Blocking the progressive city: How state pre-emptions undermine labour rights in the USA

Abstract

Chinese

While some US cities and states have taken the lead in protecting labour rights, a counter-trend is found in state pre-emptions – state laws that prohibit cities from making any ordinances or laws related to certain policy areas. What drives these state-level actions that undermine progressive city leadership in the USA? We examine recent state legislations that pre-empt city authority to regulate labour conditions and protect labour rights in the private and public sectors (i.e. minimum wage, paid leave, fair scheduling, right to work, prevailing wage). We use a 50-state regression model to explore what differentiates states with more pre-emption of labour rights and potential sources of pushback. States with low minimum wages, which have never had strong labour protections, pre-empt more. Unions can be sources of pushback – greater unionisation is linked to fewer pre-emptions. However, in Republican-controlled states, more unionisation is linked to more pre-emptions. We use Wisconsin as an example of a state that adopted anti-union policies – despite strong pushback from the public – to explore how strong labour protections can act as a ‘trigger’ for states to undermine labour rights.

Keywords

corporate interests labour rights progressive cities state pre-emption unions

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aldag

Kim

Warner

(2019) Austerity urbanism or pragmatic municipalism? Local government responses to fiscal stress in New York State. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 51(6): 1287–1305.

Arampatzi

(2017) The spatiality of counter-austerity politics in Athens, Greece: Emergent ‘urban solidarity spaces’. Urban Studies 54(9): 2155–2171.

Bayırbağ

Davies

Münch

(2017) Interrogating urban crisis: Cities in the governance and contestation of austerity. Urban Studies 54(9): 2023–2038.

Beck

(2016) 5 years after Act 10: Union membership, clout has suffered. The Wisconsin State Journal, 11 February. Available at: https://madison.com/wsj/news/local/govt-and-politics/years-after-act-union-membership-clout-has-suffered/article_2abae2a5-17a1-53f0-9d6d-8b837be0506d.html.

Blyth

(2013) Austerity: The History of a Dangerous Idea. New York: Oxford University Press.

Bravo

Warner

Aldag

(2020) Grabbing market share, taming rogue cities and crippling counties: Views from the field on state preemption of local authority. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University. Available at: http://cms.mildredwarner.org/p/298 (accessed 18 March 2020).

Buhle

(2011) It Started in Wisconsin. Brooklyn, NY: Verso.

Castree

(2007) Labour geography: A work in progress. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 31(4): 853–862.

Center for Media and Democracy (CMD) (2012) ALEC Exposed in Wisconsin: The Hijacking of a State. Madison, WI: CMD.

10.

Clifton

(2014) Beyond hollowing out: Straitjacketing the state? Political Quarterly 85(4): 437–444.

11.

Clifton

Diaz-Fuentes

Gomez

(2018) The crisis as opportunity? On the role of the Troika in constructing the European consolidation state. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 11(3): 587–608.

12.

Coe

Jordhus-Lier

(2010) Constrained agency? Re-evaluating the geographies of labour. Progress in Human Geography 35(2): 211–233.

13.

Cramer

(2016) The Politics of Resentment: Rural Consciousness in Wisconsin and the Rise of Scott Walker. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

14.

Davies

Blanco

(2017) Austerity urbanism: Patterns of neo-liberalisation and resistance in six cities of Spain and the UK. Environment and Planning A 49(7): 1517–1536.

15.

Donald

Glasmeier

Gray

, et al. (2014) Austerity in the city: Economic crisis and urban service decline? Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 7(1): 3–15.

16.

Doussard

(2015) Equity planning outside City Hall: Rescaling advocacy to confront the sources of urban problems. Journal of Planning Education and Research 35(3): 296–306.

17.

Doussard

Gamal

(2016) The rise of wage theft laws: Can community–labor coalitions win victories in state houses? Urban Affairs Review 52(5): 780–807.

18.

Doussard

Lesniewski

(2017) Fortune favors the organized: How Chicago activists won equity goals under austerity. Journal of Urban Affairs 39(5): 618–634.

19.

Economic Policy Institute (EPI) (2017) City Governments are Raising Standard for Working People – And State Legislators are Lowering them Back Down. Washington, DC: EPI.

20.

