Contingent valuation (CV) methods are used in many contexts to estimate non-tangible costs, despite some indications that they may not be reliable. In criminal justice, CV has been used to generate “costs of crime” for street, violent, and white-collar crimes. This article explores respondent fatigue using both quantitative and qualitative indicators from an open-ended CV survey where respondents were asked how much they would be willing to pay to reduce certain crimes. Our findings reveal that willingness to pay (WTP) to reduce crime increases when both problematic response patterns and fatigue effects are accounted for in the calculation, indicating that fatigued respondents who also engage in straight lining are driving the WTP estimates down. We conclude by discussing the implications of our results for policymakers and other consumers of CV studies.
American Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (5th ed.). Arlington, VA: American Psychiatric Publishing.
2.
ArielyD. (2008). Predictably irrational: The hidden forces that shape our decisions. HarperCollins.
3.
AsiuB. W.AntonsC. M.FultzM. L. (1998). Undergraduate perceptions of survey participation: Improving response rates and validity [Paper presentation]. Annual meeting of the association of institutional research, Minneapolis, MN, United Status.
4.
BackorK.GoldeS.NieN. (2007). Estimating survey fatigue in time use study [Paper presentation]. 2007 International Association for Time Use Research Conference, Washington, DC, United Status.
5.
BargeS.GehlbachH. (2012). Using the theory of satisficing to evaluate the quality of survey data. Research in Higher Education, 53, 182–200.
6.
BastianL. D.TaylorB. M. (1994). Young black male victims (NCJ 147004). Government Printing Office, U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics.
7.
BatemanI.CarsonR.DayB.HanemannM.HanleyN.HettT.Jones-LeeM.LoomesG.MouratoS.OzdemirogluE.PearceD.SugdenR.SwansonJ. (2002). Economic valuation with stated preference techniques: A manual. Edward Elgar.
8.
BaumK. (2006). Identity theft, 2004. Bureau of Justice Statistics.
9.
BradburnN. (1979). Respondent burden. In ReederL. (Ed.), Health survey research methods: Second Biennial Conference. U.S. Government Printing Office.
10.
CarsonR. T.FloresN.MeadeN. (2001). Contingent valuation: Controversies and evidence. Environmental and Resource Economics, 19, 173–210.
11.
CarsonR. T.HanemannW. M. (2005). Handbook of environmental economics (MälerK.-G.VincentJ. R., Eds., Vol. 2). Elsevier.
12.
ChalfinA. (2015). Economic costs of crime. In JenningsW. (Ed.), The encyclopedia of crime and punishment (pp. 1–12). Wiley-Blackwell.
13.
CohenM. A. (2000). Measuring the costs and benefits of crime and justice (NCJ 182411). In Measurement and analysis of crime and justice, criminal justice (Vol. 4). National Institute of Justice. https://www.ncjrs.gov/criminal_justice2000/vol_4/04f.pdf
14.
CohenM. A. (2010). Valuing crime control benefits using stated preference approaches. In RomanJ. K.DunworthT.MarshK. (Eds.), Cost-benefit analysis and crime control (Chapter 4, pp. 73–118). Urban Institute Press.
CohenM. A. (2016). The costs of white-collar crime. In Van SlykeS. R.BensonM. L.CullenF. T. (Eds.), The Oxford handbook of white-collar crime (Chapter 5, pp. 78–98). Oxford University Press.
17.
CohenM. A.PiqueroA. (2009). New evidence on the monetary value of saving a high risk youth. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 25(1), 25–49.
18.
CohenM. A.RustR.SteenS.TiddS. (2004). Willingness-to-pay for crime control programs. Criminology, 42(1), 86–106.
19.
DiamondP. A.HausmanJ. A. (1994). Contingent valuation: Is some number better than no number?The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 8, 45–64.
20.
DomínguezP.RaphaelS. (2015). The role of the cost-of-crime literature in bridging the gap between social science research and policy making. Criminology & Public Policy, 14, 589–632.
