Inter-laboratory proficiency tests in measuring thermal insulation and evaporative resistance of clothing using the Newton-type thermal manikin

Abstract

Clothing acts as an important barrier for heat and vapor transfer between the human body and the environment. Parameters that could describe that transfer include, inter alia, thermal insulation (the so-called dry heat exchange) and evaporative resistance (the so-called wet heat exchange). Once the above-mentioned parameters are determined, it is possible to consciously adapt clothing ensembles to the existing thermal environment in the workplace.

In order to validate the mentioned method of thermal insulation and evaporative resistance measurements, proficiency tests (PTs) were organized. The main goal of the PT was to compare thermal insulation and evaporative resistance for one set of clothing using the Newton-type thermal manikin. In total, four laboratories participated in the PT study. The reference value of the thermal insulation (I_t) and evaporative resistance (R_et) were calculated as the mean of all the results. The assessment criteria included permissible errors for thermal insulation and evaporative resistance measurements, which were 4% and 10%, respectively. Calculations included, inter alia, z-scores and indicators, such as the inter-laboratory coefficient of variation or the reproducibility limit. The results contribute to the worldwide discussion on standardized studies of evaporative resistance of clothing.

Keywords

thermal manikin Newton thermal insulation evaporative resistance

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Chen

Fan

Zhang

. Clothing thermal insulation during sweating. Text Res J 2003; 73: 152–157.

Wang F, Shi W, Lu Y, et al. Effects of moisture content and clothing fit on clothing apparent ‘wet’ thermal insulation: a thermal manikin study. Text Res J. 2016; 86: 57–63.

Holmer

. Thermal manikin history and applications. Eur J Appl Physiol 2004; 92: 614–618.

Oliviera

Gaspar

Quintela

. Dynamic clothing insulation. Measurements with a thermal manikin operating under the thermal comfort regulation mode. Appl Ergon 2011; 42: 890–899.

Meinander H, Anttonen H, Bartels V, et al. Thermal insulation measurement of cold protective clothing using thermal manikins. SUBZERO project, final report. Fibre Materials Science, Tampere University of Technology, 2003.

EN 342. Protection against cold environment, 2004.

McCullough E. Interlaboratory study of sweating manikins. In: Richards MGM (ed.) Proceedings of the fourth international meeting on thermal manikin, 27–28 September 2001, EMPA Switzerland, CD-ROM, pp.1–6. Swiss Federal Laboratories for Materials Testing and Research (EMPA), St. Gallen, Switzerland.

EN ISO 15831:2004. Clothing – physiological effects – measurement of thermal insulation by means of a thermal manikin.

Mayor T, Wang F, Leonard J, et al. An interlaboratory study on measurements of clothing evaporative resistance with thermal manikins. In: 5th European conference on protective clothing (ECPC) and NOKOBETEF 10 Future of Protective Clothing: Intelligent or not, Valencia, Spain, chair: Helena Makinen; Valencia, 29–31 May 2012, pp.1–4. Available at: http://www.es-pc.org/proceedings/5th_ecpc.pdf (accessed 22 November 2016).

10.

ASTM F2370:2010. Standard test method for measuring the evaporative resistance of clothing using a sweating manikin.

11.

Wang

Peng

et al.

Effect of sweating set rate on clothing real evaporative resistance determined on a sweating thermal manikin in a so-called isothermal condition (T_manikin = T_a = T_r). Int J Biometeorol 2016; 60: 481–488.

12.

Anttonen

Niskanen

Meinander

et al.

Thermal manikin measurements – exact or not?

Int J Occup Safe Ergon JOSE 2004; 10: 291–300.

13.

ISO 5725-2:1994. Accuracy (trueness and precision) of measurement methods and results – Part 2: basic method for the determination of repeatability and reproducibility of a standard measurement method.

14.

ISO/IEC GUIDE 43-1:1997. Proficiency testing by interlaboratory comparisons – Part 1: development and operation of proficiency testing schemes.

15.

Richards M and McCullough E. Revised interlaboratory study of sweating thermal manikins including results from the sweating agile thermal manikin. J ASTM Int 2005; 2: 1–13.

16.

Wang F, Havenith G, Mayor T, et al. Clothing real evaporative resistance determined by means of a sweating thermal manikin: a new round-robin study. In: Varheenmaa M (ed.) Proceedings of Ambience 14&10i3m, Scientific Conference for Smart and Functional Textiles, Well-Being, Thermal Comfort in Clothing, Design, Thermal Manikins and Modellin, Tampereen teknilllinen yliopisto, 7–9 September 2014, Tampere, Finland. ISBN 978-952-15-3269-6.

17.

Wang

Gao

Kuklane

et al.

Determination of clothing evaporative resistance on a sweating thermal manikin in an isothermal condition: heat loss method or mass loss method?

Ann Occup Hyg 2011; 55: 775–783.

18.

Wang

Peng

. Effect of two sweating simulation methods on clothing evaporative resistance in a so-called isothermal condition. Int J Biometeorol 2016; 60: 1041–1049.

19.

Parson

. Human thermal environments: The effects of hot, moderate and cold environments on human health, comfort and performance, London and New York: Taylor and Francis Group, 2003.