Proper thermal comfort plays a crucial role in supporting patient recovery. The thermal comfort needs of patients and visitors vary significantly based on environmental factors, yet current research in this area remains insufficient. We analysed thermal comfort in a large public hospital in Northwest China during the heating season using the PMV-PPD model and field measurements. Results indicate that PMV underestimates the thermal sensation of patients and visitors, especially in waiting areas, where overcrowding and noise increase occupants’ perceived thermal sensation. The neutral temperatures, estimated using the Griffiths method, were 21.8°C for waiting area patients, 20.9°C for visitors, 23.5°C for ward patients, and 22.2°C for ward visitors. Field measurements show that indoor temperatures in both thermal zones mostly exceeded neutral temperatures, indicating that uniform heating in cold-region hospitals is ineffective. Evaluation of two widely used adaptive thermal sensation models revealed that the ePMV model provided more accurate predictions. The adaptive factors (e) were determined as 1.28 for waiting area patients, 1.66 for visitors, 1.4 for ward patients, and 1.52 for ward visitors. Findings indicate that uniform heating is ineffective, highlighting the need for zoned heating strategies to improve patient and visitor comfort.
Practical Application
This study provides field evidence that uniform heating systems in cold climate hospitals do not meet the distinct thermal needs of patients and visitors. By quantifying comfort temperatures and proposing adaptive correction models, the findings support the design and implementation of zoned HVAC strategies, offering practical guidance for improving thermal comfort and energy efficiency in healthcare buildings across cold, dry regions.
DijkstraKPieterseMPruynA. Physical environmental stimuli that turn healthcare facilities into healing environments through psychologically mediated effects: systematic review. J Adv Nurs2006; 56(2): 166–181.
2.
VerheyenJTheysNAllonsiusL, et al.Thermal comfort of patients: objective and subjective measurements in patient rooms of a Belgian healthcare facility. Build Environ2011; 46(6): 1195–1204.
3.
ASHRAE. ANSI/ASHRAE standard 55-2020: thermal environmental conditions for human occupancy. Atlanta: American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers, Inc., 2020.
4.
KhodakaramiJNasrollahiN. Thermal comfort in hospitals – a literature review. Renew Sustain Energy Rev2012; 16(6): 4071–4077.
5.
YuanFYaoRSadrizadehS, et al.Thermal comfort in hospital buildings – a literature review. J Build Eng2021; 45: 103463.
6.
FangerPO. Thermal comfort: analysis and applications in environmental engineering. Copenhagen: Danish Technical Press, 1972.
7.
NicolJFHumphreysMA. Thermal comfort as part of a self-regulating system. Build Res Pract1973; 1(3): 174–179.
8.
MaSDengWLuJ, et al.Investigation of thermal comfort and preferred temperatures for healthcare staff in hospitals in Ningbo, China. J Build Eng2023; 80: 108029.
9.
Del FerraroSIavicoliSRussoS, et al.A field study on thermal comfort in an Italian hospital considering differences in gender and age. Appl Ergon2015; 50: 177–184.
10.
AlotaibiBSLoSSouthwoodE, et al.Evaluating the suitability of standard thermal comfort approaches for hospital patients in air-conditioned environments in hot climates. Build Environ2020; 169: 106561.
11.
LanLLianZ. Ten questions concerning thermal environment and sleep quality. Build Environ2016; 99: 252–259.
12.
HashiguchiNHirakawaMTochiharaY, et al.Thermal environment and subjective responses of patients and staff in a hospital during winter. J Physiol Anthropol Appl Hum Sci2005; 24(1): 111–115.
13.
HashiguchiNHirakawaMTochiharaY, et al.Effects of setting up of humidifiers on thermal conditions and subjective responses of patients and staff in a hospital during winter. Appl Ergon2008; 39(2): 158–165.
14.
YauYHChewBT. Adaptive thermal comfort model for air-conditioned hospitals in Malaysia. Build Serv Eng Technol2014; 35(2): 117–138.
15.
AzizpourFMoghimiSLimCH, et al.A thermal comfort investigation of a facility department of a hospital in hot-humid climate: correlation between objective and subjective measurements. Indoor Built Environ2013; 22(5): 836–845.
16.
