Advocacy Research on Homophobia in Education: Claims-Making,Trauma Construction and the Politics of Evidence

Abstract

Sociology has an ambivalent relationship with advocacy research because the benefits of participation and engagement must be balanced with concerns about bias. The current study uses 10 recent research reports on homophobia in British educational settings, written and funded by campaigning charities, as a case study of contemporary advocacy research. Presenting a sociological analysis of these documents and adopting a social problems approach, claims-making processes in the reports are documented and significant methodological and analytical flaws are identified. Instead of objective research, these reports are campaigning documents that seek to gain media coverage and influence policy. Implications for how the reports should be used as resources for research and social policy are examined, and a more nuanced and sophisticated approach to engaging with advocacy research is called for.

Keywords

advocacy charities education homophobia LGBT sexualities social problems trauma construction

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alexander

(2004) Cultural Trauma and Collective Identity. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

Alexander

(2012) Trauma. Cambridge: Polity.

Bacchi

(2009) Analysing Policy. Frenchs Forest: Pearson.

Bagozzi

Moore

(1994) Public service advertisements. Journal of Marketing 58(1): 56–70.

Bassel

Emejulu

(2017) Minority Women and Austerity. Bristol: Policy Press.

Beam

(2018) Gay, Inc: The Nonprofitization of Queer Politics. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.

Becker

(1967) Whose side are we on? Social Problems 14(3): 239–247.

Best

(1987) Rhetoric in claims-making. Social Problems 34(2): 101–121.

Best

(1990) Threatened Children. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

10.

Best

(2012) Damned Lies and Statistics. London: University of California Press.

11.

Best

(2012) Disease politics and medical research funding. American Sociological Review 77(5): 780–803.

12.

Booth

(1892) Life and Labour of People in London. London: Macmillan.

13.

Cairney

(2016) The Politics of Evidence-Based Policymaking. London: Palgrave Pivot.

14.

Cimpian

(2017) Classification errors and bias regarding research on sexual minority youths. Educational Researcher 46(9): 517–529.

15.

Clapton

Cree

(2017) Communicating concern or making claims? Journal of Social Work 17(1): 71–90.

16.

Clapton

Cree

Smith

(2013) Moral panics, claims-making and child protection in the UK. British Journal of Social Work 43(4): 803–812.

17.

Clements

Field

(2014) Public opinion toward homosexuality and gay rights in Great Britain. Public Opinion Quarterly 78(2): 523–547.

18.

Cornell

Klein

Konold

, et al. (2012) Effects of validity screening items on adolescent survey data. Psychological Assessment 24(1): 21–35.

19.

David

(2002) Problems of participation. International Journal of Social Research Methodology 5(1): 11–17.

20.

Davis

(2003) Public relations and news sources. In: Cottle

(ed.) News, Public Relations and Power. London: SAGE.

21.

Dean

(2015) Volunteering, the market, and neoliberalism. People, Place and Policy 9: 139–148.

22.

Dean

(2017) Doing Reflexivity. Bristol: Policy.

23.

Dean

Wood

(2017) ‘You can try to press different emotional buttons’: The conflicts and strategies of eliciting emotions for fundraisers. International Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Marketing 22(54): e1603.

24.

DfE (2015) Awards announced from £2 million homophobic bullying fund. Press release, 24 March. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/awards-announced-from-2-million-homophobic-bullying-fund.

25.

Ditch the Label (2019) Home page. Available at: https://www.ditchthelabel.org/.

26.

Durso

Gates

(2013) Best practices: Collecting and analyzing data on sexual minorities. In: Baumle

(ed.) International Handbook on the Demography of Sexuality. New York: Springer.

27.

Eikenberry

(2009) Refusing the market: A democratic discourse for voluntary and non-profit organizations. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 38(4): 582–596.

28.

Fenton

(2009) Has the Internet changed how NGOs work with established media? Available at: https://www.niemanlab.org/2009/11/natalie-fenton-has-the-internet-changed-how-ngos-work-with-established-media-not-enough/ (accessed 10 April 2019).

29.

Ferfolja

(2007) Schooling cultures. International Journal of Inclusive Education 11(2): 147–162.

30.

Fisher

Vandenbosch

Antia

(2008) An empathy-helping perspective on consumers’ responses to fund-raising appeals. Journal of Consumer Research 35(4): 519–531.

31.

Formby

(2015) Limitations of focussing on homophobic, biphobic and transphobic ‘bullying’ to understand and address LGBT young people’s experiences within and beyond school. Sex Education 15(6): 626–640.

32.

