Heightened scholarly interest in stability and change in criminal behavior has increased the demand for longitudinal data. One method that may enhance the quality of retrospective self-reported data, especially reports of timing, is the life event calendar (LEC). Using a sample of incarcerated women, we assess the validity of LEC measures of self-reported prevalence, frequency and timing of arrests over a three-year period.We also examine the validity of self—reported frequency and timing of arrest data by respondent and arrest characteristics. Results suggest that the LEC elicits valid data on prevalence and frequency of arrests, while self-reported timing of arrests is recalled with less accuracy. Saliency appears more relevant for the accuracy of self-reported frequency, as compared to timing, and substance use has no effect on validity. We discuss future research using the LEC, especially with regard to improving the recall of the timing and sequencing of criminal events.
Anglin, M.D., Y.I. Hser, and C.P. Chou.1993. "Reliability and Validity of Retrospective Behavioral Self-report by Narcotics Addicts."Evaluation Review17:91-108.
2.
Auriat, N.1992. "Autobiographical Memory and Survey Methodology: Furthering the Bridge between Two Disciplines" Pp. 295-312 in Theoretical Perspectives on Autobiographical Memory, edited by M. A. Conway, D. C. Rubin, H. Spinnler, and W. A. Wagenaar.Dordecht, the Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
3.
Babor, T.F., J. Brown, and F.K. Del Boca .1990. "Validity of Self-reports in Applied Research in Addictive Behaviors: Fact or Fiction?" Behavioral Assessment12:5-31.
4.
Ball, J.C.1967. "Reliability and Validity of Interview Data Obtained from 59 Narcotic Drug Addicts." American Journal of Sociology72:650-54.
5.
Belli, R.F.1998. "The Structure of Autobiographical Memory and the Event History Calendar: Potential Improvements in the Quality of Retrospective Reports in Surveys." Memory6:383-406.
6.
Belli, R.F.2000. "Computerized Event History Calendar Methods: Facilitating Autobiographical Recall" Pp. 471-75 in American Statistical Association Proceedings of the Section on Survey Research Methods. Alexandria, VA: American Statistical Association.
7.
Belli, R.F. and M. Callegaro.2009. "The Emergence of Calendar Interviewing: A Theoretical and Empirical Rationale" Pp. 31-52 in Calendar and Time Diary: Methods in Life Course Research, edited by R. F. Belli, F. P. Stafford, and D. F. Alwin.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
8.
Belli, R.F., W.L. Shay, and F.P. Stafford.2001. "Event History Calendars and Question List Surveys: A Direct Comparison of Interviewing Methods." Public Opinion Quarterly65:45-74.
9.
Blumstein, A., J. Cohen, J. Roth, and C. Visher.1986. "Dimensions of Active Criminal Careers ." Pp. 55-95 in Criminal Careers and "Career Criminals," Vol. 1, edited by A. Blumstein, J. Cohen , J. Roth, and C. Visher.Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
10.
Bradburn, N. and C. Danis.1984. "Potential Contributions of Cognitive Research to Survey Questionnaire Design" Pp. 101-29 in Cognitive Aspects of Survey Methodology: Building a Bridge between Disciplines, edited by T. B. Jabine, M. L. Straf, J. M. Tanur, and R. Tourangeau.Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
11.
Brown, J., H.R. Kranzler, and F.K. Del Boca .1992. "Self-reports by Alcohol and Drug Abuse Inpatients: Factors Affecting Reliability and Validity."British Journal of Addiction87:1013-24.
12.
Caspi, A., T.E. Moffitt, A. Thornton, D. Freedman, J.W. Ammell, H. Harrington, J. Smeijers, and P.A. Silva.1996. "The Life History Calendar: A Research and Clinical Assessment Method for Collecting Retrospective Event-History Data."International Journal of Methods on Psychiatric Research6:101-14.
13.
Clark, J.P. and L.L. Tift.1966. "Polygraph and Interview Validation of Self-reported Deviant Behavior."American Sociological Review41:516-23.
14.
Elliott, D.S. and H.L. Voss.1974. Delinquency and Dropout. Lexington, MA: D. C. Heath.
15.
Farrington, D.P.1973. "Self-reports of Deviant Behavior: Predictive and Stable ?" Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology64:99-110.
16.
Farrington, D.P. and R. Loeber.1989. "Relative Improvement over Chance (RIOC) and Phi as Measures of Predictive Efficiency and Strength of Association in 2 × 2 Tables ." Journal of Quantitative Criminology5:201-13.
17.
Fendrich, M. and C.M. Vaughn.1994. "Diminished Lifetime Substance Use over Time: An Inquiry into Differential Underreporting." Public Opinion Quarterly58:96-123.
18.
