Barriers to Increasing Teacher Diversity: The Need to Move Beyond Aspirational Legislation

Abstract

Research has found that teachers of color contribute to better academic, behavioral, and socioemotional outcomes for diverse students. Despite these benefits, the diversity of the teacher workforce in the United States has not kept pace with increases in student diversity. States have adopted aspirational legislation aimed at increasing teaching diversity, but have fallen short of diversity targets. This qualitative study examines barriers to increasing teacher diversity by presenting the efforts to do so at 28 diverse-by-design charter schools across five locales. Despite a range of approaches, these schools struggled to meet teacher diversity targets, suggesting a need for states to adopt alternate policy instruments rather than relying on legislative mandates.

Keywords

educational policy teachers urban education school reform charter schools

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aragon

(2018). Targeted teacher recruitment: What is the issue and why does it matter? Policy snapshot. Education Commission of the States.

Bates

L. A.

Glick

J. E.

(2013). Does it matter if teachers and schools match the student? Racial and ethnic disparities in problem behaviors. Social Science Research, 42(5), 1180–1190.

Bianco

Leech

N. L.

Mitchell

(2011). Pathways to teaching: African American male teens explore teaching as a career. The Journal of Negro Education, 80(3), 368–383.

Bianco

Marin-Paris

(2019). Pathways2Teaching: Addressing the teacher diversity gap through a grow your own program. Teaching Exceptional Children, 52(1), 38–40.

Boyd

Lankford

Loeb

Wyckoff

(2005). Explaining the short careers of high-achieving teachers in schools with low-performing students. American Economic Review, 95(2), 166–171.

Brockenbrough

(2014). “The discipline stop”: Black male teachers and the politics of urban school discipline. Education and Urban Society, 47(5), 499–522. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013124514530154

Bryan

Ford

D. Y.

(2014). Recruiting and retaining Black male teachers in gifted education. Gifted Child Today, 37(3), 156–161.

Burgess

Greaves

(2013). Test scores, subjective assessment, and stereotyping of ethnic minorities. Journal of Labor Economics, 31(3), 535–576.

Carver-Thomas

(2018). Diversifying the teaching profession: How to recruit and retain teachers of color. Learning Policy Institute.

10.

Charmaz

(2006). Constructing grounded theory: A practical guide through qualitative analysis. SAGE.

11.

Cheng

D. A.

(2019). Teacher racial composition and exclusion rates among Black or African American students. Education and Urban Society, 51(6), 822–847. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013124517748724

12.

Chief Education Office. (2016). 2016 Oregon educator equity report. Author.

13.

Coburn

(2020). Teacher diversity starts with belonging. Achieving and Succeeding With Teacher Diversity, 15(20). https://www.ascd.org/el/articles/teacher-diversity-starts-with-belonging

14.

Council of Chief State School Officers. (2019). A vision and guidance for a diverse and learner-ready teacher workforce. https://ccsso.org/resource-library/vision-and-guidance-diverse-and-learner-ready-teacher-workforce

15.

Darling-Hammond

(2010). The flat world and education: How America’s commitment to equity will determine our future. Teachers College Press.

16.

Dee

T. S.

(2004). Teachers, race and student achievement in a randomized experiment. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 86(1), 195–210. https://doi.org/10.1162/003465304323023750

17.

Durand

T. M.

Tavaras

C. L.

(2021). Countering complacency with radical reflection: Supporting White teachers in the enactment of critical multicultural praxis. Education and Urban Society, 53(2), 146–162. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013124520927680

18.

Egalite

A. J.

Kisida

Winters

M. A.

(2015). Representation in the classroom: The effect of own-race teachers on student achievement. Economics of Education Review, 45, 44–52. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econedurev.2015.01.007

19.

Ehrenberg

R. G.

Goldhaber

D. D.

Brewer

D. J.

(1995). Do teachers’ race, gender, and ethnicity matter? Evidence from the National Educational Longitudinal Study of 1988. Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 48(3), 547–561.

20.

Evans

Erwin

Macdonald

Pompelia

Aragon

Perez

(2019). 50-state comparison: Teacher recruitment and retention. Education Commission of the States.