GEO (2018) LGBT Action Plan 2018. London: Government Equalities Office.

33.

Gilbert

(1997) Advocacy research and social policy. Crime and Justice 22: 101–148.

34.

Gusfield

(1989) Constructing the ownership of social problems. Social Problems 36(5): 431–441.

35.

Hibbert

(1996) The market position of British medical charities. European Journal of Marketing 29(10): 6–26.

36.

Hunt

Jensen

(2007) The School Report. London: Stonewall.

37.

Iwaarden

Der Wiele

Williams

, et al. (2009) Charities. International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management 26(1): 5–22.

38.

Jones

(2017) Looking good: Mediatisation and international NGOs. European Journal of Development Research 29(1): 176–191.

39.

Loseke

Best

(eds) (2003) Social Problems. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.

40.

McCormack

(2012) The Declining Significance of Homophobia. New York: Oxford University Press.

41.

McCormack

(2014) Innovative sampling and participant recruitment in sexuality research. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 31(4): 475–481.

42.

McIntyre

(2008) Participatory Action Research. London: SAGE.

43.

McLaughlin

(2015) Advocacy research and social policy: Action for Children and the NSPCC as case studies. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 35(3/4): 239–251.

44.

Macmillan

(2013) ‘Distinction’ in the third sector. Voluntary Sector Review 4(1): 39–54.

45.

Matthews

Astbury

Connelly

, et al. (2015) Doing and Evaluating Community Research. Stirling: AHRC.

46.

Metro (2019) Our history. Available at: https://metrocentreonline.org/about-us/what-we-do.

47.

Milward

Provan

(2010) Managing the hollow state. Public Management Review 5(1): 1–18.

48.

Monk

(2011) Challenging homophobic bullying in schools. International Journal of Law in Context 7(2): 181–207.

49.

Nelson

(2009) A crisis of identity. Howard Journal of Crime and Justice 48(4): 401–410.

50.

Nickel

Eikenberry

(2009) A critique of the discourse of marketized philanthropy. American Behavioral Scientist 52: 974–989.

51.

NUS (2014) NUS calls for zero tolerance to LGBT bullying. Press release, 12 May. Available at: https://www.nus.org.uk/en/news/nus-calls-for-zero-tolerance-to-lgbt-bullying/.

52.

NUS (2019) The NUS. Available at: https://www.nus.org.uk/.

53.

Plummer

(1999) One of the Boys. New York: Harrington Park Press.

54.

Rhodes

(1994) The hollowing out of the state. The Political Quarterly 65(2): 138–151.

55.

Riggle

EDB

Rostosky

Reedy

(2005) Online surveys for BGLT research. Journal of Homosexuality 49(2): 1–21.

56.

Rivers

(2011) Homophobic Bullying. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

57.

Rubin

(2011) The trouble with trafficking. In: Rubin

(ed.) Deviations. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

58.

Sanderson

(2011) Evidence-based policy or policy-based evidence? Evidence & Policy 7(1): 59–76.

59.

Savin-Williams

(2005) The New Gay Teenager. Boston, MA: Harvard University Press.

60.

Savin-Williams

Joyner

(2014) The dubious assessment of gay, lesbian, and bisexual adolescents in Add Health. Archives of Sexual Behavior 43: 413–422.

61.

Schneider

(1985) Social problems theory. Annual Review of Sociology 11: 209–229.

62.

Stevens

(2011) Telling policy stories. Journal of Social Policy 40: 237–255.

63.

Strassheim

Kettunen

(2014) When does evidence-based policy turn into policy-based evidence? Evidence & Policy 10(2): 259–277.

64.

Stonewall (2017) Stonewall School Report 2017. Press release, 27 June. Available at: https://www.stonewall.org.uk/news/stonewall-school-report-2017-anti-lgbt-bullying-down-lgbt-young-people-still-risk.

65.

Stonewall (2019) Mission and priorities. Available at: https://www.stonewall.org.uk/about-us/our-mission-and-priorities.

66.

Swales

Taylor

(2017) Moral issues. In: British Social Attitudes: The 34th report. London: NatCen Social Research.

67.

Weeks

(1985) Sexuality and Its Discontents. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.

68.

Weeks

(2007) The World We Have Won. London: Routledge.

69.

Weitzer

(2010) The mythology of prostitution: Advocacy research and public policy. Sexuality Research and Social Policy 7(1): 15–29.

70.

White

Magrath

Thomas

(2018) The experiences of LGB students and staff at a Further Education college in South East England. British Educational Research Journal 44(3): 480–495.