Economic Policy Institute (EPI) (2019) Minimum Wage Tracker. Available at: https://www.epi.org/minimum-wage-tracker/ (accessed 20 February 2019).

21.

Featherstone

Ince

Mackinnon

, et al. (2012) Progressive localism and the construction of political alternatives. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 37(2): 177–182.

22.

Fuller

West

(2016) The possibilities and limits of political contestation in times of ‘urban austerity’. Urban Studies 54(9): 2087–2106.

23.

Gray

Barford

(2018) The depths of the cuts: The uneven geography of local government austerity. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 11(3): 541–563.

24.

Harris

Hershbein

Kearney

(2014) Brookings on job numbers. A tale of two jobs gaps: Private-sector recovery and public-sector stagnation. The Brookings Institution, 5 September. Available at: https://www.brookings.edu/blog/jobs/2014/09/05/a-tale-of-two-jobs-gaps-private-sector-recovery-and-public-sector-stagnation/.

25.

Hebdon

Kirkpatrick

(2005) Changes in the organization of public services and their effects on employment relations. In: Ackroyd

Batt

Thompson

, et al. (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Work and Organization. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 530–553.

26.

Henly

Lambert

(2014) Unpredictable work timing in retail jobs: Implications for employee work–life conflict. ILR Review 67(3): 986–1016.

27.

Hertel-Fernandez

(2019) State Capture: How Conservative Activists, Big Business, and Wealthy Donors Reshaped the American States – And the Nation. New York: Oxford.

28.

Hinkley

(2017) Structurally adjusting: Narratives of fiscal crisis in four US cities. Urban Studies 54(9): 2123–2138.

29.

Hipp

Morrissey

Warner

(2017) Who participates and who benefits from employer-provided child-care assistance? Journal of Marriage and Family 79(3): 614–635.

30.

Huizar

Lathrop

(2019) Fighting Wage Pre-emption: How Workers Have Lost Billions in Wages and How We Can Restore Local Democracy. New York: National Employment Law Project.

31.

Jones

Meegan

Kennett

, et al. (2016) The uneven impact of austerity on the voluntary and community sector: A tale of two cities. Urban Studies 53(10): 2064–2080.

32.

Kaufman

(2019) The Fall of Wisconsin: The Conservative Conquest of a Progressive Bastion and the Future of American Politics. New York: W.W. Norton.

33.

Kim

(2019) Limits of fiscal federalism: How narratives of local government inefficiency facilitate scalar dumping in New York State. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 51(3): 636–653.

34.

Kim

Warner

(2018) Shrinking local autonomy: Corporate coalitions and the subnational state. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 11(3): 427–441.

35.

Kim

Warner

(2020) Pragmatic municipalism or austerity urbanism? Understanding local government responses to fiscal stress. Local Government Studies. Epub ahead of print 26 February 2020. DOI: 10.1080/0300 3930.2020.1729751.

36.

Lafer

(2017) The One Percent Solution: How Corporations Are Remaking America One State at a Time. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

37.

Lobao

Martin

Rodríguez-Pose

(2009) Editorial: Rescaling the state: New modes of institutional–territorial organization. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 2(1): 3–12.

38.

Marley

(2012) A transcript of the Walker/Hendricks union discussion. The Journal Sentinel, 10 May. Available at: http://archive.jsonline.com/news/statepolitics/a-transcript-of-the-walkerhendricks-union-discussion-805952v-151052965.html/.

39.

National Association of Counties (NACo) (2016) Doing More With Less: State Revenue Limitations & Mandates on County Finances. Washington, DC: NACo.

40.

National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL) (2017) Right-To-Work Resources. Washington, DC: NCSL. Available at: http://www.ncsl.org/research/labor-and-employment/right-to-work-laws-and-bills.aspx#add.

41.

National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL) (2018) 2018 State & Legislative Partisan Composition. Washington, DC: NCSL. Available at: http://www.ncsl.org/Portals/1/Documents/Elections/Legis_Control_011018_26973.pdf.

42.

National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL) (2019a) Right to Work Resources. Washington, DC: NCSL. Available at: http://www.ncsl.org/research/labor-and-employment/right-to-work-laws-and-bills.aspx#add.

43.

National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL) (2019b) State Partisan Composition. Available at: http://www.ncsl.org/research/about-state-legislatures/partisan-composition.aspx.

