Through a quasi-experimental research design, we show that incorporating self-care reminders in an online sociology course correlates with greater student engagement. Online learning has received enhanced attention since it became the primary learning modality during COVID-19 shutdowns. Despite inconclusive evidence about the efficacy of online learning, students report feelings of isolation and disconnection they attribute to reduced learning in online courses. To enhance learning, online teachers are encouraged to cultivate emotional connections with students, although some report that performing such emotional labor is detrimental to their own mental health. Through a quasi-experimental research design conducted in six online asynchronous courses over three semesters between 2020 and 2022, this study shows incorporating self-care reminders in an online sociology class correlates with higher student engagement that is not emotionally draining for teachers. We suggest incorporating self-care reminders in online sociology courses to improve student engagement without demanding excessive emotional labor from sociology teachers.
AdkinsAngela M.2021. “Values, Compassion, and the Role of Active Learning in an Introduction to Sociology Class.” Teaching Sociology49(4):319–34.
3.
AllenI. ElainSeamanJeff. 2008. “Staying the Course: Online Education in the United States.” Alfred P. Sloan Foundation, Sloan Consortium. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED529698.
4.
AllenMikeBourhisJohnBurrellNancyMabryEdward. 2002. “Comparing Student Satisfaction with Distance Education to Traditional Classrooms in Higher Education: A Meta-analysis.” The American Journal of Distance Education16(2):83–97.
AnwarMegha. 2020. “Academic Labor and the Global Pandemic: Revisiting Life-Work Balance under COVID-19.” Purdue University Working Paper Series. Special Issue: Navigating Careers in the Academy: Gender, Race and Class3(2):5–13.
7.
ArumRichardRoksaJosipa. 2011. Academically Adrift: Limited Learning on College Campuses. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
8.
BartholomayDaniel. 2022. “A Time to Adapt, Not ‘Return to Normal’: Lessons in Compassion and Accessibility from Teaching during COVID-19.” Teaching Sociology50(1):62–72.
9.
BellasMarcia L.1999. “Emotional Labor in Academia: The Case of Professors.” The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science561(1):96–110.
10.
BergstrandKellySavageScott V.2013. “The Chalkboard versus the Avatar: Comparing the Effectiveness of Online and In-Class Courses.” Teaching Sociology41(3):294–306.
11.
BerheideCatherineCarpenterMegan A.CotterDavid A.2022. “Teaching College in the Time of COVID-19: Gender and Race Differences in Faculty Emotional Labor.” Teaching Sociology84:441–55.
12.
BerilaBeth. 2014. “Contemplating the Effects of Oppression: Integrating Mindfulness into Diversity Classrooms.” The Journal of Contemplative Inquiry1(1):55–68.
13.
BernardRobert M.AbramiPhilip C.LouYipingBorodhovskiEvgueniWadeAnneWozneyLoriWalletPeter AndrewFisetManonHuangBinru. 2004. “How Does Distance Education Compare with Classroom Instruction? A Meta-analysis of the Empirical Literature.” Review of Educational Research74(3):379–439.
14.
ButtsFrankHeidornBrentMosierBrian. 2013. “Comparing Student Engagement in Online and Face-to-Face Instruction in Health and Physical Education Teacher Preparation.” Journal of Education and Learning2(2):8–13.
15.
Clark-IbanezMarisolScottLinda. 2008. “Learning to Teach Online.” Teaching Sociology36(1):34–41.
DenardoDaniella. 2022. “Is COVID-19 Like a Zombie Apocalypse? Using Horror Films to Examine the Pandemic and Social Inequalities.” Teaching Sociology50(4):322–30.
20.
DriscollAdamJichaKarlHuntAndrea N.TichavslyLisaThompsonGretchen. 2012. “Can Online Courses Deliver In-Class Results? A Comparison of Student Performance and Satisfaction in an Online versus a Face-to-Face Introductory Sociology Course.” Teaching Sociology40(4):312–31.
HessKimberlyMcAuliffeErin L.Gleckman-KrutMiriamShapiro.Shoshana2022. “Learning from 2020: How the Challenges of Remote Teaching Reinforce the Need for Care-Informed Pedagogy.” Teaching Sociology50(1):3–16.
27.
HochschildArlie R.2012. The Managed Heart: Commercialization of Human Feeling. Berkeley: University of California Press.
HuShoupingKuhGeorge D.2002. “Being (Dis)Engaged in Educationally Purposeful Activities: The Influences of Student and Institutional Characteristics.” Research in Higher Education43:555–75.
30.
HughesClaire. 2023. “The Changing Dynamics of Student Engagement.” Pp. 91–105 in Pandemic Pedagogy: Preparedness in Uncertain Times, edited by SenguptaE.London, UK: Emerald Publishing Limited. doi:10.1108/S2055-364120230000049006.
31.
