Test the role of individual and crime characteristics on public opinions of white-collar crime seriousness and support for crime reduction policy; consider the relationship between perceptions of crime seriousness and support for public policies to reduce white-collar crime.
Methods
Data from a nationally-representative survey. Respondents (n = 2,050) rated ten white-collar crimes, relative to a street crime (burglary) and also indicated their relative support (i.e., willingness to pay) for 16 policies to reduce various types of white-collar crime. Models incorporate respondent-level random effects to account for multiple ratings per respondent.
Results
Crimes committed by organizations are perceived more seriously than those committed by individuals. Perceptions of a white-collar crime as more serious than burglary increase the likelihood of supporting prevention programs. Race and political party are related to both perceptions of crime seriousness and support for prevention policy.
Conclusions
There may be less consensus around perceptions of white-collar crime seriousness than for other crime types. Perceptions of crime seriousness are a function of both individual and crime characteristics that structure assessments of risk, harmfulness, and wrongfulness. Group differences may be related to differences in awareness of the scope, harms, and perceived victimization risk associated with particular crime types.
AdriaenssenAnPaoliLetiziaKarstedtSusanneVisschersJonasGreenfieldVictoria A.PleysierStefaan. 2020. “Public Perceptions of the Seriousness of Crime: Weighing the Harm and the Wrong.” European Journal of Criminology17(2):127‐50. doi:10.1177/1477370818772768
2.
BeckettKatherine. 2018. “The Politics, Promise, and Peril of Criminal Justice Reform in the Context of Mass Incarceration.” Annual Review of Criminology1:235‐59. doi:10.1146/annurev-criminol-032317-092458
3.
BensonMichael L. 1985. “Denying the Guilty Mind: Accounting for Involvement in White-Collar Crime.” Criminology; An Interdisciplinary Journal23:583‐607. doi:10.1111/j.1745-9125.1985.tb00365.x
4.
BensonMichael LSimpsonSally S.. 2018. White-Collar Crime: An Opportunity Perspective. 3rd ed. New York, NY: Routledge Press.
5.
BlackDan A.SolowRobert M.TaylorLowell J.. 2015. “Comments on Dominguez and Raphael.” Criminology & Public Policy14:639-46.
6.
BottomsA.1995 “The Philosophy and Politics of Punishment and Sentencing.” Pp. 17‐49 in The Politics of Sentencing Reform, edited by ClarksonC.MorganR.. New York: Oxford University Press.
7.
BowlesRoger A.FaureMichael G.GaroupaNuno. 2008. “The Scope of Criminal Law and Criminal Sanctions: An Economic View and Policy Implications.” Journal of Law and Society35:389‐416.
8.
BurtonAlexander L.CullenFrancis T.BurtonVelmer S.JrGrahamAmandaButlerLeah C.ThieloAngela J.. 2020. “Belief in Redeemability and Punitive Public Opinion: “Once a Criminal, Always a Criminal” Revisited.” Criminal Justice and Behavior47(6):712‐32.
9.
ButtonMarkLewisChrisTapleyJacki. 2014. “Not a Victimless Crime: The Impact of Fraud on Individual Victims and Their Families.” Security Journal27(1):36‐54.
10.
CarsonRichardLouviereJordan. 2017. “Estimation of Broad-Scale Tradeoffs in Community Policing Policies.” Journal of Benefit-Cost Analysis8(3):1‐14.
11.
ClarkW. W.1922. The Whittier Scale for Grading Juvenile Offenses. California Bureau of Juvenile Research, Whittier State School, Whittier, CA. Bulletin 11 (out of print).
12.
CohenMark A. 2015. “Willingness to Pay to Reduce White-Collar and Corporate Crime.” Journal of Benefit-Cost Analysis6(2):305‐24.
13.
CohenMark. A.RustRoland T.SteenSara. 2003. Executive Summary: Measuring Public Perceptions of Appropriate Prison Sentences. Report to National Institute of Justice. Washington DC: OJJDP.
14.
CopesHeithKerleyKent R.HuffRodneyKaneJohn. 2010. “Differentiating Identity Theft: An Exploratory Study of Victims Using a National Victimization Survey.” Journal of Criminal Justice38(5):1045‐52.
15.
CroallHazel. 2015 “White-Collar Crime in Europe: Afterword.” Pp. 533‐47 in The RoutledgeHandbook of White-Collar and Corporate Crime in Europe, edited by van ErpJudithHuismanWimVande WalleGudrunBeckersJoep. Abingdon, Oxon: Routledge.
16.
