This study investigates five Polish Instagram creators who self-identify as witches, examining their spiritual practices, perceptions of online communities, and experiences with hostility. Data were collected via open-ended questionnaires and analyzed using Plutchik’s Wheel of Emotions to assess emotional tone. Participants expressed diverse, syncretic approaches to witchcraft, navigating tensions between authenticity and visibility. Communities were valued but conceptualized differently. Despite recurring experiences of online discrimination – often rooted in religious intolerance – dominant emotions were trust and joy, indicating strong social bonds and positive engagement. Fear also emerged, suggesting critical awareness, while anger and disgust remained low.
AbidinC (2016) Visibility labour: Engaging with Influencers’ fashion brands and #OOTD advertorial campaigns on Instagram. Media International Australia161(1): 86–100.
2.
AbubakirSBaimbetAKabievaASarsenovBSeidilabekAAkhmetovIGelbukhA (2024) Sentiment analysis for religious tweets. Computación y Sistemas28(4): 1911–1918.
3.
AdamLShaniAKYarPBAdwan-KamarLTabongT-N (2023) Depression and quality of life of people accused of witchcraft and living in alleged witches’ camps in Northern Ghana. Health & Social Care in the Community2023: 6830762.
4.
AdamLShaniAKYarPBAdwan-KamarLTeg-Nefaah TabongP (2023) Depression and quality of life of people accused of witchcraft and living in alleged witches’ camps in Northern Ghana. Health & Social Care in the Community. Epub ahead of print 14 February. DOI: 10.1155/2023/6830762.
5.
Adjin-TetteyTDEtrueM (2025) Fostering civic engagement on ‘Ghana X’: An analysis of data-driven journalistic practices of mainstream and peripheral media actors. Journalism Studies26(6): 715–739.
6.
Al-RawiA (2022) Hashtagged trolling and emojified hate against Muslims on social media. Religions13(6): 521.
7.
AnczykAMalita-KrólJ (2018) Women of power: The image of the witch and feminist movements in Poland. Pomegranate19(2): 205–232.
8.
AnjumKR (2024) Hate speech, toxicity detection in online social media: A recent survey of state of the art and opportunities. International Journal of Information Security23: 577–608.
9.
Arroyo-BarrigüeteJL (2023) Sentiment analysis of Lovecraft’s fiction writings. Heliyon9(1): e12673.
10.
AvciHBaamsLKretschmerT (2025) A systematic review of social media use and adolescent identity development. Adolescent Research Review10: 219–236.
11.
BeierleFPryssRAizawaA (2023) Sentiments about mental health on Twitter: Before and during the COVID–19 Pandemic. Healthcare11(21): 2893.
12.
BorowikIGrygielPZwierżdżyńskiM (2024) The religiosity of Polish Roman Catholics and the meanings they attribute to homosexuality: Evidence from network analysis. Sexuality Research and Social Policy21: 110–131.
13.
BüttnerCMLalotFRudertSC (2023) Showing with whom I belong: The desire to belong publicly on social media. Computers in Human Behavior139: 107535.
14.
CaldeiraSP (2024) (Re)sharing feminisms: Re-sharing Instagram stories as everyday feminist practices. New Media & Society27(7): 4265–4284.
15.
CristescuMMaraDCuldaLNerișsanuR (2023) Applying Bert and Vader in HR sentiment analysis. HR & Technologies2: 6–23.
16.
De los SantosJRN (2021) Depression among public school teachers in the Philippines: A news sentiment analysis. International Journal of Law, Humanities & Social Science5(1): 26–34.
17.
Dos SantosV (2023) (Techno)paganism: An exploration of animistic relations with the digital. Religions14(11): 1382.
18.
DreißigackerAMüllerPIsenhardtASchemmelJ (2024) Online hate speech victimization: consequences for victims’ feelings of insecurity. Crime Science134: 204.
19.
EllerC (2009) Teenage witches: Magical youth and the search for the self. Sociology of Religion70(4): 458–459.
20.
ExlineJJVan TongerenDRBradleyDFWiltJAStaunerNPargamentKIDeWallCN (2020) Pulling away from religion: Religious/spiritual struggles and religious disengagement among college students. Psychology of Religion and Spirituality14(3): 300–311.
21.
EzzyDBanhamRBeamanL (2023) Religious diversity, legislation, and Christian privilege. Journal of Sociology59(1): 70–86.
22.
