Treatment by law enforcement officers, as representatives of the state that interact with individual citizens, may signal to individuals their political and social inclusion within society. Hispanics, as the largest minority group in the country that oftentimes must navigate two cultural identities, may be especially sensitive to the treatment of police. We test the group engagement model’s implication that procedural justice—or lack thereof—may promote or hinder attachment to the United States and/or Mexico among Latino/a adolescents and young adults.
Methods:
Using a fixed effects panel design with a subsample of Mexican Americans from the Pathways to Desistance Study, we examine whether changes in subjective procedural justice evaluations of the police are related to changes in National identification.
Results:
Changes in procedural justice perceptions are significantly related to changes in Mexican identification, whereas procedural justice is not related to changes in Anglo identification. Although, consistent with segmented assimilation theory, the relationships between changes in procedural justice and Mexican/Anglo identification may be stronger among participants born in the United States.
Conclusions:
The findings are generally consistent with the group engagement model of procedural justice and suggest procedural injustice may alienate Hispanics.
Abraído-LanzaA. F.ArmbristerA. N.FlórezK. R.AguirreA. N.. 2006. “Toward a Theory-driven Model of Acculturation in Public Health Research.” American Journal of Public Health96(8):1342–46.
2.
AbregoL. J.2011. “Legal Consciousness of Undocumented Latinos: Fear and Stigma as Barriers to Claims-making for First-and 1.5-generation Immigrants.” Law & Society Review45(2):337–70.
3.
AbregoL. J.2019. “Relational Legal Consciousness of US Citizenship: Privilege, Responsibility, Guilt, and Love in Latino Mixed-Status Families.” Law & Society Review53(3):641–70.
4.
AdlerP.AdlerP. A.. 1989. “The Aggrandizement and the Constriction of Self.” Social Psychology Quarterly52(4):299–310.
5.
AguinisH.1995. “Statistical Power with Moderated Multiple Regression in Management Research.” Journal of Management21(6):1141–58.
6.
AlbaR.KasinitzP.WatersM. C.. 2011. “The Kids Are (mostly) Alright: Second-Generation Assimilation: Comments on Haller, Portes and Lynch.” Social Forces89(3):763–73.
7.
AllisonP. D.1999. Multiple Regression: A Primer. Thousand Oaks, CA: Pine Forge Press.
ArandaE.VaqueraE.. 2015. “Racism, the Immigration Enforcement Regime, and the Implications for Racial Inequality in the Lives of Undocumented Young Adults.” Sociology of Race and Ethnicity1(1):88–104.
10.
ArandaE.MenjívarC.DonatoK. M.. 2014. “The Spillover Consequences of an Enforcement-first US Immigration Regime.” American Behavioral Scientist58(13):1687–95.
11.
ArmentaA.2017. “Racializing Crimmigration: Structural Racism, Colorblindness, and the Institutional Production of Immigrant Criminality.” Sociology of Race and Ethnicity3(1):82–95.
12.
ArmentaA.AlvarezI.. 2017. “Policing Immigrants or Policing Immigration? Understanding Local Law Enforcement Participation in Immigration Control.” Sociology Compass11(2):e12453.
13.
AugustynM. B.2018. “JRCD Commentary.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency55:463–65.
14.
BarrickK.2014. “Latino Confidence in the Police: The Role of Immigration Enforcement, Assimilation, and Immigration Status.” Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice12(4):289–307.
15.
BeckerH. S.1963. Outsiders: Studies in the Sociology of Deviance. New York: Free Press.
BirmanD.TrickettE. J.. 2001. “Cultural Transitions in First-generation Immigrants: Acculturation of Soviet Jewish Refugee Adolescents and Parents.” Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology32(4):456–77.
18.
BjerkD.2009. “How Much Can We Trust Causal Interpretations of Fixed-effects Estimators in the Context of Criminality?” Journal of Quantitative Criminology25(4):391–417.
