What explains the use of military conscription? Using a new data set of more than 100 countries over a period of 200 years, we examine the determinants of a state’s decision to implement a military draft. We argue that the decision to use conscription is largely dependent on historical factors. Specifically, we contend that former British colonies are less likely to use conscription as a means of military recruitment because of an anticonscription precedent set during the English Civil War. We find that former British colonies are far less likely to opt for conscription, even after controlling for counter arguments relating to a state’s colonial legacy. We also examine a number of existing explanations for the use of conscripts, using the data to arbitrate previous debates. We find that democracies are less likely to implement the draft, while states involved in an interstate war or interstate rivalry are more likely to do so.
AcemogluDaronJohnsonSimonRobinsonJames A.. 2001. “The Colonial Origins of Comparative Development: An Empirical Investigation.” American Economic Review91:1369–1401.
2.
AdamAntonis. 2012. “Military Conscription as a Means of Stabilizing Democratic Regimes.” Public Choice150 (3-4): 715–30.
AndersonMartin, ed. 1982. The Military Draft: Selected Readings on Conscription. Stanford, CA: Hoover Institution Press.
5.
AvantDeborah. 2000. “From Mercenary to Citizen Armies: Explaining Change in the Practice of War.” International Organization54 (1): 41–72.
6.
BeattieP. M.2001. The Tribute of Blood: Army, Honor, Race, and Nation in Brazil, 1864-1945. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
7.
BeckNathanielKatzJonathan N.. 1997. The Analysis of Binary Time-series-cross-section Data and/or the Democratic Peace. Annual meeting of the Political Methodology Group, Columbus, OH.
8.
BeckNathanielKatzJonathan N.TuckerRichard. 1998. “Taking Time Seriously: Time-series-cross-section Analysis with a Binary Dependent Variable.” American Journal of Political Science42 (4): 1260–88.
9.
BeckettIan. 1985. “The Nation in Arms, 1914-18.” In A Nation in Arms: A Social Study of the British Army in the First World War, edited by BeckettIan F. W.SimpsonKeith, 1–35. Manchester, UK: Manchester University Press.
10.
BeringerRichard E.JonesArcherStillWilliam N.Jr.1991. Why the South Lost the Civil War. Athens: University of Georgia Press.
11.
BernhardMichaelReenockChristopherNordstromTimothy. 2004. “The Legacy of Western Overseas Colonialism on Democratic Survival.” International Studies Quarterly48 (1): 225–50.
12.
BeukemaHerman. 1982. “The Social and Political Aspects of Conscription: Europe’s Experience.” In The Military Draft: Selected Readings on Conscription, edited by AndersonMartinHoneggerBarbara, 479–91. Stanford, CA: Hoover Institution Press.
13.
BoehmerCharles R.SobekDavid. 2005. “Violent Adolescence: State Development and the Propensity for Militarized Interstate Conflict.” Journal of Peace Research42 (1): 5–26.
14.
BoixCarlesMillerMichaelRosatoSebastian. 2012. “A Complete Data Set of Political Regimes, 1800-2007.” Comparative Political Studies46 (12): 1523–54.
15.
BoltJuttaBezemerDirk. 2009. “Understanding Long-run African Growth: Colonial Institutions or Colonial Education?” Journal of Development Studies45 (1): 24–54.
16.
CarterDavid B.SignorinoCurtis S.. 2010. “Back to the Future: Modeling Time Dependence in Binary Data.” Political Analysis18 (3): 271–92.
17.
CaverleyJonathan D.2010. “The Myth of Military Myopia: Democracy, Small Wars, and Vietnam.” International Security34 (3): 119–57.
18.
ChiozzaGiacomoGoemansHein E.. 2003. “Peace through Insecurity Tenure and International Conflict.” Journal of Conflict Resolution47 (4): 443–67.
19.
ChoiS. W.JamesPatrick. 2003. “No Professional Soldiers, No Militarized Interstate Disputes? A New Question for Neo-Kantianism.” Journal of Conflict Resolution47 (6): 796–816.
20.
ClarkTom S.LinzerDrew A.. 2015. “Should I Use Fixed or Random Effects?” Political Science Research and Methods3 (2): 1399–408.
21.
CohenElliot A.1985. Citizens and Soldiers: The Dilemmas of Military Service. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
22.
CollierPaulHoefflerAnke. 2002. Military Expenditure: Threats, Aid, and Arms Races. Policy Research Working Paper No. 2927. Washington, DC: World Bank.
23.
