A Gandhian answer to the threat of communism? Sarvodaya and postcolonial nationalism in India

Abstract

It is an axiom of early postcolonial Indian history that Nehru and his statist conception of nationalism and of economic development dominated the political and economic life of India. As such, scholars have assumed, Gandhian ideas, especially radically non-statist answers to the problems of development, lost influence in this period. This article explores Gandhian economic thinking, in the form of the Bhoodan Movement and three of the thinkers on sarvodaya economics in the 1950s: Vinoba Bhave, K.G. Mashruwala and J.C. Kumarappa. It goes on to demonstrate the complex relationship that these men and their ideas had with Nehru and various levels of the Indian state. It argues that the non-statist ideas remained important in the development of the postcolonial Indian nationalism.

Keywords

Vinoba Bhave K.G. Mashruwala J.C. Kumarappa M.K. Gandhi Telangana land reform development self-sufficiency Gandhian economics

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agarwal

Bina

. A Field of One’s Own: Gender and Land Rights in South Asia, Cambridge, 1994.

Akhil Bharat Sarva Seva Sangh. Bhoodan as Seen by the West: An Appraisal of the Land-gift Mission by Some Western Seekers, Tanjore, 1958.

Bhattacharjee

Manash

. ‘Aam Aadmi Party: Government of the Governed?’ Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 48(53), 28 December 2013. http://www.epw.in/journal/2013/52/web-exclusives/aam-aadmi-party-government-governed.html (accessed 3 March 2016 ).

Bhave

Vinoba

. Bhoodan Yajna (Land-Gifts Mission), Ahmedabad, 1953.

Bhave

Vinoba

. Sarvodaya and Communism, Tanjore, 1957.

Bhave

Vinoba

. Democratic Values and the Practice of Citizenship: Selections from the Addresses of Vinoba Bhave, Kashi, 1962.

Bhave

Vinoba

. Vinoba Bhave on World Peace, Tanjore, 1957–64.

Bhave

Vinoba

. Revolutionary Sarvodaya: Philosophy for the Remaking of Man, Bombay, 1964.

Bhave

Vinoba

, Mashruwala

K.G

and Kumarappa

J.C.

. Planning Commission and Sarvodaya Approach, Muzaffarpur, 1952.

10.

Chakrabarty

Dipesh

. ‘“In the Name of Politics”: Democracy and the Power of the Multitude in India’, Public Culture, Vol. 19 (1), 2007, pp. 35–58.

11.

Chandra

Bipan

. The Rise and Growth of Economic Nationalism in India, New Delhi, 2004, revised edition.

12.

Chatterjee

Partha

. ‘Development Planning and the Indian State’, in Chatterjee

Parth

, ed., State and Politics in India, New Delhi, 1997, pp. 271–97.

13.

Chatterji

Joya

. ‘South Asian Histories of Citizenship, 1946–1970’, The Historical Journal, Vol. 55 (4), 2012, pp. 1049–71.

14.

Gandhi

Mohandas Karamchand

. Collected Works of Mahatma Gandhi, Ahmedabad, 1958–84.

15.

Gould

William

. Bureaucracy, Community and Influence in India: Society and the State, 1930s–1960s, Abingdon, 2011.

16.

Gopal

ed., Selected Works of Jawaharlal Nehru, 2nd series, New Delhi, 1984.

17.

Government of Hyderabad, Department of Information and Public Relations, Bhoodan—Concept of Land through Love, Hyderabad, 1954.

18.

Government of India, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Acharya Vinoba Bhave, New Delhi, 1955.

19.

Guha

Ramachandra

. An Anthropologist among the Marxists and other Essays, New Delhi, 2001.

20.

Hardiman

David

. Gandhi in his Time and Ours: The Global Legacy of his Ideas, New Delhi, 2003.

21.

Kaviraj

Sudipta

. The Trajectories of the Indian State: Politics & Ideas, New Delhi, 2010.

22.

Khan

Yasmin

, The Great Partition: The Making of India and Pakistan, New Haven, 2007.

23.

Kumarappa

Bharatan

. ed., Toward Non-violent Socialism by M.K. Gandhi, Ahmedabad, 1951.

24.

Kumarappa

J.C.

Gandhian Economic Thought, Bombay, 1951.

25.

Kumarappa

J.C.

Sarvodaya and World Peace, Wardha, 1954.

26.

Lindley

Mark

. ‘J. C. Kumarappa—Giant or Midget?’ http://www.academia.edu/292765/J._C._Kumarappa_-_giant_or_midget (accessed 10 February 2015 ).

27.

