Using an intersectional lens, we investigate how an offender’s race and gender influence perceptions of and reactions to displays of remorse in jurors’ decision-making processes. Drawing on an experiment of a mock criminal trial (N = 1,155), we find that despite perceiving remorse equally across Black and White women and men, respondents rewarded all but Black men for displaying remorse, assigning significantly lighter sentences to remorseful offenders than their nonremorseful White and woman counterparts. Our results illustrate how emotions are used to reinforce existing racial hierarchies and that remorse is a gendered and racialized emotion.
AndersonElijah. 1999. Code of the Street: Decency, Violence, and Moral Life of the Inner City. New York, NY: W.W. Norton & Company.
2.
AndersonJoel R.HollandEliseHeldrethCourtneyJohnsonScott P.2018. “Revisiting the Jezebel Stereotype: The Impact of Target Race on Sexual Objectification.”Psychology of Women Quarterly42(4):461–76.
3.
AnsonIan G.2018. “Taking the Time? Explaining Effortful Participation among Low-Cost Online Survey Participants.”Research and Politics5(3):1–8.
4.
BagaricMirkoAmarasekaraKumar. 2001. “Feeling Sorry? Tell Someone Who Cares: The Irrelevance of Remorse in Sentencing.”Howard Journal of Crime and Justice40(4):364–76.
5.
BandesSusan A.2016. “Remorse and Criminal Justice.”Emotion Review8(1):14–19.
6.
BibasStephanosBierschbachRichard A.2004. “Integrating Remorse and Apology into Criminal Procedure.”Yale Law Journal114:85–148.
7.
BlairIreneV.2002. “The Malleability of Automatic Stereotypes and Prejudice.”Personality and Social Psychology Review6(3):242–61.
8.
BolerMegan. 1999. Feeling Power: Emotions and Education. New York, NY: Routledge.
9.
Bonilla-SilvaEduardo. 2019. “Feeling Race: Theorizing the Racial Economy of Emotions.”American Sociological Review84(1):1–25.
10.
BowersWilliam J.SteinerBenjamin D.MarlaSandys. 2001. “Death Sentencing in Black and White: An Empirical Analysis of the Role of Jurors’ Race and Jury Racial Composition.”University of Pennsylvania Journal of Constitutional Law3:171–275.
11.
BrescollVictoria L.UhlmannEric L.2008. “Can an Angry Women Get Ahead? Status Conferral, Gender, and Expression of Emotion in the Workplace.”Psychological Science19(3):268–75.
12.
BridgesTristanPascoeC. J.2014. “Hybrid Masculinities: New Directions in the Sociology of Men and Masculinities.”Sociology Compass8(3):246–58.
13.
CollinsPatricia Hill. 2004. Black Sexual Politics: African Americans, Gender, and the New Racism. New York, NY: Routledge.
14.
DilksLisa M.McGrimmonTucker S.ThyeShane R.2015. “Status, Emotional Display, and the Relationally-Based Evaluation of Criminal and Their Behavior.”Social Science Research50:246–63.
15.
DowMarie D.2016. “The Deadly Challenges of Raising African American Boys: Navigating the Controlling Image of the ‘Thug.’”Gender and Society30(2):161–88.
16.
DuncanMartha G.2002. “So Young and So Untender: Remorseless Children and the Expectation of the Law.”Columbia Law Review102:1469–526.
17.
DurrMarleseWingfieldAdia H.2011. “Keep Your ‘N’ in Check: African American Women and the Interactive Effects of Etiquette and Emotional Labor.”Critical Sociology37(5):557–71.
18.
ElfenbeinHillary AngerNaliniAmbady. 2002. “On the Universality and Cultural Specificity of Emotion Recognition: A Meta-analysis.”Psychological Bulletin128(2):203–35.
19.
EvansLouwandaMooreWendy L.2015. “Impossible Burdens: White Institutions, Emotional Labor, and Micro-resistance.”Social Problems62(3):439–54.
20.
