What is the worth of a college degree when higher education expands? The relative education hypothesis posits that when college degrees are rare, individuals with more education have less competition to enter highly-skilled occupations. When college degrees are more common, there may not be enough highly-skilled jobs to go around; some college-educated workers lose out to others and are pushed into less-skilled jobs. Using new measurements of occupation-level verbal, quantitative, and analytic skills, this study tests the changing effect of education on skill utilization across 70 years of birth cohorts from 1971 to 2010, net of all other age, period, and cohort trends. Higher-education expansion erodes the value of a college degree, and college-educated workers are at greater risk for underemployment in less cognitively demanding occupations. This raises questions about the sources of rising income inequality, skill utilization across the working life course, occupational sex segregation, and how returns to education have changed across different life domains.
AcemogluDaronAutorDavid. 2012. “What Does Human Capital Do? A Review of Goldin and Katz’s The Race between Education and Technology.” Journal of Economic Literature50(2):426–63.
2.
AutorDavid H.2014. “Skills, Education, and the Rise of Earnings Inequality among the ‘Other 99 Percent.’”Science344(6186):843–51. doi:10.1126/scie nce.1251868.
3.
AutorDavid H.DornDavid. 2013. “The Growth of Low-Skill Service Jobs and the Polarization of the US Labor Market.” American Economic Review103(5):1553–97.
4.
BakerDavid P.2011. “Forward and Backward, Horizontal and Vertical: Transformation of Occupational Credentialing in the Schooled Society.” Research in Social Stratification and Mobility29(1):5–29. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.rssm.2011.01.001.
5.
BaunachDawn Michelle. 2002. “Trends in Occupational Sex Segregation and Inequality, 1950 to 1990.” Social Science Research31(1):77–98. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1006/ssre.2001.0719.
6.
BergIvar E.1970. Education and Jobs: The Great Training Robbery. New York: Praeger Publishers.
7.
BernardFabrizioChakhaiaLelaLeopoldLiliya. 2017. “‘Sing Me a Song with Social Significance’: The (Mis)Use of Statistical Significance Testing in European Sociological Research.” European Sociological Review33(1):1–15. doi:10.1093/esr/jcw047.
8.
BernsteinElizabeth. 2007. “Sex Work for the Middle Classes.” Sexualities10(4):473–88.
9.
BielbyRobPosseltJulie ReneeJaquetteOzanBastedoMichael N.2014. “Why Are Women Underrepresented in Elite Colleges and Universities? A Non-Linear Decomposition Analysis.” Research in Higher Education55(8):735–60. doi:10.1007/s11162-014-9334-y.
10.
BillsDavid B.2016. “Congested Credentials: The Material and Positional Economies of Schooling.” Research in Social Stratification and Mobility43:65–70. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.rssm.2016.03.002.
11.
BishopJohn A.FormbyJohn P.ThistlePaul D.1992. “Explaining Interstate Variation in Income Inequality.” The Review of Economics and Statistics74(3):553–57. doi:10.2307/2109501.
12.
BoeseRonLewisPhilFrugoliPamLitwin.Karen2001. “Summary of O*Net 4.0 Content Model and Database.” National Center for O*NET Development.
13.
BolThijs. 2015. “Has Education Become More Positional? Educational Expansion and Labour Market Outcomes, 1985–2007.” Acta Sociologica58(2):105–120. doi:10.1177/0001699315570918.
14.
BoylanRoss D.1993. “The Effect of the Number of Diplomas on Their Value.” Sociology of Education66(3):206–221. doi:10.2307/2112737.
15.
BradyDavidBakerRegina S.FinniganRyan. 2013. “When Unionization Disappears: State-Level Unionization and Working Poverty in the United States.” American Sociological Review78(5):872–96.
16.
BrownDavid K.1995. Degrees of Control: A Sociology of Educational Expansion and Occupational Credentialism. New York: Teachers College Press.
17.