19.
BradfordB.2014. “Policing and Social Identity: Procedural Justice, Inclusion and Cooperation between Police and Public.” Policing and Society24(1):22–43.
20.
BradfordB.HohlK.JacksonJ.MacQueenS.. 2015. “Obeying the Rules of the Road: Procedural Justice, Social Identity, and Normative Compliance.” Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice31(2):171–91.
21.
BradfordB.MurphyK.JacksonJ.. 2014. “Officers as Mirrors: Policing, Procedural Justice and the (re) Production of Social Identity.” British Journal of Criminology54(4):527–50.
22.
BrunsonR. K.2007. “Police Don’t Like Black People”: African-American Young Men’s Accumulated Police Experiences.” Criminology & Public Policy6(1):71–101.
23.
ChaconJ. M.2007. “Unsecured Borders: Immigration Restrictions, Crime Control and National Security.” Immigration & Nationality Law Review28:613.
24.
ChamblissW. J.1973. “The Saints and the Roughnecks.” Society11(1):24–31.
25.
ColemanM.KocherA.. 2011. “Detention, Deportation, Devolution and Immigrant Incapacitation in the US, Post 9/11.” The Geographical Journal177(3):228–37.
26.
CooleyC. H.1902. Looking-glass Self. The Production of Reality: Essays and Readings on Social Interaction, 6th ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
27.
CuellarI.ArnoldB.MaldonadoR.. 1995. “Acculturation Rating Scale for Mexican Americans-II: A Revision of the Original ARSMA Scale.” Latino/a Journal of Behavioral Sciences17(3):275–304.
28.
DenverM.PickettJ. T.BushwayS. D.. 2017. “The Language of Stigmatization and the Mark of Violence: Experimental Evidence on the Social Construction and Use of Criminal Record Stigma.” Criminology55(3):664–90.
29.
DesmondM.PapachristosA. V.KirkD. S.. 2016. “Police Violence and Citizen Crime Reporting in the Black Community.” American Sociological Review81(5):857–76.
30.
EricksonE.1968. Identity: Youth and Crisis. New York: Norton.
31.
FaganJ.TylerT. R.. 2005. “Legal Socialization of Children and Adolescents.” Social Justice Research18(3):217–41.
32.
GellerA.FaganJ.TylerT.LinkB. G.. 2014. “Aggressive Policing and the Mental Health of Young Urban Men.” American Journal of Public Health104(12):2321–27.
33.
GelmanA.FaganJ.KissA.. 2007. “An Analysis of the New York City Police Department’s “Stop-and-Frisk” Policy in the Context of Claims of Racial Bias.” Journal of the American Statistical Association102(479):813–23.
34.
Golash-BozaT.2006. “Dropping the Hyphen? Becoming Latino (a)-American through Racialized Assimilation.” Social Forces85(1):27–55.
35.
GoldsmithA. J.2010. “Policing’s New Visibility.” The British Journal of Criminology50(5):914–34.
GordonM. M.1964. Assimilation in American life. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
38.
GreeneJ. A.1999. “Zero Tolerance: A Case Study of Police Policies and Practices in New York City.” Crime & Delinquency45(2):171–87.
39.
HerbstL.WalkerS.. 2001. “Language Barriers in the Delivery of Police Services: A Study of Police and Hispanic Interactions in a Midwestern City.” Journal of Criminal Justice29(4):329–40.
40.
HernándezC. C. G.2013. “Creating Crimmigration.” BYU Law Review2013:1457.
41.
HuntL. M.SchneiderS.ComerB.. 2004. “Should “Acculturation” be a Variable in Health Research? A Critical Review of Research on US Hispanics.” Social Science & Medicine59(5):973–86.
42.
JonesJ.2018. “From Open Doors to Closed Gates: Intragenerational Reverse Incorporation in New Immigrant Destinations.” International Migration Review53(4):1002–1031.
