Professionalized Heroism? Comparing US,UK,and Norwegian War Decorations From the War in Afghanistan

Abstract

This article compares the awarding of the three highest war decorations in Norway, the United Kingdom, and the United States for actions undertaken in Afghanistan between 2001 and 2018 to examine contemporary expressions of military heroism. The comparison shows Norway tends to award leadership, and gaining respect from prestigious allies, whereas the United States and the United Kingdom tend to award individual acts of courage, involving great risk to one’s own life. In the case of the United States, these acts were predominantly aimed toward rescuing fellow soldiers, whereas the U.K. cases were aimed toward defeating an enemy. The Norwegian war decoration regime, in which the highest decorations are detached from the traditional military value of sacrifice, illustrates that while professional forces may act heroically, heroism, contrary to war decoration regimes, cannot be professionalized.

Keywords

heroism war decorations Medal of Honor Victoria Cross Afghanistan professionalism/leadership

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Arstad

(2021, December 30). Syria 2017: Norske spesialsoldater forsøkt angrepet med lastebil full av sprengstoff [Syria 2017: Attempted attack on Norwegian Special Forces by truck loaded with explosives]. https://forsvaretsforum.no/forsvarets-spesialstyrker-medalje-syria/syria-2017-norske-spesialsoldater-forsokt-angrepet-med-lastebil-full-av-sprengstoff/232702

Bauerkämper

Fure

O.-B.

Hetland

Ø.

Zimmermann

(Eds.). (2014). From patriotic memory to a universalistic narrative? Shifts in Norwegian memory culture after 1945 in comparative perspective. Klartext Verlag.

Bentzrød

S. B.

(2014, May 8). Dyktighet og tapperhet i strid utover det man kan forvente [Skills and gallantry in combat above expectations]. Aftenposten, p. 11.

Bjerkelund

(2020). Marinejeger. En norsk spesialsoldat forteller [Marine soldier. The story of a special forces soldier]. Kagge forlag.

Blake

J. A.

(1973). The congressional Medal of Honor in three wars. The Pacific Sociological Review, 16(2), 166–176.

Blake

J. A.

Butler

(1976). The Medal of Honor, combat orientations and latent role structure in the United States Military. The Sociological Quarterly, 17, 561–567.

Coker

(2007). The warrior ethos: Military culture and the war on terror. Routledge.

Congressional Medal of Honor Society. (undated) . A history of heroism. https://www.cmohs.org/

Danilova

(2015). The politics of war commemoration in the UK and Russia. Palgrave Macmillan.

10.

Fjellestad

(2017, July 27). Kjempet mot terrorister—tildeles Krigskorset [Fought against terrorists – awarded the War Cross]. https://www.forsvaret.no/aktuelt-og-presse/aktuelt/feature/kjempet-mot-terrorister–tildeles-krigskorset

11.

Forsvaret. (2011, November 18). Tapperhedskors til Casper Westphalen Mathisen fra ISAF hold 9 [Gallantry Cross to Casper Westphalen Mathisen from ISAF continget 9]. www.forsvaret.dk/da/nyheder/2011/tapperhedskors-til-casper-westphalen-mathiesen-fra-isaf-hold-9/

12.

Forsvaret. (2013, September 30). Tildelte to nye krigskors [Two new War cross medals awarded]. www.forsvaret.no/aktuelt-og-presse/arkiv/aktuelt/tildelte-to-nye-krigskors

13.

Forsvaret. (2015, May 6). Dei fekk medaljar 8. mai [They received medals May 8th]. www.forsvaret.no/aktuelt-og-presse/arkiv/aktuelt/dei-fekk-medaljar-8.mai?q=amund%20berg%20st%20olav

14.

Försvarsmakten. (undated-a). Fõrsvarsmaktens medaljer [Armed forces medals]. www.forsvarsmakten.se/sv/information-och-fakta/medaljer-och-utmarkelser/forsvarsmaktens-medaljer/

15.

Försvarsmakten. (undated-b). Medaljörer från Afghanistaninsatsen [Medal recipients from the war in Afghanistan]. www.forsvarsmakten.se/sv/information-och-fakta/var-historia/mer-historia/medaljorer-fran-afghanistaninsatsen/

16.

Franco

Z. E.

Allison

S. T.

Kinsella

E. L.

Kohen

Langdon

Zimbardo

P. G.

(2018). Heroism research: A review of theories, methods, challenges, and trends. Journal of Humanistic Psychology, 58(4), 382–396.