Fikree, F.F., R.H. Gray, and F. Shah.1993. "Can Men Be Trusted? A Comparison of Pregnancy Histories Reported by Husbands and Wives." American Journal of Epidemiology138:237-42.
19.
Freedman, D., A. Thornton, D. Camburn, D. Alwin, and L. Young-DeMarco .1988. "The Life History Calendar: A Technique for Collecting Retrospective Data." Sociological Methodology18:37-68.
20.
Furstenberg, F.F., J. Brooks-Gunn, and S.P. Morgan.1987. Adolescent Mothers in Later Life. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
21.
Gladsjo, J.A., J.A. Tucker, J.L. Hawkins, and R.E. Vuchinich.1992. "Adequacy of Recall of Drinking Patterns and Event Occurrences Associated with Natural Recovery from Alcohol Problems ." Addictive Behaviors17:347-58.
22.
Golub, A., B.D. Johnson, A. Taylor, and H.J. Liberty.2002. "The Validity of Arrestees Self-reports: Variations across Questions and Persons."Justice Quarterly19:477-502.
23.
Hardt, R.H. and S. Petersen-Hardt.1977. "On Determining the Quality of the Delinquency Self-report Method."Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency14:247-61.
24.
Henry, B., T.E. Moffitt, A. Caspi, J. Langley, and P.A. Silva.1994. "On the ‘Remembrance of Things Past:’ A Longitudinal Evaluation of the Retrospective Method." Psychological Assessment6:92-101.
25.
Hindelang, M.J., T. Hirschi, and J.G. Weis.1981. Measuring Delinquency. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
26.
Hirschi, T.1969. Causes of Delinquency. Berkeley: University of California Press.
27.
Horney, J.2001. "Criminal Events and Criminal Careers" Pp. 141-96 in The Process and Structure of Crime: Criminal Events and Crime Analysis, edited by R. Meier, L. Kennedy, and V. Sacco.New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.
28.
Horney, J., D.W. Osgood, and I.H. Marshall.1995. "Criminal Careers in the Short-term: Intra-individual Variability in Crime and its Relations to Local Life Circumstances."American Sociological Review60:655-73.
29.
Hser, Y.1997. "Self-reported Drug Use: Results of Selected Empirical Investigations of Validity" Pp. 320-43 in The Validity of Self-reported Drug Use: Improving the Accuracy of Survey Estimates (NIDA Research Monograph 167) , edited by L. Harrison and A. Hughes.Rockville, MD: National Institute of Drug Abuse.
30.
Huizinga, D. and D.S. Elliott.1986. "Reassessing the Reliability and Validity of Self-report Delinquency Measures."Journal of Quantitative Criminology2:293-327.
31.
Janson, C.1990. "Retrospective Data, Undesirable Behavior, and the Longitudinal Perspective" Pp. 100-21 in Data Quality in Longitudinal Research, edited by D. Magnusson and L. R. Bergman.Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
32.
Kazemian, L. and D.P. Farrington.2005. "Comparing the Validity of Prospective, Retrospective, and Official Onset for Different Offending Categories." Journal of Quantitative Criminology12:127-47.
33.
Lauritsen, J.L.1998. "The Age-Crime Debate: Assessing the Limits of Longitudinal Self-report Data." Social Forces77:127-54.
34.
Lauritsen, J.L. and C.G. Swicegood.1997. "The Consistency of Self-reported Initiation of Sexual Activity" Family Planning Perspectives29:215-21.
35.
Lemert, E.M.1972. Human Deviance, Social Problems, and Social Control. 2nd ed. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
36.
Lin, N., W.M. Ensel, and W.G. Lai.1997. "Construction and the Use of the Life History Calendar: Reliability and Validity of Recall Data" Pp. 249-72 in Stress and Adversity over the Life Course, edited by I. H. Gotlib and B. Wheaton.Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
37.
Loeber, R. and T.J. Dishion.1983. "Early Predictors of Male Delinquency: A Review." Psychological Bulletin94:68-99.
Loftus, E.F. and W. Marburger.1983. "Since the Eruption of Mt. St. Helens, Has Anyone Beaten You Up? Improving the Accuracy of Retrospective Reports with Landmark Events ." Memory and Cognition11:114-20.
40.
Lyketsos, C.G., G. Nestadt, J. Cwi, K. Heithoff, and W.E. Eaton.1994. "The Life Chart Interview: A Standardized Method to Describe the Course of Psychopathology." International Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research4:143-55.
41.
Maddux, J.F. and D.P. Desmond.1975. "Reliability and Validity of Information from Chronic Heroin Users." Journal of Psychiatric Research12:87-95.
42.
Maxfield, M.G., B.L. Weiler, and C.S. Widom.2000. "Comparing Self-reports and Official Records of Arrests" Journal of Quantitative Criminology16:87-110.
43.