43.
JusticeB.MearesT. L.. 2014. “How the Criminal Justice System Educates Citizens.” The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science651(1):159–77.
44.
KirkD. S.PapachristosA. V.. 2011. “Cultural Mechanisms and the Persistence of Neighborhood Violence.” American Journal of Sociology116(4):1190–1233.
45.
KirkD. S.PapachristosA. V.FaganJ.TylerT. R.. 2012. “The Paradox of Law Enforcement in Immigrant Communities: Does Tough Immigration Enforcement Undermine Public Safety?” The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science641(1):79–98.
46.
KnightG. P.. Vargas-ChanesDLosoyaS. H.Cota-RoblesS.ChassinL.LeeJ. M.. 2009. “Acculturation and Enculturation Trajectories among Mexican-American Adolescent Offenders.” Journal of Research on Adolescence19(4):625–53.
47.
KochelT. R.2019. “Explaining Racial Differences in Ferguson’s Impact on Local Residents’ Trust and Perceived Legitimacy: Policy Implications for Police.” Criminal Justice Policy Review30(3):374–405.
48.
LaraM.GamboaC.KahramanianM. I.MoralesL. S.Hayes BautistaD. E.. 2005. “Acculturation and Latino Health in the United States: A Review of the Literature and its Sociopolitical Context.” Annual Review of Public Health26:367–97.
49.
LeeH.PorterL. C.ComfortM.. 2014. “Consequences of Family Member Incarceration: Impacts on Civic Participation and Perceptions of the Legitimacy and Fairness of Government.” The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science651(1):44–73.
50.
LeeJ. M.SteinbergL.PiqueroA. R.KnightG. P.. 2011. “Identity-linked Perceptions of the Police among African American Juvenile Offenders: A Developmental Perspective.” Journal of Youth and Adolescence40(1):23–37.
51.
LeeJ. M.SteinbergL.PiqueroA. R.. 2010. “Ethnic Identity and Attitudes toward the Police among African American Juvenile Offenders.” Journal of Criminal Justice38(4):781–89.
52.
LemertE. M.1951. Social Pathology: A Systematic Approach to the Theory of Sociopathic Behavior. New York: McGraw-Hill.
53.
LermanA. E.WeaverV. M.. 2014. Arresting Citizenship: The Democratic Consequences of American Crime Control. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
54.
LindE. A.TylerT. R.. 1988. The Social Psychology of Procedural Justice. Berlin, Germany: Springer Science & Business Media.
MazerolleL.AntrobusE.BennettS.TylerT. R.. 2013. “Shaping Citizen Perceptions of Police Legitimacy: A Randomized Field Trial of Procedural Justice.” Criminology51(1):33–63.
57.
McClellandG. H.JuddC. M.. 1993. “Statistical Difficulties of Detecting Interactions and Moderator Effects.” Psychological Bulletin114(2):376.
58.
MenjívarC.BejaranoC.. 2004. “Latino Immigrants’ Perceptions of Crime and Police Authorities in the United States: A Case Study from the Phoenix Metropolitan Area.” Ethnic and Racial Studies27(1):120–148.
59.
MenjívarC.AbregoL.. 2012. “Legal Violence: Immigration Law and the Lives of Central American Immigrants.” American Journal of Sociology117(5):1380–1421.
60.
MenjívarC.SimmonsW. P.AlvordD.ValdezE. S.. 2018. “Immigration Enforcement, the Racialization of Legal Status, and Perceptions of the Police: Latinos in Chicago, Los Angeles, Houston, and Phoenix in Comparative Perspective.” Du Bois Review: Social Science Research on Race15(1):107–28.
61.
MulveyE. P. 2012. Research on Pathways to Desistance [Maricopa County, AZ and Philadelphia County, PA]: Subject measures, 2000-2010. Ann Arbor, MI: Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research. Accessed March 1, 2019. (http://doi.org/10.3886/ICPSR29961.v2).
