Public services across the United States, including local public libraries, were shut down or shifted to limited operations after a national emergency was declared in March 2020 due to the spread of COVID-19. How did this event and the varied responses to COVID across local communities shape recovery of in-person public library visits? Using monthly panel data on library visits starting in January 2019 from SafeGraph, a company that compiles data on cell phone locations to track “visits” aggregated to points of interest like libraries, this work focuses on local public library visits in the State of Michigan, a politically diverse state. The findings show that political partisanship is a significant predictor of library visits after the start of the pandemic, controlling for other factors. Republican-voting areas have had a swifter return to pre-COVID library visit levels since the start of the pandemic.
AdolphChristopherAmanoKenyaBang-JensenBreeFullmanNancyWilkersonJohn. 2021. “Pandemic Politics: Timing State-Level Social Distancing Responses to COVID-19.” Journal of Health Politics, Policy, and Law46, no. 2: 211–33. doi:10.1215/03616878-8802162.
AykanianAmandaMortonPeggyTrawverKathiVictorsonLanePreskittSarahStreetKimberly. 2020. “Library-Based Field Placements: Meeting the Diverse Needs of Patrons, Including Those Experiencing Homelessness.” Journal of Social Work Education56, no. S1: 72–80.
6.
BentonJ. EdwinRisslerGrant E.WagnerSpencer. 2020. “City and County Governments in the Time of COVID-19 and the Recession: The Long and Winding Road.” State and Local Government Review52, no. 1: 28–52.
7.
BrandtnerChristofDouglassGordon C. C.KornbergerMartin. 2023. “Where Relational Commons Take Place: The City and its Social Infrastructure as Sites of Commoning.” Journal of Business Ethics184, no. 4: 917–32.
BuchhoferBeth.2008. “New Jersey Public Library Services for Homeschoolers.” Theses and Dissertations 689, Rowan University.
10.
CallaghanTimothyLueckJennifer A.TrujilloKristin LunzFerdinandAlva O.2021. “Rural and Urban Differences in COVID-19 Prevention Behaviors.”The Journal of Rural Health 37, no. 2: 287–95.
11.
CameronA. ColinTrivediPravin K.2013. Regression Analysis of Count Data. Cambridge University Press.
12.
CampAndrew M.ZamarroGema. 2022. “Determinants of Ethnic Differences in School Modality Choices during the COVID-19 Crisis.” Educational Researcher51, no. 1: 6–16.
13.
ChangSerinaPiersonEmmaKohPang Wei, et al. 2021. “Mobility Network Models of COVID-19 Explain Inequities and Inform Reopening.” Nature589:82–87.
14.
ChangTingHuYingjieTaylorDaneQuigleyBrian M.2022. “The Role of Alcohol Outlet Visits Derived from Mobile Phone Location Data in Enhancing Domestic Violence Prediction at the Neighborhood Level.” Health & Place73:102736.
15.
ChaseStephanie. 2021. “Innovative Lessons from Our Small and Rural Public Libraries.” Journal of Library Administration61, no. 2: 237–43.
16.
ChowAnthonyTianQianfei. 2021. “Public Libraries Positively Impact Quality of Life: A Big Data Study.” Public Library Quarterly40, no. 1: 1–32.
17.
CollinsJonathan. 2021. “Who Wants to Reopen Schools in a Pandemic? Explaining Public Preferences, Reopening Schools, and Public Compliance with Reopening Orders during the COVID-19 Pandemic.” EdWorkingPaper No. 21-448, Brown University.
18.
CorreiaSergioGuimarãesPauloZylkinThomas. 2019. “Verifying the Existence of Maximum Likelihood Estimates for Generalized Linear Models.” arXiv preprint arXiv:1903.01633.
19.
CorreiaSergioGuimarãesPauloZylkinTom. 2020. “Fast Poisson Estimation with High-Dimensional Fixed Effects.” The Stata Journal20, no. 1: 95–115. doi:10.1177/1536867X20909691.
20.
DalmerNicole K.MitrovicaBria L.2022. “The Public Library as Social Infrastructure for Older Patrons: Exploring the Implications of Online Library Programming for Older Adults during COVID-19.” Library and Information Science Research44, no. 3: 101177.
21.
DeeThomas S.2024. “Higher Chronic Absenteeism Threaten Academic Recovery from the COVID-19 Pandemic.”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 121, no. 3: 1–3.
22.
DuFangyeMaoLiang. 2024. “Identifying Points of Interest (POIs) as Sentinels for Infectious Disease Surveillance: A COVID-19 Study.” Spatial and Spatio-temporal Epidemiology51:100691.
23.
FáveroLuiz Paulo LopesBelfiorePatríciados SantosMarco AurélioSouzaR. Freitas. 2020. “Overdisp: A Stata (and Mata) Package for Direct Detection of Overdispersion in Poisson and Negative Binomial Regression Models.” Statistics, Optimization and Information Computing8, no. 3: 773–89.
