The authors investigate the impact of online news content on the effectiveness of display advertising. In a randomized online experiment, participants read news articles randomly paired with brand advertisements. Leveraging nonintrusive eye-tracking technology, the authors measure individual attention to both articles and ads. The authors then measure ad recall, and participants choose between cash and brand-specific vouchers. Heightened attention to articles results in “spillover” attention to ads on the same page, which, in turn, increases both brand recall and purchase probability. The authors also consider the effect of news content type, differentiating between “hard” and “soft” news. They find that advertising next to hard news is at least as effective as advertising next to soft news. This provides evidence against the blunt implementation of “block lists” for sensitive news topics by advertisers. The authors discuss the implications of attention spillovers for firms contemplating investments in engaging news content within the digital advertising landscape.
AhnJae-HyeonBaeYoon-SooJuJaehyeonOhWonseok (2018), “Attention Adjustment, Renewal, and Equilibrium Seeking in Online Search: An Eye-Tracking Approach,” Journal of Management Information Systems, 35 (4), 1218–50.
2.
AngristJoshua D.ImbensGuido W. (1995), “Two-Stage Least Squares Estimation of Average Causal Effects in Models with Variable Treatment Intensity,” Journal of the American Statistical Association, 90 (430), 431–42.
3.
AngristJoshua DavidImbensGuido W.KruegerAlan B. (1999), “Jackknife Instrumental Variables Estimation,” Journal of Applied Econometrics, 14 (1), 57–67.
4.
AribargAnochaPietersRikWedelMichel (2010), “Raising the BAR: Bias Adjustment of Recognition Tests in Advertising,” Journal of Marketing Research, 47 (3), 387–400.
5.
ArmelK. CarrieBeaumelAurelieRangelAntonio (2008), “Biasing Simple Choices by Manipulating Relative Visual Attention,” Judgment and Decision Making, 3 (5), 396–403.
6.
BeckerGary S.MurphyKevin M. (1993), “A Simple Theory of Advertising as a Good or Bad,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 108 (4), 941–64.
7.
BergerJonahMoeWendy W.SchweidelDavid (2019), “What Leads to Longer Reads? Psychological Drivers of Reading Online Content,” in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 47, BagchiRajeshBlockLaurenLeeLeonard, eds. Association for Consumer Research, 19–23.
8.
BraselS. AdamGipsJames (2008), “Breaking Through Fast-Forwarding: Brand Information and Visual Attention,” Journal of Marketing, 72 (6), 31–48.
9.
BrocasIsabelleCarrilloJuan D.WangStephanie W.CamererColin F. (2014), “Imperfect Choice or Imperfect Attention? Understanding Strategic Thinking in Private Information Games,” Review of Economic Studies, 81 (3), 944–70.
10.
CalderBobby J.MalthouseEdward C.SchaedelUte (2009), “An Experimental Study of the Relationship Between Online Engagement and Advertising Effectiveness,” Journal of Interactive Marketing, 23 (4), 321–31.
11.
CamererColin F.JohnsonEricRymonTaliaSenSankar (1993), “Cognition and Framing in Sequential Bargaining for Gains and Losses,” Frontiers of Game Theory, 104, 27–47.
12.
CerfMoranHarelJonathanEinhäuserWolfgangKochChristof (2007), “Predicting Human Gaze Using Low-Level Saliency Combined with Face Detection,” in Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, Vol. 20, J. Platt, D. Koller, Y. Singer, and S. Roweis, eds. NeurIPS, https://proceedings.neurips.cc/paper/2007/hash/708f3cf8100d5e71834b1db77dfa15d6-Abstract.html.
13.
ChandonPierreHutchinsonJ. WesleyBradlowEric T.YoungScott H. (2009), “Does in-Store Marketing Work? Effects of the Number and Position of Shelf Facings on Brand Attention and Evaluation at the Point of Purchase,” Journal of Marketing, 73 (6), 1–17.
DanaherPeter J.MullarkeyGuy W. (2003), “Factors Affecting Online Advertising Recall: A Study of Students,” Journal of Advertising Research, 43 (3), 252–67.
