Evaluating the biomechanical interaction between the medical compression stocking and human calf using a highly anatomical fidelity three-dimensional finite element model
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online June, 2021
Evaluating the biomechanical interaction between the medical compression stocking and human calf using a highly anatomical fidelity three-dimensional finite element model
The beneficial effects of the medical compression stocking (MCS) in the treatment of venous disorders of the human lower limb have been recognized. However, the effectiveness of the MCS on the internal tissues of the lower limb has not been properly evaluated. The aim of the present study was to shed light on the mechanism of compression therapy using a highly anatomical fidelity three-dimensional finite element (FE) model. A FE calf model of a 40-year-old female was created from magnetic resonance images, in which the bones, the muscle groups, three veins (the great saphenous vein, medial peroneal vein and small saphenous vein), the subcutaneous tissues (fascia) and the skin were reconstructed. The model was validated using experimental data collected in-house, and then the influence of different levels of external compression and the biomechanical effect of the MCS under the pathological conditions were investigated. The results showed that the pressure at the skin–stocking interface was largely influenced by the external compression pressure with an increase of up to 54.98%, while the pressure was neither influenced by the impairment of the muscular tissues nor by the impairment of the calf veins, with the largest change of just 5.63%. The trans-mural pressure was increased more by the impairment of the calf veins than by the impairment of the muscular tissues. The volume reductions in the calf veins were not evenly distributed. The present study provides some guidance on compression therapy.
ByrneB. Deep vein thrombosis prophylaxis: the effectiveness and implications of using below-knee or thigh-length graduated compression stockings. J Vasc Nurs2002; 20: 53–59.
4.
HiraiMIwataHHayakawaN. Effect of elastic compression stockings in patients with varicose veins and healthy controls measured by strain gauge plethysmography. Skin Res Tech2002; 8: 236–239.
5.
PourazadiSAhmadiandSMenonC. Towards the development of active compression bandages using dielectric elastomer actuators. Smart Mater Struct2014; 23: 065007–065007.
6.
MaffiodoDDe NiscoGGalloD, et al.A reduced-order model-based study on the effect of intermittent pneumatic compression of limbs on the cardiovascular system. Proc Inst Mech Eng H2016; 230: 279–287.
7.
AhmadiSMattosACBarbazzaA, et al.Fabrication and performance analysis of a DEA cuff designed for dry-suit applications. Smart Mater Struct2013; 22: 035002–035002.
8.
XiongYTaoX. Compression garments for medical therapy and sports. Polymers2018; 10: 663–663.
9.
IbegbunaVDelisTNicolaidesAN, et al.Effect of elastic compression stockings on venous hemodynamics during walking. J Vasc Surg2003; 37: 420–425.
10.
LiuRKwokYLLiY, et al.Objective evaluation of skin pressure distribution of graduated elastic compression stockings. Dermatol Surg2005; 31: 615–624.
11.
LimCSDaviesAH. Graduated compression stockings. Can Med Assoc J2014; 186: E391–E398.
12.
AgleCGCoutoCKFilhoDSA, et al.Evaluation of the effectiveness of wearing compression stockings for prevention of occupational edema in hairdressers. J Vasc Bras2020; 19: 1677–7301.
13.
TishcerTSOyeSLenzR, et al.Impact of compression stocking on leg swelling after arthroscopy – a prospective randomized pilot study. BMC Musculoskelet Disord2019; 20: 161–161.
14.
HarpaRPiroiCRaduCD. A new approach for testing medical stockings. Text Res J2010; 80: 683–695.
15.
LuYYangZWangY. A critical review on the three-dimensional finite element modelling of the compression therapy for chronic venous insufficiency. Proc Inst Mech Eng H2019; 233: 1089–1099.
16.
AvrilSBoutenLDubuisL, et al.Mixed experimental and numerical approach for characterizing the biomechanical response of the human leg under elastic compression. J Biomech Eng2010; 132: 031006–031006.
17.
Avril S, Badel P, Dubuis L, et al. Patient-specific modelling of leg compression in the treatment of venous deficiency. Berlin: Springer, 2011, pp.217–238.
18.
FrauziolsFRohanPYBadelP, et al.Patient-specific modelling of the calf muscle under elastic compression using magnetic resonance imaging and ultrasound elastography. Comput Methods Biomech Biomed Engin2013; 16: 332–333.
19.
FrauziolsFMolimardJNavarroL, et al.Prediction of the biomechanical effects of compression therapy by finite element modelling and ultrasound elastography. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng2015; 62: 1011–1019.
20.
RohanCPBadelPLunB, et al.Biomechanical response of varicose veins to elastic compression: a numerical study. J Biomech2013; 46: 599–603.
21.