17.

Frisk

(2018). Post-heroic warfare revisited: Meaning and legitimation of military losses. Sociology, 52(5), 898–914.

18.

Gangdal

Gjestvang

(2012). Trond Bolle: Alles helt—min mann [Trond Bolle. Everybody’s hero – my husband]. Kagge.

19.

Gjems-Onstad

(1995). Krigskorset og St. Olavsmedaljen med ekegren [The War cross and St Olav with oak branch]. Grøndahl Dreyer.

20.

Gustavsen

Haaland

T. L.

(2019). From obligatory to optional: Thirty years of civil-military entanglements in Norway. In Refslund

Ben-Ari

(Eds.), Civil-military entanglements (pp. 80–99). Berghahn Books.

21.

Haaland

T. L.

Gustavsen

(2021). From commemoration to celebration. The making of the Norwegian Liberation and Veteran Day. Memory Studies, 19(2), 435–450.

22.

Henriksen

Weber

Brazier

(2017). Norske krigsdekorasjoner. For innsats under andre verdenskrig [Norwegian war decorations. For efforts during World War II]. Dreyer.

23.

House of Commons Library. (2021, August 17). Afghanistan statistics: UK deaths, casualties, mission costs and refugees. https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-9298/

24.

Johansen

R. V.

(2014, May 3). Bragden som ble glemt i 20 år [The feat that was forgotten for 20 years]. Aftenposten.

25.

King

(2010). The Afghan War and “postmodern” memory: Commemoration and the dead of Helmand. The British Journal of Sociology, 61(1), 1–25.

26.

King

(2014). Cohesion: Heroic and post-heroic combat. In Scheipers

(Ed.), Heroism and the changing character of war. Toward post-heroic warfare (pp. 221–236). Palgrave Macmillan.

27.

King

Bury

(2023). How (not) to win a medal: Military professionalism, gallantry awards, and the problem of fraud. Armed Forces & Society. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1177/0095327X231160104

28.

Kinsella

E. L.

Ritchie

T. D.

Igou

E. R.

(2017). On the bravery and courage of heroes: Considering gender. Heroism Science, 2(1), 1–14.

29.

Kober

(2015). From heroic to post-heroic warfare: Israel’s way of war in asymmetrical conflicts. Armed Forces & Society, 41(1), 96–122.

30.

Kriegel

(2016). The transforming power of the Victoria Cross, 1856-2010. SEL Studies in English Literature 1500-1900, 56(4), 871–893.

31.

Kristoffersen

Stensønes

(2020). Jegerånden—å lede i krig, krise og fred [The hunting spirit—to lead in war, crisic and peace]. Gyldendal.

32.

Lachmann

Stivers

(2016). The culture of sacrifice in conscript and volunteer militaries: The U.S. Medal of Honor from the Civil War to Iraq, 1861-2014. American Journal of Cultural Sociology, 4(3), 323–358.

33.

The London Gazette . (2005, March 18). Honours and awards. Supplement No. 1, 3369. https://www.thegazette.co.uk/London/issue/57587/supplement/3369/data.pdf

34.

The London Gazette . (2006, December 15). Honours and awards. Supplement No. 1, 17351. https://www.thegazette.co.uk/London/issue/58182/supplement/17351/data.pdf

35.

The London Gazette . (2013, March 22). Honours and awards. Supplement No. 1, 5735. https://www.thegazette.co.uk/London/issue/60455/supplement/5735

36.

The London Gazette . (2015, February 26). Honours and awards. Supplement No. 1, 3466. https://www.thegazette.co.uk/London/issue/61154/supplement/3466

37.

Luttwak

E. N.

(1995). Towards post-heroic warfare. Foreign Affairs, 74, 109–122.

38.

MacFarquhar

(2022, October 16). “Coffins are already coming”: The toll of Russia’s chaotic draft. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/10/16/world/europe/russia-draft-ukraine.html

39.

Mathers

J. G.

(2019). Medals and American heroic military masculinity after 9/11. In Kitchen

Mathers

J. G.

(Eds.), Heroism and global politics (pp. 36–59). Routledge.

40.

McCartney

(2011). Hero, victim or villain? The public image of the British soldier and its implications for defence policy. Defence & Security Analysis, 27(1), 43–54.

