The Needle and the Damage Done: Research,Action Research,and the Organizational and Social Construction of Health in the "Information Society"

Abstract

This paper critically reviews the action research paradigm that has evolved over the last 50 years within and outside The Tavistock Insitute, with reference to radical shifts in the social construction of medicine and health that are occurring as a result of the transition toward the "information society." The medical domain has been chosen as an appropriate space within which to review the action research paradigm because it bridges both the past and future of the Institute. The paper firstly considers the original conception of action research and sociotechnical systems, and the role of consultants, in relation to Foucualt's analysis of power relations, social control, and "dividing practices." It then describes and analyzes recent developments in the field of medicine and healthcare service provision that, on the one hand, offer opportunities for increased self-management and control by consumers over physical, social, and emotional "self-hood" and on the other could lead to further social surveillance and the domination and subjectification of the individual. Drawing on recent work using innovative models of action research in the field of HIV/AIDS, the paper concludes by discussing ways in which action research could harness developments in information and communication technologies to maximize individual and collective engagement in new forms of organizational and social relations.

Keywords

action research power information and communication technologies healthcare HIV/AIDS

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ABDULRAHMIN, D. Working with Diversity: European Conference on HIV and AIDS for the Muslim and South Asian Communities, 1992.

AGRAFIOTIS, D. User Needs in HIV/AIDS. Internal report, SEAHORSE Project, Thvistock Institute, London, 1996.

BAHN . Policy report. London, 1991.

BEBBINGTON, A. , & WARREN, P. Tlmpering the Wind to the Shorn Lamb: HIV/AIDS Centres in the 1990s. PSSRU Bulletin, 8 1991.

BEBBINGTON, A. C. , FELDMAN, R. , GATTER, P. , & WARREN, P. Evaluation of the Landmark: Final Report. PSSRU, London, 1992.

BLOOMFIELD, B. , & COOMBS, R. Information technology, control and power: The centralisation and decentralisation debate revisited. Journal of Management Studies, 1992, 29 459-484.

COOMBS, R. , & COOPER, D.

Accounting for Patients?

Information Technology and the Implementation of the NHS White Paper. PIC7 Research Paper No. 10, Uxbridge, Brunel University, 1990.

COOMBS, R. , & HULL, R. The politics of IT in organisations. In W H. Dutton (Ed.), Information and communication technologies: Visions and realities, Oxford: OUP, 1996.

CULLEN, J. TELMED: The Impact of Telematics on Healthcare in Europe: Final Report., CEC, Brussels, 1997.

10.

CULLEN, J. SEAHORSE: Final Report, Deliverable 1.2, CEC, Brussels, 1997.

11.

CULLEN, J. , CHILD, C. , & ABRAHAM, F. Evaluation of multi-action in the community. HEA, 1995.

12.

ETZIONI, A. The moral dimension: Towards a new economy. New York: Free Press, 1988.

13.

FOUCAULT, M. The subject and power. In H. Dreyfus , and P. Rabinow (Eds.), Beyond structuralism and hermeneutics. Chicago: University Press, 1982.

14.

FOUCAULT, M. Discipline and punish. New York: Vintage, 1975.

15.

FOUCAULT, M. The history of sexuality (Vol. 1). New York: Pantheon, 1978.

16.

GARFIELD, S. Britain in the time of AIDS. London: Faber and Faber, 1994.

17.

GIDDENS, A. The consequences of modernity. Cambridge: Polity Press, 1990.

18.

GUSTAFSON, D. , BOSWORTH, K. , HAWKINS, R. , BOBERG, E. , & BRICKER, E. CHESS: A Computer-Based System for Medical and Other Health-Related Crises., Proceedings of the First National Conference on Healthcare Informatics, Wisconsin, 1993.

19.

HABERMAS, J. The theory of communicative action. Cambridge: Polity Press, 1992.

20.

JOFFE, H. Beyond the Knowledge-Attitude-Belief-Practice Paradigm of AIDS. Research Paper, IX International Conference on AIDS, Berlin, 1993.

21.

KELLEHER, J. Assessment Testing in Information Systems Development: Evaluation and Organisational Learning. Paper, Intnl. Eval. Conf., Vancouver, 1995.

22.

MacKENZIE, D. , & WACJMAN, J. The social shaping of technology. Open University Press, 1993.

23.

MANSELL, R. The new telecommunications. London: Sage, 1993.

24.

MARSHALL, P. A. , & BENNET, L. Anthropological contributions to AIDS research. Anthropology Quarter, 1990, 4 1-1.

25.

MOLINA, A. Understanding the Emergence of a Large-Scale European Technology Initiative. PICT Policy Research Paper No. 23, ESRC, 1993.

26.

OFFE, C. Changing boundaries of institutional politics: Social movements since the 1960's. Cambridge: University Press, 1982.

27.

QUINTAS, P. Social dimensions of systems engineering. New York: Ellis Harwood, 1993.

28.

SOMMERLAD, E. Final Report on User and Learner Involvement in Advanced Learning Technologies. DELTA project D2106, Brussels, EC, 1995.

29.

STERN, E. , ABRAHAMS, F. , CULLEN, J. , & KING, A. Evaluation of London Lighthouse. London: Dept. of Health, 1996.

30.

TAYLOR, C. AIDS and the pathogenesis of metaphor. In D. A, Feldman (Ed.), Culture and AIDS. New York: Praeger, 1990.

31.

TRIST E. , & MURRAY, H. The social engagement of social science (Vol. 1). Pennsylvania Press, 1990.

32.

WEEKS, J. AIDS: The intellectual agenda. In P Aggleton (Ed.), AIDS: Social representations, 1989.