Violence within armed groups in civil wars is important and understudied. Linking literatures on civil war violence and military politics, this article asks when this fratricidal violence targets soldiers who try to defect, and when it does not. It uses a unique data set of executions of officers on the Republican side of the Spanish Civil War. The article finds that while much of the violence appeared to target those who actually tried to defect, many nondefectors were likely shot too, due most likely to a pervasive stereotype that officers in general were disloyal to the Republic. This stereotype was used as an information shortcut and was promoted by political actors. Accordingly, unlikely defectors were likelier to be shot in locations in which less information was available about loyalties and in which political forces that were suspicious of officers as a group were locally stronger.
AlpertM. (2013). The Republican army in the Spanish civil war, 1936-1939. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
2.
BakkeK. M.CunninghamK. G.SeymourL. J. M. (2012). A plague of initials: Fragmentation, cohesion, and infighting in civil wars. Perspectives on Politics, 10, 265-283.
3.
BalcellsL. (2010). Rivalry and revenge: Violence against civilians in conventional civil wars. International Studies Quarterly, 54, 291-313.
4.
BellC.SudduthJ. K. (2017). The causes and outcomes of coup during civil war. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 61, 1432-1455.
5.
Bou NassifH. (2015). “Second-class”: The grievances of Sunni officers in the Syrian armed forces. Journal of Strategic Studies, 38, 626-649. doi:10.1080/01402390.2015.1053604
6.
BoydC. P. (1979). Praetorian politics in liberal Spain. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
7.
BraithwaiteJ. M.SudduthJ. K. (2016). Military purges and the recurrence of civil conflict. Research & Politics. doi: 10.1177/2053168016630730
8.
BrooksR. (1998). Political-military relations and the stability of Arab regimes (Adelphi Paper 324). London, England: International Institute for Strategic Studies.
9.
CardonaG. (1983). El Poder Militar En España Contemporanea Hasta La Guerra Civil [The military power in modern Spain up to the Civil War]. Madrid, Spain: Siglo XXI.
10.
CasanovaJ. (1999). Rebelión y revolución [Rebellion and revolution]. In JuliaS. (Ed.), Victimas de la Guerra civil [Victims of the Civil War] (pp. 57-186). Madrid, Spain: Temas de Hoy.
11.
Casas de la VegaR. (1994). El Terror: Madrid 1936 [The Terror: Madrid 1936]. Madridejos, Spain: Editorial Fénix.
12.
Castro DelgadoE. (1965). Hombres made in Moscú [Men made in Moscow]. Barcelona, Spain: Luis de Caralt.
13.
ChenowethE.StephanM. J. (2011). Why civil resistance works: The strategic logic of nonviolent conflict. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
14.
CordónG. A. (2008). Trayectoria. Recuerdos De Un Artillero [Trajectory: Memories of an artilleryman] (Edición: 1. Edición de Angel Viñas). Sevilla, Spain: Ediciones Espuela de Plata.
15.
CostaD. L.KahnM. E. (2008). Heroes and cowards: The social face of war. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
16.
DahlM. (2016). Military defection (PRIO Policy Brief 18). Oslo, Norway: Peace Research Institute Oslo.
17.
EngelC. (2008). El Cuerpo de Oficiales En La Guerra de España [The officer corps in the Spanish War]. Valladolid, Spain: Alcañiz Fresno’s Editores.
18.
FearonJ. D.LaitinD. D. (2003). Ethnicity, insurgency, and civil war. American Political Science Reviews, 97, 75-90.
19.
FjeldeH.NilssonD. (2012). Rebels against rebels: Explaining violence between rebel groups. Journal of Conflict Resolution56, 604-628.
20.
FraserR. (1979). Blood of Spain: The experience of civil war, 1936-1939. London, England: Allen Lane.
21.
GeddesB.WrightJ.FrantzE. (2014). Autocratic breakdown and regime transitions: A new data set. Perspectives on Politics, 12, 313-331.
22.
González CallejaE. (2012). Las Fuerzas de Orden Público Y La República. [The public safety forces and the Republic]. In ReverteJ. M. (Ed.), Los Militares Españoles En La Segunda República [The Spanish military officers in the Second Republic] (pp. 99-134). Madrid, Spain: Editorial Pablo Iglesias.
23.
GreenhillB.WardM. D.SacksA. (2011). The separation plot: A new visual method for evaluating the fit of binary models. American Journal of Political Science, 55, 991-1002.
24.
Gutiérrez SanínF.WoodE. J. (2017). “What should we mean by “pattern of political violence”? Repertoire, targeting, frequency, and technique. Perspectives on Politics, 15, 20-41. doi:10.1017/S1537592716004114
25.
HerrerosF.CriadoH. (2009). Pre-emptive or arbitrary: Two forms of lethal violence in a civil war. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 53, 419-445.
26.
KalyvasS. N. (2006). The logic of violence in civil war. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
27.
KalyvasS. N. (2012). Micro-level studies of violence in civil war: Refining and extending the control-collaboration model. Terrorism and Political Violence, 24, 658-668.
28.
KalyvasS. N.KocherM. A. (2007). How “free” is free riding in civil wars? Violence, insurgency, and the collective action problem. World Politics, 59, 177-216.
29.
KaufmannC. (1996). Intervention in ethnic and ideological civil wars: Why one can be done and the other can’t. Security Studies, 6, 62-101.
30.
KoehlerK.OhlD.AlbrechtH. (2016). From disaffection to defection: How networks facilitate military insubordination in civil conflict. Comparative Politics, 48, 439-457.
31.
KuranT. (1995). Private truths, public lies: The social consequences of preference falsification. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
32.
