With energy efficiency regulations coming into force, the retrofitting of existing plants has become mandatory in many European countries. The application of thermostatic radiator valves is a cheap, effective solution in case of radiator-based hydronic plants, but it requires the distribution system to be re-engineered and, in some situations, further adjusting devices to be added. In this paper, the behaviour of a vertical distribution heating system has been simulated with the aim of analysing the outcome of different hydraulic balancing strategies and proposing a method to identify the most suitable option. The common problem of noisy valves has been examined and the cost impact of the different solutions has also been considered.
Practical application: This paper applies simple calculation tools to explore the impact of different balancing solutions to a real building, using an approach that could valuably assist the practitioner in the decision process.
European Union. Directive 2010/31/EU of the European parliament and of the council of 19th May 2010 on the energy performance of buildings. Off J Eur Union 18th June 2010.
2.
European Union. Directive 2012/27/EU of the European parliament and of the council of 25th October 2012 on energy efficiency, amending Directives 2009/125/EC and 2010/30/EU and repealing Directives 2004/8/EC and 2006/32/EC. Off J Eur Union 14th November 2012.
3.
TronchinLFabbriKTommasinoMC. On the cost-optimal levels of energy-performance requirements for buildings: a case study with economic evaluation in Italy. Int J Sustain Energy Plan Manag2014; 3: 49–62.
4.
BallariniICorradoVMadonnaFet al.Energy refurbishment of the Italian residential building stock: energy and cost analysis through the application of the building typology. Energy Pol2017; 105: 148–160.
5.
CholewaTSiuta-OlchaA. Long term experimental evaluation of the influence of heat cost allocators on energy consumption in a multifamily building. Energy Build2015; 104: 122–130.
6.
AndreasenB. Take control of your system with differential pressure control. Eng Syst2012; 29: 30–36.
Parsloe C. Selection of control valves in variable flow systems. BG 51/2014. Bracknell: Building Services Research and Information Association, 2014.
9.
LefterRCPopescuD. Horizontal versus vertical heat distribution in multi-storey buildings. Appl Mech Mater2013; 371: 903–907.
10.
TahersimaFStoustrupJRasmussenH. An analytical solution for stability-performance dilemma of hydronic radiators. Energy Build2013; 64: 439–446.
11.
LiuLFuLWangCet al.A novel on-off TRV adjustment model and simulation of its thermal dynamic performance. Build Simul China2009; 2: 109–118.
12.
Novy R and Kucera M. Noise from thermostatic valves in heating systems. In: 12th International congress on sound and vibration, ICSV12 (ed M Crocker), Lisbon, Portugal, 18–22 July 2005, pp.4484–4491. Auburn: IIAV.
13.
RheeKNRyuSRYeoMSet al.Simulation study on hydronic balancing to improve individual room control for radiant floor heating system. Build Serv Eng Res T2010; 31: 57–73.
14.
RheeKNShinMSYeoMSet al.Development of an evaluation strategy of hydronic balancing valves for radiant floor heating systems. Build Serv Eng Res T2015; 36: 422–438.
15.
ZhangLXiaJThorsenJEet al.Method for achieving hydraulic balance in typical Chinese building heating systems by managing differential pressure and flow. Build Simul China2017; 10: 51–63.
16.
CIBSE. Guide C: reference data, London, UK: The Chartered Institution of Building Services Engineers, 2007.
17.
European Commission. Commission Regulation (EU) No. 622/2012 of 11 July 2012 amending regulation (EC) No 641/2009 with regard to ecodesign requirements for glandless standalone circulators and glandless circulators integrated in products. Off J Eur Union 12th July 2012.
MuniakDP. A new methodology to determine the pre-setting of the control valve in a heating installation. A general model. Appl Energy2014; 135: 35–42.
20.
EN 14336:2004. Heating systems in buildings – installation and commissioning of water based heating systems. Annex G.
21.
UNI/TS 11300 (series). Energy performance of buildings. (in Italian).
22.
GardeFAyoubJAeleneiLet al.Solution sets for net zero energy buildings: feedback from 30 net ZEBs worldwide, Berlin: Ernst & Sohn, A Wiley Brand, 2017.
23.
VDMA Einheitsblatt 24199: 2005. Control requirements for the hydraulic in the planning and installation of heating, cooling, domestic hot water and air conditioning systems. Verband Deutscher Maschinen- und Anlagenbau.
24.
Fuchs HV. Geräusche von Armaturen der Wasserinstallation. IBP-Bericht BS 76/82. Stuttgart, German: Fraunhofer-Institut für Bauphysik, 1982.
25.
BaumannHDÅbomMValve-induced noise: its cause and abatement. In: CrockerMJ (ed). Handbook of noise and vibration control, New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc, 2007, pp. 935–945.
26.
BodénHÅbomM. Modelling of fluid machines as sources of sound in duct and pipe systems. Acta Acust1995; 3: 549–560.
27.
Elnady T and Åbom M. SIDLAB: New 1D sound propagation simulation software for complex duct networks. In: 13th international congress on sound and vibration (ICSV13) (ed M Crocker), Vienna, Austria, 2–6 July 2006, pp.4262–4269. Auburn: IIAV.
28.
Ziada S, Bolleter U and Zahnd E. Ueber die Pfeiftoene an thermostatischen Heizkoerperventilen. In: Fortschritte der Akustik, FASE/DAGA ‘82, Goettingen, Germany, 13–17 September 1982, pp.523–526. German.