BrownDavid K.2001. “The Social Sources of Educational Credentialism: Status Cultures, Labor Markets, and Organizations.” Sociology of Education74:19–34. doi:10.2307/2673251.
18.
BuchmannClaudiaDiPreteThomas A.2006. “The Growing Female Advantage in College Completion: The Role of Family Background and Academic Achievement.” American Sociological Review71(4): 515–41.
BurrisVal. 1983. “The Social and Political Consequences of Overeducation.” American Sociological Review48(4):454–67. doi:10.2307/2117714.
21.
CampbellDavid E.2009. “Civic Engagement and Education: An Empirical Test of the Sorting Model.” American Journal of Political Science53(4):771–86. doi:10.1111/j.1540-5907.2009.00400.x.
22.
CappelliPeter H.2001. “Assessing the Decline of Internal Labor Markets.” Pp. 207–245 in Sourcebook of Labor Markets, edied by BergI.KallebergA. L.Boston, MA: Springer.
23.
CappelliPeter H.2015. “Skill Gaps, Skill Shortages, and Skill Mismatches: Evidence and Arguments for the United States.” ILR Review68(2):251–90. doi:10.1177/0019793914564961.
24.
CloggClifford C.1979. Measuring Underemployment. New York: Academic.
25.
CollinsRandall. 1979. The Credential Society: An Historical Sociology of Education and Stratification. New York: Academic Press.
26.
CollinsRandall. 2002. “Credential Inflation and the Future of Universities.” Pp. 23–46 in The Future of the City of Intellect: The Changing American University, edited by BrintS.Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
27.
CotterDavid A.HermsenJoan M.VannemanReeve. 2001. “Women’s Work and Working Women: The Demand for Female Labor.” Gender and Society15(3):429–52.
28.
DaviaMaria A.McGuinnessSeamusO’ConnellPhilip J.2017. “Determinants of Regional Differences in Rates of Overeducation in Europe.” Social Science Research 63(Supplement C):67–80. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssresearch.2016.09.009.
29.
del RíoCoralAlonso-VillarOlga. 2015. “The Evolution of Occupational Segregation in the United States, 1940–2010: Gains and Losses of Gender–Race/Ethnicity Groups.” Demography52(3):967–88. doi:10.1007/s13524-015-0390-5.
30.
Di StasioValentina. 2017. “Who Is Ahead in the Labor Queue? Institutions’ and Employers’ Perspective on Overeducation, Undereducation, and Horizontal Mismatches.” Sociology of Education90(2):109–26. doi:10.1177/0038040717694877.
31.
DobbinFrank. 2009. Inventing Equal Opportunity. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
32.
DornDavid.2009. “Essays on Inequality, Spatial Interaction, and the Demand for Skills.” PhD dissertation, no. 3613, Graduate School of Business Administration, Economics, Law and Social Sciences, University of St. Gallen, Switzerland.
33.
EasterlinRichard A.1987. Birth and Fortune: The Impact of Numbers on Personal Welfare. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
34.
ElderGlen H.1999. Children of the Great Depression: Social Change in Life Experience. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
35.
EnglandPaulaLiSu. 2006. “Desegregation Stalled: The Changing Gender Composition of College Majors, 1971–2002.” Gender & Society20(5):657–77. doi:10.1177/0891243206290753.
36.
FischerClaude S.HoutMichael. 2006. Century of Difference: How America Changed in the Last One Hundred Years. New York: Russell Sage Foundation Publications.
37.
FloodSarahKingMiriamRugglesStevenWarrenJ. Robert. 2015. “Integrated Public Use Microdata Series, Current Population Survey: Version 4.0.” Minneapolis: University of Minnesota.
38.
FreemanRichard B.1976. The Overeducated American. New York: Academic Press.
39.
GlennNorval D.2003. “Distinguishing Age, Period, and Cohort Effects.” Pp. 465–76 in Handbook of the Life Course, edited by MortimerJ. T.ShanahanM. J.New York: Springer Science.
40.
