A recurring question in public and scientific debates is whether occupation-specific skills enhance labor market outcomes. Is it beneficial to have an educational degree that is linked to only one or a small set of occupations? To answer this question, we generalize existing models of the effects of (mis)match between education and occupation on labor market outcomes. Specifically, we incorporate the structural effects of linkage strength between school and work, which vary considerably across industrialized countries. In an analysis of France, Germany, and the United States, we find that workers have higher earnings when they are in occupations that match their educational level and field of study, but the size of this earnings boost depends on the clarity and strength of the pathway between their educational credential and the labor market. The earnings premium associated with a good occupational match is larger in countries where the credential has a stronger link to the labor market, but the penalty for a mismatch is also greater in such countries. Moreover, strong linkage reduces unemployment risk. These findings add nuance to often-made arguments that countries with loosely structured educational systems have more flexible labor markets and produce better labor market outcomes for workers. An institutional environment that promotes strong school-to-work pathways appears to be an effective strategy for providing workers with secure, well-paying jobs.
AizenmanJoshuaJinjarakYothinNgoNamNoyIlan. 2018. “Vocational Education, Manufacturing, and Income Distribution: International Evidence and Case Studies.” Open Economies Review29(3):641–64.
2.
AllenJimBoezerooyPetraDe WeertEgbertVan Den VeldenRolf. 2000. “Higher Education and Graduate Employment in the Netherlands.” European Journal of Education35(2):211–9.
3.
AllmendingerJutta. 1989. “Educational Systems and Labor Market Outcomes.” European Sociological Review5(3):231–50.
4.
BeckerGary S.1962. “Investment in Human Capital: A Theoretical Analysis.” Journal of Political Economy70(5):9–49.
5.
BeduweCatherineGiretJean-Francois. 2011. “Mismatch of Vocational Graduates: What Penalty on French Labour Market?” Journal of Vocational Behavior78(1):68–79.
6.
BMBF. 2015. Report on Vocational Education and Training. Bonn, Germany: Federal Ministry of Education and Research.
7.
BolThijs. 2014. “Economic Returns to Occupational Closure in the German Skilled Trades.” Social Science Research46:9–22.
8.
BolThijsVan de WerfhorstHerman G.2013. “Educational Systems and the Trade-off between Labor Market Allocation and Equality of Educational Opportunity.” Comparative Education Review57(2):285–308.
9.
BolThijsWeedenKim A.2015. “Occupational Closure and Wage Inequality in Germany and the United Kingdom.” European Sociological Review31(3):354–69.
10.
BourdieuPierre. 1973. Cultural Reproduction and Social Reproduction. London, UK: Tavistock.
11.
BreenRichard. 2005. “Explaining Cross-National Variation in Youth Unemployment: Market and Institutional Factors.” European Sociological Review21(2):125–34.
12.
CollinsRandall. 1979. The Credential Society: An Historical Sociology of Education and Stratification. New York: Academic Press.
13.
CroceGiuseppeGhignoniEmanuela. 2012. “Demand and Supply of Skilled Labour and Overeducation in Europe: A Country-Level Analysis.” Comparative Economic Studies54(2):413–39.
14.
DiPreteThomas A.BolThijsEllerChristina CioccaVan de WerfhorstHerman G.2017. “School-to-Work Linkages in the United States, Germany, and France.” American Journal of Sociology122(6):1869–938.
15.
Di StasioValentina. 2017. “Who Is Ahead in the Labor Queue? Institutions’ and Employers’ Perspective on Overeducation, Undereducation, and Horizontal Mismatches.” Sociology of Education90(2):109–26.
16.
DominaThurstonPennerAndrewPennerEmily. 2017. “Categorical Inequality: Schools as Sorting Machines.” Annual Review of Sociology43:311–30.
17.
DuncanGreg J.HoffmanSaul D.1981. “The Incidence and Wage Effects of Overeducation.” Economics of Education Review1(1):75–86.
18.
