This review examines the sexual development of young men through a precarious manhood framework. The teenage and emerging adulthood years are a time of change and uncertainty for many boys and young men, heightening concerns about manhood. They are also a time when boys and young men are learning about and experimenting with sex. Sex and (hetero)sexuality are means for establishing and proving manhood, especially during a developmental period when other avenues (e.g. financial success) may be less available.
Methods and Results:
This paper reviews research connecting precarious notions of manhood to sexual development across three areas. First, we examine how precarious manhood encourages sexual risk-taking and objectification of sexual partners. Second, we review research connecting precarious manhood to men’s sexual violence. Third, we link precarious manhood to men’s derogation of gender and sexuality minority (LGBTQ+) individuals and groups.
Conclusion:
We end the paper by suggesting how sexual education programmes may consider a precarious manhood framework to foster healthier sexual development.
AbebeKZJonesKACulybaAJ, et al. (2018) Engendering healthy masculinities to prevent sexual violence: Rationale for and design of the Manhood 2.0 trial. Contemporary Clinical Trials71: 18–32.
2.
AbelsonMJ (2014) Dangerous privilege: Trans men, masculinities, and changing perceptions of safety. Sociological Forum29(3): 549–570.
3.
AbrahamsNDevriesKWattsC, et al. (2014) Worldwide prevalence of non-partner sexual violence: A systematic review. The Lancet383(9929): 1648–1654.
4.
ArnettJJ (2000) Emerging adulthood: A theory of development from the late teens through the twenties. The American Psychologist55(5): 469–480.
5.
BaamsLDubasJSvan AkenMA (2017) Comprehensive sexuality education as a longitudinal predictor of LGBTQ name-calling and perceived willingness to intervene in school. Journal of Youth and Adolescence46(5): 931–942.
6.
BakerJOSmithKKStossYA (2015) Theism, secularism, and sexual education in the United States. Sexuality Research and Social Policy12: 236–247.
7.
BakerR (1981) ‘Pricks’ and ‘chicks’: A plea for ‘persons’. In: Vetterling-BragginM (ed.) Sexist Language: A Modern Philosophical Analysis. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield, pp. 161–182.
8.
BerentJFalomir-PichastorJMChipeauxM (2015) Masculinity and sexual prejudice: A matter of heterosexual men’s need to dissociate from women and gay men. In: FanikoKLorenzi-CioldiFSarrasinO, et al. (eds) Gender and Social Hierarchies: Perspectives from Social Psychology. London: Routledge, pp. 175–187.
9.
BhanaDCreweMAggletonP (2019) Sex, sexuality and education in South Africa. Sex Education19(4): 361–370.
10.
BinghamTAHarawaNTWilliamsJK (2013) Gender role conflict among African American men who have sex with men and women: Associations with mental health and sexual risk and disclosure behaviors. American Journal of Public Health103(1): 127–133.
11.
BossonJKJurekPVandelloJA, et al. (2021) Psychometric properties and correlates of precarious manhood beliefs in 62 nations. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology52(3): 231–258.
CarpenterLM (2001) The ambiguity of ‘having sex’: The subjective experience of virginity loss in the United States. Journal of Sex Research38(2): 127–139.
14.
CarpenterLM (2002) Gender and the meaning and experience of virginity loss in the contemporary United States. Gender & Society16(3): 345–365.
15.
CarpenterLM (2010) Gendered sexuality over the life course: A conceptual framework. Sociological Perspectives53(2): 155–177.
16.
Cavazos-RehgPAKraussMJSpitznagelEL, et al. (2009) Age of sexual debut among US adolescents. Contraception80(2): 158–162.
17.
CheryanSCameronJSKatagiriZ, et al. (2015) Manning up: Threatened men compensate by disavowing feminine preferences and embracing masculine attributes. Social Psychology46(4): 218–227.
18.
ChingBH-H (2022) The effect of masculinity threat on transprejudice: Influence of different aspects of masculinity contingent self-worth. Psychology & Sexuality13(3): 550–564.
CrownLRobertsLJ (2007) Against their will: Young women’s nonagentic sexual experiences. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships24(3): 385–405.
21.
DriverRKalichmanSC (2022) Precarious manhood and intentions to initiate preexposure prophylaxis among Black sexual minority men. Health Psychology41(7): 474–483.
22.
DworkinERKrahéBZinzowH (2021). The global prevalence of sexual assault: A systematic review of international research since 2010. Psychology of Violence11(5): 497–508.
23.
EatonAARoseS (2011) Has dating become more egalitarian? A 35 year review using Sex Roles. Sex Roles64(11–12): 843–862.
24.
EndendijkJJvan BaarALDekovićM (2020). He is a stud, she is a slut! A meta-analysis on the continued existence of sexual double standards. Personality and Social Psychology Review24(2): 163–190.
25.
Falomir-PichastorJMBerentJAndersonJ (2019) Perceived men’s feminization and attitudes toward homosexuality: Heterosexual men’s reactions to the decline of the anti-femininity norm of masculinity. Sex Roles81: 208–222.
26.