16.
DengYitingMelaCarl F. (2018), “TV Viewing and Advertising Targeting,” Journal of Marketing Research, 55 (1), 99–118.
DobbieWillGoldinJacobYangCrystal S. (2018), “The Effects of Pretrial Detention on Conviction, Future Crime, and Employment: Evidence from Randomly Assigned Judges,” American Economic Review, 108 (2), 201–40.
19.
DrèzeXavierHussherrFrançois-Xavier (2003), “Internet Advertising: Is Anybody Watching?” Journal of Interactive Marketing, 17 (4), 8–23.
20.
ElsenMilliePietersRikWedelMichel (2016), “Thin Slice Impressions: How Advertising Evaluation depends on Exposure Duration,” Journal of Marketing Research, 53 (4), 563–79.
GhaffariMinouFiedlerSusann (2018), “The Power of Attention: Using Eye Gaze to Predict Other-Regarding and Moral Choices,” Psychological Science, 29 (11), 1878–89.
GoldsteinDaniel G.McAfeeR. PrestonSuriSiddharth (2011), “The Effects of Exposure Time on Memory of Display Advertisements,” in Proceedings of the 12th ACM Conference on Electronic Commerce. Association for Computing Machinery, 49–58.
25.
GoldsteinDaniel G.McAfeeR. PrestonSuriSiddharth (2015), “Improving the Effectiveness of Time-Based Display Advertising,” ACM Transactions on Economics and Computation (TEAC), 3 (2), 1–20.
26.
GordonBrett R.JerathKinshukKatonaZsoltNarayananSridharShinJiwoongWilburKenneth C. (2021), “Inefficiencies in Digital Advertising Markets,” Journal of Marketing, 85 (1), 7–25.
27.
GordonBrett R.MoaklerRobertZettelmeyerFlorian (2023), “Close Enough? A Large-Scale Exploration of Non-Experimental Approaches to Advertising Measurement,” Marketing Science, 42 (4), 768–93.
28.
HeckmanJames J.SnyderJames M.Jr. (1997), “Linear Probability Models of the Demand for Attributes with an Empirical Application to Estimating the Preferences of Legislators,” RAND Journal of Economics, 28, S142.
29.
HigginsEmilyLeinengerMallorieRaynerKeith (2014), “Eye Movements When Viewing Advertisements,” Frontiers in Psychology, 5, 210.
30.
HobanPaul R.BucklinRandolph E. (2015), “Effects of Internet Display Advertising in the Purchase Funnel: Model-Based Insights from a Randomized Field Experiment,” Journal of Marketing Research, 52 (3), 375–93.
31.
HolmqvistKennethHolsanovaJanaBarthelsonMariLundqvistDaniel (2003), “Reading or Scanning? A Study of Newspaper and Net Paper Reading,” in The Mind’s Eye: Cognitive and Applied Aspects of Eye Movement Research, Jukka Hyönä, Ralph Radach, and Heiner Deubel, eds. Elsevier, 657–70.
32.
HoyerWayne D.BrownSteven P. (1990), “Effects of Brand Awareness on Choice for a Common, Repeat-Purchase Product,” Journal of Consumer Research, 17 (2), 141–48.
IttiLaurentKochChristofNieburErnst (1998), “A Model of Saliency-Based Visual Attention for Rapid Scene Analysis,” IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 20 (11), 1254–59.
36.
JaniszewskiChris (1998), “The Influence of Display Characteristics on Visual Exploratory Search Behavior,” Journal of Consumer Research, 25 (3), 290–301.
JohnsonGarrett A.LewisRandall A.NubbemeyerElmar I. (2017a), “Ghost Ads: Improving the Economics of Measuring Online Ad Effectiveness,” Journal of Marketing Research, 54 (6), 867–84.
JohnsonGarrett A.ShriverScott K.DuShaoyin (2020), “Consumer Privacy Choice in Online Advertising: Who Opts Out and at What Cost to Industry?” Marketing Science, 39 (1), 33–51.