CullenFrancis T.ChouhyCeciliaJonsonCheryl Lero. 2019 “Public Opinion About White-Collar Crime.” Pp. 211‐28 in The Handbook of White-Collar Crime, edited by RorieMelissa. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley Blackwell.
17.
CullenFrancis T.CullenJohn B.WozniakJohn F.. 1988. “Is Rehabilitation Dead? The Myth of the Punitive Public.” Journal of Criminal Justice16(4):303‐17.
18.
CullenFrancis T.FisherBonnie S.ApplegateBrandon K.. 2000. “Public Opinion About Punishment and Corrections.” Crime and Justice27:1‐79.
19.
CullenFrancisLinBruceTravisLawrenceWozniakJohn. 1985. “Consensus in Crime Seriousness: Empirical Reality or Methodological Artifact.” Criminology23:99-118.
20.
CullenFrancis T.LinkBruce G.PolanziCraig W.. 1982. “The Seriousness of Crime Revisited.” Criminology; An Interdisciplinary Journal20(1):83‐102.
21.
DiamantisMihailis E. 2016. “Corporate Criminal Minds.” Notre Dame Law Review91(5):2049‐90.
22.
DilulioJohn J. Jr.1995. “The Coming of the Super-Predators.” The Weekly Standard (November 27).
23.
DodgeMary. 2020. “A Black Box Warning: The Marginalization of White-Collar Crime Victimization.” Journal of White Collar and Corporate Crime1(1):24‐33.
24.
DodgeMaryBosickStacey J.Van AntwerpVictoria. 2013. “Do men and Women Perceive White-Collar and Street Crime Differently? Exploring Gender Differences in the Perception of Seriousness, Motives, and Punishment.” Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice29(3):399‐415.
25.
EdelhertzHerbert. 1970. The Nature, Impact, and Prosecution of White-Collar Crime. Washington, DC: National Institute of Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice, USDOJ, LEAA.
26.
EriksonKai. 1966. Wayward Puritans. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
27.
Federal Trade Commission. 2004. “FTC Continues Crackdown on Scams Aimed at Hispanic Consumers.” Washington DC. October 6 press release.
FiglioR. M.1975. “The Seriousness of Offenses: An Evaluation by Offenders and Nonoffenders.” Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology66:189‐200.
30.
ForemanKelseyArteagaCeciliaCollinsAushawna. 2016. “The Role of Media Framing in Crime Reports: How Different Types of News Frames and Racial Identity Affect Viewer’s Perceptions of Race.” Pepperdine Journal of Communication Research4:8‐17.
31.
FrankNancyLombnessMichael. 1988. Controlling Corporate Illegality: The Regulatory Justice System. Cincinnati, OH: Anderson Publishing Co.
32.
FrostNatasha A. 2010. “Beyond Public Opinion Polls: Punitive Public Sentiment & Criminal Justice Policy.” Sociology Compass4(3):156‐68.
33.
GalvinMiranda A. 2020. “Substance or Semantics: The Consequences of Definitional Ambiguity for White-Collar Research.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency57(3):369‐99.
34.
GalvinMiranda A.LoganMatthewSnookDaniel W.. 2021. “Assessing the Validity of White-Collar Crime Definitions Using Experimental Survey Data.” Journal of Experimental Criminology. on-line first.
35.
GalvinMiranda A.LoughranThomas A.SimpsonSally S.CohenMark A.. 2018. “Victim Compensation Policy and White–Collar Crime.” Criminology & Public Policy17:553‐94.
36.
GanziniLindaMcFarlandB.BloomJoseph D. 1990. “Victims of Fraud: Comparing Victims of White Collar and Violent Crime.” The Bulletin of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law18(1):55‐63.
37.
GarfinkelHarold. 1956. “Conditions of Successful Degradation Ceremonies.” American Journal of Sociology61:420‐4.
38.
GhandnooshNazgol. 2014. “Race and Punishment: Racial Perceptions of Crime and Support for Punitive Policies.” The Sentencing Project: Washington D.C.
39.
GoffmanErving. 1963. Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity. New York: Simon and Schuster.
40.
GordonRandall A.BindrimThomas A.McNicholasMichael L.WaldenTeresa L.. 1988. “Perceptions of Blue-Collar and White-Collar Crime: The Effect of Defendant Race on Simulated Juror Decisions.” The Journal of Social Psychology128(2):191‐7.
41.
GorsuchJohn Henderson. 1938. “Scale of Seriousness of Crimes.” Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology29(2):245‐52.
42.