GoldinClaudia D.KatzLawrence F.2008. The Race between Education and Technology. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press.
41.
GoldthorpeJohn H.2014. “The Role of Education in Intergenerational Social Mobility: Problems from Empirical Research in Sociology and Some Theoretical Pointers from Economics.” Rationality and Society26(3):265–89. doi:10.1177/1043463113519068.
42.
GoyetteKimberly A.2008. “College for Some to College for All: Social Background, Occupational Expectations, and Educational Expectations over Time.” Social Science Research37(2):461–84. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ssresearch.2008.02.002.
43.
HackerJacob S.PiersonPaul. 2010. “Winner-Take-All Politics: Public Policy, Political Organization, and the Precipitous Rise of Top Incomes in the United States.” Politics & Society38(2):152–204. doi:10.1177/0032329210365042.
44.
HalabyCharles N.2004. “Panel Models in Sociological Research: Theory into Practice.” Annual Review of Sociology30:507–544. doi:10.1146/annurev.soc .30.012703.110629.
45.
HandelMichael J.2003. “Skills Mismatch in the Labor Market.” Annual Review of Sociology29:135–65.
46.
HardingDavid J.JencksChristopher. 2003. “Changing Attitudes toward Premarital Sex: Cohort, Period, and Aging Effects.” The Public Opinion Quarterly67(2):211–26.
47.
HermanowiczJoseph C.2010. Lives in Science: How Institutions Affect Academic Careers. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
48.
HirschFred. 1976. Social Limits to Growth. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
49.
HorowitzJonathan. 2015. “Doing Less with More: Cohorts, Education, and Civic Participation in America.” Social Forces94(2):747–74. doi:10.1093/sf/sov065.
50.
HorowitzJonathan. 2016. “Dimensions of Job Quality, Mechanisms, and Subjective Well-Being in the United States.” Sociological Forum31(2):419–40. doi:10.1111/socf.12251.
51.
HoutMichael. 2012. “Social and Economic Returns to College Education in the United States.” Annual Review of Sociology38(1):379–400. doi:10.1146/annurev.soc.012809.102503.
52.
JacobsDavidDirlamJonathan C.2016. “Politics and Economic Stratification: Power Resources and Income Inequality in the United States.” American Journal of Sociology122(2):469–500. doi:10.1086/687744.
53.
JacobsDavidMyersLindsey. 2014. “Union Strength, Neoliberalism, and Inequality: Contingent Political Analyses of U.S. Income Differences since 1950.” American Sociological Review79(4):752–74.
54.
JacobsJerry A.1996. “Gender Inequality and Higher Education.” Annual Review of Sociology22:153–85.
55.
KallebergArne L.2008. “The Mismatched Worker: When People Don’t Fit Their Jobs.” Academy of Management Perspectives22(1):24–40.
56.
KallebergArne L.2011. Good Jobs, Bad Jobs: The Rise of Polarized and Precarious Employment Systems in the United States, 1970s–2000s. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
57.
KlineRex. 2004. Beyond Significance Testing: Reforming Data Analysis Methods in Behavioral Research. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
58.
KristalTaliCohenYinon. 2016. “The Causes of Rising Wage Inequality: The Race between Institutions and Technology.” Socio-Economic Review15(1):187–212.
59.
LinKen-Hou. 2015. “The Financial Premium in the US Labor Market: A Distributional Analysis.” Social Forces94(1):1–30. doi:10.1093/sf/sou132.
60.
LinKen-HouTomaskovic-DeveyDonald. 2013. “Financialization and U.S. Income Inequality, 1970–2008.” American Journal of Sociology118(5):1284–1329. doi:10.1086/669499.
61.
LiuYujiaGruskyDavid B.2013. “The Payoff to Skill in the Third Industrial Revolution.” American Journal of Sociology118(5):1330–74. doi:10.1086/669498.
62.
LuoLiying. 2015. “Age-Period-Cohort Analysis: Critiques and Innovations.” PhD dissertation, Department of Sociology, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN.