FieldsELBogartLMSmithKC, et al. (2012) HIV risk and perceptions of masculinity among young black men who have sex with men. The Journal of Adolescent Health50(3): 296–303.
27.
FinerLBPhilbinJM (2013) Sexual initiation, contraceptive use, and pregnancy among young adolescents. Pediatrics131(5): 886–891.
28.
FlemingPJLeeJGDworkinSL (2014) ‘Real men don’t’: Constructions of masculinity and inadvertent harm in public health interventions. American Journal of Public Health104(6): 1029–1035.
GilmoreDD (1990) Manhood in the Making: Cultural Concepts of Masculinity. New Haven, CT and London: Yale University Press.
31.
GlickPGanglCGibbS, et al. (2007) Defensive reactions to masculinity threat: More negative affect toward effeminate (but not masculine) gay men. Sex Roles57: 55–59.
32.
HaenflerR (2015) Transitioning to a new manhood: Subcultures as sites of inclusive masculinity. In: WoodmanDBennettA (eds) Youth Cultures, Transitions, and Generations: Bridging the Gap in Youth Research. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 127–141.
33.
HamiltonCJMahalikJR (2009) Minority stress, masculinity, and social norms predicting gay men’s health risk behaviors. Journal of Counseling Psychology56(1): 132–141.
34.
HandMParkerSG (eds) (2022) Introduction: Policy special issue on relationships and sex education. Journal of Philosophy of Education56(5): 641–644.
35.
HarrisonBFMichelsonMR (2019) Gender, masculinity threat, and support for transgender rights: An experimental study. Sex Roles80: 63–75.
36.
HasanK (2021) Researching masculinity and men’s sexual health in Bangladesh: Methodological reflections. Qualitative Sociology Review17(4): 44–57.
37.
HermannCLiangCTHDeSipioBE (2018) Exploring sexual consent and hostile masculine norms using the theory of planned behavior. Psychology of Men & Masculinity19(4): 491–499.
38.
HumphreysTP (2007) Perceptions of sexual consent: The impact of relationship history and gender. Journal of Sex Research44(4): 307–315.
39.
HumphreysTP (2013) Cognitive frameworks of virginity and first intercourse. Journal of Sex Research50(7): 664–675.
40.
HuntCJFasoliFCarnaghiA, et al. (2016) Masculine self-presentation and distancing from femininity in gay men: An experimental examination of the role of masculinity threat. Psychology of Men & Masculinity17(1): 108–112.
41.
JordanJA (2022) Why don’t they just ask? Barriers to directly requesting affirmative sexual consent by gender and sexual orientation. Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation, University of South Florida, Tampa, FL.
42.
JozkowskiKNPetersonZDSandersSA, et al. (2014) Gender differences in heterosexual college students’ conceptualizations and indicators of sexual consent: Implications for contemporary sexual assault prevention education. The Journal of Sex Research51(8): 904–916.
43.
KaestleCEHalpernCTMillerWC, et al. (2005) Young age at first sexual intercourse and sexually transmitted infections in adolescents and young adults. American Journal of Epidemiology161(8): 774–780.
44.
KaplanDLJonesEJOlsonEC, et al. (2013) Early age of first sex and health risk in an urban adolescent population. The Journal of School Health83(5): 350–356.
45.
KeddeHRehseKNobreG, et al. (2018) MenCare+ in South Africa: Findings from a gender transformative young men’s group education on sexual and reproductive health and rights. Sex Education18(2): 206–218.
46.
KnoxDSturdivantLZusmanME (2001) College student attitudes toward sexual intimacy. College Student Journal35(2): 241–243.
47.
KonopkaKRajchertJDominiak-KochanekM, et al. (2021) The role of masculinity threat in homonegativity and transphobia. Journal of Homosexuality68(5): 802–829.
48.
KroeperKMSanchezDTHimmelsteinMS (2014) Heterosexual men’s confrontation of sexual prejudice: The role of precarious manhood. Sex Roles70: 1–13.
49.
La FranceBH (2010) What verbal and nonverbal communication cues lead to sex? An analysis of the traditional sexual script. Communication Quarterly58(3): 297–318.
50.
LeeCOwensRG (2002) The Psychology of Men’s Health. Philadelphia, PA: Open University Press.
LusherDRobinsG (2009) Hegemonic and other masculinities in local social contexts. Men and Masculinities11(4): 387–423.
53.
MaassACadinuMGuarnieriG, et al. (2003) Sexual harassment under social identity threat: The computer harassment paradigm. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology85(5): 853–870.
54.
MescherKRudmanLA (2014) Men in the mirror: The role of men’s body shame in sexual aggression. Personality & Social Psychology Bulletin40(8): 1063–1075.
55.
MishraSLeeMKrayLJ (2023) Precarious manhood increases men’s receptivity to social sexual behavior from attractive women at work. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology104: 104409.
56.
MongeauPASerewiczMCMHenningsenMLM, et al. (2006) Sex differences in the transition to a heterosexual romantic relationship. In: DindiaKCanaryDJ (eds) Sex Differences and Similarities in Communication. London and New York: Lawrence Erlbaum, pp. 337–358.
57.
