Weaponized volunteering in schools: The discourse of volunteering and pre-military education in Israeli high schools

Abstract

This article examines the interrelations between two educational endeavors in Israeli high schools, which are usually perceived as separated. The first is a pre-military education program that is an inherent part of Israeli schools’ formal and nonformal curriculum. The second is the incorporation of volunteering activity in and for the community as a compulsory prerequisite for the matriculation diploma. An integrative analysis of policy and curricular documents of both programs suggests that a shared common discursive framework characterizes these programs. This discourse glorifies an ideal Israeli citizen who serves his country through both civic volunteering and military service. This dual discourse blurs the boundaries between what is considered civic and what is considered military in the education system. Thus, it calls for a reconsideration of the ways in which civic education may be implemented in the education system together with militaristic ideals.

Keywords

Civic education discourse militarism service learning volunteering weaponized volunteering

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abowitz

Harnish

(2006) Contemporary discourses of citizenship. Review of Educational Research 76(4): 653–690.

Apple

(2014) Official Knowledge: Democratic Education in a Conservative Age. New York: Routledge.

Ball

(1993) What is policy? Texts, trajectories and toolboxes. The Australian Journal of Education Studies 13(2): 10–17.

Banks

(2017) Failed citizenship and transformative civic education. Educational Researcher 46(7): 366–377.

Bentwich

(2014) Education in Israel (ILS 222). New York: Routledge.

Bickford

Reynolds

(2002) Activism and service-learning: Reframing volunteerism as acts of dissent. Pedagogy 2(2): 229–252.

Cohen

(2010) A theoretical model of four conceptions of civic education. Canadian Social Studies 44(1): 17–28.

Cohen

(2016) Navigating competing conceptions of civic education: Lessons from three Israeli civics classrooms. Oxford Review of Education 42(4): 391–407.

Cohen

(2019a) Israel’s civic education wars: A review of the literature and theoretical implications. Educational Review 71(3): 287–305.

10.

Cohen

(2019b) Typologies of citizenship and civic education: From ideal types to a reflective tool. In: Peterson

Stahl

Soong

(eds) The Palgrave Handbook of Citizenship and Education. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan, pp.1–18.

11.

Director General’s Circular (DGC) (2015) The Program for Personal Development and Social Engagement (VP). Jerusalem, Israel: Ministry of Education (in Hebrew).

12.

Director General’s Circular (DGC) (2018) Meaningful Service and Preparation for the IDF (MP). Jerusalem, Israel: Ministry of Education (in Hebrew).

13.

Dror

(2007) The history of Israeli non-formal education, 1920-2000: Dimensions drawn from the past. Israel Studies Review 22(1): 75–99.

14.

Eastwood

(2017) Ethics as a Weapon of War: Militarism and Morality in Israel. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

15.

Eyal

Yarm

(2018) Schools in cross-sector alliances: What do schools seek in partnerships? Educational Administration Quarterly 54(4): 648–688.

16.

Farahmandpour

(2011) Beyond 40 hours: Meaningful community service and high school student volunteerism in Ontario. Doctoral dissertation, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada. Available at: https://tspace.library.utoronto.ca/bitstream/1807/29472/6/Farahmandpour_Hoda_201106_MA_Thesis.pdf

17.

Foucault

(1977) The Archology of Knowledge. London: Tavistock.

18.

Galston

(2004) Civic education and political participation. PS: Political Science and Politics 37(2): 263–266.

19.

Gazit

Levy

(eds) (2016) The Relationship of the Army with the Education System in Israel. Ra’anana, Israel: Open University Press (in Hebrew).

20.

Gibson

Levine

(2003) The Civic Mission of Schools (Report). New York: Carnegie Corporation of New York; The Center for Information and Research on Civic Learning and Engagement.

21.

Gifford

Mycock

Murakami

(2014) Becoming citizens in late modernity: A global-national comparison of young people in Japan and the UK. Citizenship Studies 18(1): 81–98.

22.

Gillborn

(2006) Citizenship education as placebo: ‘Standards’, institutional racism and education policy. Education, Citizenship and Social Justice 1(1): 83–104.

23.

Girsh

(2019) Negotiating the uniform: Youth attitudes towards military service in Israel. YoUnG 27(3): 304–320.

24.

Hebert

Hauf

(2015) Student learning through service learning: Effects on academic development, civic responsibility, interpersonal skills and practical skills. Active Learning in Higher Education 16(1): 37–49.

25.

Henderson

Brown

Pancer

, et al. (2007) Mandated community service in high school and subsequent civic engagement: The case of the ‘double cohort’ in Ontario, Canada. Journal of Youth and Adolescence 36(7): 849–860.

26.

Holdsworth

Brewis

(2014) Volunteering, choice and control: A case study of higher education student volunteering. Journal of Youth Studies 17(2): 204–219.

27.