GramlichJohn. 2019. From Police to Patrol, Black and White Americans Differ Widely in the Views of Criminal Justice System. Washington, DC: Pew Research Center, 5-21-2019.
43.
HaganJohn. 2010. Who are the Criminals: The Politics of Crime Policy from the Age of Roosevelt to the Age of Reagan. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
44.
HaganJohnSheddCarlaPayneMonique R.. 2005. “Race, Ethnicity, and Youth Perceptions of Criminal Injustice.” American Sociological Review70(3):381‐407.
45.
HarrisAnthony R. 1977. “Sex and Theories of Deviance: Toward a Functional Theory of Deviant Typescripts.” American Sociological Review42(1):3‐16.
46.
HealyDeirdreMcGrathJoe. 2019. “Simple Rhetoric and Complex Punitiveness: Federal Criminal Justice Responses to White-Collar Criminality.” Justice Quarterly36(7):1258‐83.
47.
HeiderFritz. 1958. The Psychology of Interpersonal Relations. New York, NY: Wiley.
48.
HerzogSergio. 2003/2004. “The Relationship Between Public Perceptions of Crime Seriousness and Support for Plea-Bargaining Practices in Israel: A Factorial-Survey Approach.” The Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology94:103‐32.
49.
HollingerRichard C. 1991. “Neutralizing in the Workplace: An Empirical Analysis of Property Theft and Production Deviance.” Deviant Behavior12(2):169‐202.
50.
HoltfreterKristyVan SlykeShannaBrattonJasonGertzMarc. 2008. “Public Perceptions of White-Collar Crime and Punishment.” Journal of Criminal Justice36:50‐60.
51.
HorowitzJuliana MenasceBrownAnnaCoxKiana. 2019. How Americans See the State of Race Relations. Washington, DC: Pew Research Center, 4-9.
52.
HuffRodneyDesiletsChristianKaneJohn. 2010. The 2010 National Public Survey On White-Collar Crime. Washington, DC: National White-collar Crime Center.
53.
HurwitzJonPeffleyMark. 1997. “Public Perceptions of Race and Crime: The Role of Racial Stereotypes.” American Journal of Political Science41:375‐401.
54.
JacobyJoseph E.CullenFrancis T.. 1998. “The Structure of Punishment Norms: Applying TheRossi-Berk Model.” Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology89(1):245‐312.
55.
JassoGuillermina. 1998. “Exploring the Justice of Punishments: Framing, Expressiveness, and the Just Prison Sentence.” Social Justice Research11(4):397‐422.
56.
KahnemanD.RitovI.. 1994. “Determinants of Stated Willingness to pay for Public Goods: A Study in the Headline Method.” J Risk Uncertainty9:5‐37.
57.
KarrasElizabethStokesCara M.WarfieldSara C.BarthShannon K.BossarteRobert M.. 2019. “A Randomized Controlled Trial of Public Messaging to Promote Safe Firearm Storage among U.S. Military Veterans.” Social Science Medicine241:Article 112205.
58.
KatzJack. 1980 “Social Movement Against White-Collar Crime.” Pp. 161‐84 in Criminology Review Yearbook, Volume 2, edited by BittnerEgonMessingerSheldon L.. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
59.
KempaMichael. 2010. “Combating White-Collar Crime in Canada: Serving Victim Needs and Market Integrity.” Journal of Financial Crime17(2):251‐64.
60.
KleckGary. 2018. “Response Errors in Surveys of Defensive Gun Use: A National Internet Survey Experiment.” Crime & Delinquency64:1119‐42.
61.
KwanYingKeungChiuLaiLinIpWai-CheungKwanPatrick. 2002. “Perceived Crime Seriousness: Consensus and Disparity.” Journal of Criminal Justice, Elsevier30(6):623-32.
62.
LayanaM. CristinaLeeJacqueline G.. 2020. “Respondent Fatigue in Estimates of the Cost of White-Collar Crime: Implications from Willingness-to-Pay Surveys.” Criminal Justice Policy Review31:1366‐89.
63.
LeviM.JonesS.. 1985. “Public and Police Perceptions for Crime Seriousness in England and Wales.” British Journal of Criminology35(3):234‐50.
64.
LiuWeiweiMumfordElizabeth A.TaylorBruce G.. 2017. “The Relationship Between Parents’ Intimate Partner Victimization and Youths’ Adolescent Relationship Abuse.” J Youth Adolescence2:321‐33.
65.
MaguireEdwardJohnsonDevon. 2015. “The Structure of Public Opinion on Crime Policy: Evidence from Seven Caribbean Nations.” Punishment & Society17(4):502‐30.