FergusonAnn Arnett. 2001. Bad Boys: Public School in the Making of Black Masculinity. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
21.
FischerAgneta H.AntonyMansteadCatharineEversMoniqueTimmersGuidoValk. 2004. “Motives and Norms Underlying Emotion Regulation.” Pp. 187–210 in The Regulation of Emotion, edited by PhilippotP.FeldmanR. S.Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
22.
FiskeSusan T.CuddyAmy J.GlickPeterJunXu. 2002. “A Model of (Often Mixed) Stereotype Content: Competence and Warmth Respectively Follow from Perceived Status and Competition.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology82(6):878–902.
23.
GaddisMichael S.2017. “How Black Are Lakisha and Jamal? Racial Perceptions from Names Used in Correspondence Audit Studies.”Sociological Science4:469–89.
24.
GoffmanErving. 1969. “The Insanity of Place.”Psychiatry: Interpersonal and Biological Processes32(4):357–88.
25.
Gonzalez Van CleveNicole. 2016. Crook County: Racism and Injustice in America’s Largest Criminal Court. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
26.
HananM. Eve. 2018. “Remorse Bias.”Missouri Law Review83:301–58.
27.
HandronCaitlinKirbyTeri A.WangJenniferMatskewichHelen E.CheryanSapna. 2017. “Unexpected Gains: Being Overweight Buffers Asian Americans from Prejudice against Foreigners.”Psychological Science28(9):1214–27.
28.
HeiseDavid R.1979. Understanding Events: Affect and the Construction of Social Action. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
29.
HeiseDavid R.2007. Expressive Order: Confirming Sentiments in Social Actions. New York, NY: Springer.
30.
Hutson-ComeauxSarah L.KellyJanice R.2002. “Gender Stereotypes of Emotional Reactions: How We Judge an Emotion as Valid.”Sex Roles47:1–10.
31.
JacksonBrandon A.2018. “Beyond the Cool Pose: Black Men and Emotion Management Strategies.”Sociology Compass12(4):e12569. doi:10.1111/soc4.12569.
KellyJanice R.Hutson-ComeauxSarah L.2000. “The Appropriateness of Emotional Expression in Women and Men: The Double-Bind of Emotion.”Journal of Social Behavior and Personality15(4):515–28.
34.
KendiIbram X.2019. How to Be an Antiracist. London: Bodley Head.
35.
KilbourneBarbaraEnglandPaulaBeronKurt. 1994. “Effects of Individual, Occupational, and Industrial Characteristics on Earnings: Intersections of Race and Gender.”Social Forces72(4):1149–76.
36.
KiviatBarbara. 2019. “The Moral Limits of Predictive Practices: The Case of Credit-Based Insurance Scores.”American Sociological Review84(6):1134–58.
37.
LivingstonRobert W.PearceNicholas A.2009. “The Teddy-Bear Effect: Does Having a Baby Face Benefit Black Chief Executive Officers?”Psychological Science20(10):1229–36.
38.
LivingstonRobert W.AshleighShelby RosetteWashingtonElla F.2012. “Can an Agentic Black Woman Get Ahead? The Impact of Race and Interpersonal Dominance on Perceptions of Female Leaders.”Psychological Science23(4):354–58.
39.
MacKinnonNeil J.RobinsonDawn T.2014. “Back to the Future: 25 Years of Research in Affect Control Theory.”Advances in Group Processes31:139–73.
40.
MajorsRichardBillsonJanet M.1992. Cool Pose: The Dilemmas of Black Manhood in America. New York, NY: New York University Press.
41.
ManagoBiancaMizeTrenton D.DoanLong. 2021. “Can You Really Study an Army on the Internet? Comparing How Status Tasks Perform in the Laboratory and Online Settings.”Sociological Methodology51(2):319–47.
42.
MatsumotoDavid. 1993. “Ethnic Differences in Affect Intensity, Emotion Judgments, Display Rule Attitudes, and Self-Reported Emotional Expression in an American Sample.”Motivation and Emotion17:107–23.