41.

Mead

(2015). Vitoria’s Cross. The untold story of Britain’s highest award for bravery. Atlantic books.

42.

Meum

H.-D.

(2021). Medaljer. Hva er det og hvorfor har vi det? En beskrivelse av Forsvarets dekorasjonssystem [Medals. What are they and why do we have them?]. https://www.forsvaret.no/om-forsvaret/uniformer-grader-medaljer/medaljer/fakta-og-artikler-om-medaljer/beskrivelse-av-forsvarets-dekorasjonssystem?q=krigskorset

43.

Norges offentlige utredninger. (2016). En god alliert. Norge i Afghanistan 2001-2014 [A good ally. Norway in Afghanistan 2001-2014]. https://www.regjeringen.no/contentassets/09faceca099c4b8bac85ca8495e12d2d/no/pdfs/nou201620160008000dddpdfs.pdf

44.

Norwegian Ministry of Defence. (2009). Statutter for krigskorset [Statutes for the War cross]. https://lovdata.no/dokument/INS/forskrift/1941-05-23-1

45.

Norwegian Ministry of Defence. (2017). Tildeles krigskorset med sverd [Awarded the War cross with sword]. https://www.regjeringen.no/no/dokumentarkiv/regjeringen-solberg/aktuelt-regjeringen-solberg/fd/pressemeldinger/2017/tildeles-krigskorset-med-sverd/id2552000/

46.

Olick

J. K.

(2007). The politics of regret: On collective memory and historical responsibility. Routledge.

47.

Powel

(2018). Iraq, Afghanistan, and rethinking the post-heroic turn: Military decorations as indicators of change in warfare. Journal of Historical Sociology, 31(1e), 16–31. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/toc/14676443/2018/31/1

48.

Regjeringen. (2021). Regjeringen har tildelt høyt rangerte krigsdekorasjoner for innsats i internasjonale operasjoner [The goverment has awarded highly ranked war decorations for efforts in international operations]. https://www.regjeringen.no/no/dokumentarkiv/regjeringen-solberg/aktuelt-regjeringen-solberg/fd/nyheter/2021/regjeringen-har-tildelt-hoyt-rangerte-krigsdekorasjoner-for-innsats-i-internasjonale-operasjoner/id2844921/

49.

Retsinformation. (2011). Cirkulære om det af Forsvarsministeriets instiftede og af Hændes Majestæt Dronningen den 14. november 2011 aproberede Tapperhedskors [Circular on, by the Defence Minstry instituted and by Her Majesty the Queen on November 14 2011, Gallantry Cross]. www.retsinformation.dk/eli/retsinfo/2011/9572

50.

Sørlie

(2021). Heroes and villains: Resistance and collaboration in Norwegian memories of the second world war. The New Past, 4, 174–195.

51.

Scheiphers

(Ed.). (2014). Heroism and the changing character of war. Palgrave Macmillan.

52.

Smith

M. C.

(2008). Awarded for valour. A history of the Victoria Cross and the Evolution of British Heroism. Palgrave Macmillan.

53.

Stensønes

(2013, May 3). Med livet som innsats [At the risk of life]. Aftenposten. https://www.aftenposten.no/sport/i/P4nMnz/med-livet-som-innsats

54.

Suliman

(2021, August 20). Nearly 20 years of war, 10 days to fall: Afghanistan, by the numbers. The Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2021/08/20/afghanistan-war-key-numbers/

55.

UK Ministry of Defence. (2012). Medals: Campaigns, descriptions and eligibility. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/medals-campaigns-descriptions-and-eligibility#decorations-gallantry-and-distinguished-conduct-medals

56.

U.S. Department of Defense. (undated). Description of medals. https://valor.defense.gov/Description-of-Awards/

57.

U.S. Department of Defense. (2023). Casualties status. https://www.defense.gov/casualty.pdf

58.

Wibe

(2014). Norges ukjente helt [Norway’s unknown hero]. https://www.forsvaret.no/aktuelt-og-presse/aktuelt/norges-ukjente-helt

59.

Widerøe

R. J.

Aass

H. P.

(2012). Krigshelten: Historien om marinejegeren og etterretningsagenten Trond Bolle [The war hero: The story about the marine and intelligence agent Trond Bolle]. Gyldendal.

60.

Winter

(2017). Commemorating catastrophe: 100 years on. War & Society, 36(4), 239–255.