66.
MannKenneth. 1992. “Punitive Civil Sanctions: The Middleground Between Criminal and Civil Law.” The Yale Law Journal181:1795‐873.
67.
MarunaShaddKingAnna. 2009. “Once a Criminal, Always a Criminal?: ‘Redeemability’and the Psychology of Punitive Public Attitudes.” European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research15(1-2):7‐24.
68.
MauerMarc. 2018. “Long-Term Sentences: Time to Reconsider the Scale of Punishment.” UMKC Law Review87:113-31.
69.
McGuireEJohnsonDevon. 2015. “The Structure of Public Opinion on Crime Policy: Evidence from Seven Caribbean Nations.” Punishment & Society17:502-30.
70.
MichelCedric. 2016. “Violent Street Crime Versus Harmful White-Collar Crime: A Comparison of Perceived Seriousness and Punitiveness.” Critical Criminology24:127-43.
71.
MichelCedric. 2017. “Was it Justified? Applying Attribution Theory to Corporate Violence.” Journal of Crime and Justice40:155‐72.
72.
MichelCedricCochranJohn K.HeideKathleen M.. 2016. “Public Knowledge About White-Collar Crime: An Exploratory Study.” Public Knowledge About White-Collar Crime: An Exploratory Study.” Crime, Law, and Social Change65:67‐91.
73.
MichelC.HeideK.CochranJ. K.. 2014. “The Consequences of Knowledge About Elite Deviance.” American Journal of Criminal Justice39(4):1‐24.
74.
MietheTerance. 1982. “Public Consensus on Crime Seriousness: Normative Structure or Methological Artifact?.” Criminology20:515-26.
75.
MillerJ. L.RossiPeter H.SimpsonJon E.. 1986. “Perceptions of Justice: Race and Gender Differences in Judgments of Appropriate Prison Sentences.” Law and Society Review20(3):313‐34.
76.
MillerJoann L.RossiPeter H.SimpsonJon E.. 1991. “Felony Punishments: A Factorial Survey of Perceived Justice in Criminal Sentencing.” Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology82:396‐422.
77.
NaginDaniel S.PiqueroAlex R.ScottElizabeth S.SteinbergLawrence. 2006. “Public Preferences for Rehabilitation Versus Incarceration of Juvenile Offenders: Evidence from a Contingent Valuation Survey.” Criminology and Public Policy5(4):627‐51.
78.
NeedlemanB.1975. “Offense Intensity and Offense Wrongfulness Hierarchies.” Paper presented at the 70th annual meeting of the American Sociological Association, August 25–29.
79.
O’ConnellM.WhelanAnthony. 1996. “TAKING WRONGS SERIOUSLY Public Perceptions of Crime Seriousness.” British Journal of Criminology36:299‐319.
80.
PeffleyMarkHurwitzJon. 2010. Justice in America: The Separate Realities of Blacks and Whites. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
81.
PicassoEmiloCohenMark A.. 2018. Valuing the Public's Demand for Crime Prevention Programs: A Discrete Choice Experiment. SSRN # 2015649.
82.
PiqueroNicole L.CarmichaelStephaniePiqueroAlex R.. 2008. “Research Note: Assessing the Perceived Seriousness of White-Collar and Street Crimes.” Crime & Delinquency54:291‐312.
83.
PiqueroNicole LeeperCohenMark A.PiqueroAlex R.. 2011. “How Much is the Public Willing to Pay to be Protected from Identity Theft?.” Justice Quarterly28(3):437-59.
84.
Rabe-HeskethSophiaSkrondalAnders. 2012. Multilevel and Longitudinal Modeling in Stata. 3rd ed. College Station, TX: Stata Press.
85.
ReissAlbert J.Jr.1984 “Selecting Strategies of Social Control Over Organizational Life.” in Enforcing Regulation, edited by HawkinsK.ThomasJ. M.. Boston: Kluwer-Nijhoff.
86.
RobinsonPaul H.DarleyJohn M.. 2007. “Intuitions of Justice: Implications for Criminal Law and Justice Policy.” Southern California Law Review81:1‐68.
87.
RorieM.AlpertM.Schell-BuseyN.SimpsonS. S.. 2017. “Using Meta-Analysis Under Conditions of Definitional Ambiguity: The Case of Corporate Crime.” Criminal Justice Studies31(1):38‐61.
88.
RosenmerkelSean P. 2001. “Wrongfulness and Harmfulness as Seriousness of White Collar Offenses.” Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice17(4):308‐27.
89.
