Many parties have seen declines in working-class legislators and increases in professional career politicians. I argue that career politicians are more likely to adopt policies for strategic political reasons, whereas working-class politicians are more likely to represent the interests of working-class voters. Changes in the representation of these occupational groups matter substantively whenever legislators’ strategic concerns contradict the interests of working-class voters. Welfare reforms adopted in the 1990s and 2000s by the British Labour Party exhibit this divergence. The two types of politicians held very different policy positions, which I measure using a scaling method applied to all speeches made about welfare in the House of Commons from 1987 to 2007. The results carry over to voting behavior and are robust to alternative explanations, including other characteristics of both MPs and their voters. The changing representation of occupational groups has therefore had substantive policy effects, lowering the political influence of working-class voters.
AdolphC. (2013). Bankers, bureaucrats and central bank politics: The myth of neutrality. London, England: Cambridge University Press.
2.
AlexiadouD. (2015). Ideologues, partisans, and loyalists: Cabinet ministers and social welfare reform in parliamentary democracies. Comparative Political Studies, 48, 1051-1086.
3.
AllenP. (2013). Linking pre-parliamentary political experience and the career trajectories of the 1997 general election cohort. Parliamentary Affairs, 66, 685-707.
4.
Austen-SmithD. (1990). Information transmission in debate. American Journal of Political Science, 34, 124-152.
5.
BenedettoG.HixS. (2007). The rejected, the ejected, and the dejected: Explaining government rebels in the 2001-2005 British House of Commons. Comparative Political Studies, 40, 755-781.
6.
BestH.CottaM. (2000). Elite transformation and modes of representation since the mid-nineteenth century: Some theoretical considerations. In BestH.CottaM. (Eds.), Parliamentary representatives in Europe 1848-2000: Legislative recruitment and careers in eleven European countries (pp. 1-28). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
7.
BorchertJ. (2003). Professional politicians: Towards a comparative perspective. In BorchertJ.ZeissJ. (Eds.), The political class in advanced democracies (pp. 1-25). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
8.
BudgeI.EzrowL.McDonaldM. D. (2010). Ideology, party factionalism and policy change: An integrated dynamic theory. British Journal of Political Science, 40, 781-804.
9.
BusemeyerM.GoerresA.WeschleS. (2009). Attitudes towards redistributive spending in an era of demographic ageing: The rival pressures from age and income in 14 OECD countries. Journal of European Social Policy, 19, 195-212.
10.
ButticeM.MilazzoC. (2011). Candidate positioning in Britain. Electoral Studies, 30, 848-857.
11.
CairneyP. (2007). The professionalisation of MPs: Refining the “politics-facilitating” explanation. Parliamentary Affairs, 60, 212-233.
12.
CampbellR.CowleyP. (2014). Rich man, poor man, politician man: Wealth effects in a candidate biography survey experiment. British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 16, 56-74.
13.
CarnesN. (2012). Does the numerical underrepresentation of the working class in congress matter?Legislative Studies Quarterly, 37, 5-34.
14.
CarnesN. (2013). White-collar government: The hidden role of class in economic policy-making. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
15.
CarnesN.LupuN. (2015). Rethinking the comparative perspective on class and representation: Evidence from Latin America. American Journal of Political Science, 59, 1-18.
16.
CarnesN.LupuN. (2016). Do voters dislike working-class candidates? Voter biases and the descriptive underrepresentation of the working class. American Political Science Review, 110, 832-844.
17.
ClasenJ. (2005). Reforming European welfare states: Germany and the United Kingdom compared. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
18.
CowleyP. (2002). Revolts and rebellions: Parliamentary voting under Blair. London, England: Politico.
19.
CowleyP. (2012). Arise, novice leader! The continuing rise of the career politician in Britain. Politics, 32, 31-38.
20.
CowleyP.StuartM. (1997). Sodomy, slaughter, Sunday shopping and seatbelts: Free votes in the house of commons, 1979 to 1996. Party Politics, 3, 119-130.
21.
CoxG.McCubbinsM. D. (2005). Setting the agenda: Responsible party government in the U.S. house of representatives. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
22.
CoxG.McCubbinsM. D. (2007). Legislative leviathan: Party government in the house (2nd ed.). New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
23.
