Government research institutes in the Italian policy advisory system

Abstract

In a Napoleonic country such as Italy, ministerial cabinets have traditionally served as central advisors in the politicised policy advisory system (PAS), while evidence-based policy-making has usually been marginal. Nevertheless, recent developments in political systems have pushed for the pluralisation of the Napoleonic PAS toward a stronger demand for scientific and expert advice. Against this backdrop, the role of government research institutes (GRIs) as advisors represents an interesting change that could potentially fuel the development of an evidence-based approach in a period of changing advisory practices. We investigate these developments through a case study concerning 20 Italian GRIs that are engaged as influential advisors or recruited to support implementation through policy work. We obtained evidence through document analysis, in-depth interviews, and a questionnaire administered to the 20 GRIs. The overall picture displays a shift in conceiving policy advice in the political system and opens the door to innovation.

Points for practitioners

Evidence-based policy making is expanding also in countries with scarce policy capacities.

Government research institutes may be asked to perform different policy works, including evidence-based advice and also implementation tasks.

The financial autonomy and reputation of the government research institute matter for their advisory role.

Policy advice is described as the result of the matching between a contingent political demand and the offer of expert knowledge.

Keywords

evidence-based policy-making Italy pluralisation policy advice policy advisory system policy work research institutes

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aubin

Brans

(2020) Policy advisory styles in the francophone Belgian civil service. International Review of Administrative Sciences 86(3): 463–478.

Brans

Aubin

(eds) (2017) Policy Analysis in Belgium. Bristol: Policy Press.

Cassese

(1999) Italy’s senior civil service: An ossified world. In: Page

Wright

(eds) Bureaucratic Elites in Western European States. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 55–64.

Castaldo

Verzichelli

(2020) Technocratic populism in Italy after Berlusconi: The trendsetter and his disciples. Politics and Governance 8(4): 485–495.

Chiaramonte

Emanuele

(2015) Party system volatility, regeneration and de-institutionalization in Western Europe (1945–2015). Party Politics 23(4): 376–388.

Christensen

(2018) Economic knowledge and the scientization of policy advice. Policy Sciences 51(3): 291–311.

Christensen

Holst

(2017) Advisory commissions, academic expertise and democratic legitimacy: The case of Norway. Science and Public Policy 44(6): 821–833.

Connaughton

(2015) Navigating the borderlines of politics and administration: Reflections on the role of ministerial advisers. International Journal of Public Administration 38(1): 37–45.

Craft

Halligan

(2020) Advising Governments in the Westminster Tradition: Policy Advisory Systems in Australia, Britain, Canada and New Zealand. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

10.

Craft

Howlett

(2012) Policy formulation, governance shifts and policy influence: Location and content in policy advisory systems. Journal of Public Policy 32(2): 79–98.

11.

Craft

Howlett

(2013) The dual dynamics of policy advisory systems: The impact of externalization and politicization on policy advice. Policy and Society 32(3): 187–197.

12.

De Giorgi

Grimaldi

(2015) The Italian political system in the last twenty years: Change, adaptation or unfinished transition? Contemporary Italian Politics 7(1): 3–9.

13.

Dente

Regonini

(1989) Politics and policies in Italy. In: Regini

Lange

(eds) State, Market, and Social Regulation. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, pp. 51–80.

14.

Diamond

(2020) Polycentric governance and policy advice: Lessons from Whitehall policy advisory systems. Policy & Politics 48(4): 563–581.

15.

Di Mascio

Natalini

(2013) Analysing the role of ministerial cabinets in Italy: Legacy and temporality in the study of administrative reforms. International Review of Administrative Sciences 79(2): 328–346.

16.

Di Mascio

Natalini

(2016) Ministerial advisers between political change and institutional legacy: The case of Italy. Acta Politica 5(4): 517–538.

17.

Fobé

Brans

Vancoppenolle

, et al. (2013) Institutionalized advisory systems: An analysis of member satisfaction of advice production and use across 9 strategic advisory councils in Flanders (Belgium). Policy and Society 32(3): 225–240.

18.