41.
KaiserUlrichWrightJulian (2006), “Price Structure in Two-Sided Markets: Evidence from the Magazine Industry,” International Journal of Industrial Organization, 24 (1), 1–28.
42.
KazaiGabriellaYusofIskanderClarkeDaoud (2016), “Personalised News and Blog Recommendations Based on User Location, Facebook and Twitter User Profiling,” in Proceedings of the 39th International ACM SIGIR Conference on Research and Development in Information Retrieval. Association for Computing Machinery, 1129–32.
43.
KellerKevin Lane (1987), “Memory Factors in Advertising: The Effect of Advertising Retrieval Cues on Brand Evaluations,” Journal of Consumer Research, 14 (3), 316–33.
44.
KhurramMehreenQadeerFaisalSheerazMuhammad (2018), “The Role of Brand Recall, Brand Recognition and Price Consciousness in Understanding Actual Purchase,” Journal of Research in Social Sciences, 6 (2), 219–41.
45.
KilgerMaxRomerEllen (2007), “Do Measures of Media Engagement Correlate with Product Purchase Likelihood?” Journal of Advertising Research, 47 (3), 313–25.
46.
KireyevPavelPauwelsKoenGuptaSunil (2016), “Do Display Ads Influence Search? Attribution and Dynamics in Online Advertising,” International Journal of Research in Marketing, 33 (3), 475–90.
47.
KnoepfleDaniel T.WangJoseph Tao-yiCamererColin F. (2009), “Studying Learning in Games Using Eye-Tracking,” Journal of the European Economic Association, 7 (2–3), 388–98.
48.
KochChristofUllmanShimon (1987), “Shifts in Selective Visual Attention: Towards the Underlying Neural Circuitry,” in Matters of Intelligence: Conceptual Structures in Cognitive Neuroscience, Lucia M. Vaina, ed. Springer, 115–41.
49.
KolesarMichal (2013), “Estimation in an Instrumental Variables Model with Treatment Effect Heterogeneity,” unpublished working paper.
50.
LagunDmitryLalmasMounia (2016), “Understanding User Attention and Engagement in Online News Reading,” in Proceedings of the Ninth ACM International Conference on Web Search and Data Mining. Association for Computing Machinery, 113–22.
51.
LeeJooWonAhnJae-Hyeon (2012), “Attention to Banner Ads and Their Effectiveness: An Eye-Tracking Approach,” International Journal of Electronic Commerce, 17 (1), 119–37.
52.
LewisRandall A.ReileyDavid H. (2014), “Online Ads and Offline Sales: Measuring the Effect of Retail Advertising via a Controlled Experiment on Yahoo!” Quantitative Marketing and Economics, 12 (3), 235–66.
LohseGerald L. (1997), “Consumer Eye Movement Patterns on Yellow Pages Advertising,” Journal of Advertising, 26 (1), 61–73.
55.
LynchJohn G.Jr.MarmorsteinHowardWeigoldMichael F. (1988), “Choices from Sets Including Remembered Brands: Use of Recalled Attributes and Prior Overall Evaluations,” Journal of Consumer Research, 15 (2), 169–84.
56.
MacdonaldEmma K.SharpByron M. (2000), “Brand Awareness Effects on Consumer Decision Making for a Common, Repeat Purchase Product: A Replication,” Journal of Business Research, 48 (1), 5–15.
57.
MacKenzieScott B. (1986), “The Role of Attention in Mediating the Effect of Advertising on Attribute Importance,” Journal of Consumer Research, 13 (2), 174–95.
58.
MartinsJoséCostaCatarinaOliveiraTiagoGonçalvesRamiroBrancoFrederico (2019), “How Smartphone Advertising Influences Consumers’ Purchase Intention,” Journal of Business Research, 94, 378–87.
59.
McGranaghanMatthewLiaukonyteJuraWilburKenneth C. (2022), “How Viewer Tuning, Presence, and Attention Respond to Ad Content and Predict Brand Search Lift,” Marketing Science, 41 (5), 873–95.
