This article reveals how law and legal interests transform medicine. Drawing on qualitative interviews with medical professionals, this study shows how providers mobilize law and engage in investigatory work as they deliver care. Using the case of drug testing pregnant patients, I examine three mechanisms by which medico-legal hybridity occurs in clinical settings. The first mechanism, clinicalization, describes how forensic tools and methods are cast in clinical terminology, effectively cloaking their forensic intent. In the second, medical professionals informally rank the riskiness of illicit substances using both medical and criminal-legal assessments. The third mechanism describes how gender, race, and class inform forensic decision-making and criminal suspicion in maternal health. The findings show that by straddling both medical and legal domains, medicine conforms to the standards and norms of neither institution while also suspending meaningful rights for patients seeking care.
AbelErnest L.KrugerMichael. 2002. “Physician Attitudes Concerning Legal Coercion of Pregnant Alcohol and Drug Abusers.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology186(4):768–72.
2.
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. 2011. “Substance Abuse Reporting and Pregnancy: The Role of the Obstetrician–Gynecologist: Committee Opinion No. 473.”Obstetrics & Gynecology117(1):200–201.
3.
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. 2017. “Opioid Use and Opioid Use Disorder in Pregnancy: Committee Opinion No. 711.”Obstetrics & Gynecology130(2):e81–94.
BehnkeMarylouSmithVincent C., Committee on Substance Abuse, and Committee on Fetus and Newborn. 2013. “Prenatal Substance Abuse: Short- and Long-Term Effects on the Exposed Fetus.”Pediatrics131(3):e1009–24. doi:10.1542/peds.2012-3931.
6.
BourgoisPhilippeHolmesSeth M.SueKimQuesadaJames. 2017. “Structural Vulnerability: Operationalizing the Concept to Address Health Disparities in Clinical Care.”Academic Medicine92(3):299–307.
7.
BridgesKhiara. 2011. Reproducing Race: An Ethnography of Pregnancy as a Site of Racialization. Berkeley: University of California Press.
8.
BridgesKhiara. 2019. “Race, Pregnancy, and the Opioid Epidemic: White Privilege and the Criminalization of Opioid Use during Pregnancy.”Harvard Law Review133(3):770–851.
9.
CampbellNancy D.1999. “Regulating Maternal Instinct: Governing Mentalities of Late Twentieth-Century US Illicit Drug Policy.”Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society24(4):895–923.
10.
CampbellNancy. 2002. Using Women: Gender, Drug Policy, and Social Justice. New York, NY: Routledge.
11.
CharmazKathy. 2014. Constructing Grounded Theory. Los Angeles, CA: SAGE.
12.
ChasnoffIra J.LandressHarvey J.BarrettMark E.1990. “The Prevalence of Illicit-Drug or Alcohol Use during Pregnancy and Discrepancies in Mandatory Reporting in Pinellas County, Florida.”New England Journal of Medicine322(17):1202–206.
13.
ChiarelloElizabeth. 2015. “The War on Drugs Comes to the Pharmacy Counter: Frontline Work in the Shadow of Discrepant Institutional Logics.”Law & Social Inquiry40(1):86–122.
14.
ChiarelloElizabethMorrillCalvin. 2020. “A Multi-field Logics Approach to Theorizing Relationships between Healthcare and Criminal Justice.” Pp. 153–68 in Research Handbook on Socio–Legal Studies of Medicine and Health, edited by JacobM. A.KirklandA.Cheltenham, UK; Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar Publishing.
15.
CollinsPatricia Hill. 1989. “A Comparison of Two Works on Black Family Life.”Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society14(4):875–84.
16.
ConradPeter. 2007. The Medicalization of Society: On the Transformation of Human Conditions into Treatable Disorders. Baltimore, MA: Johns Hopkins University Press.
17.
DiFranzaJoseph R.AligneC. AndrewWeitzmanMichael. 2004. “Prenatal and Postnatal Environmental Tobacco Smoke Exposure and Children’s Health.”Pediatrics113(3):1007–15.