La Parra-PérezÁ. (2014). The Spanish civil war: A new institutional interpretation of the social order and military factions during the second Republic (1931-1939) (Doctoral dissertation). University of Maryland, College Park.
33.
La Parra-PerezÁ. (2016). Spain is not different. Institutional development and the army in the second Spanish republic and civil war. Revista Universitaria De Historia Militar, 5(9). Retrieved from http://ruhm.es/index.php/RUHM/article/view/155
34.
LedesmaJ. L. (2007). El 1936 Más Opaco: La Violencia En La Zona Republicana Durante La Guerra Civil Y Sus Narrativas [The most opaque 1936: the violence in republican territories during the Civil War and its narratives]. Historia Social, 58, 151-168.
35.
LyallJ. (2014). Why Armies break: Explaining mass desertion in conventional war (Working paper). New Haven, CT: Yale University.
36.
LynnJ. A. (1984). The bayonets of the Republic: Motivation and tactics in the army of Revolutionary France, 1791-94. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
37.
Martín BlázquezJ. (1939). I helped to build an army: Civil war memoirs of a Spanish staff officer. London, England: Secker and Warburg.
38.
McLauchlinT. (2010). Loyalty strategies and military defection in rebellion. Comparative Politics, 42, 333-350.
39.
McLauchlinT. (2014). Desertion, terrain, and control of the home front in civil wars. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 58, 1419-1444.
40.
McLauchlinT. (2015). Desertion and collective action in civil wars. International Studies Quarterly, 59, 669-679.
41.
McLauchlinT. (2017, February22). Ideologies, violence, and self-fulfilling prophecies of disloyalty: Evidence from Spain. Presented at the Annual Meeting of the International Studies Association, Baltimore, MD.
42.
McLauchlinT.PearlmanW. (2012). Out-group conflict, in-group unity? Exploring the effect of repression on intramovement cooperation. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 5641-66.
43.
OppenheimB.SteeleA.VargasJ. F.WeintraubM. (2015). True believers, deserters, and traitors: Who leaves insurgent groups and why. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 59, 794-823.
44.
ParkinsonS. E. (2013). Organizing rebellion: Rethinking high-risk mobilization and social networks in war. American Political Science Review, 107, 418-432.
45.
PayneS. G. (1970). The Spanish revolution. London, England: Weidenfeld & Nicolson.
46.
PayneS. G. (2006). The collapse of the Spanish republic, 1933-1936: Origins of the civil war. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
47.
PiplaniV.TalmadgeC. (2016). When war helps civil–military relations: Prolonged interstate conflict and the reduced risk of coups. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 60, 1368-1394.
48.
PrestonP. (2007). The Spanish civil war: Reaction, revolution, and revenge (Rev. & Expanded ed.). New York, NY: W.W. Norton.
49.
PrestonP. (2012). The Spanish Holocaust: Inquisition and extermination in twentieth-century Spain. New York, NY: W.W. Norton.
50.
Puell de la VillaF. (2012). Julio de 1936. ¿Un Ejército Dividido? [A divided army?] In ReverteJ. M. (Ed.), Los Militares Españoles En La Segunda República [The Spanish military officers in the Second Republic] (pp. 77-98). Madrid, Spain: Editorial Pablo Iglesias.
51.
QuinlivanJ. T. (1999). Coup-proofing: Its practice and consequences in the Middle East. International Security, 24, 131-165.
52.
Reig TapiaA. (1986). Ideología e historia: sobre la represión franquista y la Guerra civil [Ideology and history: on Francoist repression and the Civil War]. Madrid, Spain: Akal.
53.
RoesslerP. G. (2011). The enemy within: Personal rule, coups, and civil wars in Africa. World Politics, 63, 300-346.
54.
RuizJ. (2009). Seventy years on: Historians and repression during and after the Spanish Civil War. Journal of Contemporary History, 44, 449-472.
55.
SaidemanS. M.ZaharM.-J. (2008). Causing security, reducing fear: Deterring intra-state violence and assuring government restraint. In SaidemanS. M.ZaharM.-J. (Eds.), Intra-state conflict, governments and security: Dilemmas of deterrence and assurance (pp. 1-19). New York, NY: Routledge.
56.
Saíz ViaderoJ. (1979). Crónicas Sobre La Guerra Civil En Santander [Chronicles on the Civil War in Santander]. Santander, Spain: Institución Cultural de Cantabria.
57.
SchellingT. C. (1966). Arms and influence. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
58.
SinghN. (2014). Seizing power: The strategic logic of military coups. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
59.
Solé i SabatéJ. M.VillaroyaJ. (1990). La Repressió a La Rereguarda de Catalunya [The repression in the Catalan]: 1936-1939 (Vol. 2). Barcelona, Spain: Abadia de Montserrat.
60.
StanilandP. (2012). Between a rock and a hard place: Insurgent fratricide, ethnic defection, and the rise of pro-state paramilitaries. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 56, 16-40.
61.
SteeleA. (2009). Seeking safety: Avoiding displacement and choosing destinations in civil wars. Journal of Peace Research, 46, 419-429. doi:10.1177/0022343309102660
62.
SudduthJ. K. (2017). Strategic logic of elite purges in dictatorships. Comparative Political Studies, 50, 1768-1801.
63.
SvolikM. W. (2012). The politics of authoritarian rule. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
64.
TalmadgeC. (2015). The dictator’s army: Battlefield effectiveness in authoritarian regimes. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
65.
ThomasH. (1961). The Spanish civil war. New York, NY: Harper & Row.
66.
ZhukovY. M. (2014). A theory of indiscriminate violence. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