63.
LuoLiyingHodgesJames S.2016. “Block Constraints in Age–Period–Cohort Models with Unequal-Width Intervals.” Sociological Methods & Research45(4):700–726. doi:10.1177/0049124115585359.
64.
LuoLiyingHodgesJamesWinshipChristopherPowersDaniel. 2016. “The Sensitivity of the Intrinsic Estimator to Coding Schemes: Comment on Yang, Schulhofer-Wohl, Fu, and Land.” American Journal of Sociology122(3):930–61. doi:10.1086/689830.
65.
McKee-RyanFrances M.HarveyJaron. 2011. “‘I Have a Job, But . . . ‘: A Review of Underemployment.” Journal of Management37(4):962–96. doi:10.1177/0149206311398134.
66.
McLaughlinDiane K.PermanLauri. 1991. “Returns vs. Endowments in the Earnings Attainment Process for Metropolitan and Nonmetropolitan Men and Women.” Rural Sociology56(3):339–65. doi:10.1111/j.1549–0831.1991.tb00438.x.
67.
MouwTedKallebergArne L.2010. “Occupations and the Structure of Wage Inequality in the United States, 1980s to 2000s.” American Sociological Review75(3):402–431.
68.
NieNorman H.JunnJaneStehlik-BarryKenneth. 1996. Education and Democratic Citizenship in America. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
69.
PampelFred C.PetersH. Elizabeth. 1995. “The Easterlin Effect.” Annual Review of Sociology21(1):163–94. doi:10.1146/annurev.so.21.080195.001115.
70.
PedullaDavid S.2016. “Penalized or Protected? Gender and the Consequences of Nonstandard and Mismatched Employment Histories.” American Sociological Review81(2):262–89. doi:10.1177/0003122416630982.
71.
PfefferFabian T.HertelFlorian R.2015. “How Has Educational Expansion Shaped Social Mobility Trends in the United States?” Social Forces94(1):143–80.
72.
QueneauHervé. 2006. “Is the Long-Term Reduction in Occupational Sex Segregation Still Continuing in the United States?” The Social Science Journal43(4):681–88. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.soscij.2006.08.019.
73.
QuillianLincolnPagerDevahHexelOleMidtbøenArnfinn H.2017. “Meta-Analysis of Field Experiments Shows No Change in Racial Discrimination in Hiring over Time.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences114(41):10870–75.
74.
RampellCatherine. 2013. “It Takes a B.A. To Find a Job as a File Clerk.” New York Times, February19.
75.
RauscherEmily. 2015. “Educational Expansion and Occupational Change: US Compulsory Schooling Laws and the Occupational Structure 1850–1930.” Social Forces93(4):1397–1422.
76.
ReskinBarbara. 1993. “Sex Segregation in the Workplace.” Annual Review of Sociology19(1):241–70. doi:10.1146/annurev.so.19.080193.001325.
77.
ReskinBarbara F.McBrierDebra B.KmecJulie A.1999. “The Determinants and Consequences of Workplace Sex and Race Composition.” Annual Review of Sociology25:335–61.
78.
ReskinBarbara F.RoosPatricia A.2009. Job Queues, Gender Queues: Explaining Women’s Inroads into Male Occupations. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
79.
RieblerAndreaHeldLeonhardRueHåvard. 2012. “Estimation and Extrapolation of Time Trends in Registry Data: Borrowing Strength from Related Populations.” Annals of Applied Statistics6(1):304–333.
80.
RiveraLauren A.2011. “Ivies, Extracurriculars, and Exclusion: Elite Employers’ Use of Educational Credentials.” Research in Social Stratification and Mobility29(1):71–90. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rssm.2010.12.001.
81.
RosenbaumJames E.2001. Beyond College for All: Career Paths for the Forgotten Half. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
82.
SchoenfeldAlan H.2007. “Problem Solving in the United States, 1970–2008: Research and Theory, Practice and Politics.” ZDM39(5):537–51. doi:10.1007/s11858-007-0038-z.