GadarianShana KushnerGoodmanSara WallacePepinskyThomas B.2022. Pandemic Politics: The Deadly Toll of Politics in the Age of COVID. Princeton University Press.
26.
GaynorTia SherèeWilsonMeghan E.2020. “Social Vulnerability and Equity: The Disproportionate Impact of COVID-19.” Public Administration Review80:832–38. doi:10.1111/puar.13264.
27.
GhadiriZahraMashhadiAfraTimmeMarcGhanbarnejadFakhteh. 2024. “Recreational Mobility Prior and during the COVID-19 Pandemic.” Communications Physics7:55. doi:10.1038/s42005-024-01535-7.
28.
GrantzKyra H.MeredithHannah R.CummingsDerek A. T., et al. 2020. “The Use of Mobile Phone Data to Inform Analysis of COVID-19 Pandemic Epidemiology.” Nature Communications11, no. 1: 4961. doi:10.1038/s41467-020-18190-5.
29.
GrossmannMattReckhowSarahStrunkKatharineTurnerMeg. 2021. “All States Close but Red Districts Reopen: The Politics of In-Person Schooling during the COVID-19 Pandemic.” Educational Researcher50, no. 9: 637–48.
30.
HansenBenjaminSabiaJoseph J.SchallerJessamyn. 2022. “Schools, Job Flexibility, and Married Women’s Labor Supply.” NBER Working Paper, National Bureau of Economic Research. https://www.nber.org/papers/w29660.
31.
HartneyMichael T.FingerLeslie K.2022. “Politics, Markets, and Pandemics: Public Education’s Response to COVID-19.” Perspectives on Politics20, no. 2: 457–73. doi:10.1017/S1537592721000955.
32.
HuTaoWendyGuan WeiheXinyanZhu, et al. 2020. “Building an Open Resources Repository for COVID-19 Research.” Data and Information Management4, no. 3: 130–47. doi:10.2478/dim-2020-0012.
33.
HuangXiaoLuJunyuGaoSongWangSichengLiuZheweiWeiHanxue. 2021. “Staying at Home is a Privilege: Evidence from Fine-Grained Mobile Phone Location Data in the United States during the COVID-19 Pandemic.” Annals of the American Association of Geographers112, no. 1: 286–305.
JohnsonNicole J.RomanCaterina G.2025. “Spillover Effects of Drug Markets on Gun Violence across a Network of Neighborhoods in Three Cities.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology1–23. https://rdcu.be/fcdFV.
36.
KlinenbergEric. 2018. Palaces for the People: How Social Infrastructure Can Help Fight Inequality, Polarization, and the Decline of Civic Life. Crown.
37.
KohlburnJoeBossallerJennyChoHyerimMoulaison-SandyHeatherAdkinsDenice. 2023. “Public Libraries and COVID-19: Perceptions and Politics in the United States.” The Library Quarterly93, no. 1: 7–25.
38.
KranzAshley M.ChenAnnieGahlonGraceSteinBradley D.2021. “Trends in Visits in Dental Offices during the 2020 COVID-19 Pandemic.” Journal of the American Dental Association152, no. 7: 535–41.
39.
LarsonLincoln R.ZhangZhenzhenOhJae In, et al. 2021. “Urban Park Use during the COVID-19 Pandemic: Are Socially Vulnerable Communities Disproportionately Impacted?”Frontiers in Sustainable Cities3:710243. doi:10.3389/frsc.2021.710243.
40.
LiMeiqingRodriguezDaniel A.PikeSusieMcNallyMichael. 2025. “Rail Transit Ridership Changes in COVID-19: Lessons for Station Area Planning in California.” Journal of Urban Mobility8:100153. doi:10.1016/j.urbmob.2025.100153.
41.
LiXiaofengMathisShelly. 2022. “‘My Mom Recommended It to Me’: Understanding Homeschoolers’ Information Practices.” Journal of Research on Libraries and Young Adults12, no. 2: 1–23.
42.
LiZhenlongLiXiaomingPorterDwayne, et al. 2020. “Monitoring the Spatial Spread of COVID-19 and Effectiveness of Control Measures through Human Movement Data: Proposal for a Predictive Model Using Big Data Analytics.” JMIR Research Protocols9, no. 12: e24432.
43.
LiZhenlongNingHuanJingFengruiLessaniM. Naser. 2024. “Understanding the Bias of Mobile Location Data across Spatial Scales and over Time: A Comprehensive Analysis of SafeGraph Data in the United States.” PLoS One19, no. 1: e0294430.
LundBrady D.WangTingAleneziAbdullah. 2022. “Bookending a Pandemic and Its Impact on Public Libraries: Policy and Announcement Information Provided by Libraries throughout the Coronavirus (COVID-19) Response.” Public Library Quarterly42, no. 4: 348–60. doi:10.1080/01616846.2022.2102844.
46.
MacedoStephenLeeFrances. 2025. In COVID’s Wake: How Our Politics Failed Us. Princeton University Press.
47.
