We address points raised by Zajonc and Sulloway, who reject findings showing that birth order has no effect on intelligence. Many objections to findings of null birth-order results seem to stem from a misunderstanding of the difference between study designs where birth order is confounded with true causal influences on intelligence across families and designs that control for some of these influences. We discuss some of the consequences of not appreciating the nature of this difference. When between-family confounds are controlled using appropriate study designs and techniques such as multilevel modeling, birth order is shown not to influence intelligence. We conclude with an empirical investigation of the replicability and generalizability of this approach.
Berbaum, M.L. & Moreland, R.I. (1980). Intellectual development within the family: A new application of the confluence model. Developmental Psychology, 16, 500-515.
2.
Brackbill, Y., & Nichols, P.L. (1982). A test of the confluence model of intellectual development. Developmental Psychology, 18, 192-198.
3.
Center for Human Resource Research. (1999). The 1998 NLSY79 child assessments: Selected tables. Columbus : The Ohio State University, CHRR User Services.
4.
Galbraith, R.C. (1982). Sibling spacing and intellectual development: A closer look at the confluence models. Developmental Psychology , 18, 151-173.
5.
Guo, G., & VanWey, L.K. (1999). Sibship size and intellectual developmental: Is the relationship causal?American Sociological Review, 64, 169-187.
6.
McCall, R.B. (1985). The confluence model and theory. Child Development, 56, 217-218.
7.
Page, E.G., & Grandon, G. (1979). Family configuration and mental ability: Two theories contrasted with U.S. data. American Educational Research Journal , 16, 257-272.
8.
Pfouts, J.H. (1980). Birth order, age-spacing, IQ differences, and family relations. Journal of Marriage and the Family, 42, 517-531.
9.
Price, G.G., Walsh, D.J., & Vilberg, W.R. (1984). The confluence models' good predictions of mental age beg the question. Psychological Bulletin,96, 195-200.
10.
Retherford, R.D., & Sewell, W.H. (1991). Birth order and intelligence: Further tests of the confluence model. American Sociological Review, 56, 141-158.
11.
Rodgers, J.L. (1984). Confluence effects: Not here, not now!Developmental Psychology, 20, 321-331.
12.
Rodgers, J.L. (1988). Birth order, SAT, and confluence: Spurious correlations and no causality. American Psychologist, 43, 476-477.
13.
Rodgers, J.L. (2000). The birth order trap. Politics and the Life Sciences, 19, 167-170.
14.
Rodgers, J.L. (2001). What causes birth order—intelligence patterns? The admixture hypothesis, revived. American Psychologist, 56, 505-510.
15.
Rodgers, J.L., Cleveland, H.H., van den Oord, E., & Rowe, D.C. (2000). Resolving the debate over birth order, family size, and intelligence. American Psychologist, 55, 599-612.
16.
Rosnow, R.L., & Rosenthal, R. (2002). Contrasts and correlations in theory assessment . Journal of Pediatric Psychology, 27, 59-66.
17.
Steelman, L.C., & Mercy, J.A. (1980). Unconfounding the confluence model: A test of sibship size and birth-order effects on intelligence. American Sociological Review, 45, 571-782.
18.
Sulloway, F.J. (1996). Born to rebel. New York: Vintage.
19.
Tabah, L., & Sutter, J. (1955). Le niveau intellectuel des enfants d'une meme famille. Annals of Human Genetics, 19, 120-150.
20.
U.S. Department of Defense. (1982). Profile of American youth: 1980 nationwide administration of the Armed Services Vocational Aptitude Battery. Washington, DC: Author.
21.
Valendia, W., Grandon, G., & Page, E.G. (1978). Family size, birth order, and intelligence in a large South American sample. American Educational Research Journal, 15, 399-416.
22.
Wechsler, D. (1974). Wechsler Intelligence Scales for Children—Revised . New York: Psychological Corporation .
23.
Wichman, A.L., Rodgers, J.L., & MacCallum, R.C. (2006). A multilevel approach to the relationship between birth order and intelligence. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 32, 117-127.
24.
Zajonc, R.B., Markus, H., & Markus, G.B. (1979). The birth order puzzle. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 37, 1325-1341.
25.
Zajonc, R.B., & Sulloway, F.J. (2007). The confluence model: Birth order as a within-family or between-family dynamic?Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 33, 1187-1194.