Gouglas

Brans

Jaspers

(2017) European commissioner cabinet advisers: Policy managers, bodyguards, stakeholder mobilizers. Public Administration 95(2): 359–377.

19.

Gregory

Lonti

(2008) Chasing shadows? Performance measurement of policy advice in New Zealand government departments. Public Administration 86(3): 837–856.

20.

Halligan

(1995) Policy advice and the public service. In: Peters

Savoie

(eds) Governance in a Changing Environment. Montreal: McGill/Queens University Press, pp. 138–172.

21.

Hoppe

Jeliazkova

(2006) How policymakers define their jobs: A Netherlands case study. In: Colebatch

(ed.) The Work of Policy: An International Survey. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books, pp. 61–82.

22.

Hustedt

Veit

(2017) Policy advisory systems: Change dynamics and sources of variation. Policy Sciences 50(1): 41–46.

23.

Lippi

(2012) La Politica Degli Intellettuali. Acireale-Roma: Bonanno editore.

24.

Manwaring

(2019) Political demand and policy advice: A framework for analysis. Policy Studies 40(3–4): 270–286.

25.

Meert

Brans

Gouglas

(2019) Undoing the cabinets ministériels. A scoping review on ‘decabinetisation’. ICPP Conference 2019 Montreal T05P01 Politics and Public Administration within Core Executives, 27 June 2019, Montreal.

26.

Mukherjee

Giest

(2020) Behavioural insights teams (BITs) and policy change: An exploration of impact, location, and temporality of policy advice. Administration & Society 52(10): 1538–1561.

27.

Page

Jenkins

(2005) Policy Bureaucracy: Government Until a Cast of Thousands. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

28.

Pattyn

Blum

Fobé

, et al. (2019). Academic policy advice in consensus-seeking countries: The cases of Belgium and Germany. International Review of Administrative Sciences. Epub ahead of print: 20 December 2019. DOI: 0020852319878780.

29.

Pedrazzani

Pinto

(2015) The electoral base: The ‘political revolution’ in the evolution. In: Tronconi

(ed.) Beppe Grillo’s Five Star Movement. Organisation, Communication and Ideology. London: Routledge, pp. 75–98.

30.

Peters

(2008) The Napoleonic tradition. International Journal of Public Sector Management 21(2): 118–132.

31.

Peters

Pierre

Randma-Liiv

(2011) Global financial crisis, public administration and governance: Do new problems require new solutions? Public Organization Review 11(1): 13–27.

32.

Pritoni

(2017) Lobby D’Italia. Il Sistema Degli Interessi tra Prima e Seconda Repubblica. Roma: Carocci.

33.

Radaelli

(2003) The Europeanization of public policies. In: Featherstone

Radaelli

(eds) The Politics of Europeanization. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 27–56.

34.

Radin

(2013) Policy analyses reaches midlife. Central European Journal of Public Policy 1(1): 8–27.

35.

Rebessi

Zucchini

(2020) Courts as extra-cabinet control mechanisms for secondary legislation: Evidence from Italy. Italian Political Science Review 50(2): 159–172.

36.

Sarewitz

Pielke

(2007) The neglected heart of science policy: Reconciling supply of and demand for science. Environmental Science & Policy 10(1): 5–16.

37.

Thunert

(2013) Non-university research institutes: Between basic research, knowledge transfer to the public and policy analysis. In: Schubert

Blum

(eds) Policy Analysis in Germany. Chicago: Policy Press, pp. 247–264.

38.

van den Berg

(2017) Dynamics in the Dutch policy advisory system: Externalization, politicization and the legacy of pillarization. Policy Sciences 50(1): 63–84.

39.

Veselý

(2013) Externalization of policy advice: Theory, methodology and evidence. Policy and Society 32(3): 199–209.

40.

Veselý

(2017) Policy advice as policy work: A conceptual framework for multi-level analysis. Policy Sciences 50(1): 139–154.

41.

Walgrave S, Caals T, Suetens M et al. (2004) Ministerial cabinets and partitocracy: A career pattern study of ministerial cabinet members in Belgium. PSW Paper 2004/7, Politieke Wetenschappen.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.68 MB