ElliottJaneGerovaVania. 2005. “Translation from US OCC 2000 to ISCO-88.” Centre for Longitudinal Studies, London, UK.
19.
ForsterAndrea G.BolThijs. 2018. “Vocational Education and Employment over the Life Course Using a New Measure of Occupational Specificity.” Social Science Research70:176–97.
20.
ForsterAndrea G.BolThijsVan de WerfhorstHerman G.2016. “Vocational Education and Employment over the Life Cycle.” Sociological Science3(21):473–94.
21.
FreemanRichard B.1976. The Overeducated American. New York: Academic Press.
22.
GanglMarkus. 2004. “Institutions and the Structure of Labour Market Matching in the United States and West Germany.” European Sociological Review20(3):171–87.
23.
GhignoniEmanuelaVerashchaginaAlina. 2014. “Educational Qualifications Mismatch in Europe: Is It Demand or Supply Driven?” Journal of Comparative Economics42(3):670–92.
24.
GoldinClaudia D.KatzLawrence F.2009. The Race between Education and Technology. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
25.
HallPeter A.SoskiceDavid. 2001. Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
26.
HandelMichael J.2003. “Skills Mismatch in the Labor Market.” Annual Review of Sociology29:135–65.
27.
HanushekEric A.SchwerdtGuidoWoessmannLudgerZhangLei. 2017. “General Education, Vocational Education, and Labor-Market Outcomes over the Lifecycle.” Journal of Human Resources52(1):48–87.
28.
HeisigJan PaulSolgaHeike. 2015. “Secondary Education Systems and the General Skills of Less- and Intermediate-Educated Adults: A Comparison of 18 Countries.” Sociology of Education88(3):202–25.
29.
HoffmanNancy. 2011. Schooling in the Workplace: How Six of the World’s Best Vocational Education Systems Prepare Young People for Jobs and Life. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
30.
IversenTorbenSoskiceDavid. 2001. “An Asset Theory of Social Policy Preferences.” American Political Science Review95(4):875–93.
31.
KallebergArne L.MouwTed. 2018. “Occupations, Organizations, and Intragenerational Career Mobility.” Annual Review of Sociology44:283–303.
32.
Katz-GerroTallyYaishMeir. 2003. “Higher Education: Is More Better? Gender Differences in Labour Market Returns to Tertiary Education in Israel.” Oxford Review of Education29:571–92.
33.
KerckhoffAlan C.2000. “Building Conceptual and Empirical Bridges between Studies of Educational and Labour Force Careers.” Pp. 37–56 in Generating Social Stratification: Toward a New Research Agenda, edited by KerckhoffA. C.Boulder, CO: Greenwood Press.
34.
KirkeboenLars J.LeuvenEdwinMogstadMagne. 2016. “Field of Study, Earnings, and Self-Selection.” Quarterly Journal of Economics131(3):1057–111.
35.
KorpiTomasTahlinMichael. 2009. “Educational Mismatch, Wages, and Wage Growth: Overeducation in Sweden, 1974–2000.” Labour Economics16(2):183–93.
36.
LabareeDavid F.1999. How to Succeed in School without Really Learning: The Credentials Race in American Education. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
37.
LeuvenEdwinOosterbeekHessel. 2011. “Overeducation and Mismatch in the Labor Market.” Pp. 283–326 in Handbook of the Economics of Education, Vol. 4, edited by HanushekE.MachinS.WoessmannL.Amsterdam: Elsevier.
38.
LeuzeKathrin. 2007. “What Makes for a Good Start? Consequences of Occupation-Specific Higher Education for Career Mobility: Germany and Great Britain Compared.” International Journal of Sociology37(2):29–53.
39.
LevelsMarkVan der VeldenRolfAllenJim. 2014. “Educational Mismatches and Skills: New Empirical Tests of Old Hypotheses.” Oxford Economic Papers66(4):959–82.
40.
MauriceMarcSellierFrançoisSilvestreJean-Jacques. 1986. The Social Foundations of Industrial Power: A Comparison of France and Germany. Boston: MIT Press.