18.
Drescher-BurkeKristaPriceAmy. 2005. Responding to Substance Exposed Newborns: An Exploratory Study of Policies and Practices. Berkeley, CA: The National Abandoned Infants Assistance Resource Center.
19.
EllsworthMarc A.StevensTimothy P.D’AngioCarl T.2010. “Infant Race Affects Application of Clinical Guidelines When Screening for Drugs of Abuse in Newborns.”Pediatrics125(6):e1379–85.
20.
FeaginJoeBennefieldZinobia. 2014. “Systemic Racism and US Health Care.”Social Science & Medicine103(2104):7–14.
21.
FongKelley. 2020. “Getting Eyes in the Home: Child Protective Services Investigations and State Surveillance of Family Life.”American Sociological Review85(4):610–38.
HaneyLynne. 2010. Offending Women. Berkeley: University of California Press.
25.
HarrisLisa H.2000. “Rethinking Maternal–Fetal Conflict: Gender and Equality in Perinatal Ethics.”Obstetrics & Gynecology96(5):786–91.
26.
HeimerCarol A.1999. “Competing Institutions: Law, Medicine, and Family in Neonatal Intensive Care.”Law and Society Review30(1):17–66.
27.
HurtHallamBetancourtLaura M.MalmudElsa K.SheraDavid M.GiannettaJoan M.BrodskyNancy L.FarahMartha J.2009. “Children with and without Gestational Cocaine Exposure: A Neurocognitive Systems Analysis.”Neurotoxicology and Teratology31(6):334–41.
28.
Illinois Abused and Neglected Child Reporting Act of 1975, 325 ILCS 5/4.4 (1975).
29.
IrnerTina Birk. 2012. “Substance Exposure in Utero and Developmental Consequences in Adolescence: A Systematic Review.”Child Neuropsychology18(6):521–49.
30.
JarvisMargaretWilliamsJessicaHurfordMatthewLindsayDawnLincolnPiperGilesLeilaLuongoPeterSafarianTaleen. 2017. “Appropriate Use of Drug Testing in Clinical Addiction Medicine.”Journal of Addiction Medicine11(3):163–73.
31.
KuninsHillary VedaBellinEranChazotteCynthiaDuEvelynArnstenJulia Hope. 2007. “The Effect of Race on Provider Decisions to Test for Illicit Drug Use in the Peripartum Setting.”Journal of Women’s Health16(2):245–55.
32.
ManzerJamie L.BellAnn V.2021. “‘We’re a Little Biased’: Medicine and the Management of Bias through the Case of Contraception.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior62(2):120–35.
33.
Lara-MillánArmando. 2014. “Public Emergency Room Overcrowding in the Era of Mass Imprisonment.”American Sociological Review79(5):866–87.
34.
LunaZakiyaLukerKristin. 2013. “Reproductive Justice.”Annual Review of Law and Social Science9(1):327–52.
35.
McKimAllison. 2014. “Roxanne’s Dress: Governing Gender and Marginality through Addiction Treatment.”Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society39(2):433–58.
36.
MillerCatherineLanhamAmyWelshChristopherRamanadhanShaaliniTerplanMishka. 2014. “Screening, Testing, and Reporting for Drug and Alcohol Use on Labor and Delivery: A Survey of Maryland Birthing Hospitals.”Social Work in Health Care53(7):659–69.
37.
MoellerKaren E.LeeKelly C.KissackJulie C.2008. “Urine Drug Screening: Practical Guide for Clinicians.”Mayo Clinic Proceedings83(1):66–76.
NetherlandJulieHansenHelena. 2017. “White Opioids: Pharmaceutical Race and the War on Drugs That Wasn’t.”BioSocieties12(2):217–38.
40.
OstermanMichelleMartinJoyce. 2018. “Timing and Adequacy of Prenatal Care in the United States, 2016.”National Vital Statistics Reports67(3):1–14.
41.