FebrianH (2024) Visualizing authority: Rise of the religious influencers on the Instagram. Social Media + Society10(4): 1–19.
23.
FeraroS (2021) The rise of the fourfold goddess construct among Western goddess women and feminist witches. Pomegranate22(1): 1–15.
24.
FlemingWH (2023) The moral injury experience wheel: An instrument for identifying moral emotions and conceptualizing the mechanisms of moral injury. Journal of Religion and Health62: 194–227.
25.
FoxJEisensteinMBreslawskiJ (2022) State support for religion and social trust. Political Studies72(1): 322–342.
26.
FramptonAGrandisonA (2023) ‘In the broom closet’: Exploring the role of online communities in shaping the identities of contemporary witchcraft practitioners. Current Psychology42: 23800–23820.
27.
GoelPArsiwalaR (2024) A comparative study of religious scriptures using natural language processing. Journal of Student Research13(2): 1–9.
28.
González-BaqueroWAmoresJJArcila-CalderónC (2023) The conversation around Islam on Twitter: Topic modeling and sentiment analysis of tweets about the Muslim community in Spain since 2015. Religions14(6): 724.
29.
GrigoropoulouN (2020) Discussing god: The effect of (ir)religious identities on topic–sentiment polarization in online debates. Review of Religious Research62: 533–561.
30.
HaumerFKoloCRothASchwarzR (2023) Influencers and their motivations to create content: A qualitative typology based on an international survey. Journal of Digital & Social Media Marketing11(2): 190–204.
31.
HooseFRosenbohmS (2023) Self-representation as platform work: Stories about working as social media content creators. Convergence30(1): 625–641.
32.
HuttoCGilbertE (2014) VADER: A parsimonious rule-based model for sentiment analysis of social media text. In: Proceedings of the international AAAI conference on web and social media, Ann Arbor, MI, 1–4 June, pp.216–225. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan.
33.
HuttonR (2017) The Witch: A History of Fear, from Ancient Times to the Present. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
34.
ItzhakiYYablonYBItzhakyH (2020) Becoming less religious (BLR) and well–being among high school dropouts. Psychology of Religion and Spirituality12(1): 45–54.
35.
KastolaniK (2023) Understanding he delivery of Islamophobic hate speech via social media in Indonesia. Indonesian Journal of Islam and Muslim Societies10(2): 247–270.
36.
KimaniS (2024) The influence of religious beliefs on social behavior and community cohesion. International Journal of Humanity and Social Sciences3(3): 60–73.
LewerissaYA (2018) Criminal policy of hate speech in social media against the religious dignity of society in the digital century. In: GasperszSGCNanuruRF (eds) Advances in Social Science Education and Humanities Research. Paris: Atlantis Press, pp.71–77.
39.
LiYChanJPekoGSundaramD (2023) Mixed emotion extraction analysis and visualisation of social media text. Data & Knowledge Engineering148: 102220.
40.
LimaBCOmarNAvansiIde CastroLN (2025) Artificial intelligence applied to the analysis of biblical scriptures: A systematic review. Analytics4(2): 13.
41.
ListiyonoHBudiarsoZSusilowatiSWindartoAP (2024) Comprehensive sentiment analysis of religious content naive Bayes algorithm model. Jurnal Media Informatika Budidarma8(1): 602–611.
42.
LiuB (2012) Sentiment Analysis and Opinion Mining. Cham: Springer.
43.
McQueeneyK (2009) ‘We are god’s children, Y’all’: Race, gender, and sexuality in Lesbian– and Gay–affirming congregations. Social Problems56(1): 151–173.
44.
Malita-KrólJ (2024) The religious biographies of Polish traditional Wiccans: Leaving the Catholic church, conversion to Wicca, and the ‘coming home’ metaphor. Pomegranate24(2): 133–159.
45.
MareiFG (2024) God’s influencers: How social media users shape religion and pious self-fashioning. Journal of Religion, Media and Digital Culture13(2): 143–172.
46.
MedojevicM (2025) Witchcraft in modern society: An ongoing tradition or a folkloric relic? An investigation into the persistence of witchcraft, from folklore stories to 21st century practices. Különleges Bánásmód Interdiszciplináris Folyóirat11(3): 191–202.
47.
MohammadSM (2016) Sentiment analysis: Detecting valence, emotions, and other affectual states from text. In: MeiselmanHL (ed) Emotion Measurement. Duxford; Kidlington; Cambridge, MA: Woodhead Publishing, pp.201–237.