41.
McGuinnessScamus. 2006. “Overeducation in the Labour Market.” Journal of Economic Surveys20(3):387–418.
42.
MonttGuillermo. 2015. “The Causes and Consequences of Field-of-Study Mismatch: An Analysis Using PIAAC.” OECD Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers No. 167. Paris: OECD.
43.
MoraRicardoRuiz-CastilloJavier. 2009. “The Invariance Properties of the Mutual Information Index of Multigroup Segregation.” Pp. 33–53 in Occupational and Residential Segregation, Vol. 17, Research on Economic Inequality, edited by FlückigerY.ReardonS. F.SilberJ.Bingley, UK: Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
MullerWalterGanglMarkus. 2003. Transitions from Education to Work in Europe: The Integration of Youth into EU Labour Markets. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press on Demand.
46.
NordinMartinPerssonIngaRoothDan-Olof. 2010. “Education-Occupation Mismatch: Is There an Income Penalty?” Economics of Education Review29(6):1047–59.
47.
PedullaDavid S.2016. “Penalized or Protected? Gender and the Consequences of Nonstandard and Mismatched Employment Histories.” American Sociological Review81(2):262–89.
48.
ProtschPaulaSolgaHeike. 2016. “The Social Stratification of the German VET System.” Journal of Education and Work29(6):637–61.
49.
RedbirdBeth. 2017. “The New Closed Shop? The Economic and Structural Effects of Occupational Licensure.” American Sociological Review82(3):600–624.
50.
RobstJohn. 2007. “Education and Job Match: The Relatedness of College Major and Work.” Economics of Education Review26(4):397–407.
51.
RoksaJosipaLeveyTania. 2010. “What Can You Do with That Degree? College Major and Occupational Status of College Graduates over Time.” Social Forces89(2):389–415.
52.
ShavitYossiMullerWalter, eds. 1998. From School to Work: A Comparative Study of Educational Qualifications and Occupational Destinations. Oxford, UK: Clarendon Press.
53.
ShavitYossiMullerWalter. 2000. “Vocational Secondary Education.” European Societies2(1):29–50.
54.
SnyderThomas D.DillowSally A.2016. “Digest of Education Statistics, 2014.” Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
55.
ThelenKathleen. 2004. How Institutions Evolve: The Political Economy of Skills in Germany, Britain, the United States, and Japan. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
56.
Van de WerfhorstHerman G.2002. “Fields of Study, Acquired Skills and the Wage Benefit from a Matching Job.” Acta Sociologica45(4):286–303.
57.
VerhaestDieterVan der VeldenRolf. 2013. “Cross-Country Differences in Graduate Overeducation.” European Sociological Review29(3):642–53.
58.
VogtenhuberStefan. 2014. “The Impact of Within Country Heterogeneity in Vocational Specificity on Initial Job Matches and Job Status.” Journal of Vocational Behavior85(3):374–84.
59.
VossensteynJohan J.KottmannAndreaJongbloedBenjamin W. A.KaiserFranciscusCremoniniLeonStensakerBjornHovdhaugenElisabethWollscheidSabine. 2015. Dropout and Completion in Higher Education in Europe: Main Report. Brussels: European Union.
60.
WeedenKim A.2002. “Why Do Some Occupations Pay More than Others? Social Closure and Earnings Inequality in the United States.” American Journal of Sociology108(1):55–101.
61.
WitteJames C.KallebergArne L.1995. “Matching Training and Jobs: The Fit between Vocational Education and Employment in the German Labour Market.” European Sociological Review11(3):293–317.
62.
WolbersMaarten H. J.2003. “Job Mismatches and Their Labour-Market Effects among School-Leavers in Europe.” European Sociological Review19(3):249–66.
63.
WolbersMaarten H. J.2007. “Patterns of Labour Market Entry: A Comparative Perspective on School-to-Work Transitions in 11 European Countries.” Acta Sociologica50(3):189–210.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