62.
MurphyK.2015. “Does Procedural Justice Matter to Youth? Comparing Adults’ and Youths’ Willingness to Collaborate with Police.” Policing and Society25(1):53–76.
63.
MurphyK.BarkworthJ.. 2014. “Victim Willingness to Report Crime to Police: Does Procedural Justice or Outcome Matter Most?” Victims & Offenders9(2):178–204.
64.
MurphyK.MazerolleL.. 2018. “Policing Immigrants: Using a Randomized Control Trial of Procedural Justice Policing to Promote Trust and Cooperation.” Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology51(1):3–22.
65.
NaginD. S.TelepC. W.. 2017. “Procedural Justice and Legal Compliance.” Annual Review of Law and Social Science13:5–28.
66.
PaternosterR.BachmanR.BrameR.ShermanL. W.. 1997. “Do Fair Procedures Matter? The Effect of Procedural Justice on Spouse Assault.” Law & Society Review31:163.
67.
PeckJ. H.2015. “Minority Perceptions of the Police: A State-of-the-art Review.” Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management38(1):172–203.
68.
PhinneyJ. S.1992. “The Multigroup Ethnic Identity Measure: A New Scale for Use with Diverse Groups.” Journal of Adolescent Research7(2):156–76.
69.
PhinneyJ. S. (1993). “A Three Stage Model of Ethnic Identity Development in Adolescence”. Pp. 61–80 in Ethnic Identity: Formation and Transmission among Hispanics and Other Minorities, edited by BernalM. E.Knight. G.P. Albany: State University of New York Press.
70.
PickettJ. T.NixJ.RocheS. P.. 2018. “Testing a Social Schematic Model of Police Procedural Justice.” Social Psychology Quarterly81(2):97–125.
71.
PierotteL. M.XieM.BaumerE. P.. 2018. “Recent Shifts in the Volume, Nature, and Scope of State Immigration Policies in the United States.” Migration Letters15(2):266–83.
72.
PiqueroA. R.BersaniB. E.LoughranT. A.FaganJ.. 2016. “Longitudinal Patterns of Legal Socialization in First-generation Immigrants, Second-generation Immigrants, and Native-born Serious Youthful Offenders.” Crime & Delinquency62(11):1403–25.
73.
PiqueroA. R.FaganJ.MulveyE. P.SteinbergL.OdgersC.. 2005. “Developmental Trajectories of Legal Socialization among Serious Adolescent Offenders.” The Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology96(1):267.
74.
PortesA.1997. “Immigration Theory for a New Century: Some Problems and Opportunities.” International Migration Review31(4):799–825.
75.
PortesA.ZhouM.. 1993. “The New Second Generation: Segmented Assimilation and Its Variants.” The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science530(1):74–96.
76.
PortesA.Fernandez-KellyP.HallerW.. 2005. “Segmented Assimilation on the Ground: The New Second Generation in Early Adulthood.” Ethnic and Racial Studies28(6):1000–1040.
77.
PryceD. K.JohnsonD.MaguireE. R.. 2017. “Procedural Justice, Obligation to Obey, and Cooperation with Police in a Sample of Ghanaian Immigrants.” Criminal Justice and Behavior44(5):733–55.
78.
RengifoA. F.FratelloJ.. 2015. “Perceptions of the Police by Immigrant Youth: Looking at Stop-and-frisk and beyond Using a New York City Sample.” Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice13(4):409–27.
79.
RengifoA. F.PaterM.. 2017. “Close Call: Race and Gender in Encounters with the Police by Black and Latino/a youth in New York City.” Sociological Inquiry87(2):337–61.
80.
RengifoA. F.SlocumL. A.. 2020. “The Identity Prism: How Racial Identification Frames Perceptions of Police Contact, Legitimacy, and Effectiveness.” Law & Social Inquiry45(3):590–617.
81.