Honohan

(2017) Liberal and republican conceptions of citizenship. In: Shachar

Bauböck

Bloemraad

, et al. (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Citizenship. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.83–106.

28.

Kimmerling

(1993) Patterns of militarism in Israel. European Journal of Sociology/Archives Européennes de Sociologie 34(2): 196–223.

29.

LeCompte

Blevins

(2015) Building civic bridges: Community-centred action civics. The Social Studies 106(5): 209–217.

30.

Lemish

(2003) Civic and citizenship education in Israel. Cambridge Journal of Education 33(1): 53–72.

31.

Levstik

Tyson

(Eds) (2010) Handbook of Research in Social Studies Education. New York: Routledge.

32.

Levy

Sasson-Levy

(2008) Militarized socialization, military service, and class reproduction: The experiences of Israeli soldiers. Sociological Perspectives 51(2): 349–374.

33.

Levy

Lomsky-Feder

Harel

(2007) From ‘obligatory militarism’ to ‘contractual militarism’ competing models of citizenship. Israel Studies 12(1): 127–148.

34.

Merry

(2020) Can schools teach citizenship? Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education 41(1): 124–138.

35.

Ministry of Education (2010) Preparing for Meaningful Service (MP). Jerusalem, Israel: Ministry of Education (in Hebrew).

36.

Ministry of Education (2015) Personal Development and Social Involvement (VP). Jerusalem, Israel: Ministry of Education (in Hebrew).

37.

MP-Portfolio (2018) Preparing for Meaningful Service. Jerusalem, Israel: Ministry of Education.

38.

National Authority for Measurement and Evaluation in Education (RAMA) (2017) Meaning Full Service – Preparation for the IDF: Evaluation Report (MP). Jerusalem, Israel: Ministry of Education (in Hebrew).

39.

National Authority for Measurement and Evaluation in Education (RAMA) (2018) Engagement: Evaluation (VP, Report). Jerusalem, Israel: Ministry of Education (in Hebrew).

40.

Niemi

Hepburn

Chapman

(2000) Community service by high school students: A cure for civic ills? Political Behavior 22(1): 45–69.

41.

Nir

Ben-David

Bogler

, et al. (2016) School autonomy and 21st century skills in the Israeli educational system. International Journal of Educational Management 30: 1231–1246.

42.

Pinson

(2007) Inclusive curriculum? Challenges to the role of civic education in a Jewish and democratic state. Curriculum Inquiry 37(4): 351–382.

43.

Reichert

(2018) Civic participation of high school students: The effect of civic learning in school. Educational Review 70(3): 318–341.

44.

Schwille

Amadeo

(2002) The paradoxical situation of civic education in schools: Ubiquitous and yet exclusive. In: Steiner-Khamsi

Torney-Purta

Schwille

(eds) New Paradigms and Recurring Paradoxes in Education for Citizenship: An International Comparison. Bingley: Emerald Group Publishing, pp.105–136.

45.

Sheffer

Barak

(eds) (2010) Militarism and Israeli Society. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.

46.

Snir

Eylon

(2017) Civic republicanism and education: Democracy and social justice in school. Studies in Philosophy and Education 36(5): 585–600.

47.

State Education Law, 5713–1953, 7 LSI 113 (1952–53) (Isr.). https://www.knesset.gov.il/review/data/eng/law/kns2_education_eng.pdf

48.

VP-Portfolio (2018). Personal Development and Social Involvement. Jerusalem, Israel: Ministry of Education.

49.

Wade

(1995) Developing active citizens: Community service learning in social studies teacher education. The Social Studies 86(3): 122–128.

50.

Wade

(2004) Citizenship for social justice. Kappa Delta Pi Record 40(2), 64–68.

51.

Wade

(2007) Service-learning for social justice in the elementary classroom: Can we get there from here? Equity & Excellence in Education 40(2): 156–165.

52.

Wade

(2010) Service-learning. In: Levstik

Tyson

(eds) Handbook of Research in Social Studies Education. New York: Routledge, pp.109–123.

53.

Westheimer

(ed.) (2007) Pledging Allegiance: The Politics of Patriotism in American’s Schools. New York: Teachers College Press.

54.

Westheimer

(2019) Civic education and the rise of populist nationalism. Peabody Journal of Education 94(1): 4–16.

55.

Westheimer

Kahne

(2004) Educating the ‘good’ citizen: Political choices and pedagogical goals. PS: Political Science and Politics 37(2): 241–247.

56.

Wilson

(2000) Volunteering. Annual Review of Sociology 26(1): 215–240.

57.

Yemini

Addi-Raccah

(2013) School principals’ agency as reflected by extracurricular activities in the Israeli education system. International Studies in Sociology of Education 23(4): 358–382.

58.

Youniss

(2011) Civic education: What schools can do to encourage civic identity and action. Applied Developmental Science 15(2): 98–103.