Several studies have examined predictors of mortality among elderly patients hospitalized with heart failure. In some, elderly African American patients hospitalized for heart failure were reported to have lower risk-adjusted in-hospital mortality compared with Whites. Whether this difference is sustained in the long term and what factors account for this difference remain poorly understood. The objective of this study was to compare risk-adjusted short-term and long-term mortality of a cohort of elderly African American and White patients hospitalized for heart failure to all 30 hospitals in northeast Ohio. The database used for this analysis includes information on demographics and detailed clinical information abstracted from patients’ hospital records. Crude and adjusted 30-day and 18-month survival were compared using Kaplan-Meier method and logistic regression models for multivariate analysis. African American patients had significantly lower 30-day mortality compared with Whites. However, this difference diminished over time and when adjusted for important explanatory covariates, including “do not resuscitate” orders.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alexander, Mark
, Kevin Grumbach, Joe Selby, Arleen Brown, and Eugene Washington. 1995. “Hospitalization for Congestive Heart Failure: Explaining Racial Differences.”Journal of the American Medical Association274: 1037-1042.
2.
American Medical Association
. 1990. “Black-White Disparities in Healthcare. Report from the Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs.”Journal of the American Medical Association263: 2344-2346.
3.
Becker, Lance B.
, Ben H. Han, Peter M. Meyer, Fred A. Wright, Karin V. Rhodes, David W. Smith, John Barrett, and the CPR Chicago Project. 1993. “Racial Differences in the Incidence of Cardiac Arrest and Subsequent Survival.”New England Journal of Medicine329: 600-606.
4.
Castner, Angel
, Brian Simmons, Maxine Mar, and Richard Cooper. 1988. “Myocardial Infarction Among Patients: Poor Prognosis After Hospital Discharge.”Annals of Internal Medicine109: 33-35.
5.
Census Bureau
. 1992. Census of Population and Housing, 1990. Summary tape film 3 on CD-ROM. Washington, DC: Bureau of Census, U.S. Department of Commerce.
6.
Cohn, Jay N.
and Thomas S. Recter. 1988. “Prognosis of Congestive Heart Failure and Predictors of Mortality.”American Journal of Cardiology62: 25A-30A.
7.
Cooper, Richard
. 1993. “Health and the Social Status of U.S. Blacks.”Annals of Epidemiology3: 137-145.
8.
Department of Health and Human Services
. 1996. Report of the Secretary’s Task Force on Black and Minority Health. Washington, DC: Department of Health and Human Services.
9.
Dries, Daniel
, Derek Exner, Bernard Gersh, Howard Cooper, and Michael Domanski. 1999. “Racial Differences in the Outcome of Left Ventricular Dysfunction.”New England Journal of Medicine340: 609-616.
10.
Ghali, Jalal
, Richard Cooper, and Earl Ford. 1990. “Trends in Hospitalization Rates for Heart Failure in the United States, 1973-86.”Archives of Internal Medicine150: 769-773.
11.
Gillium, Richard
. 1996. “Epidemiology of Cardiovascular Diseases in Black Americans.” Editorial.New England Journal of Medicine335: 1597-1599.
12.
Gordon, Howard
, Dwain Harper, and Gary Rosenthal. 1996. “Racial Variation in Predicted and Observed In-Hospital Death: A Regional Analysis.”Journal of the American Medical Association276: 1639-1644.
13.
Gradman, Alan
and Prakash Deedwania. 1994. “Predictors of Mortality in Patients With Heart Failure.”Cardiology Clinics12: 25-35.
14.
Gradman, Alan
, Prakash Deedwania, Robert Cody, Barry Massie, Milton Packer, Bertram Pitt, and Sidney Goldstein. 1989. “Predictors of Total Mortality and Sudden Death in Mild to Moderate Heart Failure.”Journal of the American College of Cardiology14: 564-570.
15.
Hoenig, Helen
, Lisa Rubenstein, and Katherine Kahn. 1996. “Rehabilitation After Hip Fracture—Equal Opportunity for All?”Archives of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation77: 58-63.
16.
Johnstone, David
, Marian Limacher, Michel Rousseau, Chang-Seng Liang, Lars Ekelund, Michael Herman, Douglas Stewart, Maureen Guillotte, Gina Bjerken, William Gaasch, Peter Held, Joel Verter, Dawn Stewart, and Salim Yusuf for the SOLVD Investigators. 1992. “Clinical Characteristics of Patients in Studies of Left Ventricular Dysfunction (SOLVD).”American Journal of Cardiology70: 894-900.
17.
Kahn, Katherine L.
, Marjorie L. Pearson, Ellen R. Harrison, Katherine A. Desmond, William H. Rogers, Lisa V. Rubenstein, Robert H. Brook, and Emmett B. Keeler. 1994. “Health Care for Black and Poor Hospitalized Medicare Patients.”Journal of the American Medical Association271: 1169-1174.
18.
Keil, Julian
. 1993. “Mortality Rates and Risk Factors for Coronary Artery Disease in Blacks as Compared With White Men and Women.”New England Journal of Medicine329: 73-78.
19.
Koegler, A.
, G. Roul, P. Bareiss, P. Gries, M. E. Moulichon, J. Sacrez, P. Germain, J. M. Mossard, and A. Sacrez. 1995. “4-Year Mortality of Heart Failure With Intact Systolic Function: A Retrospective Study.”Archives des Maladies du Coeur et des Vaisseaux88: 961-966.
20.
Laouri, Marianne
, Richard Kravitz, William French, Irene Yang, Jeffrey C. Milliken, Lee Hilborne, Roby Wachsner, and Robert H. Brook. 1997. “Underuse of Coronary Revascularization Procedures: Application of a Clinical Method.”Journal of the American College of Cardiology29: 891-897.
21.
McKinley, Elizabeth
, Jaane Garrett, Arthur Evans, and Marion Danis. 1996. “Differences in End-of-Life Decision Making Among Black and White Ambulatory Cancer Patients.”Journal of General Internal Medicine11: 651-656.
22.
Nickens, Herbert
. 1995. “The Role of Race/Ethnicity and Social Class in Minority Health Status.”Health Services Research30: 152-162.
23.
Pappas, Gregory
. 1994. “Elucidating the Relationship Between Race, Socioeconomic Status, and Health.”American Journal of Public Health84: 892-893.
24.
Philbin, Edward
and Thomas DiSalvo. 1998. “Influence of Race and Gender on Care Process, Resource Use, and Hospital-Based Outcomes in Congestive Heart Failure.”American Journal of Cardiology82: 76-81.
25.
Rosenthal, Gary
and Dwain Harper. 1994. “Cleveland Health Quality Choice: A Model for Community-Based Outcomes Assessment.”Joint Commission Journal on Quality Improvement20: 425-443.
26.
Rosenthal, Gary
, Linda Quinn, and Dwain Harper. 1997. “Declines in Hospital Mortality Associated With a Regional Initiative to Measure Hospital Performance.”American Journal of Medical Quality12: 103-112.
27.
Shepardson, Laura
, Howard Gordon, Said Ibrahim, Dwain Harper, and Gary Rosenthal. 1999. “A Community-Based Evaluation of Racial Variation in the Use of Do-Not-Resuscitate Orders.”Journal of General Internal Medicine14: 15-20.
28.
Shepardson, Laura
, Stuart Youngner, Theodore Speroff, Ralph G. O’Brien, Kathryn A. Smyth, and Gary Rosenthal. 1997. “Variations in the Use of Do-Not-Resuscitate Orders in Patients With Stroke.”Archives of Internal Medicine157: 1841-1847.