EvansG. (1999). Class voting: From premature obituary to reasoned appraisal. In EvansG. (Ed.), The end of class politics? Class voting in comparative context (pp. 1-20). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
24.
EvansG.TilleyJ. (2012). How parties shape class politics: Explaining the decline of the class basis of party support. British Journal of Political Science, 42, 137-161.
25.
EvansG.TilleyJ. (2017). The new politics of class: The political evolution of the British working class. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
26.
FiersS.SeckerI. (2007). A career through the party: The recruitment of party politicians in parliament. In CottaM.BestH. (Eds.), Democratic representation in Europe: Diversity, change, and convergence (pp. 136-159). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
27.
GingrichJ.HausermanS. (2015). The decline of the working-class vote, the reconfiguration of the welfare support coalition and consequences for the welfare state. Journal of European Social Policy, 25, 50-75.
28.
GoplerudM. (2015). The first time is (mostly) the charm: Special advisers as parliamentary candidates and members of parliament. Parliamentary Affairs, 68, 332-351.
29.
GrimmerJ.StewartB. M. (2013). Text as data: The promise and pitfalls of automatic content analysis methods for political texts. Political Analysis, 21, 267-297.
30.
HakhverdianA. (2015). Does it matter that most representatives are higher educated?Swiss Political Science Review, 21, 61-74.
31.
HanrettyC.LauderdaleB.VivyanN. (2017). Dyadic representation in a West-minster system. Legislative Studies Quarterly, 42, 235-267.
32.
HayC. (1999). The political economy of new labour: Labouring under false pretences?Manchester, MA: Manchester University Press.
33.
HeathA. F.JowellR. M.CurticeJ. (2001). The rise of new labour: Party policies and voter choices. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
34.
HeathO. (2016). Policy alienation, social alienation and working-class abstention in Britain, 1964-2010. British Journal of Political Science. Advance online publication. doi: 10.1017/S0007123416000272.
35.
HeuwieserR. J. (2018). Submissive lobby fodder or assertive political actors? Party loyalty of career politicians in the UK house of commons, 2005-15. Legislative Studies Quarterly, 43, 305-341.
36.
HibbingJ.MarshD. (1987). Accounting for the voting patterns of British MPs on free votes. Legislative Studies Quarterly, 12, 275-297.
37.
HoutM. (2008). How class works: Objective and subjective aspects of class since the 1970s. In LareauA.ConleyD. (Eds.), Social class: How does it work? (pp. 25-64). New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.
38.
HyytinnenA.MerilainenJ.SaarimaaT.ToivanenO.TukainenJ. (2018). Public Employees as politicians: Evidence from close elections. American Political Science Review, 112, 68-81.
39.
IversenT.RosenbluthF. (2006). The political economy of gender: Explaining cross-national variation in the gender division of labor and the gender voting gap. American Journal of Political Science, 50, 1-19.
40.
IversenT.SoskiceD. (2001). An asset theory of social policy preferences. American Political Science Review, 95, 875-893.
41.
JunU. (2003). Great Britain: From the prevalence of the amateur to the professional politician. In BorchertJ.ZeissJ. (Eds.), The political class in advanced democracies (pp. 164-186). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
42.
KellermanM. (2012). Estimating ideal points in the British House of Commons using early day motions. American Journal of Political Science, 56, 757-771.
43.
KitscheltH.RehmP. (2014). Occupations as a site of political preference formation. Comparative Political Studies, 47, 1670-1706.
44.
KoopR.BittnerA. (2011). Parachuted into parliament: Candidate nomination, appointed candidates, and legislative roles in Canada. Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties, 21, 431-452.
45.
LamprinakouC.MorucciM.CampbellR.van Heerde-HudsonJ. (2017). All change in the house? The profile of candidates and MPs in the 2015 British general election. Parliamentary Affairs, 70, 207-232.
46.
LaverM.BenoitK.GarryJ. (2003). Extracting policy positions from political texts using words as data. American Political Science Review, 97, 311-331.
47.
LoweW. (2008). Understanding wordscores. Political Analysis, 16, 356-371.
48.
LuptonR.HillsJ.StewartK.VizardP. (2013). Labour’s social policy record: Policy, spending and outcomes 1997-2010 (LSE Center for the Analysis of Social Exclusion, “Social Policy in a Cold Climate” project, Research Report 1).