RossiPeter H.BerkRichard A.. 1985. “Varieties of Normative Consensus.” American Sociological Review50(3):333‐47.
90.
RossiPeter HenryBerkRichard Alan. 1997. Just Punishments: Federal Guidelines and Public Views Compared. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
91.
RossiPeter H.WaiteEmilyBoseChristine E.BerkRichard E.. 1974. “The Seriousness of Crimes: Normative Structure and Individual Differences.” American Sociological Review39(2):224‐37.
92.
SchoepferAndreaCarmichaelStephaniePiqueroNicole Leeper. 2007. “Do Perceptions of Punishment Vary Between White-Collar and Street Crimes?.” Journal of Criminal Justice35:151-63.
93.
SchragerLaura ShillShortJames F.Jr.1978. “Toward a Sociology of Organizational Crime.” Social Problems25(4):407‐19.
94.
SellinThorstonWolfgangMarvin E.. 1964. The Measurement of Delinquency. New York, NY: John Wiley & Sons.
95.
ShadelDougPakKarlaSauerJenifer. 2014. “Caught in the Scammer’s Net: Risk Factors that May Lead to Becoming an Internet Fraud Victim.” AARP Survey of Florida Adults Age 18 and Older. AARP: Washington DC. www.aarp.org/research. https://doi.org/10.264119/res.00076.004.
96.
SheddCarlaHaganJohn. 2006. “Toward a Developmental Conflict Theory of Race, Ethnicity, and Perceptions of Criminal Injustice. Chapter 17.” Pp. 313-33 in The Many Colors of Crime edited by PetersonRuth D.KrivoLauren J.HaganHagan. New York, NY: NYU Press.
97.
ShelleyTara O’ConnorChiricosTed G.GertzMarc. 2011. “What About the Environment? Assessing the Perceived Seriousness of Environmental Crime.” International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice25:307‐25.
98.
SimpsonSally S. 2019. “Reimaging Sutherland 80 Years After White-Collar Crime.” Criminology; An Interdisciplinary Journal57(2):189‐207.
99.
StylianouStelios. 2002. “Measuring Crime Seriousness Perceptions: What Have we Learned and What Else do we Want to Know?” Journal of Criminal Justice31:37‐56.
100.
SutherlandEdwin H. 1949. White Collar Crime. New York: The Dryden Press.
101.
SweetenGary. 2012. “Scaling Criminal Offending.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology28:533‐57.
102.
TaylorBruce G.MumfordElizabeth A.LiuWeiwei. 2016. The National Survey of Teen Relationships and Intimate Violence (STRiV). Report Submitted to the National Institute of Justice, US Department of Justice. Washington, DC.
103.
TonryMichael. 2004. Thinking About Crime. Sense and Sensibility in American Penal Culture. New York: Oxford University Press.
104.
TonryMichael. 2018. “Punishment and Human Dignity: Sentencing Principles for Twenty-First-Century America.” Crime and Justice47(1):119‐57.
105.
TynesBrendesha M.WillisHenry A.StewartAshley M.HamiltonMatthew W.. 2019. “Race-Related Traumatic Events Online and Mental Health Among Adolescents of Color.” Journal of Adolescent Health65:371‐7.
106.
UnneverJames D.BensonMichael L.CullenFrancis T.. 2008. “Public Support for Getting Tough on Corporate Crime: Racial and Political Divides.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency45(2):163‐90.
107.
von HirschAndrew. 1992. “Proportionality in the Philosophy of Punishment.” Crime and Justice16:55‐98.
108.
WalshJ. P.1995. “Managerial and Organizational Cognition: Notes from a Trip Down Memory Lane.” Organization Science6(3):280‐321.
109.
WarrMark. 1989. “What is the Perceived Seriousness of Crimes?” Criminology; An Interdisciplinary Journal27:795‐822.
110.
WeickK. E.2010. “Reflections on Enacted Sensemaking in the Bhopal Disaster.” Journal of Management Studies47(3):537‐50.
111.
WheelerStantonRothmanMichael Lewis. 1982. “The Organization as Weapon in White-Collar Crime.” Mich Law Rev80:1403-26.
112.
WolfgangMarvin E. 1985. The National Survey of Crime Severity. Washington, DC: US DOJ, Bureau of Justice Statistics.
113.
WolfgangMarvin E.FiglioRobert M.TracyPaul E.SingerSimon I.. 1985. The National Survey Of Crime Severity. Washington, DC: US Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics.
114.
WolfsonJulia A.AzraelDeborahMillerMatthew. 2018. “Gun Ownership among US Women.” Injury Prevention26:49‐54.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