Mantena

Karuna

. ‘On Gandhi’s Critique of the State: Sources, Contexts, Conjunctures’, Modern Intellectual History, Vol. 9 (3), 2012, pp. 535–63.

28.

Mantena

Karuna

. ‘Another Realism: The Politics of Gandhian Nonviolence’, American Political Science Review, Vol. 106 (2), 2012, pp. 455–70.

29.

Markovitz

Claude

. The Un-Gandhian Gandhi: The Life and Afterlife of the Mahatma, London, 2004.

30.

Masani

M.R.

‘The Communist Party in India’, Pacific Affairs, Vol. 24 (1), 1951, pp. 18–38.

31.

Mashruwala

K.G.

Gandhi and Marx, Ahmedabad, 1951.

32.

Naoroji

Dadabhai

. Poverty and Un-British Rule in India, London, 1901.

33.

Narayan

Jayaprakash

, Jeevan-dan, Tirupur, 1954.

34.

Nayar

Sushila

. ‘Kumarappa as I knew Him’, in Nayar

Pyarelal

and Nayar

Sushila

, In Gandhi’s Mirror, Delhi, 1991.

35.

Newbigin

Eleanor

. The Hindu Family and the Emergence of Modern India: Law, Citizenship and Community, Cambridge, 2013.

36.

Pernau

Margrit

. The Passing of Patrimonialism: Politics and Political Culture in Hyderabad, 1911–1948, New Delhi, 2000.

37.

Ram

Mohan

. ‘The Telangana Peasant Armed Struggle, 1946–51’, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 8 (23), 1973, pp. 1025–32.

38.

Rao

C. Rajeswara

. The Historic Telengana [sic] Struggle: Some Useful Lessons from its Rich Experience, New Delhi, 1972.

39.

Reddy

Ravi Narayan

. Heroic Telengana [sic]: Reminiscences & Experiences, New Delhi, 1973.

40.

Roy

Srirupa

. Beyond Belief: India and the Politics of Postcolonial Nationalism, New Delhi, 2007.

41.

Shani

Ornit

. ‘Gandhi, Citizenship and the Resilience of Indian Nationhood’, Citizenship Studies, Vol. 15 (6–7), 2011, pp. 659–78.

42.

Sharma

Shalini

. ‘“Yeh Azadi Jhooti Hai!” The Shaping of the Opposition in the First Year of the Congress Raj’, Modern Asian Studies, Vol. 48 (5), 2014, pp. 1358–88.

43.

Sherman

Taylor C.

State Violence and Punishment in India, London, 2010.

44.

Sherman

Taylor C.

‘From “Grow More Food” to “Miss a Meal”: Food, Famine and the Limits of Post-colonial Nationalism in India’, South Asia: Journal of South Asian Studies, Vol. 36 (4), 2013, pp. 571–88.

45.

Sherman

Taylor C.

Muslim Belonging in Secular India: Negotiating Citizenship in Postcolonial India, Cambridge, 2015.

46.

Skaria

Ajay

. ‘Gandhi’s Politics: Liberalism and the Question of the Ashram’, The South Atlantic Quarterly, Vol. 101 (4), 2002, pp. 955–86.

47.

Skaria

Ajay

. ‘Relinquishing Republican Democracy: Gandhi’s Ramarajya’, Postcolonial Studies, Vol. 14 (2), 2011, pp. 203–29.

48.

Srinivasan

Vasanthi

. Hindu Spirituality and Virtue Politics, New Delhi, 2014.

49.

Stree

Shakti Sanghatana

. ‘We Were Making History...’ Life Stories of Women in the Telangana People’s Struggle, New Delhi, 1989.

50.

Sundarayya

Telangana People’s Struggle and its Lessons, Calcutta, 1972.

51.

Thirumali

Inukonda

. Against Dora and Nizam: People’s Movement in Telangana, New Delhi, 2003.

52.

Trumbull

Robert

. ‘Holy Man who walks in Gandhi’s Steps’, New York Times, 10 February 1952.

53.

Trumbull

Robert

. ‘Vinoba’s Loot with Love’, in Akhil Bharat Sarva Seva Sangh, Bhoodan as Seen by the West: an Appraisal of the Land-gift Mission by Some Western Seekers, Tanjore, 1958, p. 8.

54.

Victus

Solomon

. Religion and Eco-economics of Dr J.C. Kumarappa: Gandhism Redefined, New Delhi, 2003.

55.

Zamindar

Vazira

. The Long Partition and the Making of Modern South Asia: Refugees, Boundaries, Histories, New York, 2007.