21.

Fairlie

R. W.

Hoffmann

Oreopoulos

(2014). A community college instructor like me: Race and ethnicity interactions in the classroom. American Economic Review, 104(8), 2567–2591.

22.

Farinde-Wu

(2018). #Blackwomenatwork: Teaching and retention in urban schools. The Urban Review, 50(2), 247–266. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11256-018-0449-x

23.

Ferguson

R. F.

(2003). Teachers’ perceptions and expectations and the Black-White test score gap. Urban Education, 38(4), 460–507.

24.

Fiddiman

(2020). To attract racially diverse teachers, reduce student loan debt. Achieving and Succeeding With Teacher Diversity, 15(20). https://www.ascd.org/el/articles/to-attract-racially-diverse-teachers-reduce-student-loan-debt

25.

Ford

D. Y.

Grantham

T. C.

Harris III

J. J

. (1997). The recruitment and retention of minority teachers in gifted education. Roeper Review, 19(4), 213–220. https://doi.org/10.1080/02783199709553832

26.

Francies

(2020). Improving teacher workforce diversity. Education Commission of the States.

27.

Gershenson

Hart

Lindsay

Papageorge

N. W.

(2017). The long-run impacts of same-race teachers (IZA Discussion Paper No. 10630). https://ssrn.com/abstract=2940620

28.

Gershenson

Holt

S. B.

Papageorge

N. W.

(2016). Who believes in me? The effect of student–teacher demographic match on teacher expectations. Economics of Education Review, 52, 209–224.

29.

Gist

C. D.

Bianco

Lynn

(2019). Examining grow your own programs across the teacher development continuum: Mining research on teachers of color and nontraditional educator pipelines. Journal of Teacher Education, 70(1), 13–25.

30.

Gist

C. D.

White

Bianco

(2018). Pushed to teach: Pedagogies and policies for a Black women educator pipeline. Education and Urban Society, 50(1), 56–86. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013124517727584

31.

Goings

R. B.

Bianco

(2016). It’s hard to be who you don’t see: An exploration of Black male high school students’ perspectives on becoming teachers. The Urban Review, 48(4), 628–646.

32.

Grissom

J. A.

Rodriguez

L. A.

Kern

E. C.

(2017). Teacher and principal diversity and the representation of students of color in gifted programs: Evidence from national data. The Elementary School Journal, 117(3), 396–422.

33.

Haddix

M. M.

(2017). Diversifying teaching and teacher education: Beyond rhetoric and toward real change. Journal of Literacy Research, 49(1), 141–149.

34.

Hanushek

E. A.

Kain

J. F.

Rivkin

S. G.

(2004). Why public schools lose teachers. Journal of Human Resources, 39(2), 326–354.

35.

Hanushek

E. A.

Pace

R. R.

(1995). Who chooses to teach (and why)? Economics of Education Review, 14(2), 101–117.

36.

Hirsch

Koppich

Knapp

(2001). Revisiting what states are doing to improve the quality of teaching. Center for the Study of Teaching and Policy, University of Washington.

37.

Ingersoll

May

. (2011). Recruitment, retention and the minority teacher shortage. Consortium for Policy Research in Education.

38.

Ingersoll

Merrill

Stuckey

(2018). The changing face of teaching. Educational Leadership, 75(8), 44.

39.

Irizarry

J. G.

(2007). “Home-Growing” teachers of color: Lessons learned from a town-grown partnership. Teacher Education Quarterly, 34(4), 87–102.

40.

Kirby

S. N.

Berends

Naftel

(1999). Supply and demand of minority teachers in Texas: Problems and prospects. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 21(1), 4766.

41.

Kohli

(2018). Behind school doors: The impact of hostile racial climates on urban teachers of color. Urban Education, 53(3), 307–333. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085916636653

42.

Lankford

Loeb

Wyckoff

(2002). Teacher sorting and the plight of urban schools: A descriptive analysis. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 24(1), 37–62.

43.

Lau

K. F.

Dandy

E. B.

Hoffman

(2007). The pathways program: A model for increasing the number of teachers of color. Teacher Education Quarterly, 34(4), 27–40.