CotteyAndrewEdmundsTimothyForsterAnthony. 2002. “The Second Generation Problematic: Rethinking Democracy and Civil-military Relations.” Armed Forces and Society29 (1): 31–56.
24.
DandekerChristopher. 1994. “National Security and Democracy: The United Kingdom Experience.” Armed Forces and Society20 (3): 353–74.
25.
DoyleMichael W.1986. “Liberalism and World Politics.” American Political Science Review80 (December): 1151–69.
26.
DuindamSimon. 1999. Military Conscription: An Economic Analysis of the Labour Component in the Armed Forces. Heidelberg, Germany: Physica-Verlag.
27.
EdmundsTimothy. 2006. “What Are Armed Forces for? The Changing Nature of Military Roles in Europe.” International Affairs82 (6): 1059–75.
28.
EngermanStanley L.SokoloffKenneth L.. 2005. “Colonialism, Inequality, and Long-run Paths of Development.” National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper No. 11057. Accessed December 6, 2014. http://www.nber.org/papers/w11057.
29.
EnloeCynthia H.1980. Police, Military, and Ethnicity: Foundations of State Power. Piscataway, NJ: Transaction Books.
30.
FeldmannHorst. 2009. “The Unemployment Effects of Labor Regulation around the World.” Journal of Comparative Economics37 (October): 76–90.
31.
FergusonNiall. 2002. Empire: The Rise and the Demise of the British World Order and the Lessons for Global Power. New York: Basic Books.
32.
FlynnGeorge Q.2002. Conscription and Democracy: The Draft in France, Great Britain, and the United States. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
33.
ForrestAlan. 2002. “Conscription as Ideology: Revolutionary France and the Nation in Arms.” In The Comparative Study of Conscription in the Armed Forces, edited by MjosetLarsVan HoldeStephen, 95–116. Amsterdam, The Netherlands: JAI.
34.
ForsterAnthony. 2012. “The Military Covenant and British Civil–military Relations: Letting the Genie Out of the Bottle.” Armed Forces and Society38 (2): 273.
35.
FrankemaEwoutvan WaijenburgMarlous. 2013. Endogenous Colonial Institutions: Lessons from Fiscal Capacity Building in British and French Africa, 1880-1940. African Economic History Working Paper Series No. 10/2013, African Economic History Network. Accessed June 1, 2015. http://www.ewoutfrankema.com/media/publications/workingPapers/AEHN_WP_No.11.2013.pdf.
36.
FriedmanMilton. 2008. “A Draft Would Be Both Unfair and Unnecessary.” In Military Draft, edited by HayJeff, 142. Detroit, MI: Greenhaven Press.
37.
GartzkeErikJoseph HewittJ.. 2010. “International Crises and the Capitalist Peace.” International Interactions36 (2): 115–45.
38.
GearyJames W.1986. “Civil War Conscription in the North: A Historiographical Review.” Civil War History32 (3): 208–28.
39.
GilroyCurtisWilliamsCindy, eds. 2006. Service to Country: Personnel Policy and the Transformation of Western Militaries. Cambridge, MA: The Belfer Center.
40.
GrievesKeith. 1988. The Politics of Manpower, 1914-18. New York: St. Martin’s Press.
41.
HaltinerKarl W.1998. “The Definite End of the Mass Army in Western Europe?” Armed Forces and Society25 (1): 7–36.
42.
Harries-JenkinsGwyn. 1977. The Army in Victorian Society. London, UK: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
43.
Harries-JenkinsGwyn, ed. 1982. Armed Forces and the Welfare Societies: Challenges in the 1980s: Britain, the Netherlands, Germany, Sweden and the United States. London, UK: IISS.
44.
HayesDenis. 1949. Conscription Conflict: The Conflict of Ideas in the Struggle for and against Military Conscription in Britain between 1901 and 1939. London, UK: Sheppard Press.
45.
HeathcoteThomas A.1975. The Indian Army: The Garrison of British Imperial India, 1822-1922. New York: Hippocrene Books.
46.
HiggsRobert. 1999. “War and Leviathan in Twentieth-century America: Conscription as the Keystone.” In The Costs of War: America’s Pyrrhic Victories, edited by DensonJohn V., 375–88. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.
47.
HillChristopher. 1970. God’s Englishman: Oliver Cromwell and the English Revolution. New York: Dial Press.
48.
HillChristopher. 1972. The World Turned Upside Down: Radical Ideas during the English Revolution. New York: Viking Press.
49.
HillChristopher. 1980. The Century of Revolution, 1603-1714. New York: W. W. Norton.
50.