Mensch, B.S. and D.B. Kandel.1988. "Underreporting of Substance Use in a National Longitudinal Youth Cohort: Individual and Interviewer Effects." Public Opinion Quarterly52:100-24.
44.
Neugebauer, R.1984. "The Reliability of Life-Event Reports" Pp. 85-107 in Stressful Life Events and their Contexts, edited by B. S. Dohrenwend and B. P. Dohrenwend.New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
45.
Nieves, K., J. Draine, and P. Solomon.2000. "The Validity of Self-reported Criminal Arrest History among Clients of a Psychiatric Probation and Parole Service " Journal of Offender Rehabilitation30:133-51.
46.
Petersilia, J., P.W. Greenwood, and M. Lavin.1978. Criminal Careers of Habitual Felons . Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, National Institute of Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice.
47.
Rabe-Hesketh, S. and A. Skrondal.2005. Multilevel and Longitudinal Modeling Using Stata. College Station, TX: StataCorp LP.
48.
Roberts, J. and J. Horney. Forthcoming. "The Life Event Calendar Method in Criminological Research." In Handbook of Quantitative Criminology, edited by A. Piquero and D. Weisburd.New York: Springer.
49.
Roberts, J. and E.P. Mulvey.2009. "Reports of Life Events by Individuals at High Risk for Violence" Pp. 191-206 in Calendar and Time Diary: Methods in Life Course Research, edited by R. F. Belli , F. P. Stafford, and D. F. Alwin.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
50.
Roberts, J., E.P. Mulvey, J. Horney, J. Lewis, and M.L. Arter.2005. "A Test of Two Methods of Recall for Violent Events." Journal of Quantitative Criminology21:175-93.
Schober, M.F. and F.G. Conrad.1997. "Does Conversational Interviewing Reduce Survey Measurement Error?" Public Opinion Quarterly61:576-602.
53.
Slocum, L.A., S.S. Simpson, and D.A. Smith.2005. "Strained Lives and Crime: Examining Intra-individual Variation in Strain and Offending in a Sample of Incarcerated Women."Criminology43:1067-110.
54.
Sobell, L.C., M.B. Sobell, G.I. Leo, and A. Cancilla.1988. "Reliability of a Timeline Method: Assessing Normal Drinkers’ Reports of Recent Drinking and a Comparative Evaluation across Several Populations" British Journal of Addiction83:393-402.
55.
Suchman, L. and B. Jordan.1990. "Interactional Troubles in Face-to-face Survey Interviews " Journal of the American Statistical Association85:232-41.
56.
Sullivan, C.J., J.M. McGloin, T.C. Pratt, and A.R. Piquero.2006. "Rethinking the Norm of Offender Generality: Investigating Specialization in the Short-term" Criminology44:199-233.
57.
Sweeten, G.2006. "Who Will Graduate? Disruption of High School Education by Arrest and Court Involvement." Justice Quarterly23:462-80.
58.
Thornberry, T.P.1989. "Panel Effects and the Use of Self-reported Measures of Delinquency in Longitudinal Studies" Pp. 347-69 in Cross-National Research in Self-reported Crime and Delinquency, edited by M. Klein.Dordrecht, the Netherlands: Kluwer Academic.
59.
Thornberry, T.P. and M.D. Krohn.2000. "The Self-report Method for Measuring Delinquency and Crime" Pp. 33-83 in Measurement and Analysis of Crime and Justice , edited by R. D. Duffee, R. D. Crutchfield, S. Mastrofski , L. Mazerolle, D. McDowall, and B. Ostrom.Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice.
60.
Uggen, C. and M. Thompson.2003. "The Socioeconomic Determinants of Ill-gotten Gains: Within-person Changes in Drug Use and Illegal Earnings." American Journal of Sociology109:146-85.
61.
Weis, J.J.1986. "Issues in the Measurement of Criminal Careers." Pp. 1-51 in Criminal Careers and "Career Criminals," Vol. II, edited by A. Blumstein, J. Cohen , J. Roth, and C. Visher.Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
62.
Western, B.2002. "The Impact of Incarceration on Wage Mobility and Inequality ." American Sociological Review67:526-46.
63.
Western, B.2006. Punishment and Inequality in America. New York: Russell Sage.
64.
Woltman, H. and J. Bushery.1984. "Summary Results from the National Crime Survey Panel Bias Study." Pp. 98-101 in The National Crime Survey Working Papers, Methodological Studies, Vol. II, edited by R. Lehnen and W. Skogan.Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
65.
Yoshihama, M., B. Gillepsie, A.C. Hammock, R.F. Belli, and R.M. Tolman.2005. "Does the Life History Calendar Method Facilitate the Recall of Intimate Partner Violence? Comparison of Two Methods of Data Collection."Social Work Research29:151-63.