60.
MeißnerMartinMusalemAndresHuberJoel (2016), “Eye Tracking Reveals Processes That Enable Conjoint Choices to Become Increasingly Efficient with Practice,” Journal of Marketing Research, 53 (1), 1–17.
61.
MilosavljevicMilicaCerfMoran (2008), “First Attention Then Intention: Insights from Computational Neuroscience of Vision,” International Journal of Advertising, 27 (3), 381–98.
62.
MosharySarahShapiroBradley T.SongJihong (2021), “How and When to Use the Political Cycle to Identify Advertising Effects,” Marketing Science, 40 (2), 283–304.
63.
NarayananSridharKalyanamKirthi (2015), “Position Effects in Search Advertising and Their Moderators: A Regression Discontinuity Approach,” Marketing Science, 34 (3), 388–407.
64.
NavalpakkamVidhyaRaoJustinSlaneyMalcolm (2011), “Using Gaze Patterns to Study and Predict Reading Struggles Due to Distraction,” in CHI’11 Extended Abstracts on Human Factors in Computing Systems. Association for Computing Machinery, 1705–10.
65.
NixonHoward Kenneth (1924), Attention and Interest in Advertising. G.E. Stechert.
PärnametsPhilipJohanssonPetterHallLarsBalkeniusChristianSpiveyMichael J.RichardsonDaniel C. (2015), “Biasing Moral Decisions by Exploiting the Dynamics of Eye Gaze,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 112 (13), 4170–75.
68.
PietersRikWedelMichel (2004), “Attention Capture and Transfer in Advertising: Brand, Pictorial, and Text-Size Effects,” Journal of Marketing, 68 (2), 36–50.
69.
PietersRikWedelMichel (2007), “Goal Control of Attention to Advertising: The Yarbus Implication,” Journal of Consumer Research, 34 (2), 224–33.
70.
PietersRikWedelMichelBatraRajeev (2010), “The Stopping Power of Advertising: Measures and Effects of Visual Complexity,” Journal of Marketing, 74 (5), 48–60.
PitlerEmilyNenkovaAni (2008), “Revisiting Readability: A Unified Framework for Predicting Text Quality,” in Proceedings of the 2008 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing, 186–95.
73.
PlassmannHilkeRamsøyThomas ZoëgaMilosavljevicMilica (2012), “Branding the Brain: A Critical Review and Outlook,” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 22 (1), 18–36.
74.
RafieianOmidYoganarasimhanHema (2021), “Targeting and Privacy in Mobile Advertising,” Marketing Science, 40 (2), 193–218.
75.
RaynerKeithRotelloCaren M.StewartAndrew J.KeirJessicaDuffySusan A. (2001), “Integrating Text and Pictorial Information: Eye Movements When Looking at Print Advertisements,” Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 7 (3), 219.
76.
RedlineCleo D.LankfordChristopher P. (2001), “Eye-Movement Analysis: A New Tool for Evaluating the Design of Visually Administered Instruments," in Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of the American Statistical Association. American Statistical Association, http://www.asasrms.org/Proceedings/y2001/Proceed/00248.pdf.
77.
ReutskajaElenaNagelRosemarieCamererColin F.RangelAntonio (2011), “Search Dynamics in Consumer Choice Under Time Pressure: An Eye-Tracking Study,” American Economic Review, 101 (2), 900–926.
78.
RussoJ. EdwardLeclercFrance (1994), “An Eye-Fixation Analysis of Choice Processes for Consumer Nondurables,” Journal of Consumer Research, 21 (2), 274–90.
79.
RutzOliver J.BucklinRandolph E.SonnierGarrett P. (2012), “A Latent Instrumental Variables Approach to Modeling Keyword Conversion in Paid Search Advertising,” Journal of Marketing Research, 49 (3), 306–19.
SahniNavdeep S. (2015), “Effect of Temporal Spacing Between Advertising Exposures: Evidence from Online Field Experiments,” Quantitative Marketing and Economics, 13 (3), 203–47.