MunschCLWillerR (2012) The role of gender identity threat in perceptions of date rape and sexual coercion. Violence Against Women18(10): 1125–1146.
58.
MurraySH (2018) Heterosexual men’s sexual desire: Supported by, or deviating from, traditional masculinity norms and sexual scripts?Sex Roles78(1–2): 130–141.
59.
NamySHeilmanBStichS, et al. (2015) Changing what it means to ‘become a man’: Participants’ reflections on a school-based programme to redefine masculinity in the Balkans. Culture, Health & Sexuality17(Suppl. 2): 206–222.
60.
NguyenVKEatonJW (2022) Trends and country-level variation in age at first sex in Sub-Saharan Africa among birth cohorts entering adulthood between 1985 and 2020. BMC Public Health22(1): 1120.
61.
O’ConnorECFordTEBanosNC (2017) Restoring threatened masculinity: The appeal of sexist and anti-gay humor. Sex Roles77: 567–580.
62.
Pérez-MartínezVMarcos-MarcosJCerdán-TorregrosaA, et al. (2023) Positive masculinities and gender-based violence educational interventions among young people: A systematic review. Trauma, Violence & Abuse24(2): 468–486.
63.
PetersenJLHydeJS (2010). A meta-analytic review of research on gender differences in sexuality, 1993–2007. Psychological Bulletin136(1): 21–38.
64.
PlummerDC (2013) Masculinity and risk: How gender constructs drive sexual risks in the Caribbean. Sex Research and Social Policy10: 165–174.
65.
ReidyDEBrookmeyerKAGentileB, et al. (2016) Gender role discrepancy stress, high-risk sexual behavior, and sexually transmitted disease. Archives of Sexual Behavior45(2): 459–465.
66.
ReidyDESmith-DardenJPCortinaKS, et al. (2015) Masculine discrepancy stress, teen dating violence, and sexual violence perpetration among adolescent boys. The Journal of Adolescent Health56(6): 619–624.
RubinJDBlackwellLConleyTD (2020) Fragile masculinity: Men, gender, and online harassment. In: Proceedings of the 2020 CHI conference on human factors in computing systems, pp. 1–14. Available at: DOI: 10.1145/3313831.3376645.
69.
Samadaee GelehkolaeeKMaasoumiRAzinSA, et al. (2021) Stakeholders’ perspectives of comprehensive sexuality education in Iranian male adolescences. Reproductive Health18: 1–13.
70.
SánchezFJVilainE (2012) ‘Straight-acting gays’: The relationship between masculine consciousness, anti-effeminacy, and negative gay identity. Archives of Sexual Behavior41(1): 111–119.
71.
SánchezFJGreenbergSTLiuWM, et al. (2009) Reported effects of masculine ideals on gay men. Psychology of Men & Masculinity10(1): 73–87.
72.
SchmittDP (2005). Sociosexuality from Argentina to Zimbabwe: A 48-nation study of sex, culture, and strategies of human mating. Behavioral and Brain Sciences28(2): 247–275; discussion 275.
73.
SedghGFinerLBBankoleA, et al. (2015) Adolescent pregnancy, birth, and abortion rates across countries: Levels and recent trends. Journal of Adolescent Health56(2): 223–230.
74.
SterninSMcKieRMWinbergC, et al. (2022) Sexual consent: Exploring the perceptions of heterosexual and non-heterosexual men. Psychology & Sexuality13(3): 512–534.
75.
TalleyAEBettencourtBA (2008) Evaluations and aggression directed at a gay male target: The role of threat and antigay prejudice. Journal of Applied Social Psychology38(3): 647–683.
76.
TannenbaumMBHeplerJZimmermanRS, et al. (2015) Appealing to fear: A meta-analysis of fear appeal effectiveness and theories. Psychological Bulletin141(6): 1178–1204.
77.
ThepsourinthoneJDuneTLiamputtongP, et al. (2020) The relationship between masculinity and internalized homophobia amongst Australian gay men. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health17(15): 5475.
78.
TrothAPetersonCC (2000) Factors predicting safe-sex talk and condom use in early sexual relationships. Health Communication12(2): 195–218.
79.
VandelloJABossonJK (2013) Hard won and easily lost: A review and synthesis of research on precarious manhood. Psychology of Men and Masculinity14(2): 101–113.
80.
VandelloJABossonJKLawlerJR (2019) Precarious manhood and men’s health disparities. In: GriffithDMBruceMAThorpeRJ (eds) Men’s Health Equity: A Handbook. New York and London: Routledge, pp. 27–41.
81.
VandelloJABossonJKCohenD, et al. (2008) Precarious manhood. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology95: 1325–1339.
82.
VandelloJAUptonRAWilkersonM, et al. (2023) Cultural beliefs about manhood predict anti-LGBTQ+ attitudes and policies. Sex Roles88: 442–458.
83.
WandHRamjeeG (2012) The relationship between age of coital debut and HIV seroprevalence among women in Durban, South Africa: A cohort study. BMJ Open2(1): e000285.
84.
WeatherallAWaltonM (1999) The metaphorical construction of sexual experience in a speech community of New Zealand university students. British Journal of Social Psychology38(4): 479–498.