MaldonadoPeterPengAngieOuyangDerekSuckaleJennyHoDaniel E.2022. “Science Translation during the COVID-19 Pandemic: An Academic-Public Health Partnership to Assess Capacity Limits in California.” American Journal of Public Health112, no. 2: 308–315.
McBainRyan K.CantorJonathanPeraMegan F.BreslauJoshuaBravataDena M.WhaleyChristopher M.2023. “Mental Health Service Utilization Rates among Commercially Insured Adults in the US during the First Year of the COVID-19 Pandemic.” JAMA Health Forum4, no. 1: e224936. doi:10.1001/jamahealthforum.2022.4936.
50.
MervoshSarah. 2022. “The Pandemic Erased Two Decades of Progress in Reading and Math.” The New York Times, September1.
51.
MirajkarAmberOswaldAdamRiveraMarkLoganGideonMacintoshTracyWalkerAyannaLebowitzDavidGantiLatha. 2023. “Racial Disparities in Patients Hospitalized for COVID-19.”Journal of the National Medical Association 115, no. 4: 436–40.
52.
MIT Election Data and Science Lab. 2018. “U.S. President Precinct-Level Returns 2016.” Harvard Dataverse, V11. doi:10.7910/DVN/LYWX3D.
53.
MyersNathan. 2021. “Rurality versus Readiness: The Relationship between State-Level Connection and Capacity Variables and the Management of Medical Stockpiles for a Public Health Emergency.” State and Local Government Review53, no. 4: 281–97. doi:10.1177/0160323X211061352.
54.
OgorzalekThomas K.2022. “The City Re-Centered? Local Inequality Mitigation in the 21st Century.” In The American Political Economy: Politics, Markets, and Power, edited by HackerJ. S.Hertel-FernandezA.PiersonP.ThelenK., 181–208. Cambridge University Press.
55.
PannoneSarah. 2019. “Homeschoolers’ Experiences with the Public Library: A Phenomenological Study.”Children and Libraries 17, no. 1: 5–10.
56.
PattonDanaDurandAnnWhippleKyleAlbrightDavid L.2022. “Local Autonomy and Response to the COVID-19 Pandemic.” State and Local Government Review54, no. 2: 165–73. doi:10.1177%2F0160323X221089661.
PotnisDevendra DilipWinberryJosephFinnBonnieHuntCourtney. 2020. “What is Innovative to Public Libraries in the United States? A Perspective of Library Administrators for Classifying Innovations.” Journal of Librarianship and Information Science52, no. 3: 792–805.
60.
ReckhowSarahDowneyDaviaSapotichneJoshua. 2020. “Governing without Government: Nonprofit Governance in Detroit and Flint.” Urban Affairs Review56, no. 5: 1472–502.
61.
RoccoPhilipKassAmanda. 2022. “Flexible Aid in an Uncertain World: The Coronavirus State and Local Fiscal Recovery Funds Program.” State and Local Government Review54, no. 4: 346–61. doi:10.1177/0160323X221101005.
Santos SilvaJ. M. C.TenreyroSilvana. 2006. “The Log of Gravity.” The Review of Economics and Statistics88, no. 4: 641–58. doi:10.1162/rest.88.4.641.
64.
SinSei-Ching Joanna. 2011. “Neighborhood Disparities in Access to Information Resources: Measuring and Mapping U.S. Public Libraries’ Funding and Service Landscapes.”Library & Information Science Research 33, no. 1: 41–53.
65.
Spatial Data Lab. 2020. “US COVID-19 Daily Cases with Basemap.” Harvard Dataverse, V67. doi:10.7910/DVN/HIDLTK.
66.
StanwoodJane-Agnes2001. “Homeschoolers’ Use of the Atlantic County Library System.” Theses and Dissertations 1605, Rowan University.
67.
SumidaNami. 2023. “City’s Libraries Beloved and Used Differently Now.” San Francisco Chronicle, January6.
68.
SutherlandJacob. 2025. “Categories of Political Contestation in Public Libraries.” State and Local Government Review57, no. 1: 83–90.
69.
TrounstineJessica. 2018. Segregation by Design: Local Politics and Inequality in American Cities. Cambridge University Press.
70.
UhlJohannes H.HunterLori M.LeykStefan, et al. 2023. “Place-Level Urban–Rural Indices for the United States from 1930 to 2018.” Landscape and Urban Planning236:104762.
71.
WalshThomas. 2023. “Modeling COVID-19 with Big Mobility Data: Surveillance and Reaffirming the People in the Data.” Big Data & Society10, no. 1: 20539517231164115.
YanYoupeiMalikAmyn A.BayhamJudeFenichelEli P.CouzensChandraOmerSaad B.2021. “Measuring Voluntary and Policy-Induced Social Distancing Behavior during the COVID-19 Pandemic.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences118, no. 16: e2008814118.
74.
YangWanShaffJaimieShamanJeffrey. 2021. “Effectiveness of Non-Pharmaceutical Interventions to Contain COVID-19: A Case Study of the 2020 Spring Pandemic Wave in New York City.” Journal of the Royal Society Interface18, no. 175: 20200822.