HillL. M.1973. “County Government in Caroline England, 1625-1640.” In The Origins of the English Civil War, edited by RussellConrad, 66–90. New York: Barnes & Noble Books.
51.
HoremanBartStolwijkMarc, eds. 1998. Refusing to Bear Arms: A World Survey of Conscription and Conscientious Objection to Military Service. London, UK: War Resister’s International.
52.
HorowitzMichael C.LevenduskyMatthew S.. 2011. “Drafting Support for War: Conscription and Mass Support for Warfare.” Journal of Politics73 (2): 524–34.
53.
HorowitzMichael C.SimpsonErin M.StamAllan C.. 2011. “Domestic Institutions and Wartime Casualties.” International Studies Quarterly55:909–36.
54.
HuiVictoria Tin-bor.2005. War and State Formation in Ancient China and Early Modern Europe. New York: Cambridge University Press.
55.
InglehartRonald. 1997. Modernization and Postmodernization. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
56.
IrondelleBastien. 2003. “Civil-military Relations and the End of Conscription in France.” Security Studies12 (3): 157–87.
57.
JehnChristopher. 2008. “Conscription.” In The Concise Encyclopedia of Economics, edited by HendersonDavid R., 76–77. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund.
58.
KantImmanuel. [1795] 1991. “Perpetual Peace: A Philosophical Sketch.” In Kant: Political Writings, 2nd ed., edited byReissHans and translated byNisbetH. B., 93–130. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
59.
KarshEfraim. 2002. The Iran-Iraq War: 1980-1988. Osceola, WI: Osprey.
60.
KeeganJohn, ed. 1983. World Armies. 2nd ed. Detroit, MI: Gale Research Company.
61.
KeeganJohn. 1985. “Foreword.” In A Nation in Arms: A Social Study of the British Army in the First World War, edited by BeckettIan F. W.SimpsonKeith,viii–x. Manchester, UK: Manchester University Press.
62.
KenezPeter. 1977. Civil War in South Russia, 1919-1920: The Defeat of the Whites. Oakland: University of California Press.
KubikTimothy R. W.2001. “Military Professionalism and the Democratic Peace: How German Is It?” In Democracy, Liberalism, and War: Rethinking the Democratic Peace Debate, edited by BarkawiTarakLaffeyMark, 237. Boulder, CO: Lynne Reinner.
65.
LandesDavid S.1998. The Wealth and Poverty of Nations: Why Are Some So Rich and Others So Poor?New York: W. W. Norton.
66.
LeanderAnna. 2004. “Drafting Community: Understanding the Fate of Conscription.” Armed Forces and Society30 (4): 571–99.
67.
LeeDwight R.McKenzieRichard B.. 1992. “Reexamination of the Relative Efficiency of the Draft and the All-volunteer Army.” Southern Economic Journal58 (3): 644–54.
68.
LeviMargaret. 1997. Consent, Dissent, and Patriotism. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
69.
LifshitzYaacov. 2010. “Conscription versus Recruitment through Markets: Economic Considerations.” In The New Citizen Armies: Israel’s Armed Forces in Comparative Perspective, edited by CohenStuart A., 132–43. London, UK: Routledge.
70.
MarshallMonty G.JaggersKeith. 2010. Polity IV Project: Political Regime Characteristics and Transitions, 1800-2010. Accessed February 15, 2011.www.systemicpeace.org/inscr/inscr.html.
71.
MawdsleyEvan. 2007. The Russian Civil War. New York: Pegasus Books.
72.
MeromGil. 2003. How Democracies Lose Small Wars: State, Society, and the Failures of France in Algeria, Israel in Lebanon, and the United States in Vietnam. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
73.
MulliganCasey B.ShleiferAndrei. 2005. “Conscription as Regulation.” American Law and Economics Review7 (1): 85–111.
74.
NickersonHoffman. 1942. The Armed Horde, 1793-1939: A Study in the Rise, Survival, and Decline of the Mass Army. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons.
75.
NordhausWilliamOnealJohnRussettBruce. 2012. “The Effects of the International Security Environment on National Military Expenditures: A Multicountry Study.” International Organization66 (3): 491–513.
76.
NorthDouglass C.SummerhillW.WeingastBarry R.. 2000. “Order, Disorder and Economic Change.” In Governing for Prosperity, edited by de MesquitaBruce BuenoRootHilton L., 17–58. New York: Yale University Press.
77.
OstromCharles WJr. 1978. “A Reactive Linkage Model of the U.S. Defense Expenditure Policymaking Process.” American Political Science Review72 (3): 941–57.