49.
MacKenzieS. A. (2015). Life before congress: Using pre-congressional experience to assess competing explanations for political professionalism. Journal of Politics, 77, 505-518.
50.
MaltzmanF.SigelmanL. (1996). The politics of talk: Unconstrained floor time in the US house of representatives. Journal of Politics, 58, 819-830.
51.
ManzaJ.BrooksC. (2008). Class and politics. In LareauA.ConleyD. (Eds.), Social class: How does it work? (pp. 201-231). New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.
52.
MarxP.SchumacherG. (2013). Will to power? Intra-party conflict in social democratic parties and the choice for neoliberal policies in Germany, The Netherlands and Spain. European Political Science Review, 5, 151-173.
53.
NarudH. M.ValenH. (2008). The Norwegian storting: “People’s parliament” or coop for “political broilers”?World Political Science, 4(2), 1-34.
54.
NorrisP.LevenduskyJ. (1995). Political recruitment: Gender, race and class in the British parliament. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
55.
OhmuraT.BailerS.MeissnerP.SelbP. (2018). Party animals, career changers and other pathways into parliament. West European Politics, 41, 169-195.
56.
PallageS.ScruggsL.ZimmermanC. (2013). Measuring unemployment insurance generosity. Political Analysis, 21, 524-549.
57.
PattieC.FieldhouseE.JohnstonR. (1994). The price of conscience: The electoral correlates and consequences of free votes and rebellions in the British House of Commons, 1987-92. British Journal of Political Science, 24, 359-380.
58.
PedersenM. (2000). The incremental transformation of the Danish legislative elite: The party system as prime mover. In BestH.CottaM. (Eds.), Parliamentary representatives in Europe 1848–2000: Legislative recruitment and careers in eleven European countries (pp. 29-49). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
59.
ProkschS.-O.SlapinJ. (2012). Institutional foundations of legislative speech. American Journal of Political Science, 56, 520-537.
60.
RehmP. (2009). Risks and redistribution: An individual-level analysis. Comparative Political Studies, 42, 855-881.
61.
RuostetsaariI. (2000). From political amateur to professional politician and expert representative: Parliamentary recruitment in Finland since 1863. In BestH.CottaM. (Eds.), Parliamentary representatives in Europe 1848–2000: Legislative recruitment and careers in eleven European countries (pp. 50-87). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
62.
ScarrowS. E. (1997). Political career paths and the European parliament. Legislative Studies Quarterly, 22, 253-263.
63.
ShabadG.SlomczynskiK. M. (2002). The emergence of career politicians in post-communist democracies: Poland and the Czech Republic. Legislative Studies Quarterly, 27, 333-359.
64.
SlapinJ.KirklandP.LazzarroJ.LeslieP.O’GradyT. (2018). Ideology, grandstanding, and strategic party disloyalty in the British Parliament. American Political Science Review, 112, 15-30.
65.
SmithT. (2013). Are you sitting comfortably? Estimating incumbency advantage in the UK: 1983-2010: A research note. Electoral Studies, 32, 167-173.
66.
StolzK. (2010). Towards a regional political class? Professional politicians and regional institutions in Catalonia and Scotland. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
67.
StromK. (1990). A behavioral theory of competitive political parties. American Journal of Political Science, 34, 565-598.
68.
SvallforsS. (2006). The moral economy of class: Class and attitudes in comparative perspective. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
69.
vanHeerde-HudsonJ.CampbellR. (2015). Parliamentary candidates UK dataset (v. 1). Available from www.parliamentarycandidates.org
70.
VivyanN.WagnerM. (2012). Do voters reward rebellion? The electoral accountability of MPs in Britain. European Journal of Political Research, 51, 235-264.
71.
WallerR.CriddleB. (1999). The almanac of British politics (6th ed.). London, England: Routledge.
72.
WautersB. (2012). Blue collars striking the red flag: Formal and descriptive representation of the working class in the Belgian house of representatives 1946-2007. Labor History, 53, 225-243.
73.
WeedenK.GruskyD. (2005). The case for a new class map. American Journal of Sociology, 111, 141-212.
74.
WoodS. (2001). Labour market regimes under threat? Sources of continuity in Germany, Britain, and Sweden. In PiersonP. (Ed.), The new politics of the welfare state (pp. 368-409). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