43.
MessnerMichael. 1993. “‘Changing Men’ and Feminist Politics in the United States.”Theory and Society22:723–37.
44.
MizeTrenton D.2019. “Best Practices for Estimating, Interpreting, and Presenting Nonlinear Interaction Effects.”Sociological Science6:81–117.
45.
MotroDaphnaEvansJonathan B.EllisAleksander P.J.LehmanBensonIII. 2022. “Race and Reactions to Women’s Expressions of Anger at Work: Examining the Effects of the ‘Angry Black Woman’ Stereotype.”Journal of Applied Psychology107(1):142–52.
46.
OngMaria. 2005. “Body Projects of Young Women of Color in Physics: Intersections of Gender, Race, and Science.”Social Problems52(4):593–617.
47.
PaolacciGabrieleChandlerJesse. 2014. “Inside the Turk: Understanding Mechanic Turk as a Participant Pool.”Current Directions in Psychological Science23(3):184–88.
48.
PedullaDavid S.2014. “The Positive Consequences of Negative Stereotypes: Race, Sexual Orientation, and the Job Application Process.”Social Psychology Quarterly77(1):75–94.
49.
PhelpsEdmund S.1972. “The Statistical Theory of Racism and Sexism.”The American Economic Review62(4):659–61.
50.
PierceJennifer L.1995. Gender Trials: Emotional Lives of Contemporary Law Firm. Berkeley: University of California Press.
51.
PierceJennifer L.1999. “Emotional Labor among Paralegals.”Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science561(1):127–42.
52.
PotterHillary. 2015. Intersectionality and Criminology: Disrupting and Revolutionizing Studies of Crime. Abingdon, UK: Routledge.
53.
Purdie-VaughnsValerie J.EibachRichard P.2008. “Intersectional Invisibility: The Distinctive Advantages and Disadvantages of Multiple Subordinate-Group Identities.”Sex Roles59:377–91.
54.
RayVictor. 2019. “A Theory of Racialized Organizations.”American Sociological Review84(1):26–53.
55.
RidgewayCecilia L.TamarKricheli-Katz. 2013. “Intersecting Cultural Beliefs in Social Relations: Gender, Race, and Class Binds and Freedoms.”Gender and Society27(3):294–318.
56.
RobinsonDawn T.LynnSmith-Lovin. 1999. “Emotion Display as a Strategy for Identity Negotiation.”Motivation and Emotion23:73–104.
57.
RobinsonDawn T.LynnSmith-LovinOlgaTsoudis. 1994. “Heinous Crime or Unfortunate Accident? The Effects of Remorse in Response to Mock Criminal Confessions.”Social Forces73(1):175–90.
58.
RosetteAshleigh S.LivingstonRobert W.2012. “Failure Is Not an Option for Black Women: Effects of Organizational Performance on Leaders with Single versus Dual-Subordinate Identities.”Journal of Experimental Social Psychology48(5):1162–67.
59.
SapersteinAliyaPennerAndrew M.2012. “Racial Fluidity and Inequality in the United States.”American Journal of Sociology118(3):676–727.
60.
SchwartzJenniferRookeyBryan D.2008. “The Narrowing Gender Gap in Arrests: Assessing Competing Explanations Using Self-Report, Traffic Fatality, and Official Data on Drunk Driving, 1980-2004.”Criminology46(3):637–71.
61.
SeskoAmanda K.MonicaBiernat. 2010. “Prototypes of Race and Gender: The Invisibility of Black Women.”Journal of Experimental Social Psychology46(2):356–60.
62.
ShieldsStephanie A.2002. Speaking from the Heart: Gender and the Social Meaning of Emotion. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
63.
SmithJacqueline S.BrescollVictoria L.ThomasErin L.2016. “Constrained by Emotion: Women, Leadership, and Expressing Emotion in the Workplace.” Pp. 209–24 in Handbook on Well-Being of Working Women, edited by ConnerleyM. L.DordrechtJ. Wu.Netherlands: Springer.
