Seeking to explain divergent empirical findings regarding the direct effect of social support on well-being, the authors posit that the pattern of supportive exchange (i.e., reciprocal, under-, or over-reciprocating) determines the impact of receiving support on well-being. Findings generated on the basis of longitudinal data collected from a sample of older blue-collar workers support the authors’ predictions, indicating that receiving emotional support is associated with enhanced well-being when the pattern of supportive exchange is perceived by an individual as being reciprocal (support received equals support given), with this association being weaker when the exchange of support is perceived as being under-reciprocating (support given exceeds support received). Moreover, receiving support was found to adversely affect well-being when the pattern of exchange was perceived as being over-reciprocating (support received exceeds support given). Theoretical and practical implications of these findings are discussed.
AdamsJ. Stacy. 1963. “Toward an Understanding of Inequity.” Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology67:422–36.
2.
AntonucciToni C.FuhrerRebeccaJacksonJames S.1990. “Social Support and Reciprocity: A Cross-Ethic and Cross National Perspective.” Journal of Social and Personal Relationships7:519–30.
3.
BacharachSamuel B.BambergerPeter A.McKinneyValerie. 2000. “Boundary Management Tactics and Logics of Action: The Case of Peer Support.” Administrative Science Quarterly45:704–36.
4.
BacharachSamuel B.BambergerPeter A.SonnenstuhlWilliam J.1994. Member Assistance Programs: The Role of Labor in the Prevention and Treatment of Substance Abuse. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
5.
BacharachSamuel B.BambergerPeter A.SonnenstuhlWilliam J.2001. Mutual Aid and Union Renewal: Cycles of Logics of Action. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
6.
BacharachSamuel B.BambergerPeter A.VashdiDanna. 2005. “Diversity and Homophily at Work: Supportive Relations among White and African-American Peers.” Academy of Management Journal48:619–44.
7.
BaltesPaul B.BaltesMargret M.1990. “Psychological Perspectives on Successful Aging: The Model of Selective Optimization with Compensation.” Pp. 1–34 in Successful Aging: Perspectives from the Behavioral Sciences, edited by BaltesP. B.BaltesM. M.New York: Cambridge University Press.
8.
BarreraManuelSandlerIrwin N.RamsayThomat B.1981. “Preliminary Development of a Scale of Social Support: Studies on College Students.” American Journal of Community Psychology9:435–47.
9.
BatsonC. Daniel. 1998. “Altruism and Prosocial Behavior.” Pp. 282–316 in The Handbook of Social Psychology, edited by GilbertD. T.FiskeS. T.LindzeyG.New York: McGraw-Hill.
10.
BeehrTerry A.FarmerSuzanne J.GlazerSaronGudanowskiDavid M.NairVandana N.2003. “The Enigma of Social Support and Occupational Stress: Source Congruence and Gender Role Effects.” Journal of Occupational Health Psychology8:220–31.
11.
BlauPeter. 1964. Exchange and Power in Social Life. New York: John Wiley.
12.
BloomJoan R.StewartSusan L.JohnstonMonicaBanksPriscillaFobairPatricia. 2001. “Sources of Support and the Physical and Mental Well-Being of Young Women with Breast Cancer.” Social Science and Medicine53:1513–524.
13.
BolgerNiallFosterMarkAmiramVinokur D.RosannaNg. 1996. “Close Relationships and Adjustment to a Life Crisis: The Case of Breast Cancer.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology70:283–94.
14.
BolgerNiallZuckermanAdamKesslerRonald C.2000. “Invisible Support and Adjustment to Stress.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology79:953–61.
15.
BowlingNathan A.BeehrTerry A.JohnsonAdam L.SemmerNorbert K.HendricksElizabeth A.WebsterHeather A.2004. “Explaining Potential Antecedents of Workplace Social Support: Reciprocity or Attractiveness?” Journal of Occupational Health Psychology9:339–50.
16.
BuunkBram P.DoosjeBert J.JansLiesbeth G. J. M.HopstakenLiliane E.M.1993. “Perceived Reciprocity, Social Support, and Stress at Work: The Role of Exchange and Communal Orientation.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology65:801–11.
17.
BuunkBram P.PrinsKarin S.1998. “Loneliness, Exchange Orientation, and Reciprocity in Friendships.” Personal Relationships5:1–14.
18.
CaplanRobert D.CobbSidneyFrenchJohn R. P.Van HarrisonR.PinneauRichard S.1975. Job Demands and Workers Health: Main Effects and Occupational Differences. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare.
19.
CohenAyalaNahum-ShaniInbalDovehEtti. 2010. “Further Insight and Additional Inference Methods for Polynomial Regression Applied to the Analysis of Congruence.” Multivariate Behavioral Research45:828–52.