RiceS. K.PiqueroA. R.. 2005. “Perceptions of Discrimination and Justice in New York City.” Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management28(1):98–117.
82.
RiosV. M.2011. Punished: Policing the Lives of Black and Latino Boys. New York: NYU Press.
83.
RudminF. W.2003. “Critical History of the Acculturation Psychology of Assimilation, Separation, Integration, and Marginalization.” Review of General Psychology7(1):3–37.
84.
RudminF. W.2009. “Constructs, Measurements and Models of Acculturation and Acculturative Stress.” International Journal of Intercultural Relations33(2):106–23.
85.
SampsonR. J.2011. Great American City: Chicago and the Enduring Neighborhood Effect. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
86.
SampsonR. J.BartuschD. J.. 1998. “Legal Cynicism and (subcultural?) Tolerance of Deviance: The Neighborhood Context of Racial Differences.” Law and Society Review32(4):777–804.
87.
SampsonR. J.MorenoffJ. D.Gannon-RowleyT.. 2002. “Assessing “Neighborhood Effects”: Social Processes and New Directions in Research.” Annual Review of Sociology28(1):443–78.
88.
SampsonR. J.MorenoffJ. D.RaudenbushS.. 2005. “Social Anatomy of Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Violence.” American Journal of Public Health95(2):224–32.
89.
SampsonR. J.RaudenbushS. W.. 2004. “Seeing Disorder: Neighborhood Stigma and the Social Construction of “Broken Windows”.” Social Psychology Quarterly67(4):319–42.
90.
SchubertC. A.MulveyE. P.SteinbergL.CauffmanE.LosoyaS. H.HeckerT.ChassinL.KnightG. P.. 2004. “Operational Lessons from the Pathways to Desistance Project.” Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice2(3):237–55.
91.
SchwartzS. J.UngerJ. B.ZamboangaB. L.SzapocznikJ.. 2010. “Rethinking the Concept of Acculturation: Implications for Theory and Research.” American Psychologist65(4):237.
92.
SkoganW. G.2006. “Asymmetry in the Impact of Encounters with Police.” Policing & Society16(2):99–126.
93.
SolisC.PortillosE. L.BrunsonR. K.. 2009. “Latino Youths’ Experiences with and Perceptions of Involuntary Police Encounters.” The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science623(1):39–51.
94.
StJeanP. K. 2008. Pockets of Crime: Broken Windows, Collective Efficacy, and the Criminal Point of View. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
95.
StuesseA.ColemanM.. 2014. “Automobility, Immobility, Altermobility: Surviving and Resisting the Intensification of Immigrant Policing.” City & Society26(1):51–72.
96.
Suárez-OrozcoM.1990. “Migration and Education: United States–Europe Comparison.” Pp. 265–87 in Status Inequality: The Self in Culture, edited by De VosG.Suarez-OrozcoM.. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
97.
SunshineJ.TylerT. R.. 2003a. “The Role of Procedural Justice and Legitimacy in Shaping Public Support for Policing.” Law & Society Review37(3):513–48.
98.
SunshineJ.TylerT.. 2003b. “Moral Solidarity, Identification with the Community, and the Importance of Procedural Justice: The Police as Prototypical Representatives of a Group’s Moral Values.” Social Psychology Quarterly66(2):153–65.
99.
TrevelyanE.GambinoC.GrynT.LarsenL.AcostaY.GriecoE.HarrisD.WaltersN.. 2016. Characteristics of the US Population by Generational Status: 2013. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.
100.
TrinknerR.CohnE. S.. 2014. “Putting the “Social” back in Legal Socialization: Procedural Justice, Legitimacy, and Cynicism in Legal and Nonlegal Authorities.” Law and Human Behavior38(6):602.
101.
TrinknerR.TylerT. R.. 2016. “Legal Socialization: Coercion Versus Consent in an Era of Mistrust.” Annual Review of Law and Social Science12:417–39.
