiet, Janine , and Sumantra Ghoshal1998‘Social capital, intellectual capital, and the organizational advantage’ . Academy of Management Review23/2: 242–267 .
67.
Nakatani, Iwao1988The Japanese firm in transition. Tokyo: Quality Resources .
68.
Nelson, Richard R. , and Sidney G. Winter1982An evolutionary theory of economic change. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press .
69.
Nightingale, Paul1998‘A cognitive theory of innovation’ . Research Policy27: 689–709 .
70.
Nishiguchi, T. , editor1996Managing product development. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
71.
Nonaka, Ikujiro , and Noburu Konno1998‘The concept of “ba”: Building a foundation for knowledge creation’ . California Management Review40/3: 40–56 .
72.
Nonaka, Ikujiro , and H. Takeuchi1995The knowledge-creating company: How Japanese companies create the dynamics of innovation. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
73.
Nonaka, Ikujiro , and S. Yonekura1982‘Innovation through group dynamics: Organisational learning in JK activity at Nippon Steel's Kimitsu Works’. Discussion Paper No.124, Institute of Business Research, Hitotsubashi University, Tokyo .
74.
Odagiri, Hiroki , and Akira Goto1993‘The Japanese system of innovation: Past, present and future’ in National innovation systems: A comparative analysis. Richard R. Nelson (ed.). New York: Oxford University Press .
75.
Pavitt, Keith P.1984‘Sectoral patterns of technical change: Towards a taxonomy and a theory’ . Research Policy13: 343–373 .
76.
Pavitt, Keith P.2000SEWP 45 ‘Innovating routines in the business firm: What matters, what's staying the same, and what's changing?’ July 2000, SPRU Working Paper, SPRU, Sussex University .
77.
Pentland, Brian T.1995‘Grammatical models of organizational processes’ . Organization Science6/5: 541–556 .
78.
Pentland, Brian T. , and Henry H. Rueter1994‘Organizational routines as grammars of action’ . Administrative Science Quarterly39: 484–510 .
Porter, Michael E. , Hirotaka Takeuchi , and Miriko Sakakibara2000Can Japan compete?Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan .
81.
Reger, G.1999‘How R&D is coordinated in Japanese and European multinationals’ . R&D Management29/1: 71–88 .
82.
Rothwell, Roy , and Tom G. Whiston 1989 ‘Design innovation and corporate integration’ , Keynote paper for the International Conference on R&D Design and Manufacturing, University of Ghent, Belgium, 12–13 September.
83.
Rulke, Diane L. , and Joseph Galaskiewicz2000‘Distribution of knowledge, group network structure, and group performance’ . Management Science46/5: 612–626 .
84.
Rulke, Diane, L. and Devaki Rau1997‘Examining the encoding process of transactive memory in group training’. Academy of Management Proceedings, 349–354.
85.
Sakakibara, K. , and Eleanor D. Westney1985‘Comparative study of the training, careers, and organisation of engineers in the computer industry in the United States and Japan’ . Hitotsubashi Journal of Commerce and Management20: 1–20 .
86.
Sako, Mari1997Japanese labour and management in transition: Diversity, flexibility and participation. London: Routledge .
87.
Scarbrough, Harry , editor1996The management of expertise. Basingstoke: Macmillan .
88.
Sobrero, M. , and O. Toulan2000‘Task partitioning, communication activities, and the performance of supplier relations in product development’ in The flexible firm: Capability management in network organisations. J. Birkinshaw and P. Hagström (eds). Oxford: Oxford University Press .
89.
Sorge, Arndt1991‘Strategic fit and the societal effect: Interpreting cross-national comparisons of technology, organization and human resources’ . Organization Studies12/2: 161–190 .
90.
Spender, J.-C.1996‘Making knowledge the basis of a dynamic theory of the firm’ . Strategic Management Journal17/10: 45–63 .
91.
Starr, M. Kenneth1992‘Comparative investment strategies in training and technology’ . International Journal of Technology Management8/1/2: 8–94 .
92.
Stene, E.1940‘An approach to the science of administration’ . American Political Science Review34: 1124–1137 .
93.
Steward, Fred , and Steve Conway1996‘Informal networks in the origination of successful innovations’ in Technological collaboration: The dynamics of cooperation in industrial innovation. R. Coombs , A. Richards , P.P. Saviotti , and V. Walsh (eds). Cheltenham: Edward Elgar .
94.
Teece, David J.1977‘Technology transfer by multinational firms: The resource cost of transferring technological know-how’ . Economic Journal87/346: 242–261 .
95.
Teece, David J.1998‘Research directions for knowledge management’ . California Management Review40/3: 289–294 .
96.
Teece, David J. , and Gary Pisano1994‘The dynamic capabilities of firms: An introduction’ .Industrial and Corporate Change3/3: 537–556 .
97.
Tsoukas, Hari1996‘The firm as a distributed knowledge system: A constructionist approach’ . Strategic Management Journal17: 11–26 .
98.
Tsoukas, Hari , and E. Vladimirou2001‘What is organisational knowledge?’Journal of Management Studies38/7: 973–993 .
99.
Von Hippel, Eric2000‘“Sticky information” and the locus of problem solving: Implications for innovation’ in The dynamic firm. A. D. Chandler Jr , P. Hagstrom , and O. Solvell (eds). Oxford: Oxford University Press .
100.
Whitley, Richard D.1990‘Eastern Asian enterprise structures and the comparative analysis of business organizations’ . Organization Studies11/1: 47–74 .
101.
Whitley, Richard D.1995‘Academic knowledge and work jurisdiction in management’ . Organization Studies16/1: 81–105 .
102.
Wilson, David C.1999A strategy of change. New York: International Thomson .
Yamada, H.1991‘Obstacles to basic research in Japanese firms’ . Research-Technology Management34/3: 32–34 .
105.
Yamamura, K.1997‘The Japanese political economy after the “Bubble”: Plus ca Change?’Journal of Japanese Studies23/2: 291–331 .
106.
Yonekura, S.1994The Japanese iron and steel industry, 1850–1990. New York: St Martin's Press .
107.
Zander, Udo , and Bruce Kogut1995‘Knowledge and the speed of the transfer and imitation of organizational capabilities: An empirical test’ . Organization Science6/1: 76–92 .
108.
Ziman, J.2000Innovation and evolutionary theory?Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
109.
Zollo, Maurizio , and Sidney G. Winter2001‘From organizational routines to dynamic capabilities’ . Organization Science9/2: 42–56 .