AzizpourFMoghimiSSallehE, et al.Thermal comfort assessment of large-scale hospitals in tropical climates: a case study of University Kebangsaan Malaysia Medical Centre (UKMMC). Energy Build2013; 64: 317–322.
17.
Kameni NematchouaMRicciardiPReiterS, et al.Thermal comfort and comparison of some parameters coming from hospitals and shopping centers under natural ventilation: the case of Madagascar Island. J Build Eng2017; 13: 196–206.
18.
ZaniboniLPernigottoGToftumJ, et al.Subjective and objective assessment of thermal comfort in physiotherapy centers. Build Environ2020; 176: 106808.
19.
FabbriKGaspariJVandiL. Indoor thermal comfort of pregnant women in hospital: a case study evidence. Sustainability2019; 11(23): 6664.
20.
KottekMGrieserJBeckC, et al.World Map of the Köppen-Geiger climate classification updated. Metz2006; 15(3): 259–263.
21.
ShiYYanZLiC, et al.Energy consumption and building layouts of public hospital buildings: a survey of 30 buildings in the cold region of China. Sustain Cities Soc2021; 74: 103247.
22.
TaleghaniMTenpierikMKurversS, et al.A review into thermal comfort in buildings. Renew Sustain Energy Rev2013; 26: 201–215.
23.
GoughHFaulknall-MillsSKingMF, et al.Assessment of overheating risk in gynaecology scanning rooms during near-heatwave conditions: a case study of the Royal Berkshire Hospital in the UK. Int J Environ Res Publ Health2019; 16(18): 3347.
24.
OlesenBW. A new and simpler method for estimating the thermal insulation of a clothing ensemble. ASHRAE Trans1985; 91: 478–484.
25.
ASHRAE. ASHRAE handbook–fundamentals. SI EditionAtlanta, GA: American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers, Inc., 2021.
26.
LinZDengS. A study on the thermal comfort in sleeping environments in the subtropics–Measuring the total insulation values for the bedding systems commonly used in the subtropics. Build Environ2008; 43(5): 905–916.
27.
WangYLiuYSongC, et al.Appropriate indoor operative temperature and bedding micro climate temperature that satisfies the requirements of sleep thermal comfort. Build Environ2015; 92: 20–29.
28.
KhalidWZakiSARijalHB, et al.Investigation of comfort temperature and thermal adaptation for patients and visitors in Malaysian hospitals. Energy Build2019; 183: 484–499.
29.
d’Ambrosio AlfanoFRDell’isolaMFiccoG, et al.On the measurement of the mean radiant temperature by means of globes: an experimental investigation under black enclosure conditions. Build Environ2021; 193: 107655.
30.
ShapiroSSWilkMB. An analysis of variance test for normality (complete samples). Biometrika1965; 52(3–4): 591–611.
31.
TohidHChoudhurySMAgoubaS, et al.Perceptions and attitudes to clinical research participation in Qatar. Contemp Clin Trials Commun2017; 8: 241–247.
32.
WuYMengQLiL, et al.Interaction between sound and thermal influences on patient comfort in the hospitals of China’s northern heating region. Appl Sci2019; 9(24): 5551.
33.
HuZWuJYangL, et al.Physiological and perceptual responses of exposure to different altitudes in extremely cold environment. Energy Build2021; 242: 110844.
34.
TartariniFSchiavonSCheungT, et al.CBE Thermal Comfort Tool: online tool for thermal comfort calculations and visualizations. SoftwareX2020; 12: 100563.
35.
WilliamsJR. The Declaration of Helsinki and public health. Bull World Health Organ2008; 86: 650–652.
36.
PengTZhangYJiangX, et al.Investigation of pregnant women thermal comfort in the waiting area of the hospital in South China, Guangzhou. J Build Eng2021; 44: 103254.
37.
NimlyatPSKandarMZ. Appraisal of indoor environmental quality (IEQ) in healthcare facilities: a literature review. Sustain Cities Soc2015; 17: 61–68.
38.
DovjakMShukuyaMKrainerA. User-centred healing-oriented conditions in the design of hospital environments. Int J Environ Res Publ Health2018; 15(10): 2140.
39.
SattayakornSIchinoseMSasakiR. Clarifying thermal comfort of healthcare occupants in tropical region: a case of indoor environment in Thai hospitals. Energy Build2017; 149: 45–57.