PaltrowLynn M.FlavinJeanne. 2013. “Arrests of and Forced Interventions on Pregnant Women in the United States, 1973–2005: Implications for Women’s Legal Status and Public Health.”Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law38(2):299–343.
ReinarmanCraigLevineHarry G.2004. “Crack in the Rearview Mirror: Deconstructing Drug War Mythology.”Social Justice31(1/2):182–99.
44.
ReynoldsLawrence A.2005. “Historical Aspects of Drugs-of-Abuse Testing in the United States.” Pp. 1–10 in Drugs of Abuse: Body Fluid Testing, edited by WongR. C.HarleyY. T.Totowa, NJ: Humana Press.
45.
RobertsDorothy E.1999. Killing the Black Body: Race, Reproduction, and the Meaning of Liberty. New York, NY: Vintage Books.
46.
RobertsDorothy E.2002. Shattered Bonds: The Color of Child Welfare. New York, NY: Basic Civitas Books.
47.
RobertsSarah C. M.PiesCheri. 2011. “Complex Calculations: How Drug Use during Pregnancy Becomes a Barrier to Prenatal Care.”Maternal and Child Health Journal15(3):333–41.
48.
RobertsSarah C. M.ZahndE.SufrinCarolynArmstrongM. A.2015. “Does Adopting a Prenatal Substance Use Protocol Reduce Racial Disparities in CPS Reporting Related to Maternal Drug Use? A California Case Study.”Journal of Perinatology35(2):146–50.
49.
SchiffDavida M.NielsenTimothyTerplanMishkaHoodMalenaBernsonDanaDiopHafsatouBharelMonica, et al2018. “Fatal and Nonfatal Overdose among Pregnant and Postpartum Women in Massachusetts.”Obstetrics and Gynecology132(2):466–74.
50.
StoneRebecca. 2015. “Pregnant Women and Substance Use: Fear, Stigma, and Barriers to Care.”Health & Justice3(1):1–15.
51.
StuddertDavid M.MelloMichelle M.SageWilliam M.DesRochesCatherine M.PeughJordonZapertKingaBrennanTroyen A.2005. “Defensive Medicine among High-Risk Specialist Physicians in a Volatile Malpractice Environment.”JAMA293(21):2609–17.
52.
Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. 2012. Clinical Drug Testing in Primary Care: Technical Assistance Publication (TAP) 32. HHS Publication No. (SMA) 12-4668. Rockville, MD: Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration.
53.
SweetPaige L.2019. “The Paradox of Legibility: Domestic Violence and Institutional Survivorhood”. Social Problems66(3):411–27.
54.
TerplanMishkaMinkoffHoward. 2017. “Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome and Ethical Approaches to the Identification of Pregnant Women Who Use Drugs.”Obstetrics & Gynecology129(1):164–67.
55.
TigerRebecca. 2012. Judging Addicts: Drug Courts and Coercion in the Justice System. New York: NYU Press.
56.
TimmermansStefanAngellAlison. 2001. “Evidence-Based Medicine, Clinical Uncertainty, and Learning to Doctor.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior42(4):342–59.
57.
TimmermansStefanGabeJonathan. 2002. “Introduction: Connecting Criminology and Sociology of Health and Illness.”Sociology of Health & Illness24(5):501–16.
VulliamyAnne P.SullivanRichard. 2000. “Reporting Child Abuse: Pediatricians’ Experiences with the Child Protection System.”Child Abuse & Neglect24(11):1461–70.
60.
WarnerElizabeth A.WalkerRobert M.FriedmannPeter D.2003. “Should Informed Consent Be Required for Laboratory Testing for Drugs of Abuse in Medical Settings?”The American Journal of Medicine115(1):54–58.
61.
WilsonJames Maxwell GloverJungnerGunnar1968. Principles and Practice of Screening for Disease. Geneva: World Health Organization.
62.
WoodElissa. 2006. The Costs and Utility of Parental Drug-Testing in Child Protection: A Review of the Available Literature and Commentary. Sydney: National Drug and Alcohol Research Centre.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