RohanPYBadelPLunB, et al.Prediction of the biomechanical effects of compression therapy on deep veins using finite element modelling. Ann Biomed Eng2015; 43: 314–324.
22.
WangYPierceIGatehouseP, et al.Analysis of flow and wall shear stress in the peroneal veins under external compression based on real-time MR images. Med Eng Phys2012; 34: 17–27.
23.
WangYDownieSWoodN, et al.Finite element analysis of the deformation of deep veins in the lower limb under external compression. Med Eng Phys2013; 35: 515–523.
24.
Al-DiriniRMReedMPHuJ, et al.Development and validation of a high anatomical fidelity FE model for the buttock and thigh of a seated individual. Ann Biomed Eng2016; 44: 2805–2816.
25.
LevyAKopplinKGefenA. Simulations of skin and subcutaneous tissue loading in the buttocks while regaining weight-bearing after a push-up in wheelchair users. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater2013; 28: 436–447.
26.
LiuRKwokYLLiY, et al.A three-dimensional biomechanical model for numerical simulation of dynamic pressure functional performances of graduated compression stocking (GCS). Fiber Polym2006; 7: 389–397.
27.
LiuRKwokYLLiY, et al.Numerical simulation of internal stress profiles and three-dimensional deformations of lower extremity beneath medical graduated compression stocking (GCS). Fiber Polym2007; 8: 302–308.
28.
ZhangLSunGLiJ, et al.The structure and pressure characteristics of graduated compression stockings: experimental and numerical study. Text Res J2019; 89: 5218–5225.
29.
YuXAzorASharpDJ, et al.Mechanisms of tensile failure of cerebrospinal fluid in blast traumatic brain injury. Extreme Mech Lett2020; 38: 100739–100739.
30.
BeldieLWalkerBLuY, et al.Finite element modelling of maxillofacial surgery and facial expressions – a preliminary study. Int J Med Robotics Comput Assist Surg2010; 6: 422–430.
31.
SimkinRUlloaJ. Classification of primary varicose veins of the lower extremities: a consensus statement from Latin America. Phlebolymphology2004; 44: 244–248.
32.
IivarinenJTKorhonenRKJulkunenP, et al.Experimental and computational analysis of soft tissue stiffness in forearm using a manual indentation device. Med Eng Phys2011; 33: 1245–1253.
33.
DubuisLAvrilSDebayleJ, et al.Identification of the material parameters of soft tissues in the compressed leg. Comput Methods Biomech Biomed Engin2012; 15: 3–11.
34.
KeenanMJHegstedMJonesKL, et al.Comparison of bone density measurement techniques: DXA and Archimedes’ Principle. J Bone Miner Res1997; 12: 1903–1907.
35.
BeidokhtiHJanssenDKhoshgoftarM, et al.A comparison between dynamic implicit and explicit finite element simulations of the native knee joint. Med Eng Phys2016; 38: 1123–1130.
36.
KohnJCLampiMCReinhart-KingC. Age-related vascular stiffening: causes and consequences. Front Genet2015; 6: 112–112.
37.
GefenAChenJEladD. A biomechanical model of Peyronie’s Disease. J Biomech2000; 33: 1739–1744.
38.
Linder-GanzEShabshinNItzchakY, et al.Assessment of mechanical conditions in sub-dermal tissues during sitting: a combined experimental-MRI and finite element approach. J Biomech2007; 40: 1443–1454.
39.
DelalleauAJosseGLagardeJM, et al.Characterization of the mechanical properties of skin by inverse analysis combined with the indentation test. J Biomech2006; 39: 1603–1610.
40.
WeslyRLVaishnavRNFuchsJC, et al.Static linear and nonlinear elastic properties of normal and arterialized venous tissue in dog and man. Circ Res1975; 37: 509–520.
41.
HanHC. Determination of the critical buckling pressure of blood vessels using the energy approach. Ann Biomed Eng2011; 39: 1032–1040.
42.
ZhaoJAndreasenJJYangJ, et al.Manual pressure distension of the human saphenous vein changes its biomechanical properties – implication for coronary artery bypass grafting. J Biomech2007; 40: 2268–2276.
43.
AndrewsBSommervilleKAustinS, et al.Effect of foot compression on the velocity and volume of blood flow in the deep veins. Br J Surg1993; 80: 198–200.
44.
LiJLuYMillerSC, et al.Development of a finite element musculoskeletal model with the ability to predict contractions of three-dimensional muscles. J Biomech2019; 94: 230–234.
45.
MoFLiJDanM, et al.Implementation of controlling strategy in a biomechanical lower limb model with active muscles for coupling multibody dynamics and finite element analysis. J Biomech2019; 91: 51–60.