64.
SrivastavaSarita. 2006. “Tears, Fears and Careers: Racism and Emotion in Social Movement Organizations.”The Canadian Journal of Sociology31:55–90.
65.
SteenslandBrian. 2006. “Cultural Categories and the American Welfare State: The Case of Guaranteed Income Policy.”American Journal of Sociology111(5):1273–326.
66.
StuartForrestBenezraAva. 2018. “Criminalized Masculinities: How Policing Shapes the Construction of Gender and Sexuality in Poor Black Communities.”Social Problems65(2):174–90.
67.
TangneyJune P.JeffStuewigMashekDebra J.2007. “Moral Emotions and Moral Behavior.”Annual Review of Psychology58:345–72.
68.
TinklerJustine E.JunZhaoLiYan E.CeciliaRidgeway. 2019. “Honorary Whites? Asian American Women and the Dominance Penalty.”Socius5. doi:10.1177/2378023119836000.
69.
TsaiJeanne L.YuliaChentsova-DuttonFreire-BebeauLiliananPrzymusDiane E.2002. “Emotional Expression and Physiology in European Americans and Hmong Americans.”Emotion2(4):380–97.
70.
TsoudisOlgaSmith-LovinLynn. 1998. “How Bad Was It? The Effects of Victim and Defendant Emotion on Responses to Criminal Court Vignettes.”Social Forces77(2):695–722.
71.
TsoudisOlgaSmith-LovinLynn. 2001. “Criminal Identity: The Key to Situational Construals in Mock Criminal Court Cases.”Sociological Spectrum21(1):3–31.
72.
TudorSteven K.2008. “Why Should Remorse be a Mitigating Factor in Sentencing.”Criminal Law and Philosophy2:241–57.
WarnerLeah R.ShieldsStephanie A.2007. “The Perception of Crying in Women and Men: Angry Tears, Sad Tears, and the ‘Right Way’ to Cry.” Pp. 92–117 in Group Dynamics and Emotional Expression, edited by HessU.PhilippotP.New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
75.
WeinbergJillFreeseJeremyMcElhattanDavid. 2014. “Comparing Data Characteristics and Results of an Online Factorial Survey between a Population Based and a Crowdsource-Recruited Sample.”Sociological Science1:292–310.
76.
WeismanRichard. 2014. Showing Remorse: Law and the Social Control of Emotion. Farnham, UK: Ashgate Press.
77.
WelhausenCandice. 2019. “Precarious Data: Crack, Opioids, and Visualizing a Drug Abuse Epidemic.”Online Journal of Public Health Informatics11:e315. doi:10.5210/ojphi.v11i1.9687.
78.
WilkinsAmy C.2012. “Not to Start a Revolution: Race, Gender, and Emotional Restraint among Black University Men.”Journal of Contemporary Ethnography41:34–65.
79.
WingfieldAdia H.2010. “Are Some Emotions Marked ‘Whites Only’? Racialized Feeling Rules in Professional Workplaces.”Social Problems57:251–68.
80.
WingfieldAdia H.2013. No More Invisible Men: Race and Gender in Men’s Work. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
81.
WingfieldAdia H.2021. “The (Un)Managed Heart: Racial Contours of Emotion Work in Gendered Occupations.”Annual Review of Sociology47:197–212.
82.
WingfieldAdia H.AlstonRenée S.2014. “Maintaining Hierarchies in Predominantly White Organizations: A Theory of Racial Tasks.”American Behavioral Scientist58:247–87.
83.
ZawadzkiMatthew J.WarnerLeah R.ShieldsStephanie A.2013. “Sadness Is Believed to Signal Competence When Displayed with Passionate Restraint.”Social Psychology44:219–30.
84.
ZhaoJunRogalinChristabel L.2017. “Heinous Crime or Unfortunate Incident: Does Gender Matter?”Social Psychology Quarterly80:330–41.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