48.
NeumaierA (2019) Christian online communities: Insights from qualitative and quantitative data. Online–Heidelberg Journal of Religions on the Internet14: 20–40.
49.
NovakCHaselbacherMMattesALimacherK (2022) Religious ‘bubbles’ in a superdiverse digital landscape? Research with religious youth on Instagram. Religions13(3): 213.
50.
ObadiaL (2023) ‘Spiritual’ witchcraft and magic 2.0 as weapons of resistance: The emergence of a new movement?Social Compass70(4): 549–565.
51.
PargamentKIRaiyaHA (2007) A decade of research on the psychology of religion and coping: Things we assumed and lessons we learned. Psyke & Logos28(2): 742–766.
52.
PlutchikR (1982) A psychoevolutionary theory of emotions. Social Science Information21(4–5): 529–553.
53.
PohjonenMUdupaS (2017) Extreme speech online: An anthropological critique of hate speech debates. International Journal of Communication11: 1173–1191.
54.
PreeceJMaloney-KrichmarD (2005) Online communities: Design, theory, and practice. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication10(4): 00–00.
55.
RähmeB (2018) Digital religion, the supermarket and the commons. Sociétés139(1): 73–86.
56.
RenserBTiidenbergK (2020) Witches on Facebook: Mediatization of neo-paganism. Social Media + Society6(3): 1–11.
57.
RichterL (2021) Laughing about religious authority – But not too loud. Religions12(2): 73.
58.
RupcicT (2023) Techno-religion and cyberspace spirituality in dystopian video games. Religions14: 247.
59.
SahaSShowrovMIHRahmanMMMajumderMZH (2023) VADER vs. BERT: A comparative performance analysis for sentiment on Coronavirus outbreak. In: SatuMSMoniMAKaiserMSArefinMS (eds) Machine Intelligence and Emerging Technologies. MIET 2022. Lecture Notes of the Institute for Computer Sciences, Social Informatics and Telecommunications Engineering, vol. 490. Cham: Springer, pp.371–385.
SandeNMaforoB (2022) Hate speech as a politico-religious tool in contemporary Zimbabwe. Journal of Religion in Africa51(3–4): 348–363.
62.
SinkCA (2004) Spirituality and comprehensive school counseling programs. Professional School Counseling7(5): 309–317.
63.
SiudaP (2021) Mapping digital religion: Exploring the need for new typologies. Religions12: 373.
64.
St LawrenceE (2024) The algorithm holy: TikTok, technomancy, and the rise of algorithmic divination. Religions15: 435.
65.
StanleyC (2025) Hate speech in the digital age: Balancing constitutional freedoms with just regulation. Maine Policy Review34(1): 108–110.
66.
Stecko-ŻukowskaA (2022) We revolutionized it a bit and changed the image of a fairy: Contemporary witches and magical practices in social media. Stan Rzeczy1(22): 415–443.
67.
TaylorJArmesG (2024) Social comparison on Instagram, and its relationship with self-esteem and body-esteem. Discover Psychology4: 126.
68.
TsuriaR (2024) Hidden religious identities online: Digital religion and LGBTQIA+ individuals. In: CampbellHACheongPHR (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Digital Religion. New York: Oxford University Press, pp.254–271.
69.
TursunalievaAAlexanderDLJDunneRLiJRieraLZhaoY (2024) Making sense of machine learning: A review of interpretation techniques and their applications. Applied Sciences14(2): 496.
70.
van der VeenAMBleichE (2025) The advantages of lexicon-based sentiment analysis in an age of machine learning. PLoS ONE20(1): e0313092.
71.
VitulloA (2021) The online intersection among Islamophobia, populism, and hate speech: An Italian perspective. Journal of Religion, Media and Digital Culture10(1): 95–114.
72.
WilkinsonDJJohnsonA (2020) A systematic review of qualitative studies capturing the subjective experiences of Gay and Lesbian individuals’ of faith or religious affiliation. Mental Health, Religion & Culture23(1): 80–95.
73.
ZhangL (2025) The digital age of religious communication: The shaping and challenges of religious beliefs through social media. Studies on Religion and Philosophy1(1): 25–41.
74.
ZhuJJMaY XiaGMohamed SalleSHuangHNazmi SannusiS (2024) Self-perception evolution among university student TikTok users: Evidence from China. Frontiers in Psychology14: 1217014.