83.
ShavitYossiParkHyunjoon. 2016. “Introduction to the Special Issue: Education as a Positional Good.” Research in Social Stratification and Mobility43:1–3. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.rssm.2016.03.003.
84.
SlackTimJensenLeif. 2008. “Birth and Fortune Revisited: A Cohort Analysis of Underemployment, 1974–2004.” Population Research and Policy Review27(6):729–49. doi:10.1007/s11113-008-9091-8.
85.
SmithHerbert L.1986. “Overeducation and Underemployment: An Agnostic Review.” Sociology of Education59(2):85–99. doi:10.2307/2112434.
86.
SnyderThomas D.Cristobal de Brey, and Sally A. Dillow. 2018. “Digest of Education Statistics 2016.” National Center for Education Statistics, Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education, Washington, DC.
87.
SpenceMichael. 1973. “Job Market Signaling.” Quarterly Journal of Economics87(3):355–74. doi:10.2307/1882010.
88.
TeitelbaumMichael S.2014. Falling Behind? Boom, Bust, and the Global Race for Scientific Talent. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
89.
TennSteven. 2005. “An Alternative Measure of Relative Education to Explain Voter Turnout.” Journal of Politics67(1):271–82.
90.
ThorntonStephen J.2008. “Continuity and Change in Social Studies Curriculum.” Pp. 15–32 in Handbook of Research in Social Studies Education, edited by LevstikL. S.TysonC. A.New York: Routledge.
Tomaskovic-DeveyDonaldLinKen-Hou. 2011. “Income Dynamics, Economic Rents, and the Financialization of the U.S. Economy.” American Sociological Review76(4):538–59. doi:10.1177/ 0003122411414827.
93.
Tomaskovic-DeveyDonaldZimmerCatherineStainbackKevinRobinsonCorreTaylorTiffanyMcTagueTricia. 2006. “Documenting Desegregation: Segregation in American Workplaces by Race, Ethnicity, and Sex, 1966–2003.” American Sociological Review71(4):565–88. doi:10.1177/000312240607100403.
94.
TurleyRuth N. LópezSantosMartínCejaCecilia. 2007. “Social Origin and College Opportunity Expectations across Cohorts.” Social Science Research36(3):1200–18. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssresearch.2006.09.004.
95.
VaiseyStephen. 2006. “Education and Its Discontents: Overqualification in America, 1972–2002.” Social Forces85(2):835–64.
96.
Van de WerfhorstHerman G.AndersenRobert. 2005. “Social Background, Credential Inflation and Educational Strategies.” Acta Sociologica48(4):321–40. doi:10.1177/0001699305059945.
97.
VolschoThomas W.KellyNathan J.2012. “The Rise of the Super-Rich: Power Resources, Taxes, Financial Markets, and the Dynamics of the Top 1 Percent, 1949 to 2008.” American Sociological Review77(5):679–99. doi:10.1177/0003122412458508.
98.
WesternBruceRosenfeldJake. 2011. “Unions, Norms, and the Rise in U.S. Wage Inequality.” American Sociological Review76(4):513–37.
99.
YangYangFuWenjiang J.LandKenneth C.2004. “A Methodological Comparison of Age-Period-Cohort Models: The Intrinsic Estimator and Conventional Generalized Linear Models.” Sociological Methodology34(1):75–110. doi:10.1111/j.0081-1750.2004.00148.x.
100.
YangYangLandKenneth C.2008. “Age–Period–Cohort Analysis of Repeated Cross-Section Surveys: Fixed or Random Effects?” Sociological Methods & Research36(3):297–326. doi:10.1177/ 0049124106292360.
101.
YuWei-hsinKuoJanet Chen-Lan. 2017. “The Motherhood Wage Penalty by Work Conditions: How Do Occupational Characteristics Hinder or Empower Mothers?” American Sociological Review82(4):744–69. doi:10.1177/0003122417712729.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