44.

Lindsay

C. A.

Hart

C. M. D.

(2017). Teacher race and school discipline: Are students suspended less often when they have a teacher of the same race? Education Next, 17(1), 72–78.

45.

LoCascio

S. J.

Smeaton

P. S.

Waters

F. H.

(2016). How induction programs affect the decision of alternate route urban teachers to remain teaching. Education and Urban Society, 48(2), 103–125. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013124513514772

46.

Lyons

(2019). Bill requiring more minority teachers in connecticut schools goes to lamont. The CT Mirror. https://ctmirror.org/2019/06/04/bill-requiring-more-minority-teachers-in-connecticut-schools-goes-to-lamont-for-signing/

47.

Maxwell

J. A.

(2013). Qualitative research design: An interactive approach (3rd ed.). SAGE.

48.

McDonnell

L. M.

Elmore

R. F.

(1987). Getting the job done: Alternative policy instruments. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 9(2), 133–152.

49.

Merriam

S. B.

(2009). Qualitative research: A guide to design and implementation. Jossey-Bass.

50.

Mikulyuk

A. B.

Braddock

J. H.

(2018). K-12 school diversity and social cohesion: Evidence in support of a compelling state interest. Education and Urban Society, 50(1), 5–37. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013124516678045

51.

Miles

M. B.

Huberman

A. M.

Saldana

(2013). Qualitative data analysis. SAGE.

52.

Mitchell

(2019). Wanted: Teachers as diverse as their students. Districts try ‘grow your own’ programs to get the workforce to better mirror the student body. Education Week, 39(5), 1–8.

53.

Naslund

Ponomariov

(2019). Do charter schools alleviate the negative effect of teacher turnover? Management in Education, 33(3). https://doi.org/10.1177/0892020618780963

54.

National Center for Education Statistics. (2016). Trends in public and private school principal demographics and qualifications: 1987-88 to 2011-12. U.S. Department of Education. https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2016/2016189.pdf

55.

O’Dea

(2019). Lawmakers seeking more diversity among NJ’s public school teachers. NY Spotlight News. https://www.njspotlightnews.org/2019/02/19-02-07-lawmakers-look-to-increase-diversity-among-njs-public-school-teachers/

56.

Patton

M. Q.

(2002). Qualitative research and evaluation methods (3rd ed.). SAGE.

57.

Reed

C. B.

(2007). The future cannot wait. Change: The Magazine of Higher Learning, 39(6), 28–33.

58.

Scott

L. A.

(2017). Experience of Black male special education teachers: Are alternative licensure programs the desired route for recruitment and preparation? Education and Urban Society, 51(3), 332–350. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013124517719971

59.

Scott

S. V.

Rodriguez

L. F.

(2015). “A Fly in the Ointment” African American male preservice teachers’ experiences with stereotype threat in teacher education. Urban Education, 50(6), 689–717.

60.

Sohn

(2009). Teacher turnover: An issue of workgroup racial diversity. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 17(11), 1–26. https://doi.org/10.14507/epaa.v17n11.2009

61.

Starck

J. G.

Riddle

Sinclair

Warikoo

(2020). Teachers are people too: Examining the racial bias of teachers compared to other American adults. Educational Researcher, 49(4), 273–284. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X20912758

62.

Torres

Santos

Peck

N. L.

Cortes

(2004). Minority teacher recruitment, development, and retention. Northeast and Islands Regional Educational Laboratory Lab.

63.

Ujifusa

(2019). Groups tell Washington to make teacher diversity a priority, but how? EducationWeek. https://www.edweek.org/education/groups-tell-washington-to-make-teacher-diversity-a-priority-but-how-exactly/2019/05

64.

Wallace

D. L.

Gagen

L. M.

(2020). African American males’ decisions to teach: Barriers, motivations, and supports necessary for completing a teacher preparation program. Education and Urban Society, 52(3), 415–432. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013124519846294

65.

Wronowski

M. L.

(2018). Filling the void: A grounded theory approach to addressing teacher recruitment and retention in urban schools. Education and Urban Society, 50(6), 548–574. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013124517713608