102.
TylerT. R.1987. “Conditions Leading to Value-expressive Effects in Judgments of Procedural Justice: A Test of Four Models.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology52(2):333.
103.
TylerT. R.1990. “Justice, Self-interest, and the Legitimacy of Legal and Political Authority.” Pp. 171–79 in Beyond Self-interest, edited by MansbridgeJ. J.Chicago: University of Press.
104.
TylerT. R.2003. “Procedural Justice, Legitimacy, and the Effective Rule of Law.” Crime and Justice30:283–357.
105.
TylerT. R.BladerS. L.. 2003. “The Group Engagement Model: Procedural Justice, Social Identity, and Cooperative Behavior.” Personality and Social Psychology Review7(4):349–61.
106.
TylerT. R.FaganJ.GellerA.. 2014. “Street Stops and Police Legitimacy: Teachable Moments in Young Urban Men’s Legal Socialization.” Journal of Empirical Legal Studies11(4):751–785.
107.
TylerT. R.GoffP. A.MacCounR. J.. 2015. “The Impact of Psychological Science on Policing in the United States: Procedural Justice, Legitimacy, and Effective Law Enforcement.” Psychological Science in the Public Interest16(3):75–109.
108.
TylerT. R.HuoY.. 2002. Trust in the Law: Encouraging Public Cooperation with the Police and Courts.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
109.
TylerT. R.LindE. A.. 1992. “A Relational Model of Authority in Groups.” Advances in Experimental Social Psychology25:115–91.
110.
TylerT. R.WakslakC. J.. 2004. “Profiling and Police Legitimacy: Procedural Justice, Attributions of Motive, and Acceptance of Police Authority.” Criminology42(2):253–82.
111.
Viruell-FuentesE. A.2007. “Beyond Acculturation: Immigration, Discrimination, and Health Research among Mexicans in the United States.” Social Science & Medicine65(7):1524–35.
112.
WatersM. C.1994. “Ethnic and Racial Identities of Second-generation Black Immigrants in New York City.” International Migration Review28(4):795–820.
113.
WatersM. C.KasinitzP.. 2015. “The War on Crime and the War on Immigrants: Racial and Legal Exclusion in the Twenty-first-century United States.” Pp. 115–42 in Fear, Anxiety, and National Identity: Immigration and Belonging in North America and Western Europe, edited by FonerN.SimonP.. New York: Russel Sage Foundation.
114.
WeaverV. M.LermanA. E.. 2010. “Political Consequences of the Carceral State.” American Political Science Review104(4):817–33.
115.
WeitzerR.2014. “The Puzzling Neglect of Hispanic Americans in Research on Police–citizen Relations.” Ethnic and Racial Studies37(11):1995–2013.
116.
WeitzerR.2017. “Theorizing Racial Discord over Policing before and After Ferguson.” Justice Quarterly34(7):1129–53.
117.
WeitzerR.TuchS. A.. 2004a. “Race and Perceptions of Police Misconduct.” Social Problems51(3):305–25.
118.
WeitzerR.TuchS. A.. 2004b. “Reforming the Police: Racial Differences in Public Support for Change.” Criminology42(2):391–416.
119.
WhyteW. F.1943. Street Corner Society: The Social Structure of an Italian Slum. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
120.
WolfeS. E.McLeanK.PrattT. C.. 2016. “I learned It by Watching You: Legal Socialization and the Intergenerational Transmission of Legitimacy Attitudes.” British Journal of Criminology57(5):1123–43.
121.
WordenR.McLeanS.. 2017. Mirage of Police Reform: Procedural Justice and Police Legitimacy, p. 268. Berkeley: University of California Press.
122.
XieM.BaumerE. P.. 2019. “Neighborhood Immigrant Concentration and Violent Crime Reporting to the Police: A Multilevel Analysis of Data from the National Crime Victimization Survey.” Criminology57(2):237–67.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
