This study examines the prevalence of overconfidence in the perceived risk of committing crime and whether such overconfidence is related to criminal behavior.
Methods:
Two samples were used—a sample of high school students who committed minor offenses and a sample of serious juvenile offenders most with felony arrests. Overconfidence in risk was estimated as the difference between the perceived risk of arrest for one’s self and for a generalized other. The proportion of over- and underconfident persons were estimated in both samples, while pooled and random effects logit models were used to estimate the effect of risk on both self-reported offending and arrest within the sample of serious offenders.
Results:
A large proportion of youth were found to be overconfident with respect to their perceived risk, with a higher prevalence in the conventional high school sample. Within the sample of serious juvenile offenders, being overconfident about one’s own risk was found to be related to both self-reported offending and arrest, net of a base rate measure of others’ risk.
Conclusions:
We outline a theory of the relationship between overconfidence and crime that links overconfidence with a self-attribution bias and biased updating of perceived risk with new information.
AnwarShamenaLoughranThomas. 2011. “Testing a Bayesian Learning Theory of Deterrence among Serious Juvenile Offenders.”Criminology49:667–98.
2.
BarberBrad M.OdeanTerrance. 2001. “Boys Will be Boys: Gender, Overconfidence, and Common Stock Investment.”Quarterly Journal of Economics116:261–92.
3.
Ben-DavidItzhakGrahamJohn R.HarveyCampbell R.. 2010. “Managerial Miscalibration.”Charles A. Dice Center Working Paper No. 2010-12; Fisher College of Business Working Paper No. 2010-03-012. Accessed: May 1, 2012. Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1640552.
4.
CamererColin F.LoewensteinGeorgeRabinMatthew. 2004. Advances in Behavioral Economics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
5.
CamererColin F.LovalloDan. 1999. “Overconfidence and Excess Entry: An Experimental Approach.”American Economic Review89:306–18.
6.
ChemersM. M.HuL.GarciaB.2001. “Academic Self-Efficacy and First-Year College Student Performance and Adjustment.” Journal of Educational Psychology93:55–65.
7.
CornishDerekClarkeRonald V.. 1986. “Introduction.” Pp. 1-16 in The Reasoning Criminal, edited by CornishDerekClarkeRonald. New York: Springer-Verlag.
8.
CrossP.1977. “Not Can But Will College Teaching Be Improved?” New Directions for Higher Education17: 1–15.
9.
DeckerScott H.WrightRichardLogieRobert. 1993. “Perceptual Deterrence among Active Residential Burglars: A Research Note.”Criminology31:135–47.
10.
DunningD.2005. Self-insight: Roadblocks and Detours on the Path to Knowing Thyself. New York: Psychology Press.
11.
FirebaughGlenn. 2008. Seven Rules for Social Research. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
12.
FischhoffBaruchSlovicPaulLichtensteinSarah. 1977. “Knowing with Certainty: The Appropriateness of Extreme Confidence.”Journal of Experimental Psychology3:552–64.
13.
FiskeSusan E.TaylorShelley E.. 2007. Social Cognition. New York: McGraw-Hill.
14.
GervaisSimonOdeanTerrance. 2001. “Learning to be Overconfident.”Review of Financial Studies14:1–27.
15.
HeatonJ. B.2002. “Managerial Optimism and Corporate Finance.”Financial Management (Summer):33–45.
16.
HuizingaDavidEsbensenF-AWeiharA.1991. “Are There Multiple Paths to Delinquency?” Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology82:83–118.
17.
JensenGary. 1969. ““Crime Doesn’t Pay”: Correlates of a Shared Misunderstanding (1969).”Social Problems. 17:189–201.
18.
LennyE.1977. “Women's Self-Confidence in Achievement Settings.” Psychological Bulletin84:1–13.
19.
KoellingerP.MinnitiM.SchadeC.2007. “I Think I Can, I Think I Can: Overconfidence and Entrepreneurial behavior.” Journal of Economic Psychology28:502–527.
20.
LichtensteinSarahFischhoffBaruchPhillipsLawrence. 1982. “Calibration of Probabilities: The State of the Art to 1980.” In Judgment Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases, (pp. 275-324) edited by KahnemanDanielSlovicPaulTverskyAmos, New York: Cambridge University Press.
21.
LundebergMary A.FoxPaul W.PunćochaŕJudith1994. “Highly Confident But Wrong; Gender Differences and Similarities in Confidence Judgments.”Journal of Educational Psychology86:114–21.
22.
MalmendierUlrikeTateGeoffrey. 2005. “CEO Overconfidence and Corporate Investment.”Journal of Finance60:2661–700.
23.
MalmendierUlrikeTateGeoffrey. 2008. “Who Makes Acquisitions? CEO Overconfidence and the Market’s Reaction.”Journal of Financial Economics89:20–43.
24.