78.
PeledA.1998. A Question of Loyalty: Military Manpower Policy in Multiethnic States. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
79.
PepperSuzanne. 1999. Civil War in China: The Political Struggle, 1945-1949. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
80.
PfaffenzellerStephan. 2010. “Conscription and Democracy: The Mythology of Civil—military Relations.” Armed Forces & Society36 (3): 481–504.
81.
PhillipsBrian. 1991. “The Institution of Conscription: The Case of Finland.” In The Institution of War, edited by HindeRobert A., 229–43. New York: St. Martin’s Press.
82.
PickeringJeffrey. 2011. “Dangerous Drafts? A Time-series, Cross-national Analysis of Conscription and the Use of Military Force, 1946-2001.” Armed Forces & Society37 (1): 119–40.
83.
PosenBarry R.1995. “Nationalism, the Mass Army and Military Power.” In Perspectives on Nationalism and War, edited by, ComaroffJ.SternP., 135–86. Amsterdam, The Netherlands: Gordon and Breach.
84.
PoutvaaraPanuWagenerAndreas. 2011. “Ending Military Conscription.” DICE Report9 (2): 36–43.
85.
RangelCharles. 2003. “For the Draft.” American Legion Magazine, June 3, 28.
86.
RichardsonLewis F.1960. Arms and Insecurity: A Mathematical Study of the Causes and Origins of War. Pittsburgh, PA: The Boxwood Press.
87.
RobsonLeslie Lloyd. 1982. The First A.I.F.: A Study of Its Recruitment, 1914-1918. Carlton, Australia: Melbourne University Press.
88.
RossThomas. 1994. “Raising an Army: A Positive Theory of Military Recruitment.” Journal of Law and Economics37 (1): 109–31.
89.
RussellConrad, ed. 1973. “Introduction.” In The Origins of the English Civil War, 1–31. New York: Barnes & Noble Books.
90.
RussettBruceOnealJohn R.. 2001. Triangulating Peace: Democracy, Interdependence, and International Organizations. New York: Norton.
SegalDavid R.1994. “National Security and Democracy in the United States.” Armed Forces and Society20 (3): 375–93.
94.
SherzadA.1992. “The Kurdish Movement in Iraq: 1975-88.” In The Kurds: A Contemporary Overview, edited by KreyenbroekP. G.SperlStefan, 134–42. New York: Routledge.
95.
SingerJ. DavidBremerStuartStuckeyJohn. 1972. “Capability Distribution, Uncertainty, and Major Power War, 1820-1965.” In Peace, War, and Numbers, edited by RussettBruce, 19–48. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
96.
SmithAdam. 1998[1776]. An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations: A Selected Edition. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
97.
SokoloffKenneth L.EngermanStanley L.. 2000. “History Lessons: Institutions, Factor Endowments, and Paths of Development in the New World.” Journal of Economic Perspectives14 (3): 217–32.
98.
SpiersEdward M.1980. The Army and Society: 1815-1914. London, UK: Longman.
99.
StephensAlanBakerNicola. 2006. Making Sense of War: Strategy for the 21st Century. Vol. 247. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
100.
TeorellJ.HadeniusA.. 2005. Determinants of Democratization: Taking Stock of the Large-N Evidence. MIMEO. Uppsala, Sweden: Department of Government, Uppsala University.
101.
TillyCharles. 1985. “War Making and State Making as Organized Crime.” In Bringing the State Back in, edited by EvansPeter B.RueschemeyerDietrichSkocpolTheda, 169–91. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
102.
ThompsonWilliam R. 2001. “Identifying Rivals and Rivalries in World Politics.” International Studies Quarterly45 (4): 557–86.
TreismanDaniel. 2000. “The Causes of Corruption: A Cross-national Study.” Journal of Public Economics76 (3): 399–457.
106.
van CreveldMartin. 1999. The Rise and Decline of the State. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
107.
VasquezJoseph PaulIII2005. “Shouldering the Soldiering: Democracy, Conscription, and Military Casualties.” Journal of Conflict Resolution49 (6): 849–73.
108.
VasquezJoseph PaulIII2011. “More than Meets the Eye: Domestic Politics and the End of British Conscription.” Armed Forces and Society37 (4): 636–56.
109.
WolfowitzPaul. 2003. Remarks as Delivered at the All-volunteer Force Conference. Washington, DC: Department of Defense.
110.
WollochIsser. 1986. “Napoleonic Conscription: State Power and Civil Society.” Past and Present111:101–29.
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