21.
DurkheimÉ. (1895) 1964. The rules of sociological method. The Free Press. (Originally published as Les règles de la méthode sociologique, Paris: Alcan, 1895).
22.
FazioR. H. (1989). On the power and functionality of attitudes. In PratkanisA. R.BrecklerS. J.GreenwaldA. G. (Eds.), Attitude structure and function (pp. 153–179). Lawrence Erlbaum.
FontaW. M.IchokuH. E.Kabubo-MariaraJ. (2010). The effect of protest zeros on estimates of willingness to pay in healthcare contingent valuation analysis. Applied Health Economics and Health Policy, 8(4), 225–237.
25.
GalvinM. A.LoughranT.SimpsonS.CohenM. A. (2018). Victim compensation policy and white-collar crime: Public preferences in a national willingness-to-pay survey. Criminology & Public Policy, 17, 553–594.
26.
HindelangM. J. (1978). Race and involvement in crimes. American Sociological Review, 43, 93–109.
27.
HuffR.DesiletsC.KaneJ. (2010). The 2010 national public survey on white collar crime. National White Collar Crime Center.
28.
KerrG. N.SharpB. M. H.WhiteP. (2003). The economics of augmenting Christchurch’s water supply. Journal of Hydrology, 42, 113–124.
29.
KnäuperB. (1999a). Age differences in question and response order effects. In SchwarzN.ParkD.KnäuperB.SudmanS. (Eds.), Cognition, aging, and self-reports (pp. 341–363). Psychology Press.
30.
KnäuperB. (1999b). The impact of age and education on response order effects in attitude measurement. Public Opinion Quarterly, 63, 347–370.
31.
KrosnickJ. A. (1991). Response strategies for coping with the cognitive demands of attitude measures in surveys. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 5, 213–236.
32.
KrosnickJ. A. (1999). Survey research. Annual Review of Sociology, 50, 537–567.
33.
KrosnickJ. A.AlwinD. (1987). An evaluation of a cognitive theory of response-order effects in survey measurement. Public Opinion Quarterly, 51, 201–219.
34.
KrosnickJ. A.HolbrookA. L.BerentM. K.CarsonR. T.HanemannW. M.KoppR. J.MitchellR. C.PresserS.RuudP. A.SmithV. K.MoodyW. R.GreenM. C.ConawayM. (2002). The impact of “no opinion” response options on data quality: Non-attitude reduction or invitation to satisfice?Public Opinion Quarterly, 66, 371–403.
35.
KruglanskiA. W. (1980). Lay epistemologic process and contents: Another look at attribution theory. Psychological Reviews, 87, 70–87.
36.
LevyD. S.HammittJ. K.DuanN.Downes-LeGuinT.FriedmanD. (1995). Conceptual and statistical issues in contingent valuation: Estimating the value of altered visibility in the Grand Canyon. RAND.
37.
LudwigJ.CookP. (2001). The benefits of reducing gun violence: Evidence from contingent-valuation survey data. The Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 22(3), 207–226.
38.
MillerJ. L.RossiP. H.SimpsonJ. E. (1986). Perceptions of justice: Race and gender differences in judgments of appropriate prison sentences. Law & Society Review, 20(3), 313–334.
39.
MitchellR. C.CarsonR. T. (1989). Using surveys to value public goods: The contingent valuation method (Resources for the future). Resources for the Future Press.
40.
MurataT.GwartneyP. (1999). Question salience, question difficulty and item nonresponse in survey research [Paper presentation]. International Conference on Survey Non-response, Portland, OR, United States.
41.
NaginD. S. (2015). Cost-benefit analysis of crime prevention policies. Criminology & Public Policy, 14, 583–587.
42.
NarayanS.KrosnickJ. (1996). Education moderates some response effects in attitude measurement. Public Opinion Quarterly, 60, 6058–6088.
43.