82.
ScottNoelGreenChristineFairleySheranne (2016), “Investigation of the use of eye Tracking to Examine Tourism Advertising Effectiveness,” Current Issues in Tourism, 19 (7), 634–42.
83.
ShiSavannah WeiTrusovMichael (2021), “The Path to Click: Are You on It?” Marketing Science, 40 (2), 344–65.
84.
SimolaJaanaKuismaJarmoÖörniAnssiUusitaloLiisaHyönäJukka (2011), “The Impact of Salient Advertisements on Reading and Attention on Web Pages,” Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 17 (2), 174–90.
85.
SimonovAndreyHillShawndra (2021), “Competitive Advertising on Brand Search: Traffic Stealing and Click Quality,” Marketing Science, 40 (5), 923–45.
86.
SimonovAndreyNoskoChrisRaoJustin M. (2018), “Competition and Crowd-Out for Brand Keywords in Sponsored Search,” Marketing Science, 37 (2), 200–215.
StenforsIréneMorénJanBalkeniusChristian (2003), “Behavioural Strategies in Web Interaction: A View from Eye-Movement research,” in The Mind’s Eye: Cognitive and Applied Aspects of Eye Movement Research, Jukka Hyönä, Ralph Radach, and Heiner Deubel, eds. Elsevier, 633–44.
TeixeiraThales S.WedelMichelPietersRik (2010), “Moment-to-Moment Optimal Branding in TV Commercials: Preventing Avoidance by Pulsing,” Marketing Science, 29 (5), 783–804.
91.
TreistmanJoanGreggJohn P. (1979), “Visual, Verbal, and Sales Responses to Print Ads,” Journal of Advertising Research, 19 (4), 41–47.
92.
TuchmanAnna E.NairHarikesh S.GardetePedro M. (2018), “Television Ad-Skipping, Consumption Complementarities and the Consumer Demand for Advertising,” Quantitative Marketing and Economics, 16 (2), 111–74.
93.
UhlChristinaNaboutNadia AbouMillerKlaus (2020), “How Much Ad Viewability Is Enough? The Effect of Display Ad Viewability on Advertising Effectiveness,” arXiv preprint, https://arxiv.org/abs/2008.12132.
94.
Van der LansRalfPietersRikWedelMichel (2021), “Online Advertising Suppresses Visual Competition During Planned Purchases,” Journal of Consumer Research, 48 (3), 374–93.
WedelMichel (2015), “Attention Research in Marketing: A Review of Eye-Tracking Studies,” in The Handbook of Attention, Jonathan Fawcett, Evan Risko, and Alan Kingstone, eds. MIT Press, 569–88.
97.
WedelMichelPietersRik (2000), “Eye Fixations on Advertisements and Memory for Brands: A Model and Findings,” Marketing Science, 19 (4), 297–312.
98.
WedelMichelPietersRik (2007), “A Review of Eye-Tracking Research in Marketing,” Review of Marketing Research, 4, 123–46.
99.
WedelMichelPietersRikLiechtyJohn (2008), “Attention Switching During Scene Perception: How Goals Influence the Time Course of eye Movements Across Advertisements,” Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 14 (2), 129.
WilsonRick T.BaackDaniel W.TillBrian D. (2015), “Creativity, Attention and the Memory for Brands: An Outdoor Advertising Field Study,” International Journal of Advertising, 34 (2), 232–61.
105.
YanShunyaoMillerKlaus M.SkieraBernd (2022), “How Does the Adoption of Ad Blockers Affect News Consumption?”Journal of Marketing Research,59 (5), 1002–18.
106.
ZhangJieWedelMichelPietersRik (2009), “Sales Effects of Attention to Feature Advertisements: A Bayesian Mediation Analysis,” Journal of Marketing Research, 46 (5), 669–81.
107.
ZhangXuebaiYuanShyan-Ming (2018), “An Eye Tracking Analysis for Video Advertising: Relationship Between Advertisement Elements and Effectiveness,” IEEE Access, 6, 10699–707.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
