The comparatively poor U.S. response to COVID-19 was not due to federal inaction or a flawed federal system per se but to party polarization and presidential and gubernatorial preferences that frustrated federalism’s capacity to respond more effectively. The U.S. response is examined in terms of four models: coercive or regulatory federalism, nationalist cooperative federalism, non-centralized cooperative federalism, and dual federalism--finding that state-led dual federalism was the predominant response. The crisis also raised questions about interpretations of “federal inaction” because party divisions led some to regard the federal government’s response as inadequate while others viewed it as appropriate.
AroneyNicholasBoyceMichael. 2020. Australia and the COVID-19 pandemic: Federal, state and local responses. Unpublished paper, November 11. SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3728488 (accessed November 21, 2020).
3.
ArsovaPenka. 2020. Trump calls governors “mutineers” for creating their own plans to reopen the economy. LaCorte News.
4.
AxelrodTal. 2020. Biden slams Trump response to coronavirus epidemic: This is no time for ‘fearmongering’. The Hill.
5.
BaderChristopher. 2014. A dynamic defense of cooperative federalism. Whittier Law Review35 (2): 161–97.
6.
BrandtnerChristofBettencourtLuisBermanMarcStierAndrew. 2020. Creatures of the state? Metropolitan counties compensated for state inaction in initial U.S. response to Covid-19 pandemic. August 10, Mansueto Institute for Urban Innovation Research Paper, University of Chicago.
7.
Bulman-PozenJessicaGerkenHeather. 2009. Uncooperative federalism. Yale Law Journal118 (7): 1256–310.
8.
BurnsAlexanderMartinJonathanHabermanMaggie. 2020. As Trump ignores virus crisis, Republicans start to break ranks. New York Times.
9.
ClintonJoshuaCohenJonLapinskiJohnTrusslerMarc. 2020. Partisan pandemic: How partisanship and public health concerns affect individuals’ social distancing during COVID-19. Unpublished paper
10.
Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget. 2020. Update: COVID-related state & local aid will total $280 billion.
11.
CookeJacob E.1961. The Federalist. Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press.
12.
CorwinEdward. 1950. The passing of dual federalism. Virginia Law Review36 (1): 1–23.
13.
DehnerGeorge. 2012. Influenza: A century of science and public health response. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.
14.
DetterbeckKlausRenzschWolfgangKincaidJohn, Eds. 2015. Political parties and civil society in federal countries. Don Mills, ON: Oxford University Press.
15.
Editorial Board. 2020. Woodward’s non-revelation. Wall Street Journal.
16.
ElazarDaniel. 1984. American federalism: A view from the states, 3rd ed. New York: Harper & Row.
17.
ElazarDaniel. 1991. Cooperative Federalism. In Competition among states and local governments, edited by KenyonDaphneKincaidJohn, 65–86. Washington, DC: Urban Institute Press.
18.
FischhoffBaruchWong-ParodiGabrielleGarfinDana RoseHolmanAlisonCohenRoxanne. 2018. Public understanding of Ebola risks: Mastering an unfamiliar threat. Risk Analysis38 (1): 71–83.
19.
ForgeyQuint. 2020. ‘We’re not a shipping clerk’: Trump tells governors to step up efforts to get medical supplies. Politico.
20.
GerkenHeather. 2014. Federalism as the new nationalism. Yale Law Journal123 (6): 1889–918.
21.
GordonSarahHuberfeldNicoleJonesDavid. 2020. What federalism means for the US response to Coronavirus disease. 2019. JAMA Health Forum.
22.
GreenblattAlan. 2020. Political hypocrisy is undermining public health. Governing.
23.
HarrisonDavid. 2020. State, local governments slashed spending after COVID. Next year could be worse. Wall Street Journal.
24.
HennesseySusanWittesBenjamin. 2020. Unmaking the presidency: Donald Trump’s war on the world’s most powerful office. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
25.
HiggsRobert. 1987. Crisis and leviathan: Critical episodes in the growth of American government. New York: Oxford University Press.
26.
JacobsEmily. 2020. Biden walks back national mask mandate over ‘constitutional issue’. New York Post.
27.
KincaidJohn. 1990. From cooperative to coercive federalism. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science509 (May): 139–52.
28.
KincaidJohn. 2017. Introduction: The Trump interlude and the states of American federalism. State and Local Government Review49 (3): 156–69.
29.
KincaidJohn. 2019. Dynamic de/centralization in the United States, 1790-2010. Publius: The Journal of Federalism49 (1): 166–93.
30.
KlainRon. 2019. Purely fortuity’ that more people didn’t die during 09 swine flu. C-SPAN.
31.
LeonhardtDavid. 2020. The unique U.S. failure to control the virus. New York Times.
32.
MartinJonathan. 2020. Trump to governors on ventilators: ‘Try getting it yourselves’. New York Times.
33.
MervoshSarahRogersKatie. 2020. Governors fight back against Coronavirus chaos: ‘It’s like being on eBay with 50 other states’. New York Times.
34.
MiloshMariaPainterMarcusSoninKonstantinDijckeDavid VanWrightAustin. 2020. Unmasking partisanship: Polarization undermines public response to collective risk, November 17, CEPR Discussion Paper No. DP15464.
35.
MordecaiMaraConnaughtonAidan. 2020. Public opinion about coronavirus is more politically divided in U.S. than in other advanced economies. Pew Research Center.
36.
National League of Cities. 2020. New survey data quantifies pandemic’s impact on cities: Municipal revenues down twenty-one percent while expenses increase seventeen percent. Washington, DC.
37.
NeergaardLauranFingerhutHannah. 2020. AP-NORC poll: Only half in US want shots as vaccine nears. Associated Press.
38.
PurcellEdward. 2019. The Class Action Fairness Act in perspective: The old and the new in federal jurisdictional reform. University of Pennsylvania Law Review156 (6): 1823–927.
39.
RainieLeeKeeterScottPerrinAndrew. 2019. Trust and distrust in America. Pew Research Center.
SaurerJohannes. 2020. COVID-19 and cooperative administrative federalism in Germany. The Regulatory Review.
42.
ShethSonam. 2020. ‘Try getting it yourselves’: Trump told governors they’re responsible for getting their own medical equipment to treat coronavirus patients. Business Insider.
43.
SidmanAndrew H.2019. Pork barrel politics. New York: Columbia University Press.
44.
SiewertMarkusWursterStefanMesserschmidtLucaChengCindyButheTim. 2020. A German miracle? Crisis management during the COVID-19 pandemic in a multi-level system. In PEX Special Report: Coronavirus outbreak, presidents’ responses, and institutional consequences, edited by InacioMagnaBurniAline. doi: 10.2139/ssrn.3637013 (accessed July 23, 2020).
45.
SnyderTimothy. 2018. The road to unfreedom. New York: Tim Duggan Books.
46.
SominIlya. 2020. Trump’s eviction moratorium could set a dangerous precedent. The Volokh Conspiracy.
47.
StolbergSheryl Gay. 2020. Battered by Trump, the C.D.C.’s director faces pressure to speak out. New York Times.
48.
TankersleyJim. 2020. No virus deaths by mid-May? White House economists say they didn’t forecast early end to fatalities. New York Times.
49.
VielkindJimmyPalazzoloJoeGershmanJacob. 2020. In worst-hit COVID state, New York’s Cuomo called all the shots. Wall Street Journal.
50.
WilliamsPaige. 2020. Urgent care. The New Yorker, August 3 & 10: 26–33.
51.
WoodwardBob. 2020. Rage. New York: Simon and Schuster.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