20.
CohenJacobCohenPatricia. 1983. Applied Multiple Regression/Correlation Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
21.
CohenSheldon. 2004. “Social Relationships and Health.” American Psychologist59:676–84.
22.
DykstraPearl A.1995. “Network Composition.” Pp. 97–114 in Living Arrangements and Social Networks of Older Adults, edited by KnipscheerC. P. M.de Jong GierveldJ.van TilburgT. G.DykstraP. A.Amsterdam: Free University Press.
23.
EdwardsJeffrey R.2001. “Ten Difference Score Myths.” Organizational Research Methods4:265–87.
24.
FischerClaude S.ShavitYossi. 1995. “National Differences in Network Density: Israel and the United States.” Social Networks17:129–45.
25.
FreedyJohn R.HobfollSteven E.RibbeDavid P.1994. “Life Events, War and Adjustment: Lessons for the Middle East.” Anxiety, Stress and Coping: An International Journal7:191–203.
26.
GleasonMarci E. J.IidaMasumiBolgerNiallShroutPatrick E.2003. “Daily Supportive Equity in Close Relationships.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin29:1036–045.
27.
GouldnerAlvin W.1960. “The Norms of Reciprocity: A Preliminary Statement.” American Sociological Review25:161–78.
28.
GrantAdam M.DuttonJane E.RossoBrent. 2008. “Giving Commitment: Employee Support Programs and the Prosocial Sensemaking Process.” Academy of Management Journal51:898–918.
29.
HeaphyEmily D.DuttonJane E.2008. “Positive Social Interactions and the Human Body at Work: Linking Organizations and Physiology.” Academy of Management Review33:137–62.
30.
HobfollSteven E.1989. “Conservation of Resources: A New Attempt at Conceptualizing Stress.” American Psychologist44:513–24.
31.
HobfollSteven E.2002. “Social and Psychological Resources and Adaptation.” Review of General Psychology6:307–24.
32.
HomansGeorge. 1958. “Social Behavior as Exchange.” American Journal of Sociology62:597–606.
33.
Ingersoll-DaytonBeritAntonucciToni C.1988. “Reciprocal and Nonreciprocal Social Support: Contrasting Sides of Intimate Relationships.” Journal of Gerontology43:S65–73.
34.
JouYuh H.FukadaHiromi. 2002. “Stress, Health, and Reciprocity and Sufficiency of Social Support: The Case of University Students in Japan.” The Journal of Social Psychology142:353–70.
35.
KelleyHarold H.BerscheidEllenChristensenAndrew A.HarveyJohn H.HustonTed L.LevingerGeorgeMcClintockEviePeplauLetitia A.PetersonDonald R.1983. Close Relationships. New York: Freeman.
36.
KesslerRonald C.2003. “Epidemiology of Women and Depression.” Journal of Affective Disorders74:5–13.
37.
Klein IkkinkKarenvan TilburgTheo. 1999. “Broken Ties: Reciprocity and Other Factors Affecting the Termination of Older Adults’ Relationships.” Social Networks21:131–46.
38.
KlocknerChristian A.MatthiesEllen. 2004. “How Habits Interfere with Norm-Directed Behaviour: A Normative Decision-Making Model for Travel Mode Choice.” Journal of Environmental Psychology24:319–27.
39.
KrauseNealBorawski-ElaineElaine. 1995. “Social Class Differences in Social Support among Older Adults.” The Gerontologist35:498–508.
40.
LatkinCarl A.CurryAaron D.2003. “Stressful Neighborhood and Depression: A Prospective Study of the Impact of Neighborhood Disorder.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior44:34–44.
41.
LeeFiona. 1997. “When The Going Get Tough, Do the Tough Ask for Help? Help Seeking and Power Motivation in Organization.” Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes72:336–63.
42.
LiangJerseyKrauseNealBennetJoan M.2001. “Social Exchange and Well-Being: Is Giving Better than Receiving?” Psychology and Aging16:511–23.
43.
LincolnKaren D.ChattersLinda M.TaylorRobert J.2005. “Social Support, Traumatic Events, and Depressive Symptoms among African Americans.” Journal of Marriage and Family67:754–66.
44.
LuLuo. 1997. “Social Support, Reciprocity, and Well-Being.” The Journal of Social Psychology137:618–28.
45.
MeilichOfer. 2006. “Bivariate Models of Fit in Contingency Theory.” Organizational Research Methods9:161–93.
46.
MitchellRoger E.TrickettEdison J.1980. “Task Force Report: Social Networks as Mediators of Social Support.” Community Mental Health Journal16:27–44.