MatsuedaRoss L.KreagerDerek A.HuizingaDavid. 2006. “Deterring Delinquents: A Rational Choice Model of Theft and Violence.”American Sociological Review71:95–122.
25.
MatzaDavid. 1964. Delinquency and Drift. New York: Wiley.
26.
MulveyEdward P.SteinbergLaurenceFaganJeffreyCauffmanElizabethPiqueroAlex R.ChassinLaurieKnightGeorge P.KnightGeorge P.
…
LosoyaSandra H.2004. “Theory and Research on Desistance from Antisocial Activity Among Serious Juvenile Offenders.” Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice2:213–36.
27.
NaginDaniel S.1998. Criminal Deterrence Research at the Outset of the Twenty-First Century. Crime and Justice: A Review of Research23:1–42.
28.
NaginDaniel S.2007. “Moving Choice to the Center Stage in Criminological Research and Theory: The American Society of Criminology 2006 Sutherland Address.”Criminology45:259–72.
29.
NaginDaniel S.PaternosterRaymond. 1993. “Enduring Individual Differences and Rational Choice Theories of Crime.”Law and Society Review27:467–96.
30.
PanCarrieStatmanMeir. 2010. “Beyond Risk-Tolerance Overconfidence, Regret, Personality, and Other Investor Characteristics.”Accessed: May 1, 2012. Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1549912.
31.
PaternosterRaymond. 1987. “The Deterrent Effect of the Perceived Certainty and Severity of Punishment: A Review of the Evidence and Issues.” Justice Quarterly4:173–218.
32.
PaternosterRaymond. 2010. “How Much Do We Really Know About Criminal Deterrence?”Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology100:765–823.
33.
PaternosterRaymondSaltzmanLinda E.WaldoGordon P.ChiricosTheodore G.. 1983. “Estimating Perceptual Stability and Deterrent Effects: The Role of Perceived Legal Punishment in the Inhibition of Criminal Involvement.”Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology74:270–97.
34.
PiqueroAlex R.PaternosterRaymondPogarskyGregLoughranThomas. 2011. “Elaborating the individual difference component in deterrence theory.” Annual Review of Law and Social Science7:335–60.
35.
PiqueroAlexRengertGeorge F.. 1999. “Studying Deterrence with Active Residential Burglars.”Justice Quarterly16:451–71.
36.
PiqueroAlex R.TibbettsStephen G.. 1996. “Specifying the Direct and Indirect Effects of Low Self-Control and Situational Factors in Offender Decision Making: Toward a More Complete Model of Rational Offending.”Justice Quarterly13:601–31.
37.
RutterD. R.QuineL.AlberyI. P.1998. “Perceptions of Risk in Motorcyclists: Unrealistic Optimism, Relative Optimism, and Predictions of Behaviour.” British Journal of Psychology89:681–697.
38.
SchubertCarol A.MulveyEdward P.CauffmanElizabethSteinbergLaurenceHecklerThomasLosoyaSandra H.ChassinLaurieKnightGeorge P.2004. “Operational Lessons from the Pathway to Desistance Project.” Youth Violence & Juvenile Justice2:237–255.
39.
PuriManjuRobinsonDavid T.. 2005. “Optimism and Economic Choice.”Journal of Financial Economics86:71–99.
40.
RollRichard. 1986. “The Hubris Hypothesis of Corporate Takeovers.”Journal of Business59:197–216.
41.
ProninE.LinD. Y.RossL.2002. “The Bias Blind Spot: Perceptions of Bias in Self Versus Others.”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin28:369–381.
ShoverNeal. 1983. “The Later Stages of Ordinary Property Offender Careers.”Social Problems31:208–18.
44.
ShoverNeal. 1996. Great Pretenders: Pursuits and Careers of Persistent Thieves. Boulder, CO: Westview.
45.
ThalerRichard H.1988. “Anomalies: The Winner’s Curse.”Journal of Economic Perspectives2:191–202.
46.
TittleCharles R.1980. Sanctions and Social Deviance: The Question of Deterrence. New York: Praeger.
47.
TunnellKenneth D.1992. Choosing Crime: The Criminal Calculus of Property Offenders. Chicago, IL: Nelson-Hall.
48.
VohsKathleen D.BaumeisterRoy F.LoewensteinGeorge. 2007. Do Emotions Help or Hurt Decision Making? A Hedgefoxian Perspective. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
49.
WaldoGordonChiricosTed1972. “Perceived Penal Sanction and Self-Reported Criminality.” Social Problems19: 522-540.
50.
WrightRichard T.DeckerScott H.. 1997. Armed Robbers in Action: Stickups and Street Culture. Boston, MA: Northeastern University Press.
51.
WrightRichardLogieRobertDeckerScott H.. 1995. “Criminal Expertise and Offender Decision-Making: An Experimental Study of the Target Selection Process on Residential Burglary.”Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency32:39–53.
52.
ZimringFranklin E.HawkinsGordon J.1973. Deterrence: The Legal Threat in Crime Control. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