HustonDanielGarlandEric L.FarbNorman A. S.2011. “Mechanisms of Mindfulness in Communication Training.” Journal of Applied Communication Research39(4):406–21.
KentnorHope. 2015. “Distance Education and the Evolution of Online Learning in the United States.” Curriculum and Teaching Dialogue17(1&2):21–34, 175.
34.
KinzieJillian. 2023. “Tracking Student (Dis)Engagement through the Pandemic: What Colleges & Universities Can Do to Foster an Engagement Reset.” Journal of Postsecondary Student Success2(2):1–14.
35.
KuhG. D.KinzieJ.SchuhJ. H.WhittE. J.1991. Involving Colleges: Successful Approaches to Fostering Student Learning and Personal Development inside the Classsroom. New York, NY: Jossey-Bass, Wiley Publishing.
36.
LampeNik. 2023. “Teaching with Tiktok in Online Sociology of Sex and Gender Courses.” Teaching Sociology51(4):323–35.
37.
LoganElisabethAugustyniakRebeccaReesAlison. 2002. “Distance Education as Different Education: A Student-Centered Investigation of Distance Learning Experience.” Journal of Education for Library and Information Science43(1):32–42.
38.
Martinez-ColaMarisela, with Rocco English, MinJenniferPerazaJonathanTambahJamesettaYebuahChristina. 2018. “When Pedagogy Is Painful: Teaching in Tumultuous Times.” Teaching Sociology46(2):97–111.
39.
MeansBarbaraToyamaYukieMurphyRobertBakiaMarianneJonesKarla. 2009. Evaluation of Evidence-Based Practices in Online Learning: A Meta-analysis and Review of Online Learning Studies. Washington, DC: Office of Planning, Evaluation, and Policy Development, U.S. Department of Education.
RossCourtneyBeardallTheresa Rocha. 2022. “Promoting Empathy and Reducing Hopelessness Using Contemplative Practices.” Teaching Sociology50(3):256–68.
46.
RovaiAlfred P.2007. “Facilitating Online Discussions Effectively.” The Internet and Higher Education10:77–88.
47.
RussellThomas L.1999. The No Significant Difference Phenomenon. Chapel Hill: Office of Instructional Telecommunications, University of North Carolina.
48.
SaddT. W. (2018). “Putting the Student at the Center: Contemplative Practices as Classroom Pedagogy.” Pp. 228–40 in Learning from Each Other: Refining the Practice of Teaching in Higher Education, edited by Kozimor-KingM. L.ChinJ.Berkeley: University of California Press.
ShererPamelaSheaTimothy. 2011. “Using Online Video to Support Learning and Engagement.” College Teaching59(2): 56–59.
51.
SitzmannTraciKraigerKurtStewardDavidWisherRobert. 2006. “The Comparative Effectiveness of Web-Based and Classroom Instruction: A Meta-analysis.” Personnel Psychology59(3):623–64.
52.
SongKirsten Y.MuschertGlenn W.2014. “Opening the Contemplative Mind in the Sociology Classroom.” Humanity & Society38(3):314–38.
53.
Starr-GlassDavid. 2013. “Experiences with Military Learners: Toward a Mindful Practice.” MERLOT Journal of Online Learning and Teaching9(3):353–64.
54.
SupianoBeckie. 2023. “Course Correction: Students Expect ‘Total Flexibility’ in the Pandemic-Era Classroom. But Is That Really What They Need?” Chronicle of Higher Education, February13. https://www.chronicle.com/article/course-correction.
55.
TuckerSheila. 2001. “Distance Education: Better, Worse or as Good as Traditional Education?” Online Journal of Distance Learning Administration4(4). https://ojdla.com/archive/winter44/tucker44.pdf.
56.
UrtelMark G.2008. “Assessing Academic Performance between Traditional and Distance Education Course Formats.” Educational Technology & Society11(1):322–30.
WeiChun-WangChenNian ShingKinshuk. 2012. “A Model for Social Presence in Online Classrooms.” Educational Technology Research and Development60(3):529–45.
WilliamsL. Susan. 2017. “The Managed Heart: Adult Learners and Emotional Presence Online.” The Journal of Continuing Higher Education65:124–31.
61.
WynnColleenZiffElizabethSnyderAllison H.SchmidtKamryn T.HillLauryn L.2023. “The Sociological Role of Empathy in the Classroom.” Teaching Sociology51(2):181–192.
62.
YoganLissa. 2015. “North Central Sociological Association Presidential Address 2014: Positively Teaching Positive Sociology.” Sociological Focus48:1–15.
63.
YorkReginald O.2008. “Comparing Three Modes Instruction in a Graduate Social Work Program.” Journal of Social Work Education44(2):157–71.
64.
YoungKimEkachaiDaradirek “Gee”. 2020. “Exploring the Effects of Different Online Syllabus Formats on Student Engagement and Course-Taking Intentions.” College Teaching68(4):176–86.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