44.

National Governors Association, National Conference of State Legislatures, The Council of State Governments, National Association of Counties, National League of Cities, The U.S. Conference of Mayors … National Association of State Retirement Administrators (2015) State and Local Fiscal Facts: 2015. Available at: https://www.nasact.org/files/News_and_Publications/White_Papers_Reports/2015_02_Fact_Sheet.pdf (accessed 2 June 2015).

45.

National League of Cities (NLC) (2018) City Rights in an Era of Pre-emption: A State-by-State Analysis. 2 April. Washington, DC: NLC.

46.

Newman

(2014) Landscapes of antagonism: Local governance, neoliberalism and austerity. Urban Studies 51(15): 3290–3305.

47.

Peck

(2014) Pushing austerity: State failure, municipal bankruptcy and the crises of fiscal federalism in the USA. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 7(1): 17–44.

48.

Peck

(2016) The right to work, and the right at work. Economic Geography 92: 4–30.

49.

Peck

(2017) Transatlantic city, part 2: Late entrepreneurialism. Urban Studies 54(2): 327–363.

50.

Peck

Theodore

Brenner

(2012) Neoliberalism resurgent? Market rule after the great recession. South Atlantic Quarterly 111(2): 265–288.

51.

Peters

(2012) Neoliberal convergence in North America and Western Europe: Fiscal austerity, privatization, and public sector reform. Review of International Political Economy 19(2): 208–235.

52.

Pike

Tomaney

(2009) The state and uneven development: The governance of economic development in England in the post-devolution UK. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 2(1): 13–34.

53.

Riverstone-Newell

(2017) The rise of state pre-emption laws in response to local policy innovation. Publius: The Journal of Federalism 47(3): 403–425.

54.

Schragger

(2016) City Power: Urban Governance in a Global Age. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

55.

Squire

(2017) A Squire index update. State Politics & Policy Quarterly 17(4): 361–371.

56.

Stein

Marley

(2013) More Than They Bargained For: Scott Walker, Unions, and the Fight for Wisconsin. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.

57.

Swanson

Barrilleaux

(2018) State government pre-emption of local government decisions through the state courts. Urban Affairs Review 56(2): 671–697.

58.

Taylor-Gooby

(2013) The Double Crisis of the Welfare State and What We Can Do About It. London: Palgrave Macmillan.

59.

Thompson

(2012) The metamorphosis of a crisis. In: Castells

Caraça

Cardoso

(eds) Aftermath: The Cultures of the Economic Crisis. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, pp. 59–81.

60.

Umhoefer

(2016) From Milwaukee County to Madison, Scott Walker’s rise marked by union battles. Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, 27 November.

61.

Ungar

(2011) A secret deal between Gov. Walker and Koch Brothers buried in state budget? Forbes, 22 February.

62.

US Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) (2017) Union membership (Annual) news release. Available at: https://www.bls.gov/news.release/archives/union2_01262017.htm.

63.

Vyse

(2018) ALEC outlines 2019 agenda to Erode union power. Governing Magazine, 5 December.

64.

Walker

Thiessen

(2014) Unintimidated: A Governor’s Story and a Nation’s Challenge. New York: Penguin Publishing Group.

65.

Warner

Clifton

(2014) Marketisation, public services and the city: The potential for Polanyian counter movements. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 7(1): 45–61.

66.

Warner

Hefetz

(2019) Contracting dynamics and unionisation: Managing labour, contracts and markets. Local Government Studies. Epub ahead of print 11 October 2019. DOI: 10.1080/03003930.2019.1670167.

67.

Warner

Aldag

Kim

(2019) Pragmatic Municipalism: US Local Government Responses to Fiscal Stress. 8th Annual State & Local Government Law Works-in-Progress Conference, 20 September 2019, Charlottesville, VA.

68.

Weaver

(2017) Urban crisis: The genealogy of a concept. Urban Studies 54(9): 2039–2055.

69.

Wolman

McManmon

Bell

, et al. (2010) Comparing local government autonomy across states. In: Bell

Brunori

Youngman

(eds) The Property Tax and Local Autonomy. Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, pp. 69–120.

70.

Warner

(2016) Does devolution crowd out development? A spatial analysis of US local government fiscal effort. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 48(5): 871–890.