47.
MorganDavid L.SchusterTonya L.ButlerEdgar W.1991. “Role Reversals in the Exchange of Social Support.” Journal of Gerontology46:278–87.
48.
NadlerArie. 1990. “Help-Seeking Behavior as a Coping Resource.” Pp. 127–62 in Learned Resourcefulness: On Coping Skills, Self-Control and Adaptive Behavior, edited by RosenbaumM.New York: Springer.
49.
RadloffLenore S.1977. “The CES-D Scale: A Self Report Depression Scale for Research in the General Population.” Applied Psychological Measurement1:385–401.
50.
RookKaren S.1987. “Reciprocity of Social Exchange and Social Satisfaction among Older Woman.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology52:145–54.
51.
RosenbergMorrisMcCulloughClair B.1981. “Mattering: Inferred Significance and Mental Health among Adolescents.” Research in Community and Mental Health2:163–82.
52.
RugosaDavid. 1980. “A Critique of Cross-Lagged Correlation.” Psychological Bulletin88:245–58.
53.
SarasonBarbara R.SarasonIrwin G.GurungRegan A.R.1997. “Close Personal Relationships and Heath Outcomes: A Key to the Role of Social Support.” Pp. 547–73 in Handbook of Personal Relationships, edited by DuckS.New York: John Wiley.
54.
SherbourneCathy D.HaysRon D.1990. “Material Status, Social Support, and Health Transitions in Chronic Disease Patients.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior31:328–43.
55.
SiebertDarcy C.MutranElizabeth J.ReitzesDonald C.1999. “Friendships and Social Support: The Importance of Role Identity to Aging Adults.” Social Work44:522–33.
56.
SongLijunLinNan. 2009. “Social Capital and Health Inequality: Evidence from Taiwan.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior50:149–63.
57.
StephensMary Ann. 1990. “Social Relationships as Coping Resources in Later Life Families.” Pp. 1–20 in Stress and Coping in Later Life Families, edited by StephensM. A.New York: Hemisphere Publishing Company.
58.
TaylorJohnTurnerJay R.2001. “A Longitudinal Study of the Role and Significance of Mattering to Others for Depressive Symptoms.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior42:310–25.
59.
ThoitsPeggy A.1982. “Life Stress, Social Support, and Psychological Vulnerability: Epidemiological Considerations.” Journal of Community Psychology10:341–62.
60.
ThoitsPeggy. 1995. “Stress, Coping and Social Support Processes: Where Are We? What Next?” Journal of Health and Social Behavior35:53–79.
61.
TryfanBarbara. 1992. “Family Support to Elderly People in Poland.” Pp. 160–70 in Family Support for the Elderly: The International Experience, edited by KendigH. L.Hashimoto, A.CoppardL. C.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
62.
TurnerHeather A.1994. “Gender and Social Support: Taking the Bad with the Good?” Sex Roles30:521–41.
63.
UmbersonDebraChenMeichu D.JamesHouseHopkinsKristineSlatenEllen. 1996. “The Effect of Social Relationships on Psychological Well-Being: Are Men and Women Really so Different?” American Sociological Review61:837–57.
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. 2009b. “Union Members in 2008 (USDL 09–0095).” Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Labor. Retrieved July 1, 2009 (http://www.bls.gov/news.release/union2.t01.htm).
66.
VäänänenAriBuunkBram P.KivimakiMikaPenttiJaanaVahteraJussi. 2005. “When It Is Better to Give Than to Receive: Long-Term Effects of Perceived Reciprocity in Support Exchange.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology89:176–93.
67.
Van TilburgTheovon SonderenEricOrmelJohan. 1991. “The Measurement of Reciprocity in Ego-Centered Networks of Personal Relationships: A Comparison of Various Indices.” Social Psychology Quarterly54:54–66.
68.
VerbruggeLois M.1983. “A Research Note on Adult Friendship Contact: A Dyadic Perspective.” Social Forces62:78–83.
69.
WalsterElaineWalsterWilliam G.BerscheidEllen. 1978. Equity: Theory and Research. Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon.
70.
WengerClare G.1986. “A Longitudinal Study of Change and Adaptation in the Support Networks of Welsh Elderly Over 75.” Journal of Cross Cultural Gerontology1:277–304.
71.
WrightErik OlinChoDonmoon. 1992. “The Relative Permeability of Class Boundaries to Cross-Class Friendships: A Comparative Study of the United States, Canada, Sweden, and Norway.” American Sociological Review57:85–102.
72.
ZettelLaura A.RookKaren S.2004. “Substitution and Compensation in the Social Networks of Older Widowed Women.” Psychology and Aging19:433–43.