PasekJ.KrosnickJ. (2010). Optimizing survey questionnaire design in political science: Insights from psychology. In LeighleyJ. (Ed.),Oxford handbook of American elections and political behavior (pp. 27–50). Oxford University Press.
PiqueroN. L.CohenM. A.PiqueroA. R. (2010). How much is the public willing to pay to be protected from identity theft?Justice Quarterly, 28(3), 437–458.
46.
PoutaE. (2005). Sensitivity to scope of environmental regulation in contingent valuation of forest cutting practices in Finland. Forest Policy and Economics, 7, 539–550.
47.
ReadyR. C.BuzbyJ. C.HuD. (1996). Differences between continuous and discrete contingent value estimates. Land Economics, 72, 397–411.
48.
RennisonC. M. (2001). Violent victimization and race, 1993-98 (NCJ 176354). Government Printing Office, U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics.
49.
RennisonC. M. (2002). Hispanic victims of violent crime, 1993-2000 (NCJ 191208). Government Printing Office, U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics.
50.
RobertsA. L.GilmanS. E.BreslauJ.BreslauN.KoenenK. C. (2011). Race/ethnic differences in exposure to traumatic events, development of post-traumatic stress disorder, and treatment-seeking for post-traumatic stress disorder in the United States. Psychological Medicine: A Journal of Research in Psychiatry and the Allied Sciences, 23, 4171–4183.
51.
RobertsL. D.IndermaurD.SpiranovicC. (2013). Fear of cyber-identity theft and related fraudulent activity. Psychiatry, Psychology and Law, 20(3), 315–328.
52.
SchwarzN.StrackF. (1985). Cognitive and affective processes in judgments of subjective well-being: A preliminary model. In BrandstatterH.KirchlerE. (Eds.), Economic psychology (pp. 439–447). Tauner.
53.
SharpL. M.FrankelJ. (1983). Respondent burden: A test of some common assumptions. Public Opinion Quarterly, 47, 36–53.
54.
SimonH. A. (1955). A behavioral model of rational choice. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 69(1), 99–118.
55.
SimonH. A. (1957). Models of man, social and rational: Mathematical essays on rational human behavior in a social setting. John Wiley.
56.
SimonH. A.StredyA. C. (1969). Psychology and economics. In LindzeyG.AaronsonE. (Eds.), The handbook of social psychology (pp. 269–314). Addison Wesley.
ThalerR. H. (2015). Misbehaving: The making of behavioral economics. W.W. Norton.
59.
TourangeauR.McNeeleyM. (2003). Measuring crime and crime victimization: Methodological issues. In National Research Council (Ed.), Measurement problems in criminal justice research (pp. 10–42). National Academies Press.
60.
TourangeauR.RasinskiK. A. (1988). Cognitive processes underlying context effects in attitude measurement. Psychological Bulletin, 3, 299–314.
TurnbullG. J. (1998). A review of post-traumatic stress disorder; part I: Historical development and classification. Injury, 29, 87–91.
63.
UnneverJ. D.BensonM. L.CullenF. T. (2008). Public support for getting tough on corporate crime: Racial and political divides. Journal of Research in Crime & Delinquency, 45(2), 163–190. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022427807313707
WarwickD. P.LiningerC. A. (1975). The sample survey: Theory and practice. McGraw-Hill.
66.
WeisbergH. F. (2005). The total survey error approach: A guide to the new science of survey research. University of Chicago Press.
67.
YuX.AblerD. (2014). Incorporating zero and missing responses into CVM with open-ended bidding: Willingness to pay for blue skies in Beijing. Environment and Development Economics, 15, 535–556.
68.
ZarkinG. A.BalaM.V.CatesS.C. (2000) Estimating the willingness to pay for drug abuse treatment. J Subst Abuse Treat, 18, 149–160.
69.
ZhaoJ. S.LawtonB.LongmireD. (2015). An examination of the micro-level crime–fear of crime link. Crime & Delinquency, 61(1), 19–44.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
