After being overlooked in major education debates and policy initiatives for decades, civic education has recently become the topic of highly polarized debates and legislative battles over what and how we should be teaching our young people about the nation’s history. How should racial injustice be discussed in schools? Are schools indoctrinating students? In a robust democracy, controversy about what students should learn is appropriate and desirable, but some of the rhetoric that has dominated the recent discussions violates the deliberative norms that schools should help students to develop. At a time when the public should be carefully deliberating how to educate students, civic education is instead being used instrumentally to win political contests. I present one approach to facing this challenge—the Educating for American Democracy project. This project is not the conclusive answer to the question, “What should we teach?” but rather an attempt to model deliberative values, and I show that it offers important lessons for people and institutions who are attempting to address matters of curricular content.
AllenDanielle. 2004. Talking to strangers: Anxieties of citizenship since Brown v. Board of Education. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
3.
BeatieNancyBurkholderZoë. 2021. From the diffusion of knowledge to the cultivation of agency: A short history of civic education policy and practice in the United States. In Educating for civic reasoning and discourse, eds. LeeCarol D.WhiteGregoryDongDian, 109–56. Washington, DC: National Academy of Education.
4.
BellahRobert N.1967. Civil religion in America. Dædalus [Journal of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences]96 (1): 1–21.
5.
CarresePaul. 2023. Civic preparation of American youth: Reflective patriotism and our constitutional democracy. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science (this volume).
6.
ChenowethEricaHamiltonBarton H.LeeHedwigPapageorgeNicholas W.RollStephen P.ZahnMatthew V.2022. Who protests, what do they protest, and why? NBER Working Paper 29987, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.
CookTimothy E.1985. The bear market in political socialization and the costs of misunderstood psychological theories. American Political Science Review79 (4): 1079–93.
DurkheimÉmile. 1912/2008. The elementary forms of religious life. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
11.
Educating for American Democracy (EAD). 2March2021. Educating for American democracy: Excellence in history and civics for all learners. iCivics. Available from www.educatingforamericandemocracy.org.
12.
GibsonCynthiaLevinePeter. 2003. The civic mission of schools. College Park, MD: CIRCLE and Carnegie Corporation of New York.
GouldJonathanJamiesonKathleen HallLevinePeterMcConnellTedSmithDavid B.2011. Guardian of democracy: The civic mission of schools. Philadelphia, PA: Lenore Annenberg Institute of Civics of the Annenberg Public Policy Center, Campaign for the Civic Mission of Schools.
15.
KurtzStanley. 2March2021. GOP suicide by civics. National Review.
16.
LevinePeter. 2022. Putting the U.S. Constitution in its place. In Citizenship and civic leadership in America, eds. McNamaraCarolShellyTrevor, 281–92. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.
17.
LevinePeterAbromowitzDavid. 2023. Challenges reported by candidates for local office. State and Local Government Review55 (2): 139–52. doi:10.1177/0160323X221130449.
RansbyBarbara. 2018. Making all Black lives matter: Reimagining freedom in the twenty-first century. Kindle ed. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
21.
RogersJohnIshimotoMichaelKwakoAlexanderBerrymanAnthonyDieraClaudia. 2019. School and society in the age of Trump. Los Angeles, CA: UCLA’s Institute for Democracy, Education, and Access.
SchwartzSarah. 11June2021. Map: Where critical race theory is under attack. Education Week. Updated 15 July 2021.
24.
StitzleinSarah M.2021. Defining and implementing civic reasoning and discourse: Philosophical and moral foundations for research and practice. In Educating for civic reasoning and discourse, eds. LeeCarol D.WhiteGregoryDongDian, 23–52. Washington, DC: National Academy of Education.
25.
StoutCathrynWilburnThomas. 1February2022. CRT map: Efforts to restrict teaching racism and bias have multiplied across the U.S. ChalkBeat.
26.
SwanKathyBartonKeithBucklesStephenBurkeFlanneryCharkinsJimGrantS. G.HardwickSusanLeeJohnLevinePeterLevinsonMeiraMarriAnand. 2013. The college, career, and civic life (C3) framework for social studies state standards: Guidance for enhancing the rigor of K-12 civics, economics, geography, and history. Silver Spring, MD: National Council for the Social Studies.
27.
Sweet-CushmanJennie. 2020. Where does the pipeline get leaky? The progressive ambition of school board members and personal and political network recruitment. Politics, Groups, and Identities8 (4): 762–85.
Wallace-WellsBenjamin. 18June2021. How a conservative activist invented the conflict over critical race theory. The New Yorker. Available from www.newyorker.com.
32.
WooAshleyWolfeRebecca L.SteinerElizabeth D.DoanSyLawrenceRebecca AnnBerdieLisaGreerLucasGittensAllyson D.SchwartzHeather L.2022. Walking a fine line—Educators’ views on politicized topics in schooling: Findings from the State of the American Teacher and State of the American Principal Surveys. Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation. Available from https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RRA1108-5.html.