40.
GriffithsID. Thermal comfort in buildings with passive solar features: field studies commission of the European communities. Brussels: Commission of the European Communities, 1991.
41.
RijalHBHonjoMKobayashiR, et al.Investigation of comfort temperature, adaptive model and the window-opening behaviour in Japanese houses. Archit Sci Rev2013; 56(1): 54–69.
42.
VelleiMHerreraMFosasD, et al.The influence of relative humidity on adaptive thermal comfort. Build Environ2017; 124: 171–185.
43.
WangDJiangJLiuY, et al.Student responses to classroom thermal environments in rural primary and secondary schools in winter. Build Environ2017; 115: 104–117.
44.
ShresthaMRijalHBKayoG, et al.A field investigation on adaptive thermal comfort in school buildings in the temperate climatic region of Nepal. Build Environ2021; 190: 107523.
45.
Sagha ZadehRShepleyMMOworaAH, et al.The importance of specific workplace environment characteristics for maximum health and performance: healthcare workers’ perspective. J Occup Environ Med2018; 60(5): e245–e252.
46.
MingRYuWZhaoX, et al.Assessing energy saving potentials of office buildings based on adaptive thermal comfort using a tracking-based method. Energy Build2020; 208: 109611.
47.
ChenSWangXLunI, et al.Effect of inhabitant behavioral responses on adaptive thermal comfort under hot summer and cold winter climate in China. Build Environ2020; 168: 106492.
48.
WuYZhangZLiuH, et al.Age differences in thermal comfort and physiological responses in thermal environments with temperature ramp. Build Environ2023; 228: 109887.
49.
YaoRZhangSDuC, et al.Evolution and performance analysis of adaptive thermal comfort models–A comprehensive literature review. Build Environ2022; 217: 109020.
50.
Ole FangerPToftumJ. Extension of the PMV model to non-air-conditioned buildings in warm climates. Energy Build2002; 34(6): 533–536.
51.
YaoRLiBLiuJ. A theoretical adaptive model of thermal comfort–Adaptive Predicted Mean Vote (aPMV). Build Environ2009; 44(10): 2089–2096.
52.
TangHDingJLinZ. On-site measurement of indoor environment quality in a Chinese healthcare facility with a semi-closed hospital street. Build Environ2020; 173: 106637.
53.
IndragantiMOokaRRijalHB. Thermal comfort in offices in summer: findings from a field study under the ‘setsuden’ conditions in Tokyo, Japan. Build Environ2013; 61: 114–132.
54.
MaNAvivDGuoH, et al.Measuring the right factors: a review of variables and models for thermal comfort and indoor air quality. Renew Sustain Energy Rev2021; 135: 110436.
55.
ShajahanACulpCHWilliamsonB. Effects of indoor environmental parameters related to building heating, ventilation, and air conditioning systems on patients’ medical outcomes: a review of scientific research on hospital buildings. Indoor Air2019; 29(2): 161–176.
56.
KatafygiotouMCSerghidesDK. Thermal comfort of a typical secondary school building in Cyprus. Sustain Cities Soc2014; 13: 303–312.
57.
LiuYWangZZhangZ, et al.Investigation on the indoor environment quality of health care facilities in China. Build Environ2018; 141: 273–287.
58.
KarmannCBaumanFSRafteryP, et al.Cooling capacity and acoustic performance of radiant slab systems with free-hanging acoustical clouds. Energy Build2017; 138: 676–686.
59.
BhadraJBeizaeeALomasK, et al.0219 Experimental study on thermal comfort and sleep quality of sleeping people in overheated bedroom conditions in the UK. Sleep2023; 46(Suppl_1): A96–A97.
60.
SheppyMPlessSKungF. Healthcare energy end-use monitoring (No. NREL/TP-5500-61064). Golden, CO: National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL), 2014.
61.
JankowskiTMłynarczykM. An impact of the efficient functioning of the ventilation and air-conditioning system on thermal comfort of the medical staff in the operating room. J Ecol Eng2016; 17(5): 114–119.
62.
McCulloughEAZbikowskiPJJonesBW, et al.Measurement and prediction of the insulation provided by bedding systems. ASHRAE Trans1987; 93: 1055–1068.
